2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: QUIETShooter on October 03, 2023, 12:14:23 PM
-
So as you all probably know, Keven McCarthy has been ousted as Speaker of the House. The pro tem speaker called for a recess and the future of congress is anyone's guess. Check out how the pro tem speaker slams the gavel down. I thought Thor came down from the heavens, LOL! He is a staunch supporter of McCarthy and obviously pissed off at a congressman named Gaetz.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oFkjtvK63Pk
Looks like the real work at hand ailing our country will be further kicked down the road.......
-
The House voted to eject Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) as leader Tuesday,
making him the first speaker in history to ever be removed after just 269 days
at the helm, following a rebellion among far-right lawmakers that serves as the
latest example of the deep divisions within the Republican Party.
Eight Republicans—Reps. Matt Gaetz (Fla.), Andy Biggs (Ariz.), Ken Buck (Colo.),
Tim Burchett (Tenn.), Eli Crane (Ariz.), Bob Good (Va.), Nancy Mace (S.C.) and
Matt Rosendale (Md.)—voted alongside all Democrats present to remove McCarthy,
who will remain a member of Congress despite his ouster from the speaker’s office.
“Chaos is somebody who we cannot trust with their word,” Gaetz said on the House
floor Tuesday. “I think $33 trillion in debt is chaos. I think that facing a $2.2 trillion
annual deficit is chaos. I think their not passing single-subject spending bills is chaos …
the way to liberate ourselves from that is a series of reforms to this body.”
https://www.forbes.com/sites/saradorn/2023/10/03/mccarthy-ousted-first-house-speaker-ever-booted-from-the-job/?sh=20ff2f3f606d
i agree with Gaetz when he says we need to stop these omnibus spending bills year after year. Nobody, even with a half dozen staffers, can do a deep dive into a more-than-5,000-page spending bill in the short time they are given and know how they should vote. It's a "take it or shut the government down" proposition every single year. No debate or revisions offered since nobody knows what's in the bill except how much they each get for their individual states. That's all that matters -- pork for the next reelection campaign. Look at the ads from our own Congress-critters touting how much money they "procured" for Hawaii. Knowing that is all borrowed deficit spending is just sickening.
The Swamp is a non-partisan group. Anybody putting their personal wealth and career ahead of the country's best interests is accepted.
-
Panicked McCarthy Looks For Fire Alarm
(https://i.imgur.com/zU2mwyv.jpg)
https://babylonbee.com/news/panicked-mccarthy-looks-for-a-fire-alarm
-
This could backfire in the 2024 elections where we lose the presidency. Gaetz is a Trump supporter but Trump criticized the move today.
I don't see how this benefits us since we don't control the presidency nor senate. It's not a good time to do something like this with the small republican majority in Congress. Should wait till 2025 to make those big changes
I see a worse spending bill being passed with democrat support which defeats the purpose of this.
-
45 days clicking away.
CR's are becoming the norm and has been since the 90's.
Sad state of affairs. Instead of fixing our nation they will now be pre-occupied with finding a new Speaker.
What's nuts is McCarthy can throw his hat in the ring again when the nominations start.
What really is going to be nuts is if he somehow gets re-elected. Again. By making deals. Again.
And again. And again........Wasted time. Wasted money. Swamp gets bigger, deeper, and stinker.
Meanwhile the can got kicked so far down the road nobody can see it anymore. So they go ahead and pass another CR.......
edited to add: Just read a Newsweek article stating that McCarthy will not seek the Speaker position anymore.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/kevin-mccarthy-has-harsh-words-for-the-republicans-who-ousted-him/ar-AA1hF1PN?ocid=msedgdhp&pc=U531&cvid=03a39c42f2e84bd1b892b3ca36de032f&ei=41#image=1
-
What's nuts is McCarthy can throw his hat in the ring again when the nominations start.
What really is going to be nuts is if he somehow gets re-elected. Again. By making deals. Again.
There's no one else that can be voted in as speaker. That's how it was when McCarthy was voted in, just barely after weeks of chaos.
It will be chaotic in the House and democrats will use it to their advantage in 2024. That's why all the democrats voted with Gaetz to oust McCarthy.
Gaetz essentially was working for the democrats in a way
-
The uniparty got a kick in the nuts today, and while that's an excellent turn of events it's no cause for celebration.
Right now they are reeling with rage and terror trying to figure out how to keep their Ukranian money laundering scheme going.
Most Americans are tossing out their yellow and blue flags after realizing it was just another con job.
The populist revolt is picking up momentum, and now we wait to see what kind of "emergency" comes up next in order to try and stop it.
-
This could backfire in the 2024 elections where we lose the presidency.
You are assuming there will be a 2024 election
-
There's no one else that can be voted in as speaker. That's how it was when McCarthy was voted in, just barely after weeks of chaos.
It will be chaotic in the House and democrats will use it to their advantage in 2024. That's why all the democrats voted with Gaetz to oust McCarthy.
Gaetz essentially was working for the democrats in a way
Actually, Gaetz is working for the people. He showed the GOP that a weak majority is no majority if they are unwilling to act differently than the Democrats.
IMO, it's McCarthy who's been working for the Democrats. That's why the effort to impeach Biden has been moving like cold molasses.
The Dems were impeding Trump at every turn, most immediately by beating him to death with records requests in the FBI/Mueller Russia3 probes/investigations/hoax. So far, the House Republicans haven't done much to curtail Biden and the Ukraine spending.
-
if mccarthy were working for the dems, why did they all vote to oust him?
(kind of a rhetorical question, i guess. because they voted to oust him to cause chaos and make the GOP look bad...)
Actually, Gaetz is working for the people. He showed the GOP that a weak majority is no majority if they are unwilling to act differently than the Democrats.
IMO, it's McCarthy who's been working for the Democrats. That's why the effort to impeach Biden has been moving like cold molasses.
The Dems were impeding Trump at every turn, most immediately by beating him to death with records requests in the FBI/Mueller Russia3 probes/investigations/hoax. So far, the House Republicans haven't done much to curtail Biden and the Ukraine spending.
-
Pretty confusing to me as to how the democrats are maneuvering through this.
Somehow I was thinking, what would really make the GOP look bad and dysfunctional is if the democrats actually foiled the attempt to oust McCarthy by voting to keep him Speaker.
Somehow make it look like the Dems are the adults and the GOP are the pouting mid-teens throwing tantrums.
But we all know the Dems hate McCarthy and their minority leader put the word out to oust him.
We the people are the losers. I understand where Gaetz and those other 7 or so Republicans are coming from but I wonder if this is the right time to be doing this. One can argue that this is as good a time as any to stop irresponsible pkg. deal budgets where one can hide all kinds of BS in the 1000's of pages of the Bill and have only a day or two to vote on it.
I do wonder about McCarthy's trustworthiness but Gaetz is no Boy Scout either.
-
When he was placed there, some GOP members didnt want to vote for him. Which is why it took so long. They then casted yes, but told him he was on a short leash to prove hes not a RINO. IIRC, bohbert was 1. She mentioned no more 5000 page bill with hidden, non related things.
She voted not to oust him.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
if mccarthy were working for the dems, why did they all vote to oust him?
(kind of a rhetorical question, i guess. because they voted to oust him to cause chaos and make the GOP look bad...)
The same reason the Dems always vote as a block: they were all told to.
If your question is why would they do decide to do that, because they are trying to stoke the fires of disorganization and use it to their advantage in the election.
What has McCarthy done since becoming speaker to disprove my theory?
-
unless the Dems have something to leverage over Gaetz... I think they do.
-
I’ll take a little chaos if it means change for the better. The establishment uniparty is what is killing this country in the first place.
The abysmal 2022 election for the republicans was a blessing in disguise. If Mcarthy had more support he would’ve never agreed to terms that curbed his power. They’d be voting on one massive spending bill that benefitted no one but the elites.
I 100% Back Gaetz.
-
Actually, Gaetz is working for the people. He showed the GOP that a weak majority is no majority if they are unwilling to act differently than the Democrats.
Seems more like Gaetz is upset he isn't getting everything he wanted. He is letting perfect be the enemy of good. McCarthy was seeking to cut government spending of about 8%. Maybe not ideal but still decent. Now the House will be in turmoil again when it tries to pick another speaker and democrats will use that to their advantage. Great going Gaetz...
-
He is letting perfect be the enemy of good.
If a wide open border, 33 trillion in the hole, and pending nuclear confrontation with Russia are "good" then give me whatever the opposite of that is, please.
-
If a wide open border, 33 trillion in the hole, and pending nuclear confrontation with Russia are "good" then give me whatever the opposite of that is, please.
Take the abortion issue for example. The hard core want a complete ban on elective abortions. The moderates want a ban after the first trimester. Don't cooperate and you get no restrictions at all and the end results are more abortions than either side wanted.
An 8% reduction in spending does more to reduce the debt than does anything the democrats would do. Not sure what Russia has to do with this, that gorilla is looming no matter what we do.
-
https://youtu.be/Ph1Qlwn1QT8
-
The political chess game being played out right now goes way over my head.
I really appreciate all you guys input whether for or against what is happening now. It helps me try to make sense of it all. If one ever can, really.
But yeah. Interesting. I'm really concerned about that can they kicked way down the road. I read somewhere a comment that said that congress is the only job in the world where you can put off important issues for another day. And another. And....yeah, it's a great job. Try doing that in the private sector.
So all congress does is agree upon another CR......
-
What was the plan to make this effective and ensure lower spending in the future? Who did Gaetz want to take over as Speaker?
Usually when you do these kinds of things you have a clear plan to succeed.
-
So Pelosi, the former speaker was in a "speaker of the house" type of 2ndary office. Even though her role ended months ago. The new temporary speaker of the house gave her a notice to vacate within the first day on the job. IDK what the common practice is for someone who was speaker for years to move back to a normal office.
I think that the boot is sending a message to the GOP that if you're in a role that they vote for, then you need to fullfill enough promises or you will get the boot. That's how it should be, do you job or get fired.
***IDK what role the speaker has in said promises or if the person even has any control over it as I never looked into the matter. But going on face value to assume the speaker does have control is my opinions in this thread. It would be silly to boot someone who has zero control over the matters. Unless said person didn't even try.
-
Take the abortion issue for example. The hard core want a complete ban on elective abortions. The moderates want a ban after the first trimester. Don't cooperate and you get no restrictions at all and the end results are more abortions than either side wanted.
An 8% reduction in spending does more to reduce the debt than does anything the democrats would do. Not sure what Russia has to do with this, that gorilla is looming no matter what we do.
Yeah so instead of going 70 mph over the cliff we would’ve gone 50 mph. They’re both shit sandwiches no matter what. McCarthy lied and tried to bully the more conservative wing of the Republican Party by using shutdown politics to force them to vote. Good riddance.
-
What was the plan to make this effective and ensure lower spending in the future? Who did Gaetz want to take over as Speaker?
Usually when you do these kinds of things you have a clear plan to succeed.
The plan is to hold people in power to their word. How is allowing a speaker of the house who doesn’t keep to their word ensure a balanced budget, spending cuts, and lower debt? Politics as usual is what got us here in the first place.
Winning elections at this point doesn’t really matter. With republicans like McCarthy who needs democrats?
-
So Pelosi, the former speaker was in a "speaker of the house" type of 2ndary office. Even though her role ended months ago. The new temporary speaker of the house gave her a notice to vacate within the first day on the job. IDK what the common practice is for someone who was speaker for years to move back to a normal office.
I think that the boot is sending a message to the GOP that if you're in a role that they vote for, then you need to fullfill enough promises or you will get the boot. That's how it should be, do you job or get fired.
***IDK what role the speaker has in said promises or if the person even has any control over it as I never looked into the matter. But going on face value to assume the speaker does have control is my opinions in this thread. It would be silly to boot someone who has zero control over the matters. Unless said person didn't even try.
First of all, Senators all get a "hide away" office separate from their normal office so they can take time to to catch up on things or, of course, do those back-door, under-the-table meetings that really get things done in DC.
Only certain high-ranking members of the House are afforded the same hide-away office. The Speaker is obviously higher-up than the rest, so they not only have a second office, but they get to decide who else has one.
Second, i think the Speaker Pro Tem should have waited until Pelosi was back in DC. She said she accompanied Senator Feinstein's body to CA and attended the burial services. As a fellow CA elected official in Congress, I'm sure it was her responsibility to be as involved in the state ceremonies as possible.
Assigning or vacating those special office spaces is 100% up to the Speaker of the House. Pelosi said she gave her predecessor as Speaker (Dennis Hastert - R) the use of his office for as long as he wanted it. That was her choice.
I don't know what tradition is in this situation, but something tells me it's different for each Speaker depending on their needs. Perhaps this House now has more committees or other positions in need of that space than existed in 2007?
Regardless, I think they could have waited a few days rather than evicting her on the new Speaker's first day.
Anytime something like this happens, it creates a higher likelihood that the next time the Speaker's gavel changes parties, the same treatment will be used on the next ex-Speaker.
This should have never been a news item. It only hurts the GOP as a whole and the House majority even more.
-
First of all, Senators all get a "hide away" office separate from their normal office so they can take time to to catch up on things or, of course, do those back-door, under-the-table meetings that really get things done in DC.
Only certain high-ranking members of the House are afforded the same hide-away office. The Speaker is obviously higher-up than the rest, so they not only have a second office, but they get to decide who else has one.
Second, i think the Speaker Pro Tem should have waited until Pelosi was back in DC. She said she accompanied Senator Feinstein's body to CA and attended the burial services. As a fellow CA elected official in Congress, I'm sure it was her responsibility to be as involved in the state ceremonies as possible.
Assigning or vacating those special office spaces is 100% up to the Speaker of the House. Pelosi said she gave her predecessor as Speaker (Dennis Hastert - R) the use of his office for as long as he wanted it. That was her choice.
I don't know what tradition is in this situation, but something tells me it's different for each Speaker depending on their needs. Perhaps this House now has more committees or other positions in need of that space than existed in 2007?
Regardless, I think they could have waited a few days rather than evicting her on the new Speaker's first day.
Anytime something like this happens, it creates a higher likelihood that the next time the Speaker's gavel changes parties, the same treatment will be used on the next ex-Speaker.
This should have never been a news item. It only hurts the GOP as a whole and the House majority even more.
Thanks for the info. So the boot does sound political. But it doesn't bother me as Pelosi tries to take my right away all the time.
-
Thanks for the info. So the boot does sound political. But it doesn't bother me as Pelosi tries to take my right away all the time.
Sometimes doing what makes you feel good isn't the best thing for you.
if they really needed the space, they could have had their own staffers box her stuff up and secure it somewhere. She could have then had her stuff moved out when she returned. That would have made the whole thing look less like a petty jab and more like a bonafide need for the space.
Just sayin'.
-
Sometimes doing what makes you feel good isn't the best thing for you.
if they really needed the space, they could have had their own staffers box her stuff up and secure it somewhere. She could have then had her stuff moved out when she returned. That would have made the whole thing look less like a petty jab and more like a bonafide need for the space.
Just sayin'.
Pelosi and her lemmings already try to screw me and America, so can't get any worst.
-
Pelosi and her lemmings already try to screw me and America, so can't get any worst.
Help me out.
How did vacating her from that office change anything Pelosi did, or in the future may do, to you and America?
-
Help me out.
How did vacating her from that office change anything Pelosi did, or in the future may do, to you and America?
It showed that we have someone in charge who isn't afraid to give someone the boot to make a statement. Even if it's only temporary.
-
It showed that we have someone in charge who isn't afraid to give someone the boot to make a statement. Even if it's only temporary.
Once again, how does "making a statement" change what's she's already done?
What's the statement? Do what we think you should, or we'll take your office -- which 95% of House members don't even have?
-
Once again, how does "making a statement" change what's she's already done?
What's the statement? Do what we think you should, or we'll take your office -- which 95% of House members don't even have?
You cannot change what someone has already done, unless you own a time machine. But then, if you did go back in time to change said action, then why would 1 have to go back in time if said action didn't occur? So was the time travel successful? Or is there an alternate timeline created that you retain the information of what took place, but no one else does since it's been changed.
IMO, the statement is that her job is over so she gets the boot. She is no longer in a powerful position to retain a special office.
-
You cannot change what someone has already done, unless you own a time machine. But then, if you did go back in time to change said action, then why would 1 have to go back in time if said action didn't occur? So was the time travel successful? Or is there an alternate timeline created that you retain the information of what took place, but no one else does since it's been changed.
IMO, the statement is that her job is over so she gets the boot. She is no longer in a powerful position to retain a special office.
Taking a government-owned office from a mega-millionaire who spent years as the 3rd in line to be president is a weak statement.
Most people aren't that invested in having an office.
-
Taking a government-owned office from a mega-millionaire who spent years as the 3rd in line to be president is a weak statement.
Most people aren't that invested in having an office.
Can you name another time that a statement was made to Pelosi? Although small, it's the concept that counts. Like when she ripped up Trumps speech at his SOTU.
-
What was the plan to make this effective and ensure lower spending in the future? Who did Gaetz want to take over as Speaker?
Usually when you do these kinds of things you have a clear plan to succeed.
Some people just want to watch the world burn?
I am quite idealistic but even I know sometimes you have to compromise.
-
Yeah so instead of going 70 mph over the cliff we would’ve gone 50 mph. They’re both shit sandwiches no matter what. McCarthy lied and tried to bully the more conservative wing of the Republican Party by using shutdown politics to force them to vote. Good riddance.
And where would we be otherwise? Government shut down, angry voters, give ammo to democrats?
It is a physical impossibility to make everyone on one side of the aisle happy on something like this.
-
And where would we be otherwise? Government shut down, angry voters, give ammo to democrats?
It is a physical impossibility to make everyone on one side of the aisle happy on something like this.
What do you mean where would we be? McCarthy had 9 months to put together single subject bills to fund the parts of the government that mattered. He didn’t want to do that because he’s a corrupt piece if shit and he tried to snake his way into another Omnibus bill to further put us into debt like politics as usual. It’s not like this popped up out of no where, he agreed to it from the start.
-
Can you name another time that a statement was made to Pelosi? Although small, it's the concept that counts. Like when she ripped up Trumps speech at his SOTU.
Statement from whom? There were a few from Trump (cancelling her military air for a boondoggle shortly before she was to depart).
As Speaker, there are going to be conflict situations, like with the radical progressives in the "Squad". In just a few months, they stopped sniping at Pelosi and learned to shut up and color.
Saying someone is "making a statement" would mean more of we didn't have to be told they are making a statement.
-
I am quite idealistic but even I know sometimes you have to compromise.
We’re comprised enough already
-
What do you mean where would we be? McCarthy had 9 months to put together single subject bills to fund the parts of the government that mattered. He didn’t want to do that because he’s a corrupt piece if shit and he tried to snake his way into another Omnibus bill to further put us into debt like politics as usual. It’s not like this popped up out of no where, he agreed to it from the start.
And what would have happened if that bill cut too much spending for the more moderate republicans and they voted no? Republicans only have a slim majority, it only takes a few republicans to block a bill. What do you think should have been different about the spending bill which would have made everyone happy?
-
We’re comprised enough already
Are you saying we're included? composed?
:geekdanc: :shaka:
-
Some people just want to watch the world burn?
I am quite idealistic but even I know sometimes you have to compromise.
"I am quite idealistic but even I know sometimes you have to compromise."
I'm on very thin ice on this site at the moment.
That being said, compromise only works if you are dealing with people
ethical enough to honor their words. That is a rare quality in modern
USA lop sided politics.
-
And what would have happened if that bill cut too much spending for the more moderate republicans and they voted no? Republicans only have a slim majority, it only takes a few republicans to block a bill. What do you think should have been different about the spending bill which would have made everyone happy?
It's understandable why you would want to believe there is some way to work this out. Uncertainty can be terrifying, especially when it comes to existential national crises.
These are criminals, however, and we need to peel back their fingers form the levers of power and stop them from doing more damage before they kill us all.
-
Are you saying we're included? composed?
:geekdanc: :shaka:
compromised
just like the spell check bots
-
It seemed like there was no real plan after the move to oust McCarthy.
More like a punishment move and then after that was accomplished, look around and then say, "ok, now that that is done, where do we go from here.....?"
Seems like it anyway.
-
It's understandable why you would want to believe there is some way to work this out. Uncertainty can be terrifying, especially when it comes to existential national crises.
These are criminals, however, and we need to peel back their fingers form the levers of power and stop them from doing more damage before they kill us all.
You didn't answer the question though. It is easy to complain about their failure but often much harder to say how it could have been done so much better
-
It seemed like there was no real plan after the move to oust McCarthy.
More like a punishment move and then after that was accomplished, look around and then say, "ok, now that that is done, where do we go from here.....?"
Seems like it anyway.
And democrats are going to use that to their advantage.
-
It seemed like there was no real plan after the move to oust McCarthy.
More like a punishment move and then after that was accomplished, look around and then say, "ok, now that that is done, where do we go from here.....?"
Seems like it anyway.
That was the plan. in the beginning, the GOP reps who kept not voting for McCarthy used their votes to leverage some concessions, one of which was a rule change that allowed a single member to call for a vote of no confidence to oust the Speaker.
Gaetz's plan worked. He knew McCarthy would not keep his word about changing he budgeting process, so he played that "no confidence" card. What happens after is not something he should have to plan. There are processes in place to elect a new Speaker and appoint a temporary replacement in the meantime.
There were others nominated in the votes before McCarthy won. I'm sure those names are already being talked about, like Jim Jordon and Steve Scalise.
The vacancy could have been filled by Friday, but the Speaker Pro Tem decided to give everyone a week off instead.
Our tax dollars at work.
-
And what would have happened if that bill cut too much spending for the more moderate republicans and they voted no? Republicans only have a slim majority, it only takes a few republicans to block a bill. What do you think should have been different about the spending bill which would have made everyone happy?
Stop deflecting from the actual issue. This is not about spending cuts, it’s about mccarthy not holding to his word. If Mccarthy put up a single subject bill and got every republicans vote except Gaetz we wouldn’t be talking about this. Gaetz would have zero support to oust him as speaker. How are you just ignoring the fact that McCarthy planned the entire time to remit his deal he made to become speaker? HES the one who made the deal with no intention of honoring it knowing full well that he could be ousted at any point yet he still chose to fuck around, and now he found out.
-
The omnibus spending bill has become a symptom of a Congress unable to do their jobs.
There are 12 appropriation bills that are supposed to come from the 12 House subcommittees that appropriate funding for all the discretionary programs and expenses Congress wants to support.
When Congress fails to pass individual appropriations bills, the bills will be rolled up into an omnibus bill that only requires one vote to pass it.
Ask yourself, if the individual bills were not good enough to be passed on their own merits, why should they be automatically passed as part of the omnibus bill? Just to avert a government shutdown?
If Congress could actually do their job and pass a budget by end of Summer, this annual government shutdown on October 1st would cease, and the budget would be less of "everything including the kitchen sink".
-
The omnibus spending bill has become a symptom of a Congress unable to do their jobs.
There are 12 appropriation bills that are supposed to come from the 12 House subcommittees that appropriate funding for all the discretionary programs and expenses Congress wants to support.
When Congress fails to pass individual appropriations bills, the bills will be rolled up into an omnibus bill that only requires one vote to pass it.
Ask yourself, if the individual bills were not good enough to be passed on their own merits, why should they be automatically passed as part of the omnibus bill? Just to avert a government shutdown?
If Congress could actually do their job and pass a budget by end of Summer, this annual government shutdown on October 1st would cease, and the budget would be less of "everything including the kitchen sink".
You obviously have never been sailing.
Pissing into the wind is not a good idea.
Congress ceased to work around 1964.
LJB was elected. Vietnam BS accelerated and
Democrats rioted.
They run the Kublai show now.
:wtf: :grrr:
-
The omnibus spending bill has become a symptom of a Congress unable to do their jobs.
There are 12 appropriation bills that are supposed to come from the 12 House subcommittees that appropriate funding for all the discretionary programs and expenses Congress wants to support.
When Congress fails to pass individual appropriations bills, the bills will be rolled up into an omnibus bill that only requires one vote to pass it.
Ask yourself, if the individual bills were not good enough to be passed on their own merits, why should they be automatically passed as part of the omnibus bill? Just to avert a government shutdown?
If Congress could actually do their job and pass a budget by end of Summer, this annual government shutdown on October 1st would cease, and the budget would be less of "everything including the kitchen sink".
Don't forget sometimes 5000 page bills are given to the voters a few hours prior to the vote.
-
Pretty interesting video to watch.
They talked about how Shumer brought up non-essential appropriations for vote on the Senate floor instead of the more pressing issues that needed to be addressed. Makes you wonder about things and the intricacies of how politics work.
Seems like the House busts their asses to form an appropriations bill, then send it to the Senate where those pompous old farts just sit on it.
But I think if they pushed to present these bills way ahead of the closing deadline things would have gone smoother. What's been happening lately is these appropriation bills are submitted too close to the deadlines and the scheduling for hearings on the floor gets all bottled up.
Kinda like when we were in High School and we studied for our final exams a half hour before.
OMG. Congress is just like High School.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKEV66wdyHw
-
Don't forget sometimes 5000 page bills are given to the voters a few hours prior to the vote.
I wish I'd said that.
Oh, wait!
...
i agree with Gaetz when he says we need to stop these omnibus spending bills year after year.
Nobody, even with a half dozen staffers, can do a deep dive into a more-than-5,000-page
spending bill in the short time they are given and know how they should vote."
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=51278.msg462621#msg462621
:geekdanc: :shaka:
-
Stop deflecting from the actual issue. This is not about spending cuts, it’s about mccarthy not holding to his word. If Mccarthy put up a single subject bill and got every republicans vote except Gaetz we wouldn’t be talking about this. Gaetz would have zero support to oust him as speaker. How are you just ignoring the fact that McCarthy planned the entire time to remit his deal he made to become speaker? HES the one who made the deal with no intention of honoring it knowing full well that he could be ousted at any point yet he still chose to fuck around, and now he found out.
What parts of his deal did he fail to live up to?
-
Don't forget sometimes 5000 page bills are given to the voters a few hours prior to the vote.
I think we need some sort of law which prohibits massive bills that cover lots of things. Make it so that any bill can only cover one particular subject. Not a bill that has everything from rules for schools to environmental rules to military rules to criminal law changes, etc.
-
A couple of decades ago, if Congress was unable to reconcile the full budget by 1 Oct, they would vote to pass as many of the 12 bills as possible before the deadline. That normally kept the military employed, the Social Security checks printing, and the government operating.
Now that the omnibus bills have become the norm as opposed to the last resort before a shutdown, It's become a cudgel with which to force House and Senate members to pass the bill or be blamed for a shutdown.
There's a reason Congress only has an 11% approval rating among voters.
-
I wonder if that 11% are our country's oligarchs. ;D
-
I wonder if that 11% are our country's oligarchs. ;D
I was thinking lobbyists...
-
What parts of his deal did he fail to live up to?
Read his post again.
-
I was thinking lobbyists...
Ah yes. I overlooked these guys.
-
You didn't answer the question though. It is easy to complain about their failure but often much harder to say how it could have been done so much better
That’s like asking me to give advice to armed robbers about how to be kinder and gentler when they steal our money.
I’d rather cheer on the guy who lets the air out of the tires of their getaway car
-
That’s like asking me to give advice to armed robbers about how to be kinder and gentler when they steal our money.
I’d rather cheer on the guy who lets the air out of the tires of their getaway car
If I hire someone for $176,000 a year (plus sweetheart pension and lifetime retirement benefits), I have a right to say I'm not satisfied with the job they are doing.
And if they reply, "Well, if you think you can do any better, go ahead!" I'm going to be looking for someone else who hopefully knows what the hell they are doing.
Imagine a 56 year old, 35 year career sports coach telling a 20 year old player not to drop their shoulder, keep their eye on the ball, do a few more laps, etc. Then imagine if a player tells the coach, "Why don't you show me how to do it?" That player isn't going to be in the rotation schedule for long.
It's a childish, emotional backlash to tell someone complaining about your work to "go do it yourself if you want it done better." Most of these Congress critters went to Harvard, Yale, Princeton, or other Ivy :League university and have law degrees or went on to finish medical school. They are almost all highly educated and campaigned for the job they now have. If they can't get the results they PROMISED US, then they don't deserve to be getting that paycheck and all those sweet benefits that go along with it.
i'm sure there are some on this forum who have no problem pretending they know everything they need to know to tell someone how they should be doing their jobs -- there seems to be a lot of opinions on how to run the military from people with no military experience. Rather than come up with a solution of our own, it makes more sense to hire someone new or contract with consultants who have the skills and experience to get the job done right.
-
The issue is how do you reduce the budget effectively. You can fire congressmen and scream for it, but it's not going to happen and you end up going backward instead of forward. The budget was cut under McCarthy which is good considering the President and Senate are under Democrat control, and the House has a very slim majority. The chaos created in Congress isn't going to help bring down the budget, rather there's a chance it actually increases the budget. Would you trade firing McCarthy for a democrat president, house, and senate in 2024?
The chaos it created will turn off Independants and moderate Republicans where some won't vote in 2024. It's going to be a close race for the Presidency, House and Senate and every vote is needed. If a government shutdown occurs the Republicans will be blamed and you'll have Federal workers, military servicemenbers, and businesses with government contracts not getting paid. They'll get backpaid when the shutdown is over, but that military family isn't going to be happy when they don't get a paycheck for a month or two.
The other issue is it takes the focus away from Biden and Democrats bumbles. 100% of the spotlight should be on their mistakes, not the Republicans creating their own chaos. That's one of the reasons why Trump lost and Redwave didn't happen in 2020 and 2022.
A balanced budget takes time to accomplish and there's many difficulties with it. First you need to win the Presidency, Senate, and House by a good margin. To do that, you need the votes from the people. But you lose votes if you make major cuts in spending or increase taxes. Everyone wants lower spending as long as it doesn't affect themselves. The most conservative Republican's will be pissed if you cut their social security check or they lose their job.
Cuts can be made, but it has to be over time or else you lose votes. If you piss off too many people, they'll just vote the other way and reinstate spending again.
-
Stop deflecting from the actual issue. This is not about spending cuts, it’s about mccarthy not holding to his word. If Mccarthy put up a single subject bill and got every republicans vote except Gaetz we wouldn’t be talking about this. Gaetz would have zero support to oust him as speaker. How are you just ignoring the fact that McCarthy planned the entire time to remit his deal he made to become speaker? HES the one who made the deal with no intention of honoring it knowing full well that he could be ousted at any point yet he still chose to fuck around, and now he found out.
McCarthy has been attempting to pass single bills but can't get the Republican votes to pass them, much less getting the votes in the Senate. He only has 4 votes to spare, or in other words, he needs 98.5% agreement with the cuts they're proposing. Thats a very difficult task. We can't get that type of agreement in the 2A community for 2A stuff.
-
Business as usual is not going to fix this. Multiple layers of our government have gone rogue and/or have been infiltrated by the Chinese Communist Party.
Way too many people live in an echo chamber where they have no idea how bad things have gotten in the real world. Someone has to shock them out of their trance.
This "chaos" is absolutely necessary, because if we don't hit the reset button now the consequence down the road will be even worse.
If you have enough cash on hand to ride out the current inflationary economic death spiral without experiencing significant lifestyle changes then good for you.
Your turn to feel the burn is coming however, just like everyone else who counts their wealth in dollars.
-
You obviously have never been sailing.
Pissing into the wind is not a good idea.
Congress ceased to work around 1964.
LJB was elected. Vietnam BS accelerated and
Democrats rioted.
They run the Kublai show now.
:wtf: :grrr:
I'm going to defer to your expertise and experience on that one!
:D
-
The issue is how do you reduce the budget effectively. You can fire congressmen and scream for it, but it's not going to happen and you end up going backward instead of forward. The budget was cut under McCarthy which is good considering the President and Senate are under Democrat control, and the House has a very slim majority. The chaos created in Congress isn't going to help bring down the budget, rather there's a chance it actually increases the budget. Would you trade firing McCarthy for a democrat president, house, and senate in 2024?
The chaos it created will turn off Independants and moderate Republicans where some won't vote in 2024. It's going to be a close race for the Presidency, House and Senate and every vote is needed. If a government shutdown occurs the Republicans will be blamed and you'll have Federal workers, military servicemenbers, and businesses with government contracts not getting paid. They'll get backpaid when the shutdown is over, but that military family isn't going to be happy when they don't get a paycheck for a month or two.
The other issue is it takes the focus away from Biden and Democrats bumbles. 100% of the spotlight should be on their mistakes, not the Republicans creating their own chaos. That's one of the reasons why Trump lost and Redwave didn't happen in 2020 and 2022.
A balanced budget takes time to accomplish and there's many difficulties with it. First you need to win the Presidency, Senate, and House by a good margin. To do that, you need the votes from the people. But you lose votes if you make major cuts in spending or increase taxes. Everyone wants lower spending as long as it doesn't affect themselves. The most conservative Republican's will be pissed if you cut their social security check or they lose their job.
Cuts can be made, but it has to be over time or else you lose votes. If you piss off too many people, they'll just vote the other way and reinstate spending again.
"If you piss off too many people, they'll just vote the other way and reinstate spending again."
You point out the biggest problem in our system - people that don't pay the bills can vote.
The 16th amendment killed America.
:grrr:
-
I'm going to defer to your expertise and experience on that one!
:D
A mistake a 5 year old learned.
:shaka:
-
Could it be that these 8 GOP members are saying "Enough Already". Stop the same old same old. At the risk of shutting the government down.
Remove the Speaker. At the worst time in my opinion. When the nation is on the brink of not being funded with no progress in sight. Elect a new Speaker that will change the same old, same old.
However, for the Republican majority, how is this going to win them over? If the republican majority felt the same way as those 8 GOP individuals, why did the GOP majority vote to keep McCarthy as Speaker?
Maybe the Republican majority do feel the same way but felt the timing was wrong? Was that it?
Interesting stuff. Next week should be a doozy.
-
Could it be that these 8 GOP members are saying "Enough Already". Stop the same old same old. At the risk of shutting the government down.
Remove the Speaker. At the worst time in my opinion. When the nation is on the brink of not being funded with no progress in sight. Elect a new Speaker that will change the same old, same old.
However, for the Republican majority, how is this going to win them over? If the republican majority felt the same way as those 8 GOP individuals, why did the GOP majority vote to keep McCarthy as Speaker?
Maybe the Republican majority do feel the same way but felt the timing was wrong? Was that it?
Interesting stuff. Next week should be a doozy.
McCarthy is the fundraising machine for the Republican Party. They are beholden to him so they can be re elected,Which is the entire problem with our politics. They worry more about their next election cycle than they do the country.
-
McCarthy has been attempting to pass single bills but can't get the Republican votes to pass them, much less getting the votes in the Senate. He only has 4 votes to spare, or in other words, he needs 98.5% agreement with the cuts they're proposing. Thats a very difficult task. We can't get that type of agreement in the 2A community for 2A stuff.
Yeah I hear you zippz and I’m not saying that the speakership is an easy task. However our country is $33 trillion in debt and something has to change. A nominal 10% reduction in spending may have been “good enough” when the deficit was running at $1 million and the debt was at $2 trillion. But a 10% reduction running at $2 trillion deficit and $33 trillion in debt is absolutely nothing. You’re taking one shovel of dirt out of a hole while 10 scoops get thrown right back on top of you.
A balanced budget should be 1st priority among both parties and we as citizens should not accept anything less. At this point I don’t even really care for republicans, they spend just like democrats do. If we can’t even expect the party who’s supposed to be fiscally conservative to agree on hardline fiscal policies then this country is done.
-
Yeah I hear you zippz and I’m not saying that the speakership is an easy task. However our country is $33 trillion in debt and something has to change. A nominal 10% reduction in spending may have been “good enough” when the deficit was running at $1 million and the debt was at $2 trillion. But a 10% reduction running at $2 trillion deficit and $33 trillion in debt is absolutely nothing. You’re taking one shovel of dirt out of a hole while 10 scoops get thrown right back on top of you.
A balanced budget should be 1st priority among both parties and we as citizens should not accept anything less. At this point I don’t even really care for republicans, they spend just like democrats do. If we can’t even expect the party who’s supposed to be fiscally conservative to agree on hardline fiscal policies then this country is done.
He should do single item bills and if they all fail, then it's easy to blame it on those who voted no. Would it cause more harm than good at the specific time, maybe. But in the long run, the excuse that nothing will get done will always then be present. And no change will ever take place.
Our government has to get back to making things simpler, like no more 5000 page bills and give only a few hours to read and understand it.
He is more concerned about reelection than doing what's best for our country and it's time for a change. This is what happens when there are no term limits.
-
Many here are old enough to remember the Clinton years and the GOP's Contract with America.
That's when the House (under Newt's leadership) let the government shutdown for 3-4 months. in the aftermath, the bills that had to be paid, like military and other gov't employee salaries, were paid. Some had banks that were nice enough to cover checks written in that time and take the funds back incrementally as the customer got paid.
One thing that came out of that is we actually had a balanced budget. Only spending 3 quarters of the discretionary budget was at that time enough to erase the deficit.
Of course, Slick Willy made sure to take 100% credit for that, even though it never would have been balanced without shutting down part of government and keeping that money in the treasury.
That ties into something else many may not be old enough to know -- or just didn't know because they aren't associated with the military. I believe it was around FY 1987 when the geniuses decided to lower spending in one fiscal year by shifing military and DoD government employees' paychecks from the last day of the month to the first day.
This had the effect of eliminating the Sept 30 payday completely in the year they needed to reduce spending, and paying that money the following fiscal year.
It was accounting smoke and mirrors. No money was saved, and all the people getting a DoD paycheck had to make accommodations to pay their bills without that end of September paycheck. One day sounds trivial unless you need that money to pay a bill that's due 30 Sep. Many people would mail checks 2-3 days before payday to make their payment deadlines knowing the checks won't get cashed before payday. This shift hurt those people even more.
Anyway, it illustrates the stupidity that can come from DC just to juggle the books and make it look like they aren't doing as terrible a job budgeting as they actually are.
-
"Hello, Guard? There must be some kind of mistake. I'm not supposed to be in the re-education camp..... I'm one of the conservatives who tried to compromise with the Democrats!"
https://legalinsurrection.com/2023/10/hillary-calls-for-deprogramming-trump-supporters/
(https://media.tenor.com/yk0yFyQOg0UAAAAC/lol-hillary.gif)
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2I1vCYnfJ6M
They figured this week. Maybe next week?
You know, Speaker?
If and when they do decide on Speaker, the Israeli crisis will take precedence. The spending bills that are to keep the lights on in this country will be kicked so far down the road they will need blood hounds to find it.........
With all that's happening around the world and in congress this ABBA song keeps playing in my head. The beginning lyrics are pretty interesting too.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lamri2KlgrY
-
Oh well. Looks like Jim Jordan will drop out as nominee for speaker also. So two weeks went by and nothing was done in congress.
But the fackahs got paid. Maybe we should pass legislation that their pay is dependent on performance and timely governance results.
Maybe that would light a flame up their asses.
I even read that they are planning to draw this crap out juuuuust before the CR runs out in November before electing a speaker and getting back to doing their f*ckn jobs.
In other words, same old, same old and another lump legislation that nobody really vetted gets passed while the American sheeple continue to fund the corrupt swamp called US government.
government my ass. :grrr:
-
With no GOP speaker, woul dthis mean that the budget bill to Israel and Ukraine is on pause?
-
Damn Matt Gaetz started some shit :rofl:
He exposed the corrupt republican establishment better than Trump did. Watching all those republicans simp for McCarthy so they can beg him for his donations to their campaigns is hilarious.
-
Damn Matt Gaetz started some shit :rofl:
He exposed the corrupt republican establishment better than Trump did. Watching all those republicans simp for McCarthy so they can beg him for his donations to their campaigns is hilarious.
It's definitely one of those pants around the ankles kind of moments
(https://media.tenor.com/vCEMkiXSquYAAAAC/stmlch.gif)
-
Yep. Worrying about re-election is more important than serving as a congress member and administering your oath of office.
There is one congresswoman that already declared she will retire and not seek re-election in 2025. She said Congress is Broken.
No sh*t, Sherlock.
-
Yep. Worrying about re-election is more important than serving as a congress member and administering your oath of office.
There is one congresswoman that already declared she will retire and not seek re-election in 2025. She said Congress is Broken.
No sh*t, Sherlock.
That's been my complaint since I started watching politics. Our "representatives" start their reelection campaigns the day after they are sworn in, if not on election night.
It's one reason incumbents are so hard to beat. They are campaigning for money from day one. Unless a challenger is independently wealthy and using their own funds, newcomers have an extremely low chance of winning.
Money wins elections, and incumbents raise the most money 9 times out of 10.
#FactCheckMeBro
-
With no GOP speaker, woul dthis mean that the budget bill to Israel and Ukraine is on pause?
From my understanding, based on political experts, it does seem like this would stop funding bills. The interim Speaker might be able to get the bills passed though, I don't know if there are any limits to his authority beyond a regular speaker
-
From my understanding, based on political experts, it does seem like this would stop funding bills. The interim Speaker might be able to get the bills passed though, I don't know if there are any limits to his authority beyond a regular speaker
So good news then.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Patrick McHenry, Republican of North Carolina, is now the speaker pro-tem.
Under the rules, he is limited in his powers and likely unable to conduct any
normal legislative business. His primary task is to organize the election of a
new speaker. If an impasse over choosing someone for that position ensues,
the House could grant McHenry time-limited authority to preside over debate
and votes on ordinary bills. That, however, would take a majority vote.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/10/12/a-house-still-with-no-speaker-what-this-means-for-us/02a90f94-6966-11ee-9753-2b3742e96987_story.html
-
As the debacle drags on, McHenry looks more and more pissed off. He's a staunch ally of McCarthy and was so pissed about what happened.
I loved the way he slammed that gavel sending congress to "cool off" after taking the helm. He was so mad he looked like he wanted to fight everyone.
For all we know he would be a good speaker of the house. Usually the ones who don't seek the limelight are the ones who are the most effective.
-
I hope Liz Cheney gets the seat. She's a real republican.
(https://i.imgur.com/oy92qJE.png)
-
Looks like they finally will start earning their keep. Hope they start governing.
Instead of always fighting.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/louisiana-s-mike-johnson-replaces-kevin-mccarthy-as-house-speaker/ar-AA1iQdMa?ocid=msedgdhp&pc=HCTS&cvid=6a775e13af234662af1b25088b3a055f&ei=16
-
I don' t know much about him, but this is what was posted:
1) Only voted for the 1st Ukraine funding, voted no for every one after that
2) Supported/faught for Trump during the phoney impeachment hearings (2)
3) Supported Trumps XO banning certain Muslim countries from immigrating
4) Voted against certifying Biden's election
-
I don' t know much about him, but this is what was posted:
1) Only voted for the 1st Ukraine funding, voted no for every one after that
2) Supported/faught for Trump during the phoney impeachment hearings (2)
3) Supported Trumps XO banning certain Muslim countries from immigrating
4) Voted against certifying Biden's election
I like him already
-
Also pro 2a. Again, unverfied. IG/YTers posted about him.
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20231025/91124a4c4c208077dc6c2d972c618783.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
-
I like him already
Me too. ;D
Also pro 2a. Again, unverfied. IG/YTers posted about him.
Ooooh. If true I love him already. ;D
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20231025/91124a4c4c208077dc6c2d972c618783.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
Aaaah. I no like Loona teek. Step on um. :rofl:
-
I don' t know much about him, but this is what was posted:
1) Only voted for the 1st Ukraine funding, voted no for every one after that
2) Supported/faught for Trump during the phoney impeachment hearings (2)
3) Supported Trumps XO banning certain Muslim countries from immigrating
4) Voted against certifying Biden's election
There was no Muslim Ban. It was a temporary stand-down barring immigration from initially 5 mostly Muslim countries where known terrorists trained, were supported by those countries and home to some of the worst terrorists to strike around the world.
Later, the list was lengthened and included non-Muslim countries, such as North Korea, Venezuela and Chad.
It was never a full-on ban, it was not permanent, and it never once mentioned the words Muslim or Islam. The purpose was to give the State Dept and Homeland Security a window to reevaluate what current policies and procedures can be improved upon to better ensure our borders are protected against terrorism.
Is it any wonder the corrupt government now says domestic terrorism is our #1 threat to security? Takes the focus off the actual sources of terrorism. Anybody remember the "Shoe Bomber," "Underwear Bomber," and other Islamic terrorist trying to down commercial airliners? The successes were limited, but not for a lack of trying.
-
There was no Muslim Ban.
Correct
-
So it was Mccarthy sabotaging the process all along so that he could weasel back into position.
Because of him it took 3 weeks instead of 3 days. This is a great victory though and was well worth it
And now the time has finally arrived to...
(https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61MH1LJeBhL._AC_UF894,1000_QL80_.jpg)
-
Also pro 2a. Again, unverfied. IG/YTers posted about him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGsw_gnmf_k
-
This is a pretty huge win. We’ll see how it plays out but for now the swamp is in deep trouble