2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: zippz on June 04, 2020, 02:18:06 PM
-
Has anyone applied, or attempted to apply, for open carry? Or was told open carry was only for security guards at the police station? Pls call me at 255-3066 if so.
-
I have been thinking about it for some time now. I'm waiting to see how the en banc oral argument in Young v. Hawaii goes.
Anyone who applies should remember to include rifle and shotgun Open Carry in your application. It is concealable weapons (e.g.) that have always been suspect. Long guns, particularly rifles and muskets, have always been held to be protected arms.
If you are looking for plaintiffs for a lawsuit, the case law in support of long guns is on your side. When it comes to handguns, particularly handguns that are easily and ordinarily carried concealed, you face an uphill battle.
-
Still no form for OPEN CARRY.
http://www.honolulupd.org/downloads/LTC2018Application.pdf
And have they ever fixed the fees for RAPBACK? The AG is now charging $30 so the $43.25 is still wrong as the statute states "ยง134-2 Permits to acquire. (i) No fee shall be charged for permits, or applications for permits, under this section, except for a single fee chargeable by and payable to the issuing county, for individuals applying for their first permit, in an amount equal to the fee charged by the Hawaii criminal justice data center pursuant to section 846-2.7"
https://ag.hawaii.gov/hcjdc/criminal-history-records-check/ (https://ag.hawaii.gov/hcjdc/criminal-history-records-check/)
-
So...nobody applied for an Open Carry license?
-
I haven't found anyone. Everyone's focus is on CCW.
On a side note, I'm considering changing strategies when it comes to showing demand for permits for legislative actions. Instead of having people apply for Hawaii open and ccw permits which is difficult to get people to do. We instead show demand for out of state permits.
-
:wacko:
I haven't found anyone. Everyone's focus is on CCW.
On a side note, I'm considering changing strategies when it comes to showing demand for permits for legislative actions. Instead of having people apply for Hawaii open and ccw permits which is difficult to get people to do. We instead show demand for out of state permits.
I have a out of state permit lol paid alot for it too and don't even leave the state :wacko:
-
Almost no one currently applies because everyone knows it will be automatically denied. If the courts rule favorably for 2A rights, you will see hundreds of applicants. Let's be honest. No one wants to waste valuble time on a futile effort.
-
:wacko:
I have a out of state permit lol paid alot for it too and don't even leave the state :wacko:
you also have a lot of guns that you paid a lot of money for and don't shoot... :wacko:
-
Almost no one currently applies because everyone knows it will be automatically denied. If the courts rule favorably for 2A rights, you will see hundreds of applicants. Let's be honest. No one wants to waste valuble time on a futile effort.
I used to request a conceal carry most every year,
Last time around I also tried for open carry.
I even complained to the Police commission.
Basically until we get some court rulings
concealed or open carry is dead in Hawaii county.
Plus we got screwed when the Republicans killed
the Hunter bill by inaction.
Hopefully we can get some better people in the courts.
and things will change.
-
Almost no one currently applies because everyone knows it will be automatically denied. If the courts rule favorably for 2A rights, you will see hundreds of applicants. Let's be honest. No one wants to waste valuble time on a futile effort.
Isn't it simply a matter of filling out an application and paying $10?
-
Isn't it simply a matter of filling out an application and paying $10?
Satisfying government requirements is often more complicated than just showing up and filling out a form. Not everyone has the flexibility in their lives to take time off from work during Police Dept business hours, deal with traffic based on whenever they could get an appointment, etc.
It's an inconvenience of varying degrees.
-
you also have a lot of guns that you paid a lot of money for and don't shoot... :wacko:
Quarantine
-
Quarantine
what was your excuse before march 2020?
-
Almost no one currently applies because everyone knows it will be automatically denied. If the courts rule favorably for 2A rights, you will see hundreds of applicants. Let's be honest. No one wants to waste valuble time on a futile effort.
I beg your pardon. Have you ever seen the 10-20 page testimonies I've submitted to the legislature over the years?
Of course now I know better. My idealism deluded me into thinking that facts and reasoned argument could sway Democrats. Okay, maybe sway one Democrat. Okay, maybe get a committee hearing on "allowing" standard capacity magazines for handguns. Talk about "futile effort"! :rofl:
I wanted to write the HCPD and DA and tell them I was showing up at a particular public location and would be openly bearing a handgun and a long gun and take the case to court, but was strongly advised by people familiar with the likely consequences not to.
So, hoping for a home run Thursday morning in Young v. Hawaii orals! Not "expecting", hoping. I expect a loss, or a mostly "hollow" victory. :shaka:
-
So, hoping for a home run Thursday morning in Young v. Hawaii orals! Not "expecting", hoping. I expect a loss, or a mostly "hollow" victory. :shaka:
A loss in the 9th is still beneficial for us. It means the State cannot prevent the lawsuit from going to SCOTUS.
Our prospects in SCOTUS has improved dramatically in the past few days.
-
Also the link for Thursday's hearing if you didn't catch it in the other thread.
Link for the youtube feed on 9/24 at 10:30am
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX71KI_VR14
-
A loss in the 9th is still beneficial for us. It means the State cannot prevent the lawsuit from going to SCOTUS.
Our prospects in SCOTUS has improved dramatically in the past few days.
Maybe. But if there is a "hollow victory", one in which the "new right" to be imposed on the state is so "narrow" such that Mr. Young and three other people in the whole state now qualify to receive unloaded open carry permits/licenses while the rest of us languish legally unarmed in public due to the remaining or new criteria... well, we won and thus can't appeal, but we've gained virtually nothing. I believe the Nichols v Newsom case is much more likely to have a wider effect on our rights. But everything at this point is (baseless?) conjecture, so... wait until mid 2021 (?) for the next step to unfold.
I mean, seriously, can anyone really imagine people walking around Hawaii open carrying in public? While Democrats control the legislature by 92%, with even a higher percentage of the executive and judicial branches? They're gonna be throwing a ton of shit all over walls to see if anything at all sticks while the years go by... and by... and by. Just my two cents.
-
Satisfying government requirements is often more complicated than just showing up and filling out a form. Not everyone has the flexibility in their lives to take time off from work during Police Dept business hours, deal with traffic based on whenever they could get an appointment, etc.
It's an inconvenience of varying degrees.
What are the requirements? Can you provide a link to the requirements?
-
A loss in the 9th is still beneficial for us. It means the State cannot prevent the lawsuit from going to SCOTUS.
Our prospects in SCOTUS has improved dramatically in the past few days.
True, if Young loses then nothing stops him from filing a cert petition. But if his cert petition is granted then nothing stops Hawaii from granting him a license to carry a handgun, openly or concealed, for at least three years. That would moot his case deader than NYSRPA v. NYC.
Our prospects in SCOTUS might dramatically improve if Trump gets a pro-gun justice confirmed. That is not a done deal.
-
What are the requirements? Can you provide a link to the requirements?
I was speaking in general terms regarding the variety of ways applicants must rearrange their lives to show up to fill out the form and pay the fee (as you put it), demonstrating that the process is not isolated to those 2 actions.
-
I was speaking in general terms regarding the variety of ways applicants must rearrange their lives to show up to fill out the form and pay the fee (as you put it), demonstrating that the process is not isolated to those 2 actions.
If you don't know it is okay to say that you don't know.
-
If you don't know it is okay to say that you don't know.
I was stating that your simplified version of applying for a permit doesn't involve a complete picture of the time it takes -- it IS a "waste of time." How much time it wastes varies.
You don't take other viewpoints very well, do you?
-
What are the requirements? Can you provide a link to the requirements?
http://www.honolulupd.org/downloads/LTC2018Application.pdf (http://www.honolulupd.org/downloads/LTC2018Application.pdf)
1. Must have a handgun registered in Hawaii at the time of your application
2. Two passport photos
3. Fill out the application in person with government issued identification
4. If born outside of the United States, USA Passport, USA Citizenship documents, or USA Permanent Resident Card
5. Provide handwritten or typed reasons for License to Carry Concealed 6. Proof of completion of a Hunter Education Course or other Firearms Safety or Training Course described by Section 134-2(g), Hawaii Revised Statutes
An applicant MUST go in person to the main Honolulu police station to submit all documents. The $10 fee is only applicable if approved, however, if a applicant has never been finger printed or enrolled in their RAPBACK, then they must pay that fee.
Problem is, since the beginning of the year, when they instituted the appointment system, there is no way for a citizen to gain an appointment to even apply for a permit to conceal/open carry.( "License to Carry - Security ") One cannot even apply to purchase a firearm without a 3 month wait, if you are lucky enough to secure an appointment.
-
http://www.honolulupd.org/downloads/LTC2018Application.pdf (http://www.honolulupd.org/downloads/LTC2018Application.pdf)
1. Must have a handgun registered in Hawaii at the time of your application
2. Two passport photos
3. Fill out the application in person with government issued identification
4. If born outside of the United States, USA Passport, USA Citizenship documents, or USA Permanent Resident Card
5. Provide handwritten or typed reasons for License to Carry Concealed 6. Proof of completion of a Hunter Education Course or other Firearms Safety or Training Course described by Section 134-2(g), Hawaii Revised Statutes
An applicant MUST go in person to the main Honolulu police station to submit all documents. The $10 fee is only applicable if approved, however, if a applicant has never been finger printed or enrolled in their RAPBACK, then they must pay that fee.
Problem is, since the beginning of the year, when they instituted the appointment system, there is no way for a citizen to gain an appointment to even apply for a permit to conceal/open carry.( "License to Carry - Security ") One cannot even apply to purchase a firearm without a 3 month wait, if you are lucky enough to secure an appointment.
Just to fill in the "waste of time" concept...
1. What is the range of travel times to and from the only available police station from various parts of Oahu during appointment hours?
2. What are the hours appointments are available? All during normal work hours requiring people to take off work?
3. How long does it take to find parking down there and how much does it cost?
4. How long (phone time/calls) does it typically take to actually get an appointment?
5. Anything else?
Since we know that during the past 20 years of mandated record reporting not one single license has been issued on Oahu, would it be fair to say that unless a person wants to receive a denial in anticipation of filing a lawsuit that it would otherwise be a "waste of time" to submit an application given that there is zero chance of approval? Even if it only took 2 minutes.
-
I was stating that your simplified version of applying for a permit doesn't involve a complete picture of the time it takes -- it IS a "waste of time." How much time it wastes varies.
You don't take other viewpoints very well, do you?
I had no version, simplified or otherwise, that is why I asked.
Then two people managed to answer my question, something you did not even bother to attempt.
I do not suffer fools gladly. Neither do I have any patience for whiners who don't even try to make an effort. I am about to begin my 10th year of litigation fighting California's Open Carry bans. George Young filed his lawsuit six months after mine.
Tell us again? Who are you?
-
I had no version, simplified or otherwise, that is why I asked.
Then two people managed to answer my question, something you did not even bother to attempt.
I do not suffer fools gladly. Neither do I have any patience for whiners who don't even try to make an effort. I am about to begin my 10th year of litigation fighting California's Open Carry bans. George Young filed his lawsuit six months after mine.
Tell us again? Who are you?
this tells us all we need to know about you...
-
I had no version, simplified or otherwise, that is why I asked.
Then two people managed to answer my question, something you did not even bother to attempt.
I do not suffer fools gladly. Neither do I have any patience for whiners who don't even try to make an effort. I am about to begin my 10th year of litigation fighting California's Open Carry bans. George Young filed his lawsuit six months after mine.
Tell us again? Who are you?
I answered your question, just not in the fashion you would have liked.
You seem very sensitive for someone in the legal profession.
I foresee a political office in your future. Maybe Lt Gov? The current one also likes to remind us of his credentials as if that somehow makes his comments better supported.
Have a nice evening.
-
Just to fill in the "waste of time" concept...
Since we know that during the past 20 years of mandated record reporting not one single license has been issued on Oahu, would it be fair to say that unless a person wants to receive a denial in anticipation of filing a lawsuit that it would otherwise be a "waste of time" to submit an application given that there is zero chance of approval? Even if it only took 2 minutes.
Just to update you, my research of mandated record reporting (AG) done in 2016 shows IN THE STATE OF HAWAII between 2000-2015,
There were 3,486 security firm applicants. 3,442 approved (64 rejected).
There were 128 private citizen applicants (2014 had 21, 2015 had 44 and 2 of those in each year were my household)
Between 2000-2015, 4 private citizen CCW permits had been issued.
2001 - 2
2006 - 1
2013 - 1
RUMOR has it at least one of the above was not on Oahu, one was to a judge, another to a retired military officer,
It's not what you know it's who you know. ::)
In 2016
Hawaii county 6 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Kauai county 5 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Maui county 0 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Honolulu county 15 applications, 0 (0) approvals (2 of those were my household)
Entire state 26, applications, 0 (0) approvals
2017
I acquire a Utah CFP and Utah CFP Instructors license. :thumbsup:
-
Between 2000-2015, 4 private citizen CCW permits had been issued.
2001 - 2
2006 - 1
2013 - 1
RUMOR has it at least one of the above was not on Oahu, one was to a judge, another to a retired military officer,
It's not what you know it's who you know. ::)
No permits were issued since 2015, so those stats of 4 issued remain through 2019.
The 2 CCW permits in 2001 were from the Maui PD. They claim all records regarding those permits no longer exist and that no one in the department as of several years ago had any information or knowledge of who got them or what specific claim they made to be issued the permits.
The 2006 permit was on Kauai to a judge, and included multiple gross violations of the permitting law regarding length of permit validity (statutorily one year) and renewal procedures (statutorily apply 30 days prior to expiration).
The 2013 permit was also on Kauai and appears to have been issued to either a military member or a family member of a military member, and was withdrawn after 6 weeks.
I have photocopies of the two Kauai permit applications/approvals. It's obvious that law enforcement doesn't abide by the law at all on those extremely rare occasions when they have actually deemed someone eligible to exercise their right to bear arms for self-defense outside the home.
That's why it's gonna take an extremely deep and thorough court decision to force these third world good old boy police departments to actually abide by the Constitution. They ain't going willingly, and if there are any cracks or loopholes available, they will make sure to use them to deny us all our rights.
Hopefully a start: Young v Hawaii today at 10:30 AM:
https://youtu.be/YX71KI_VR14 (https://youtu.be/YX71KI_VR14)
-
Just to fill in the "waste of time" concept...
I estimate it costs the average working person between $100 to $250 in lost pay and productivity for permit/registration everytime they acquire a firearm. The hidden 2A tax.
-
Just to update you, my research of mandated record reporting (AG) done in 2016 shows IN THE STATE OF HAWAII between 2000-2015,
There were 3,486 security firm applicants. 3,442 approved (64 rejected).
There were 128 private citizen applicants (2014 had 21, 2015 had 44 and 2 of those in each year were my household)
Between 2000-2015, 4 private citizen CCW permits had been issued.
2001 - 2
2006 - 1
2013 - 1
RUMOR has it at least one of the above was not on Oahu, one was to a judge, another to a retired military officer,
It's not what you know it's who you know. ::)
In 2016
Hawaii county 6 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Kauai county 5 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Maui county 0 applications, 0 (0) approvals
Honolulu county 15 applications, 0 (0) approvals (2 of those were my household)
Entire state 26, applications, 0 (0) approvals
2017
I acquire a Utah CFP and Utah CFP Instructors license. :thumbsup:
No permits were issued since 2015, so those stats of 4 issued remain through 2019.
The 2 CCW permits in 2001 were from the Maui PD. They claim all records regarding those permits no longer exist and that no one in the department as of several years ago had any information or knowledge of who got them or what specific claim they made to be issued the permits.
The 2006 permit was on Kauai to a judge, and included multiple gross violations of the permitting law regarding length of permit validity (statutorily one year) and renewal procedures (statutorily apply 30 days prior to expiration).
The 2013 permit was also on Kauai and appears to have been issued to either a military member or a family member of a military member, and was withdrawn after 6 weeks.
I have photocopies of the two Kauai permit applications/approvals. It's obvious that law enforcement doesn't abide by the law at all on those extremely rare occasions when they have actually deemed someone eligible to exercise their right to bear arms for self-defense outside the home.
That's why it's gonna take an extremely deep and thorough court decision to force these third world good old boy police departments to actually abide by the Constitution. They ain't going willingly, and if there are any cracks or loopholes available, they will make sure to use them to deny us all our rights.
Hopefully a start: Young v Hawaii today at 10:30 AM:
(https://i.imgflip.com/4g6rz3.jpg)
-
(https://i.imgflip.com/4g6rz3.jpg)
In Drake v. Filko, the SAF handgun "carry" case out of New Jersey, the State of New Jersey filed supplemental briefing showing that year in and year out, New Jersey issued handgun carry permits to over 90% of the people who applied.
If this case goes to SCOTUS, Hawaii will say something along the lines of, "We only denied a few applications for handgun carry permits." And Hawaii won't be lying.
-
Would it help if we did a survey of gun owners asking if they would get a hawaii permit, why they haven't applied for one, and if they have an out of state permit?
-
Would it help if we did a survey of gun owners asking if they would get a hawaii permit, why they haven't applied for one, and if they have an out of state permit?
If by "help" you mean help Young's appeal? No.
-
this tells us all we need to know about you...
It certainly does. It tells you I am exactly the kind of person who fights for the Second Amendment. I am a person who is about to begin my 10th year of litigation in a Federal lawsuit to vindicate your Second Amendment right as well as the Second Amendment right of every other lazy whiner in the 9th circuit, and possibly the United States if my case goes before SCOTUS.
And unlike all of the so-called gun-rights lawyers who work for the so-called gun-rights groups, I am not going to collect even a dime in attorney fees for all of my efforts. Not even for the issues the State of California already conceded in my appeal.