2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on November 12, 2023, 08:30:53 PM

Title: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 12, 2023, 08:30:53 PM
Just listened to this recent podcast breaking down the Rahimi case revolving around a male caught with a gun while he was prohibited by a domestic violence protection order. If you nerd out on legal challenges it is pretty interesting.

Ultimately this is pretty much the last type of case we want as a test case for gun rights in relation to restraining orders because this guy was a dirt bag domestic violence guy who should have been in jail instead of merely a restraining order on him. Because of the details of the case, due process wasn't even at issue.

The panel didn't seem to think Rahimi would win and frankly I don't think the defendant should win in this case either.

Maybe in the future we will get a proper due process case but depends how they rule on this one first.

https://thedispatch.com/podcast/advisoryopinions/solicitor-general-9000/
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 13, 2023, 01:12:45 PM
The DOJ will win on "it's face", which is a very broad meaning.  Watch 4 boxes Diner's YT vid on it.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 13, 2023, 03:55:34 PM
The DOJ will win on "it's face", which is a very broad meaning.  Watch 4 boxes Diner's YT vid on it.

What do you mean they will win on it's face?

The panel in the podcast I linked to predicted a 9-0 or 8-1 decision in this case against Rahimi.

I suppose the silver lining for gun rights will be that this case does address the question of due process so in the future there could still be a due process type question case in the future.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 13, 2023, 05:21:56 PM
What do you mean they will win on it's face?

The panel in the podcast I linked to predicted a 9-0 or 8-1 decision in this case against Rahimi.

I suppose the silver lining for gun rights will be that this case does address the question of due process so in the future there could still be a due process type question case in the future.
Watch the vid. He explains everything and why its a win still

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 13, 2023, 07:24:20 PM
Watch the vid. He explains everything and why its a win still

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Link?
Seems premature to call it a win since we have no idea what the SCOTUS will put in their final ruling.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: macsak on November 13, 2023, 07:40:21 PM
Link?
Seems premature to call it a win since we have no idea what the SCOTUS will put in their final ruling.

"Watch 4 boxes Diner's YT vid on it."
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 13, 2023, 09:15:44 PM
Link?
Seems premature to call it a win since we have no idea what the SCOTUS will put in their final ruling.
Google.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 14, 2023, 12:38:05 AM
Google.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I see a bunch of videos by him on 2A issues. Don't know which one you are referring to.

Did you listen to the podcast?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 14, 2023, 08:12:21 AM
I see a bunch of videos by him on 2A issues. Don't know which one you are referring to.

Did you listen to the podcast?

The one that has a title of Rahimi.  Also they're recent as the court hearing was recent. So no need to go back 6 months.  After you watch it, come back here and post what you learned that the AG stated during the hearing and if the other sources you listened to mentioned this.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 14, 2023, 09:55:09 AM
The one that has a title of Rahimi.  Also they're recent as the court hearing was recent. So no need to go back 6 months.  After you watch it, come back here and post what you learned that the AG stated during the hearing and if the other sources you listened to mentioned this.

The most recent videos from him on Rahimi were 5 days ago posted after the hearing:

DOJ ON VERGE OF MAJOR SUPREME COURT 2A LOSS:
Don't Believe Media Hype about Rahimi Case

https://youtu.be/GZU9XiopU14

2A BREAKING: AUDIO RECORDING OF SCOTUS
US v. RAHIMI ORAL ARGUMENT IS HERE

https://youtu.be/_8j_hHw8kUA
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 14, 2023, 10:02:50 AM
The most recent videos from him on Rahim were 5 days ago posted after the hearing:

DOJ ON VERGE OF MAJOR SUPREME COURT 2A LOSS:
Don't Believe Media Hype about Rahimi Case

https://youtu.be/GZU9XiopU14

2A BREAKING: AUDIO RECORDING OF SCOTUS
US v. RAHIMI ORAL ARGUMENT IS HERE

https://youtu.be/_8j_hHw8kUA

Bruh. Give a man a fish why don't u.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 14, 2023, 10:03:59 AM
Bruh. Give a man a fish why don't u.

You enjoy pulling the wings off flies, I bet....

 :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 14, 2023, 10:29:13 AM
https://youtu.be/_8j_hHw8kUA

I like the justice at time mark ~15:00 going in the direction that historical precedence may not have considered domestic violence as "dangerousness."

Attitudes toward discipline of children and treatment of spouses have changed greatly.  I think not too long ago, we still believed in "spare the rod, spoil the child."  Women were expected to respect the decisions and opinions of their husbands. 

What constitutes "domestic violence" today has absolutely changed over the last 200+ years -- probably over the last 80 years.

Analogy:  We give children wanting to transition their gender rights that were never afforded minors in the past.  Schools are providing secrecy for some students to the point of not allowing parents to know what they are doing to "affirm" the student's trans status.  This would have been 100% against moral and legal standards for the state schools not long ago.

I think we need to stop redefining everything in favor of Liberal ideology.  That's taking us into a direction that bifurcates the historical analogues that might apply to laws being passed today.  What was not prohibited behavior in the 1800s can be 100% prohibited today -- and that might also apply to protected actions identified as Constitutional rights.

i think they are missing the biggest point.  The gov't wants to pass laws to PREVENT potentially dangerous actions, whereas the standard for centuries was to protect the rights of individuals to exercise free will and then PUNISH dangerous actions.

The federal attorney keeps bringing up mental illness.  Stats prove that the rate of violence among the mentally ill population is no different than violence among mentally healthy individuals.  Grouping people into these "dangerous" categories ignores the individuality inherent in human behavior.  Unless and until an individual demonstrates a tendency to behave dangerously, there's no justification for revoking civil rights....

... in my humble opinion.

It's impossible to predict the good or bad behavior in groups of humans.  A mentally ill adult raised to properly use and respect the dangers of firearms is no more risky than handing a mentally healthy adult a firearm with no background in firearm safety.  And classes don't provde actual training, correction of incorrect handling of firearms, or constant reinforcement of the responsibilities involved in having and using firearms.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 14, 2023, 11:19:51 AM





I think we need to stop redefining everything in favor of Liberal ideology.  That's taking us into a direction that bifurcates the historical analogues that might apply to laws being passed today.  What was not prohibited behavior in the 1800s can be 100% prohibited today -- and that might also apply to protected actions identified as Constitutional rights.




I knew a guy who worked in a judges chamber who handled lots of DV restraining orders.  When he first began, it was majority women who filed them.  He then learned that this is often used as leverage for a custody battle.  The womans atty looks for any reason to file a TRO.  Unfortunatlly, a lot of these were issued.

As the years went, he noticed that men began to file them a lot more.  They figured this out and it comes down to who ever files first wins.

I wasn't a 2a guy at the time, so I never asked this, but I can see if the man was a gun owner, then they would get their guns taken away. THen used by the womans atty and say something like "He is such a danger that the cops took all his guns away, how can someone like this be allowed custody of a child".

So Rahimi altough sounds like a total a-hole, at the time wasn't convicted of anything.

This TRO would be very similar to a red flag law.  Today it's only certain people who can petition for 1, but now the door is open. How long before anyone who has come into contact with phsycially or online can file one?

I hope EEF pays attention to the 1mph or 10mph analogy used.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 14, 2023, 01:37:16 PM
Rahimi is bigger than just the DOJ wining on "face".

Range Lawsuit. And maybe soon to be Williams vs. Garland which was just won. DUI is "non-violent" and doesn't strip someone of their 2a right.  Like Range who failed to disclose $500 when applying for food stamps.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 14, 2023, 04:08:33 PM
Rahimi is bigger than just the DOJ wining on "face".

Range Lawsuit. And maybe soon to be Williams vs. Garland which was just won. DUI is "non-violent" and doesn't strip someone of their 2a right.  Like Range who failed to disclose $500 when applying for food stamps.

Domestic abuse takes a lot of forms and not always involving violence or physical abuse. 

Automatically placing every domestic abuse case in the "dangerous person" category without considering the type of abuse is nothing more than gun confiscation without due process.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Sodie on November 14, 2023, 05:57:49 PM
"Watch 4 boxes Diner's YT vid on it."

Mr. Smith does a LOT of videos.  Telling somebody to go watch the Four Boxes Diner video about any particular 2A case is a little like saying “go watch the Demo Ranch video, the one with the guns in it.”

I think the “on it’s face” reference has to do with the ways you can challenge the constitutionality of a law… a “facial” or “as applied” challenge.

If a law is unconstitutional “on its face,” the court is saying there’s no case in which the law could be constitutional, and it therefore can’t be enforced.

If a law is unconstitutional “as applied,” the court is saying there are cases in which the law can be enforced, but in the particular case before them, it was applied in an unconstitutional way… the particular case is overturned, but the law can stay in place.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 14, 2023, 09:12:10 PM
The one that has a title of Rahimi.  Also they're recent as the court hearing was recent. So no need to go back 6 months.  After you watch it, come back here and post what you learned that the AG stated during the hearing and if the other sources you listened to mentioned this.

So I have to find and watch the video you didn't link but you aren't going to answer whether you listened to the podcast I linked?

You could simply summarize the argument like I tried to do. If you don't want to thats fine, maybe i'll get around to watching it.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 14, 2023, 09:41:26 PM
I knew a guy who worked in a judges chamber who handled lots of DV restraining orders.  When he first began, it was majority women who filed them.  He then learned that this is often used as leverage for a custody battle.  The womans atty looks for any reason to file a TRO.  Unfortunately, a lot of these were issued.

As the years went, he noticed that men began to file them a lot more.  They figured this out and it comes down to who ever files first wins.

I wasn't a 2a guy at the time, so I never asked this, but I can see if the man was a gun owner, then they would get their guns taken away. THen used by the womans atty and say something like "He is such a danger that the cops took all his guns away, how can someone like this be allowed custody of a child".

So Rahimi altough sounds like a total a-hole, at the time wasn't convicted of anything.

This TRO would be very similar to a red flag law.  Today it's only certain people who can petition for 1, but now the door is open. How long before anyone who has come into contact with phsycially or online can file one?

I hope EEF pays attention to the 1mph or 10mph analogy used.

The reason why this case does not really apply to most red flag and TRO laws is that Rahimi agreed to not have any firearms. Most of the time with TROs the respondent has no choice, the judge sets the terms of the order and the responded has to abide. In other words, Rahimi does not have the same due process challenge that most other people facing gun rights revocation would face.

The speeding analogy wasn't an argument that any restriction of rights is unconstitutional, it was more a rhetorical question about where the line should be drawn as to when someone's gun rights should be revoked. What is a responsible citizen considered to be in terms of the test of whether they are too dangerous to own a firearm? Clearly this right would not be revoked for speeding.


After many mass shootings and domestic violence murders many people, including people here, bemoan how the system failed, how cops or doctors, or family members knew the individual was dangerous but did nothing. But at the same time you are staunchly against any sort of restraining order or red flag law of any kind. You can't bemoan the failure of authorities meanwhile not giving them any powers to act.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 15, 2023, 07:58:38 AM
So I have to find and watch the video you didn't link but you aren't going to answer whether you listened to the podcast I linked?

You could simply summarize the argument like I tried to do. If you don't want to thats fine, maybe i'll get around to watching it.

I didn't answer about the podcast as I didn't listen to it.  As you've never asked me until now if I listened to it, I never felt a need to state so.

I could summarize, but the vids are worth a watch.

Yes, you have to find the vids. It won't be hard if you know how to search, which you do know how to do. Here's a hint, the vids you need have "Rahimi" in the title/search and are from less than 2 weeks old.  Which should be obvious because the oral arguments just began and didn't happen say 1 year ago or 4 years ago.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 15, 2023, 08:09:53 AM
The reason why this case does not really apply to most red flag and TRO laws is that Rahimi agreed to not have any firearms. Most of the time with TROs the respondent has no choice, the judge sets the terms of the order and the responded has to abide. In other words, Rahimi does not have the same due process challenge that most other people facing gun rights revocation would face.

The speeding analogy wasn't an argument that any restriction of rights is unconstitutional, it was more a rhetorical question about where the line should be drawn as to when someone's gun rights should be revoked. What is a responsible citizen considered to be in terms of the test of whether they are too dangerous to own a firearm? Clearly this right would not be revoked for speeding.


After many mass shootings and domestic violence murders many people, including people here, bemoan how the system failed, how cops or doctors, or family members knew the individual was dangerous but did nothing. But at the same time you are staunchly against any sort of restraining order or red flag law of any kind. You can't bemoan the failure of authorities meanwhile not giving them any powers to act.

Response to 1st paragraph:
In red flag laws, there is no "due process" whether you can keep your guns or not. Same with the title USC and the TRO as Rahimi was awaiting his court date.  For a TRO, 1 is served the papers and unknown to them it was happening.  My friend got a TRO when the Sheriff showed up at his door. But he was off island at the time and had no clue.  Then when they got to court, the days his exgf alleged he threatened her in person, he was again off island.  So the TRO was dismissed.  This is similar to red flag, which we covered. "take the guns first" is the phrase. But then again, you agree that red flags are consitutional, even though there's no due process, so I would figure that you also agree with TRO's.

Paragraph 2
SWOOOOSSHHHHH

Paragraph 3
What we have is a failure of the process. Court dates have been backlogged going on for decades.  Imagine if someone got their court date within a few days instead of weeks/months/even years.  Then due process can be given.

"But at the same time you are staunchly against any sort of restraining order or red flag law of any kind. You can't bemoan the failure of authorities meanwhile not giving them any powers to act." Do you mean me or they as your first sentance states "many people".  I am not 1 of these "many people".  I see if the system failed like the TN church shooting where his dishonorable discharge wasn't logged, which would have prevented the shooter from buying a gun.  I don't blame doctors, cops, or family members, but instead an error.  And same would be for any similar situations as I believe in "due process".  This is what the anti 2a wants you to believe that they "system" failed.  The system is handicapped by politics and orgs like MDA/ET who rather spend money on taking law abiding peoples rights away, instead of spending their money on help for those who need it or a faster court process. What is failing the US is disarming the victims like gun free zones and the anti 2a propoganda that the left pushes.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on November 15, 2023, 09:32:55 AM



After many mass shootings and domestic violence murders many people, including people here, bemoan how the system failed, how cops or doctors, or family members knew the individual was dangerous but did nothing. But at the same time you are staunchly against any sort of restraining order or red flag law of any kind. You can't bemoan the failure of authorities meanwhile not giving them any powers to act.

You have that backwards. I don’t want to give them any powers BECAUSE they have shown their failure time and time again with the laws they already have on the books.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 15, 2023, 09:41:27 AM
You have that backwards. I don’t want to give them any powers BECAUSE they have shown their failure time and time again with the laws they already have on the books.

Let people choose to arm themselves or not.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 15, 2023, 09:22:45 PM
I didn't answer about the podcast as I didn't listen to it.  As you've never asked me until now if I listened to it, I never felt a need to state so.

I could summarize, but the vids are worth a watch.

Yes, you have to find the vids. It won't be hard if you know how to search, which you do know how to do. Here's a hint, the vids you need have "Rahimi" in the title/search and are from less than 2 weeks old.  Which should be obvious because the oral arguments just began and didn't happen say 1 year ago or 4 years ago.

I asked you before that, but maybe you missed it, no biggie.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 15, 2023, 09:33:06 PM
Response to 1st paragraph:
In red flag laws, there is no "due process" whether you can keep your guns or not. Same with the title USC and the TRO as Rahimi was awaiting his court date.  For a TRO, 1 is served the papers and unknown to them it was happening.  My friend got a TRO when the Sheriff showed up at his door. But he was off island at the time and had no clue.  Then when they got to court, the days his exgf alleged he threatened her in person, he was again off island.  So the TRO was dismissed.  This is similar to red flag, which we covered. "take the guns first" is the phrase. But then again, you agree that red flags are consitutional, even though there's no due process, so I would figure that you also agree with TRO's.

Paragraph 2
SWOOOOSSHHHHH

Paragraph 3
What we have is a failure of the process. Court dates have been backlogged going on for decades.  Imagine if someone got their court date within a few days instead of weeks/months/even years.  Then due process can be given.

"But at the same time you are staunchly against any sort of restraining order or red flag law of any kind. You can't bemoan the failure of authorities meanwhile not giving them any powers to act." Do you mean me or they as your first sentance states "many people".  I am not 1 of these "many people".  I see if the system failed like the TN church shooting where his dishonorable discharge wasn't logged, which would have prevented the shooter from buying a gun.  I don't blame doctors, cops, or family members, but instead an error.  And same would be for any similar situations as I believe in "due process".  This is what the anti 2a wants you to believe that they "system" failed.  The system is handicapped by politics and orgs like MDA/ET who rather spend money on taking law abiding peoples rights away, instead of spending their money on help for those who need it or a faster court process. What is failing the US is disarming the victims like gun free zones and the anti 2a propoganda that the left pushes.



You cannot make blanket statements about red flag laws in such a manner, I have pointed this out to you before. Each jurisdiction comes up with their own form of red flag laws, they are not all the same. One jurisdiction's laws could have due process while another jurisdiction might not have proper due process procedures in place.

I believe red flag laws can be constitutional. Again, it all depends on what protections are put in place by the specific jurisdiction.

Thank you for clarifying your position. So here is the key questions:
How do we stop these individuals who exhibit "red flags" but have not yet committed a crime but while still protecting their constitutional rights? It seemed like you were getting at court dates being timely. Were you implying that a red flag law gun revocation could be reasonable if the hearing is within a short time period? That is one of my key things for me, someone should get their hearing quickly, like 5 days or something
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 16, 2023, 08:25:10 AM


You cannot make blanket statements about red flag laws in such a manner, I have pointed this out to you before. Each jurisdiction comes up with their own form of red flag laws, they are not all the same. One jurisdiction's laws could have due process while another jurisdiction might not have proper due process procedures in place.

I believe red flag laws can be constitutional. Again, it all depends on what protections are put in place by the specific jurisdiction.

Thank you for clarifying your position. So here is the key questions:
How do we stop these individuals who exhibit "red flags" but have not yet committed a crime but while still protecting their constitutional rights? It seemed like you were getting at court dates being timely. Were you implying that a red flag law gun revocation could be reasonable if the hearing is within a short time period? That is one of my key things for me, someone should get their hearing quickly, like 5 days or something

We covered this already in another thread. I asked you to show which jurisdiction has due process and you didn't come back with anything.  So now you're making a statement again that 1 may have, so I'm asking again to prove it.  Because I"m making a statement that I don't know of any who provide this (due process).  They ALL are take the guns first, due process later.

Red flag or gun confiscation can be constitutional IF the person gets their fair day in court BEFORE any guns are taken away.  And if they are taken away, then the person is also in jail without bail as they are so dangerous that they souldn't be on the streets because they have commited a crime.

Since the USA has more freedoms than other countries, it is very difficult to stop someone who hasn't committed a crime yet.  Which the alternative is do away with gun free zones and let law abiding people carry easily and give people the chance to protect themselves from said dangerous individuals.

We have seen in history that without the freedoms the USA has, governments often abuse that power.  I mean even here in HI during covid, citatons and arrest were made due to a proclamation that is unconstitutional and not law.  Which the news reported 96% of cases were dismissed.  I saw HPD "following orders" and not allowing people to peacefully assemble.  Only to change their mind 20 mins later and allow it, but look for reasons to arrest.  Like not wearing a mask (not law).  I also witnessed 1 good cop not following orders and stating the proclamation is unconstitutional so he won't tell the people he was interacting with what to do.  So overall a 50:1 ratio of following orders.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 16, 2023, 08:26:03 AM
EEF,

Did you watch Mark Smiths videos?  Thoughts on what the AG statements are?

Also FYI Mark Smith wrote an amicus brief to support the Wolfard lawsuit, the sensitive places lawsuit.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Sodie on November 16, 2023, 04:58:27 PM
We covered this already in another thread. I asked you to show which jurisdiction has due process and you didn't come back with anything.  So now you're making a statement again that 1 may have, so I'm asking again to prove it.  Because I"m making a statement that I don't know of any who provide this (due process).  They ALL are take the guns first, due process later.

Red flag or gun confiscation can be constitutional IF the person gets their fair day in court BEFORE any guns are taken away.  And if they are taken away, then the person is also in jail without bail as they are so dangerous that they souldn't be on the streets because they have commited a crime.

Since the USA has more freedoms than other countries, it is very difficult to stop someone who hasn't committed a crime yet.  Which the alternative is do away with gun free zones and let law abiding people carry easily and give people the chance to protect themselves from said dangerous individuals.

We have seen in history that without the freedoms the USA has, governments often abuse that power.  I mean even here in HI during covid, citatons and arrest were made due to a proclamation that is unconstitutional and not law.  Which the news reported 96% of cases were dismissed.  I saw HPD "following orders" and not allowing people to peacefully assemble.  Only to change their mind 20 mins later and allow it, but look for reasons to arrest.  Like not wearing a mask (not law).  I also witnessed 1 good cop not following orders and stating the proclamation is unconstitutional so he won't tell the people he was interacting with what to do.  So overall a 50:1 ratio of following orders.

There are more than 38,000 jurisdictions that could enact red flag laws in the U.S., so it might take a minute to sort through all of them…
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 16, 2023, 05:38:47 PM
There are more than 38,000 jurisdictions that could enact red flag laws in the U.S., so it might take a minute to sort through all of them…

How many states have red flag laws as of 2023?

Hint: 22 including The District of Columbia

You can also eliminate Oklahoma from having red flag laws anytime soon.  They passed an "anti-red-flag" law.  So, 22 out of a possible 50.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/red-flag-laws-states

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Sodie on November 16, 2023, 05:45:04 PM
How many states have red flag laws as of 2023?

Hint: 22 including The District of Columbia

You can also eliminate Oklahoma from having red flag laws anytime soon.  They passed an "anti-red-flag" law.  So, 22 out of a possible 50.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/red-flag-laws-states

So red flag laws can only be enacted at the state level?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 16, 2023, 06:04:34 PM
So red flag laws can only be enacted at the state level?

Yep.  By definition, it can only be enacted at the state level since it requires a state court to issue the order.

Imagine trying to enforce a protection order from one county if the dangerous person lives in a county without red flag laws, but works in another county where they exist.  Messy.  His employer could call the cops, and the cops apply for a protection order, but it'll be meaningless.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 16, 2023, 06:53:03 PM
How many states have red flag laws as of 2023?

Hint: 22 including The District of Columbia

You can also eliminate Oklahoma from having red flag laws anytime soon.  They passed an "anti-red-flag" law.  So, 22 out of a possible 50.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/red-flag-laws-states
Wow, i thought it was like 12.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 16, 2023, 10:53:43 PM
We covered this already in another thread. I asked you to show which jurisdiction has due process and you didn't come back with anything.  So now you're making a statement again that 1 may have, so I'm asking again to prove it.  Because I"m making a statement that I don't know of any who provide this (due process).  They ALL are take the guns first, due process later.

Red flag or gun confiscation can be constitutional IF the person gets their fair day in court BEFORE any guns are taken away.  And if they are taken away, then the person is also in jail without bail as they are so dangerous that they souldn't be on the streets because they have commited a crime.

Since the USA has more freedoms than other countries, it is very difficult to stop someone who hasn't committed a crime yet.  Which the alternative is do away with gun free zones and let law abiding people carry easily and give people the chance to protect themselves from said dangerous individuals.

We have seen in history that without the freedoms the USA has, governments often abuse that power.  I mean even here in HI during covid, citatons and arrest were made due to a proclamation that is unconstitutional and not law.  Which the news reported 96% of cases were dismissed.  I saw HPD "following orders" and not allowing people to peacefully assemble.  Only to change their mind 20 mins later and allow it, but look for reasons to arrest.  Like not wearing a mask (not law).  I also witnessed 1 good cop not following orders and stating the proclamation is unconstitutional so he won't tell the people he was interacting with what to do.  So overall a 50:1 ratio of following orders.

I don't have to show which one has due process protections because I am not making a blanket statement. You are the one suggesting that none of them do. I am pointing out that it is possible to create a red flag law with proper due process. I don't have to prove that some particular jurisdiction did to prove that it is possible.

On top of that, I don't know what you consider to be adequate due process. If you are accused of assault the officer arrests you based on probable cause yet you don't get a hearing before you are arrested. A red flag law deprives you of property, an arrest deprives you of freedom. Accused of a crime is different than being accused of a dangerous mental health condition though. The question has been asked as to why, if the person is dangerous, aren't they admitted to the mental hospital. That is a very fair question but is that preferable instead of a lesser restriction of rights? So even if I list a bunch of jurisdictions that I think have adequate due process protections, you might consider them not adequate.

You say the due process should happen first, but is this practical? If I think someone is going to shoot up a school tomorrow, how effective would it be to have a hearing in two weeks as to whether that person should keep their guns? Even someone brought in against their will on a mental health confinement doesn't get a hearing before they are taken into the mental hospital, they get it later.
I am not a fan of gun free zones but I don't factor that into this issue because there is not much evidence it has any bearing. It is a bandage, not a solution.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 16, 2023, 10:54:23 PM
EEF,

Did you watch Mark Smiths videos?  Thoughts on what the AG statements are?

Also FYI Mark Smith wrote an amicus brief to support the Wolfard lawsuit, the sensitive places lawsuit.

I have not, I am not familiar with Mark Smith.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 17, 2023, 08:08:43 AM
I don't have to show which one has due process protections because I am not making a blanket statement. You are the one suggesting that none of them do. I am pointing out that it is possible to create a red flag law with proper due process. I don't have to prove that some particular jurisdiction did to prove that it is possible.



I am making a blanket statement and I cannot prove which ones do have due process as none of them do.  But you stated that one or more may, which is why I asked you to prove it.  Nice try, trying to turn this around again.  All you have to say is "My statement that a red flag law may be constitutional was based on not looking up all of them (23), but a guess.  This guess was wrong".  Also nice goal post moving.

I gotta learn how to bold paragraphs so I don't gotta quote each one.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 17, 2023, 08:10:56 AM


On top of that, I don't know what you consider to be adequate due process. If you are accused of assault the officer arrests you based on probable cause yet you don't get a hearing before you are arrested. A red flag law deprives you of property, an arrest deprives you of freedom. Accused of a crime is different than being accused of a dangerous mental health condition though. The question has been asked as to why, if the person is dangerous, aren't they admitted to the mental hospital. That is a very fair question but is that preferable instead of a lesser restriction of rights? So even if I list a bunch of jurisdictions that I think have adequate due process protections, you might consider them not adequate.


We already covered in the prior red flag thread when this law was being suggested/passed what is due process AKA constitutional. If you forgot, then go search and read the entire post, especially the part where you suggest it is constitutional.  I am not talking about being arrested, I'm talking about red flag. Nice goal post moving again to try to show you're right. Here's a hint, no one is arrested if a red flag consfiscation is impemented, so you cannot use your arrest example.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 17, 2023, 08:13:45 AM


You say the due process should happen first, but is this practical? If I think someone is going to shoot up a school tomorrow, how effective would it be to have a hearing in two weeks as to whether that person should keep their guns? Even someone brought in against their will on a mental health confinement doesn't get a hearing before they are taken into the mental hospital, they get it later.
I am not a fan of gun free zones but I don't factor that into this issue because there is not much evidence it has any bearing. It is a bandage, not a solution.

If someone is threatening to shoot a school tomorrow, then aren't there other laws that can be implemented and arrest/detainment can be made? Which means said person has no access to their guns cause they're in jail.  IF red flag were to be highly successful, then that means ALL states that have it must require ALL guns be registered.  Which we all have learned from your prior post that you think registration is constitutional.

Thanks again for playing. Do not pass go, do not collect $200.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 17, 2023, 08:14:43 AM
I have not, I am not familiar with Mark Smith.

You should watch the recent Rahimi vids first, then any other ones that catch your eye.  Since he did help with the sensitive places lawsuit here by writing a brief.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 03:01:48 AM
I am making a blanket statement and I cannot prove which ones do have due process as none of them do.  But you stated that one or more may, which is why I asked you to prove it.  Nice try, trying to turn this around again.  All you have to say is "My statement that a red flag law may be constitutional was based on not looking up all of them (23), but a guess.  This guess was wrong".  Also nice goal post moving.

I gotta learn how to bold paragraphs so I don't gotta quote each one.

You have looked at the text of the red flag laws of all states and determined that none of them have due process protections?

You avoided the most important question I asked you, what do you define as constitutional due process protections? Just because you think there are not enough due process protections or they don't work as you think they should work does not mean they are unconstitutional.

Hawaii's red flag law does due process protections. Within 14 days of an ex parte order there has to be a hearing for the respondent where the order is either extended for a year or is dissolved. Even if granted, the respondent may petition the court at any time during the 1 year revocation for a hearing to terminate the order.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm

So apparently you haven't looked at the texts of all the states, you haven't even looked at the due process protections in our own red flag law.
On top of that you continue to argue a strawman, I clearly was talking about the concept of red flag laws but you swoosh in and start asking where they exist. Saying they can exist is not the same thing as saying they do exist... swoosh!
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 03:10:00 AM
If someone is threatening to shoot a school tomorrow, then aren't there other laws that can be implemented and arrest/detainment can be made? Which means said person has no access to their guns cause they're in jail.  IF red flag were to be highly successful, then that means ALL states that have it must require ALL guns be registered.  Which we all have learned from your prior post that you think registration is constitutional.

Short answer: It depends

Long answer: it would matter what the nature of the comments were. Did the person say they would shoot up a school? Did they say they wanted to shoot up a school? Did they say they had temptations to shoot up a school? Someone may pose an immediate threat to themselves or others without verbalizing the threat. In order to arrest someone on a threatening charge you need to prove a few things: he threat has to be specific and the threat has to be something realistically possible. Absent that you cannot put them in jail but that doesn't mean they are not a danger.

I don't think that registration as a whole is unconstitutional, but thats another topic.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on November 18, 2023, 11:48:59 AM
You have looked at the text of the red flag laws of all states and determined that none of them have due process protections?

You avoided the most important question I asked you, what do you define as constitutional due process protections? Just because you think there are not enough due process protections or they don't work as you think they should work does not mean they are unconstitutional.

Hawaii's red flag law does due process protections. Within 14 days of an ex parte order there has to be a hearing for the respondent where the order is either extended for a year or is dissolved. Even if granted, the respondent may petition the court at any time during the 1 year revocation for a hearing to terminate the order.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm

So apparently you haven't looked at the texts of all the states, you haven't even looked at the due process protections in our own red flag law.
On top of that you continue to argue a strawman, I clearly was talking about the concept of red flag laws but you swoosh in and start asking where they exist. Saying they can exist is not the same thing as saying they do exist... swoosh!

Boy you are having a hard time with this huh? Due process = getting convicted/mentally adjudicated. I’m not going to put my rights into the hands of corrupt left wing judges who can decide to take my 2A rights away because I punched a wall out of anger.

BTW  you suck at using swoosh. CMO asking you to provide an example of a functioning red flag law is not a strawman. YOU said it can be constitutional so it’s on you to provide the evidence. Simply saying “it’s the details that matter” is not providing evidence. Just say there is no current red flag law that you can put forward that looks constitutional.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 11:56:18 AM
You have looked at the text of the red flag laws of all states and determined that none of them have due process protections?

You avoided the most important question I asked you, what do you define as constitutional due process protections? Just because you think there are not enough due process protections or they don't work as you think they should work does not mean they are unconstitutional.

Hawaii's red flag law does due process protections. Within 14 days of an ex parte order there has to be a hearing for the respondent where the order is either extended for a year or is dissolved. Even if granted, the respondent may petition the court at any time during the 1 year revocation for a hearing to terminate the order.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm

So apparently you haven't looked at the texts of all the states, you haven't even looked at the due process protections in our own red flag law.
On top of that you continue to argue a strawman, I clearly was talking about the concept of red flag laws but you swoosh in and start asking where they exist. Saying they can exist is not the same thing as saying they do exist... swoosh!

A bunch of states i have ans non r constiturional, so i stopped looking. Nice try again, trying to flip it back "mr.redflag law may be constitutional without posting a single one".

Do u not know what due process is? We already covered the why theyre unconstitutional in the other thread u replied to.

Thanks for playing. Do not pass Go. Pay every player tax of $200

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 01:17:03 PM
Boy you are having a hard time with this huh? Due process = getting convicted/mentally adjudicated. I’m not going to put my rights into the hands of corrupt left wing judges who can decide to take my 2A rights away because I punched a wall out of anger.

BTW  you suck at using swoosh. CMO asking you to provide an example of a functioning red flag law is not a strawman. YOU said it can be constitutional so it’s on you to provide the evidence. Simply saying “it’s the details that matter” is not providing evidence. Just say there is no current red flag law that you can put forward that looks constitutional.
The funny part is we covered this with him a while ago. I also find it hilarious when he tries to use swoosh.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 01:18:30 PM
Short answer: It depends

Long answer: it would matter what the nature of the comments were. Did the person say they would shoot up a school? Did they say they wanted to shoot up a school? Did they say they had temptations to shoot up a school? Someone may pose an immediate threat to themselves or others without verbalizing the threat. In order to arrest someone on a threatening charge you need to prove a few things: he threat has to be specific and the threat has to be something realistically possible. Absent that you cannot put them in jail but that doesn't mean they are not a danger.

I don't think that registration as a whole is unconstitutional, but thats another topic.
Read what u posted very slowly. Then read what i did in ur quote. Then read what u wrote again.

Maybe night shifts cause lack of comprehension.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 01:22:12 PM
You have looked at the text of the red flag laws of all states and determined that none of them have due process protections?

You avoided the most important question I asked you, what do you define as constitutional due process protections? Just because you think there are not enough due process protections or they don't work as you think they should work does not mean they are unconstitutional.

Hawaii's red flag law does due process protections. Within 14 days of an ex parte order there has to be a hearing for the respondent where the order is either extended for a year or is dissolved. Even if granted, the respondent may petition the court at any time during the 1 year revocation for a hearing to terminate the order.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm

So apparently you haven't looked at the texts of all the states, you haven't even looked at the due process protections in our own red flag law.
On top of that you continue to argue a strawman, I clearly was talking about the concept of red flag laws but you swoosh in and start asking where they exist. Saying they can exist is not the same thing as saying they do exist... swoosh!
Ill entertain this one as im taking a shit.
Nice try and thanks for leaving out the part the guns are taken away BEFORE the hearing.

If u dont know what due process is, i hope u dont end up on a YT channel like Lack Luster.

Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 18, 2023, 01:51:56 PM
Ill entertain this one as im taking a shit.
Nice try and thanks for leaving out the part the guns are taken away BEFORE the hearing.

If u dont know what due process is, i hope u dont end up on a YT channel like Lack Luster.

Thanks for playing.
"what do you define as constitutional due process protections?"

LOL!  He's asking for YOUR definition, because most of the time, he's working off his own definitions of terms and vocabulary.  He thinks looking up the formal definition -- which most of us use -- would be contrary to his arguments.

Due process is not something defined for the sake of creating legislation by state or federal lawmakers.  There's no template for what due process entails.

Due process from its inception is intended to apply fairness toward the individual -- a way to balance the massive power of the government against the individual rights of the accused.

In all cases where a constitutional right is being adjudicated by the state, the standard for protecting the individual's rights is much stricter than, say, weighing those rights against the common good.  That last part is how gun control laws have survived constitutional scrutiny in the past.  Before Bruen, state and federal courts used a balancing scheme to decide if second amendment rights were as important as the benefit to society a given law is supposed to have.  i.e. the "If it can save one life..." argument.  That two step analysis has now been replaced with the historical analgue test.

Confiscation of guns from a private citizen is obviously a 2A situation.  Therefore, the process leading up to that action must be fair TO THE GUN OWNER.  The interests of the state to protect the public from a danger that has yet to manifest -- and which may never manifest -- by taking a person's property -- property that is protected by the second amendment -- can not be the "process" if fairness is involved. 

How is it fair to punish a gun owner by showing up unannounced to seize their gun collection and ammo before they have had a chance to produce evidence that the fears of the state are unfounded?  There's been no professional diagnosis of any sort, no arrest, and no hearing to contest the veracity of the accusations.  Basically, the "process" is backward. in which the interests of the state ("public safety") are given precedence over the rights of the individual to keep and bear arms.

There's no constitutional protection that i know of that applies to the state nor the public at large.  The protections are intended shield the individual from the government, not the other way around.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 10:13:27 PM
Boy you are having a hard time with this huh? Due process = getting convicted/mentally adjudicated. I’m not going to put my rights into the hands of corrupt left wing judges who can decide to take my 2A rights away because I punched a wall out of anger.

BTW  you suck at using swoosh. CMO asking you to provide an example of a functioning red flag law is not a strawman. YOU said it can be constitutional so it’s on you to provide the evidence. Simply saying “it’s the details that matter” is not providing evidence. Just say there is no current red flag law that you can put forward that looks constitutional.

I swooshed CMO because his comments suggest red flag laws with due process are not possible and when I point out they are possible, he switches and asks where they exist. He is changing the parameters of the debate. Do they exist is a different question of whether they can exist.

Not sure if you meant to do this but you basically laid out an argument about whether due process was present based on whether you trusted the judges. Due process does not exist based on whether you (or I) trust the judges. I share your skepticism of the judges but that does not have a bearing of whether the law, as written, contains due process protections or not.

On the previous page I linked to part of the Hawaii red flag law and I illustrated how there is due process in the hearings that are prescribed. I explained how there is a short initial revocation (14 days) followed by a hearing in which the respondent may argue their case. And even after that, the respondent may ask the court for an additional hearing anytime during the year long revocation. This is, by definition, due process.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 10:22:46 PM
A bunch of states i have ans non r constiturional, so i stopped looking. Nice try again, trying to flip it back "mr.redflag law may be constitutional without posting a single one".

Do u not know what due process is? We already covered the why theyre unconstitutional in the other thread u replied to.

Thanks for playing. Do not pass Go. Pay every player tax of $200

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

So I asked you what you consider to be due process and your response is to as me if I know what due process is. You must have a low opinion of me if you think I am going to fall for that trick.

You asked for a single example of a red flag law with due process and I gave you Hawaii's law as an example. You may not like the due process in it but it still has due process.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 10:27:08 PM
Ill entertain this one as im taking a shit.
Nice try and thanks for leaving out the part the guns are taken away BEFORE the hearing.

If u dont know what due process is, i hope u dont end up on a YT channel like Lack Luster.

Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Okay, lets focus on a specific thing here so you can articluate yourself.

Why do you feel that taking firearms before a hearing is unconstitutional and/or lacks due process?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 10:27:57 PM
I swooshed CMO because his comments suggest red flag laws with due process are not possible and when I point out they are possible, he switches and asks where they exist. He is changing the parameters of the debate. Do they exist is a different question of whether they can exist.
Wait, wut? I think someone either had a stroke or fell off a chair and is imagining things.

Thanks for playing. Utlility bills due, pay  8% of all property values to tax.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 10:29:16 PM
Wait, wut? I think someone either had a stroke or fell off a chair and is imagining things.

Thanks for playing. Utlility bills due, pay  8% of all property values to tax.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

If you cannot understand the difference between concept and application then maybe you did have a stroke
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 10:33:26 PM
So I asked you what you consider to be due process and your response is to as me if I know what due process is. You must have a low opinion of me if you think I am going to fall for that trick.

You asked for a single example of a red flag law with due process and I gave you Hawaii's law as an example. You may not like the due process in it but it still has due process.
Wait, wut? Srs, go get a med eval because ur imagining things that arent there.

The only remaining tactic u got left would be to make false statements hoping people are too busy to reply. Which many of ur points already have been shown as false in prior threads as red flag isnt a new topic.

 Thanks for playing. Move back 3 spaces.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 10:34:17 PM
Okay, lets focus on a specific thing here so you can articluate yourself.

Why do you feel that taking firearms before a hearing is unconstitutional and/or lacks due process?
This was answered already when u asked it in the other red flag thread. Go read the entire thing again after u see a doctor.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 10:35:05 PM
If you cannot understand the difference between concept and application then maybe you did have a stroke
Nice deflection. Urgent care is open, but ur condition isnt a real emergency. It can wait till monday.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 18, 2023, 10:36:31 PM


You must have a low opinion of me




*points to nose with index finger


Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 18, 2023, 10:40:36 PM
Wait, wut? Srs, go get a med eval because ur imagining things that arent there.

The only remaining tactic u got left would be to make false statements hoping people are too busy to reply. Which many of ur points already have been shown as false in prior threads as red flag isnt a new topic.

 Thanks for playing. Move back 3 spaces.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

This is what your debating has devolved into? Catch phrases about video games and suggesting comprehension problems? Talk about deflection... I am talking about legal concepts here. I linked to Hawaii law and explained how the law had due process within it and your rebuttal is to say I am imaging things. What we have here is an articulated argument, with facts, agaisnt an ad hom. Check (since you like game references)
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 19, 2023, 07:10:40 AM
This is what your debating has devolved into? Catch phrases about video games and suggesting comprehension problems? Talk about deflection... I am talking about legal concepts here. I linked to Hawaii law and explained how the law had due process within it and your rebuttal is to say I am imaging things. What we have here is an articulated argument, with facts, agaisnt an ad hom. Check (since you like game references)
Read the law again.

Maybe ur opinion has been debunked and i dont feel like running in circles due to wasting time?
 
Someone thinks highly of themselves huh? I guess if u ask a girl if she thinks ur cute and then doesnt reply, u must take it as "wow, she didnt say no. Therefore, she must think im hot".

Take a step back and think about things. How often do i reply in this manner to ur non or wrong opinions? Compare this to how others replied over the years.

Heres a hint, i entertained ur waste of time and circular post for more than i should have as its not productive as an example of ur recent post, which we already covered some time ago and u still didnt show proof of a constitutional red flag law on top of that.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 19, 2023, 03:47:58 PM


*points to nose with index finger

That's not an opinion.

That's a FACT!

 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

 :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 19, 2023, 09:59:25 PM
Read the law again.

Maybe ur opinion has been debunked and i dont feel like running in circles due to wasting time?
 
Someone thinks highly of themselves huh? I guess if u ask a girl if she thinks ur cute and then doesnt reply, u must take it as "wow, she didnt say no. Therefore, she must think im hot".

Take a step back and think about things. How often do i reply in this manner to ur non or wrong opinions? Compare this to how others replied over the years.

Heres a hint, i entertained ur waste of time and circular post for more than i should have as its not productive as an example of ur recent post, which we already covered some time ago and u still didnt show proof of a constitutional red flag law on top of that.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't give you opinions, I gave you facts.

What even are wrong opinions?

But lets save time and end it here because it isn't going anywhere. I pointed to the specific law to show you where due process exists and you are saying that isn't due process. I can point to due process and you are going to say that doesn't count. Clearly nothing I can say will matter, you have your mind made up here. Save your game related ad homs for the next issue because I don't see anything coming of further debate. . Due process wasn't even at issue in this case.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 20, 2023, 05:38:18 AM


I didn't give you opinions, I gave you facts.

What even are wrong opinions?

But lets save time and end it here because it isn't going anywhere. I pointed to the specific law to show you where due process exists and you are saying that isn't due process. I can point to due process and you are going to say that doesn't count. Clearly nothing I can say will matter, you have your mind made up here. Save your game related ad homs for the next issue because I don't see anything coming of further debate. . Due process wasn't even at issue in this case.

"Clearly nothing i can say..."

Hahhaha. Still didnt read the law huh?

Thanks for playing. Left hand blue. Right foot yellow.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 20, 2023, 07:50:53 AM
Btw, still waiting for eef to read the ENTIRE HI red flag law and not just the ending part.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 20, 2023, 10:14:48 PM
Btw, still waiting for eef to read the ENTIRE HI red flag law and not just the ending part.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I gave you parts with the due process in it because due process was the topic. Wouldn't make sense to post links to all 12 sections

Here, ill give a few more links, all these sections contain due process aspects.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0063.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0064.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0065.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 21, 2023, 11:27:21 AM
I gave you parts with the due process in it because due process was the topic. Wouldn't make sense to post links to all 12 sections

Here, ill give a few more links, all these sections contain due process aspects.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0063.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0064.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0065.htm
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0066.htm

Have someone read this to you since you are failing to understand there is no due process.  Thanks for playing and proving I'm right. I didn't even have to post the links. Makes my part much less time consuming.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 21, 2023, 12:44:07 PM
Have someone read this to you since you are failing to understand there is no due process.  Thanks for playing and proving I'm right. I didn't even have to post the links. Makes my part much less time consuming.

Botton line: the lawmakers were very careful to avoid using terms like confiscate or seize in the language of the statute.  Even HPD  pussy-footed around it by saying this:

Quote
Reasonable efforts should be made to serve any type of GVPO

and to recover all firearms and ammunition covered by such orders.

Officers shall enforce all valid court-issued GVPOs.
https://www.honolulupd.org/policy/policy-gun-violence-protective-orders/

"Recover."  Yeah.  Right.

Basically, the initial GVPO is granted with only the applicant and their witnesses giving the court their side of the story.  Once the GPVO is granted, there's a hearing scheduled and the respondant (gun owner) notified via serving the order.

What happens, but is glossed over, is the GVPO was issued without the gun owner's knowledge, then the Cops show up to "recover" all his guns and ammo.

Only then will a hearing be held to decide if a one-year GVPO will be granted.

As we all know, even if the respondent prevails in the hearing, they still have to go through the permit process again to retrieve their firearms. 

What's also not included because of the timing of when the law was written is whether or not someone with a CC license will (a) have it revoked as well, and (b) allowed to bypass all the permit BS when they try to "recover" their property.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 21, 2023, 01:12:39 PM
Have someone read this to you since you are failing to understand there is no due process.  Thanks for playing and proving I'm right. I didn't even have to post the links. Makes my part much less time consuming.

It's there, don't know why you can't find it. Perhaps you need reading glasses. Jenga!
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 21, 2023, 01:17:55 PM
Botton line: the lawmakers were very careful to avoid using terms like confiscate or seize in the language of the statute.  Even HPD  pussy-footed around it by saying this:
https://www.honolulupd.org/policy/policy-gun-violence-protective-orders/

"Recover."  Yeah.  Right.

Basically, the initial GVPO is granted with only the applicant and their witnesses giving the court their side of the story.  Once the GPVO is granted, there's a hearing scheduled and the respondant (gun owner) notified via serving the order.

What happens, but is glossed over, is the GVPO was issued without the gun owner's knowledge, then the Cops show up to "recover" all his guns and ammo.

Only then will a hearing be held to decide if a one-year GVPO will be granted.

As we all know, even if the respondent prevails in the hearing, they still have to go through the permit process again to retrieve their firearms. 

What's also not included because of the timing of when the law was written is whether or not someone with a CC license will (a) have it revoked as well, and (b) allowed to bypass all the permit BS when they try to "recover" their property.

Wait, how did you know about this info?  EEF posted that its constitutional and due process is met. He even posted the link to the law, which was only 1 part and didn't even address what I was saying. Then he posted other parts and STILL DIDN'T READ IT CORRECTLY.


Hahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhaahahhaha "CMO, I was wrong, even though I posted various link and thought I was right. For future issues, I will ask someone who's nearest in proximity to me to read stuff aloud to me and explain it.  I appreaciate you letting me play".
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 21, 2023, 01:18:34 PM
It's there, don't know why you can't find it. Perhaps you need reading glasses. Jenga!


Hmmmmmm, flap found it. OOPPPSIIEEE DAISSSSYYY. (In Billy Madison voice) Someone was wrong.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 21, 2023, 01:20:47 PM
Botton line: the lawmakers were very careful to avoid using terms like confiscate or seize in the language of the statute.  Even HPD  pussy-footed around it by saying this:
https://www.honolulupd.org/policy/policy-gun-violence-protective-orders/

"Recover."  Yeah.  Right.

Basically, the initial GVPO is granted with only the applicant and their witnesses giving the court their side of the story.  Once the GPVO is granted, there's a hearing scheduled and the respondant (gun owner) notified via serving the order.

What happens, but is glossed over, is the GVPO was issued without the gun owner's knowledge, then the Cops show up to "recover" all his guns and ammo.

Only then will a hearing be held to decide if a one-year GVPO will be granted.

As we all know, even if the respondent prevails in the hearing, they still have to go through the permit process again to retrieve their firearms. 

What's also not included because of the timing of when the law was written is whether or not someone with a CC license will (a) have it revoked as well, and (b) allowed to bypass all the permit BS when they try to "recover" their property.


The law does not say that a person has to get a permit to purchase when retrieving their firearms after a cancelled GVPO, it just says a criminal background check.
[§134-68]  Return and disposal of firearms or ammunition.  (a)  A county police department shall return any surrendered or removed firearm or ammunition requested by a respondent only after confirming, through a criminal history background check, that the respondent is currently eligible to own or possess firearms and ammunition.

Firearm owners have the option of turning in the firearms later if they are served when they are not in possession, like for example if they are at work.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 21, 2023, 01:21:32 PM

Hmmmmmm, flap found it. OOPPPSIIEEE DAISSSSYYY. (In Billy Madison voice) Someone was wrong.

So you can thank Flapp for finding it for you
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 21, 2023, 01:25:42 PM
Wait, how did you know about this info?  EEF posted that its constitutional and due process is met. He even posted the link to the law, which was only 1 part and didn't even address what I was saying. Then he posted other parts and STILL DIDN'T READ IT CORRECTLY.

You seem to confuse constitutionality and due process, they are not the same thing. Whether the law is constitutional is a separate question from whether the law has due process.

You said there was no due process. I posted the sections that had due process in them. Now you are saying it didn't address what you were saying... moving goalposts.

I am beginning to think you don't understand what due process is.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process

Uno!
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 21, 2023, 01:54:17 PM
You seem to confuse constitutionality and due process, they are not the same thing. Whether the law is constitutional is a separate question from whether the law has due process.

You said there was no due process. I posted the sections that had due process in them. Now you are saying it didn't address what you were saying... moving goalposts.

I am beginning to think you don't understand what due process is.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process

Uno!

Due process is in the Constitution Jean. I'll let you figure out which part, hint hint, it's not the 1st or 2nd amendment...

Thanks for trying to turn it around and show how silly ur wrong arguement is.

BTW, you still didn't admit you were wrong. Jean 2.0.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 21, 2023, 01:54:32 PM
So you can thank Flapp for finding it for you

So you gonna admit you were wrong?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 21, 2023, 09:09:08 PM
Due process is in the Constitution Jean. I'll let you figure out which part, hint hint, it's not the 1st or 2nd amendment...

Thanks for trying to turn it around and show how silly ur wrong arguement is.

BTW, you still didn't admit you were wrong. Jean 2.0.

I don't lie, that is why I didn't admit I was wrong.

Yes, due process is in the constitution, I didn't say it wasn't. Swoosh

You haven't even shown why it is unconstitutional or lacks due process, you only claim it, wrongly. Maybe because you still don't know what due process means. 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 08:24:03 AM
I don't lie, that is why I didn't admit I was wrong.

Yes, due process is in the constitution, I didn't say it wasn't. Swoosh

You haven't even shown why it is unconstitutional or lacks due process, you only claim it, wrongly. Maybe because you still don't know what due process means.

Wow, now you think lying is the same as being wrong? No wonder you think that the constitution and due process aren't part of each other.

Thanks for pushing it back on me Jean and not reading it for yourself. 

Flapp explained why it lacks due process/unconstitutional, your ego isn't allowing you to admit you were wrong.  Maybe you should re-read the ENTIRE red flag law section very slowly again. 

Also, I'm still waiting for you to post another states red flag law that shows is constitutional (ie.due process).

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on November 22, 2023, 08:56:08 AM
I swooshed CMO because his comments suggest red flag laws with due process are not possible and when I point out they are possible, he switches and asks where they exist. He is changing the parameters of the debate. Do they exist is a different question of whether they can exist.

Not sure if you meant to do this but you basically laid out an argument about whether due process was present based on whether you trusted the judges. Due process does not exist based on whether you (or I) trust the judges. I share your skepticism of the judges but that does not have a bearing of whether the law, as written, contains due process protections or not.

On the previous page I linked to part of the Hawaii red flag law and I illustrated how there is due process in the hearings that are prescribed. I explained how there is a short initial revocation (14 days) followed by a hearing in which the respondent may argue their case. And even after that, the respondent may ask the court for an additional hearing anytime during the year long revocation. This is, by definition, due process.

So just because a judge is present that makes it due process? No trial and guns get taken before you’ve had a chance to even know what’s going on satisfies the components of due process?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 09:53:58 AM
So just because a judge is present that makes it due process? No trial and guns get taken before you’ve had a chance to even know what’s going on satisfies the components of due process?

I guess to EEF, this is what he calls "due process".  SSD shows up at your door to give you the order and take your guns away at the same time. Then you go to court by 14 days to give your side of the situation. Guilty until you prove youre innocent. Due process.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 22, 2023, 10:48:56 AM
I guess to EEF, this is what he calls "due process".  SSD shows up at your door to give you the order and take your guns away at the same time. Then you go to court by 14 days to give your side of the situation. Guilty until you prove youre innocent. Due process.

If I've said it once, I'll I've said it 100 times:  If someone is deemed too dangerous to possess guns and ammo, they are too dangerous to be free in society.

Either lock them up during an evaluation, or leave them and their guns alone.

Of course, the red flag law can't possibly be focused on the mental health of a human being and the risk they pose to themselves and/or others.  It's all about the guns and taking them away.

After all, people have a Constitutional right to not be arrested before they've committed a crime.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 04:24:14 PM
So just because a judge is present that makes it due process? No trial and guns get taken before you’ve had a chance to even know what’s going on satisfies the components of due process?

Having a judge present would be part of the due process but not all of it. Due process involves laying out procedures and steps that must be taken to protect an individual's rights. Due process includes the right to present evidence, the right to appeal, the right to a hearing, rules that are set out to give consistent application, etc.

Hawaii's red flag law incorporates these due process steps. Certainly one could make the argument that there is not enough due process in Hawaii's red flag law but what CMO cannot seem to understand is that even if he thinks there is not enough due process protections it is factually inaccurate to say there is no due process in the law.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 04:26:28 PM
Wow, now you think lying is the same as being wrong?

Swoosh!

Quote
No wonder you think that the constitution and due process aren't part of each other.

Strawman, swoosh


Quote
Flapp explained why it lacks due process/unconstitutional, your ego isn't allowing you to admit you were wrong.  Maybe you should re-read the ENTIRE red flag law section very slowly again. 

Wrong.

Quote
Also, I'm still waiting for you to post another states red flag law that shows is constitutional (ie.due process).

I never made such a claim.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 04:30:17 PM
If I've said it once, I'll I've said it 100 times:  If someone is deemed too dangerous to possess guns and ammo, they are too dangerous to be free in society.

Either lock them up during an evaluation, or leave them and their guns alone.

Of course, the red flag law can't possibly be focused on the mental health of a human being and the risk they pose to themselves and/or others.  It's all about the guns and taking them away.

After all, people have a Constitutional right to not be arrested before they've committed a crime.

I think the problem is people view this through the lens of criminal law. This falls into the realm of mental health law which has a different burden of proof than criminal law so it is difficult to try and apply the standards of criminal law to mental health law.

I have agreed with you in the past though, that if we think the person is too mentally unstable to own a firearm that they should be brought in for a mental health evaluation. It makes no sense to saw someone is mentally dangerous but then not do any mental health assessment.

I do not subscribe to your belief that it is simply about disarming a population. I think that the left genuinely believes they are doing things that will save lives.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 04:31:54 PM
Having a judge present would be part of the due process but not all of it. Due process involves laying out procedures and steps that must be taken to protect an individual's rights. Due process includes the right to present evidence, the right to appeal, the right to a hearing, rules that are set out to give consistent application, etc.

Hawaii's red flag law incorporates these due process steps. Certainly one could make the argument that there is not enough due process in Hawaii's red flag law but what CMO cannot seem to understand is that even if he thinks there is not enough due process protections it is factually inaccurate to say there is no due process in the law.

You just posted EVERYTHING that out law doesn't have before they take the guns away. Thanks for making my point that you're wrong and unable to post a Constitutional red flag law.  YOU clearly cannot seem to understand what due process is.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 04:33:22 PM
Swoosh!

Strawman, swoosh


Wrong.

I never made such a claim.


Hahahhahha nice Jeanism answer. Just because u keep saying something, doesn't make it correct. At first I was making fun of Jean, but now I think we found the new Jean.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 04:34:25 PM
I think the problem is people view this through the lens of criminal law. This falls into the realm of mental health law which has a different burden of proof than criminal law so it is difficult to try and apply the standards of criminal law to mental health law.



Constitutional law maybe? Still waiting for you to post one that's constitutional.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 04:35:26 PM
Constitutional law maybe? Still waiting for you to post one that's constitutional.

Why bother, you are just going to deny it.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 04:37:33 PM
You just posted EVERYTHING that out law doesn't have before they take the guns away. Thanks for making my point that you're wrong and unable to post a Constitutional red flag law.  YOU clearly cannot seem to understand what due process is.


I mentioned aspects of due process, all of those aspects are within Hawaii's law. You are either lying or willfully ignorant
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 06:17:22 PM
Why bother, you are just going to deny it.
So u cant find any. We all knew this from many post ago. Thanks for playing. Do not pass Go. Return the game.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 06:19:22 PM

I mentioned aspects of due process, all of those aspects are within Hawaii's law. You are either lying or willfully ignorant
Wow, keep pushing it back on me. Just goes to show u cant prove it.


So heres a thought. If eef thinks HIs red flag is constitutional and i keep asking to post another cause it isnt. Then eef could post any of the other 22 ones because they are all the same concept. But he didnt. So he knows hes wrong but refuses to admit it.

God i hope u dont ever have to uphold the constitution.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 22, 2023, 07:10:32 PM
CMO:1+1=2

EEF:it may equal 3

CMO:prove it

EEF:ignores

*some time later

CMO:asked eef to prove it again

EEF: all u gotta do is add 7 to that. Then divide the total by 3. Thus getting 1+1=3

CMO:wrong

EEF: ur lying. U prove it. Ill take ur silence that u admit i won.

Lul. Bruh.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 22, 2023, 10:14:29 PM
Wow, keep pushing it back on me. Just goes to show u cant prove it.


I already pointed to the hearings, I already pointed to the appeals process, etc. What do you think will come of me posting it for you a 3rd time or 4th time? You think the text will magically change by posting it again?

Not sure why you can't let this go, am I living rent free in your head?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 23, 2023, 07:11:27 AM



I already pointed to the hearings, I already pointed to the appeals process, etc. What do you think will come of me posting it for you a 3rd time or 4th time? You think the text will magically change by posting it again?

Not sure why you can't let this go, am I living rent free in your head?

"I already pointed to the hearings". Wow. 1+1=3.

U still dont understand due process.

Just because u keep posting wrong info, doesnt make u correct Jean.

Why dont u admit ur wrong?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 25, 2023, 12:25:28 AM

"I already pointed to the hearings". Wow. 1+1=3.

U still dont understand due process.

Just because u keep posting wrong info, doesnt make u correct Jean.

Why dont u admit ur wrong?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

So you are saying a hearing is not part of due process? You are saying that an appeals process is not part of due process? You are saying that considering evidence is not part of due process?

Thank you for confirming you don't understand what due process is.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 25, 2023, 07:04:25 AM
So you are saying a hearing is not part of due process? You are saying that an appeals process is not part of due process? You are saying that considering evidence is not part of due process?

Thank you for confirming you don't understand what due process is.
Thank u for saying 1+1 can = 3.

Still waiting for u to post a red flag law that allows due process.

Thanks for ignoring and trying to play.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 25, 2023, 09:40:47 AM
Thank u for saying 1+1 can = 3.

Still waiting for u to post a red flag law that allows due process.

Thanks for ignoring and trying to play.

He apparently has a problem with chronology.

It's not 1 + 1 = 3, as much as it's 1 o'clock is immediately followed by 3 o'clock.  After 3, 2 o'clock chimes. 

As long as the numbers are all there, sequence is unimportant.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 25, 2023, 04:45:29 PM
He apparently has a problem with chronology.

It's not 1 + 1 = 3, as much as it's 1 o'clock is immediately followed by 3 o'clock.  After 3, 2 o'clock chimes. 

As long as the numbers are all there, sequence is unimportant.
U did spell it out for him. But i guess u, me, many pro 2a orgs are all wrong and eef, moms demand action, everytown, brady org are all right.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 25, 2023, 10:52:49 PM
Thank u for saying 1+1 can = 3.

Still waiting for u to post a red flag law that allows due process.

Thanks for ignoring and trying to play.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Gotcha, so hearings, judges, evidence, and appeals are not due process. Where do you teach law again?.

I am pointing at an apple and you are sitting here trying to tell me it isn't an apple. Nothing more I can do if you want to ignore reality.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 25, 2023, 10:58:08 PM


Gotcha, so hearings, judges, evidence, and appeals are not due process. Where do you teach law again?.

I am pointing at an apple and you are sitting here trying to tell me it isn't an apple. Nothing more I can do if you want to ignore reality.

Read what flapp posted. Due process doesnt mean what YOU feel/think it means.

Thanks for playing and ignoring reality.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 25, 2023, 10:58:45 PM
Still waiting for u to post a constitutional red flag law.........

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 25, 2023, 11:14:52 PM

Read what flapp posted. Due process doesnt mean what YOU feel/think it means.

Thanks for playing and ignoring reality.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process
 ::)
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 26, 2023, 07:33:29 AM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process
 ::)
Thanks for proving im right.

Funny, we had this convo before when red flags 1st were invented.

How come eef hasnt posted any other states red flag since there "may" be 1 thats constitutional. Its because theyre all the same and he knows hes wrong. Which is why he 1st posted the tail end of our red flag law, instead of the enite thing.

Guess since they 1st began, he still hasnt realized the violation.

Heres a huuuuuge hint. TAKE THE GUNS 1ST isnt due process.

Thanks for playing. Its obvious u havent seen a doc yet.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 26, 2023, 09:24:40 AM
Thanks for proving im right.

Funny, we had this convo before when red flags 1st were invented.

How come eef hasnt posted any other states red flag since there "may" be 1 thats constitutional. Its because theyre all the same and he knows hes wrong. Which is why he 1st posted the tail end of our red flag law, instead of the enite thing.

Guess since they 1st began, he still hasnt realized the violation.

Heres a huuuuuge hint. TAKE THE GUNS 1ST isnt due process.

Thanks for playing. Its obvious u havent seen a doc yet.

He thinks a hearing within 2 weeks AFTER the guns and ammo are confiscated constitutes "fairness" for the respondent. 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 26, 2023, 09:59:05 AM
He thinks a hearing within 2 weeks AFTER the guns and ammo are confiscated constitutes "fairness" for the respondent.
This is the 2nd time in this thread that this was mentioned. And again in the prior red flag thread.

But hey, i guess as long as "due process" is applied at some point, even after a right is taken away, its all G.

How come red flags dont also take knives, hammers, etc...away?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 26, 2023, 01:54:25 PM
This is the 2nd time in this thread that this was mentioned. And again in the prior red flag thread.

But hey, i guess as long as "due process" is applied at some point, even after a right is taken away, its all G.

How come red flags dont also take knives, hammers, etc...away?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 26, 2023, 04:21:13 PM
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.

Name the 2 categories of Due Process in the US, and then maybe you'll see why your comment above is wrong.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 26, 2023, 05:33:44 PM
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.
I sense goal post moving....

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 26, 2023, 05:34:32 PM
Still waiting for u to post a red flag law that has due process....

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 26, 2023, 10:26:13 PM
Name the 2 categories of Due Process in the US, and then maybe you'll see why your comment above is wrong.

Substantive due process and procedural due process.

Hawaii red flag law clearly has procedural due process, so no, I wasn't wrong in there.

Substantive due process is more of a gray area and is subject to more interpretation. Some justices, Clarence Thomas included, reject the substantive due process concept. Within this concept there is more room where you could make that Hawaii's red flag law does not have/does not have enough due process protections. Not really any definitive answers on this one, not until a court rules on it and sets precedence.

Red flag laws aren't the only times rights are taken away prior to a hearing though so why do you think red flag laws are unique from others?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 26, 2023, 10:49:56 PM
Substantive due process and procedural due process.

Hawaii red flag law clearly has procedural due process, so no, I wasn't wrong in there.

Substantive due process is more of a gray area and is subject to more interpretation. Some justices, Clarence Thomas included, reject the substantive due process concept. Within this concept there is more room where you could make that Hawaii's red flag law does not have/does not have enough due process protections. Not really any definitive answers on this one, not until a court rules on it and sets precedence.

Red flag laws aren't the only times rights are taken away prior to a hearing though so why do you think red flag laws are unique from others?

Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
Quote
"substantive due process protects individuals against majoritarian policy
enactments that exceed the limits of governmental authority: courts may
find that a majority's enactment is not law and cannot be enforced as such,
even if the processes of enactment and enforcement were actually fair.[3]
...
Much substantive due process litigation involves legal challenges to the validity
of unenumerated rights and seek particular outcomes instead of merely contesting
procedures and their effects.

In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 27, 2023, 07:43:34 AM
Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.

IDK how many times you or me have to spell it out for EEF. Ego is probably getting in the way of logical thinking at this point.  Or incompetence, but at this point, because it was spelled out, one cannot blame that anymore really.  Versus not being told the why he's wrong.

BRB, HPD is locking someone up for 5 years and then giving them their trial to "prove their innocence". #dueprocess cause it was given at some point along the way.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 27, 2023, 10:07:46 AM
IDK how many times you or me have to spell it out for EEF. Ego is probably getting in the way of logical thinking at this point.  Or incompetence, but at this point, because it was spelled out, one cannot blame that anymore really.  Versus not being told the why he's wrong.

BRB, HPD is locking someone up for 5 years and then giving them their trial to "prove their innocence". #dueprocess cause it was given at some point along the way.

There was a case that perfectly demonstrates the due process concept.

A person who was ineligible to possess firearms was found to have an unregistered gun.  He was charged with a registration infraction.

That charge was thrown out on due process violations, because the laws infringed on the defendant's 5th amendment protections.

Since he was not legally allowed guns, registration would have constituted confessing to having guns he shouldn't.  So, the law to register was deemed unconstitutional IN THAT CASE.

It had nothing to do with the law being applied fairly or correctly in general.  Nor did it turn on any procedural mistakes or improprieties.  It was about violating the man's RIGHTS, which falls under Substantive Due Process. 

The state passing a law may make its enforcement legal, but not when it violates the rights of the individual.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 27, 2023, 11:58:18 PM
Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.


An absence of substantive due process does not mean an absence of procedural due process. Yes, they both matter, but I never said they didn't.

If you think there is no gray area in substantive due process you might want to take that up with the justices who disagree significantly about it.

If the law states 2 weeks to the hearing, for example, but they are backed up and it takes 2 months then I do think that is a big problem because then the government isn't even following the rules it is supposed to and I do think there would be grounds to file a suit over due process violations there. Personally I think 2 weeks is longer than I would like to see, I would like to see something much shorter, like 3 days. But if we use criminal charges as any parallel by which to measure, people are often held much longer waiting for trial when they are arrested upon accusation of a crime. Even if there was no crime and you were taken in on an involuntary mental health evaluation, you aren't going to get an immediate hearing if you are detained longer than a day or two. Furthermore a judge doesn't make the initial detention call, a doctor does. So whether you look at it from a criminal lens or a mental health lens, taking the firearms only, with a hearing in 2 weeks, is still less restriction on a person's rights than physically locking them away.

Ideally I would prefer to see a system where there is a hearing before any revocation of rights instead of an initial order followed by a hearing soon after but I do not think that an initial revocation followed by a 2 week wait is in and of iteself unconstitutional. Honestly I do not know exactly where I would draw the line between a constitutional time and an unconstitutional time, 3 days would be allowable in my opinion, 3 months would be too long. 2 weeks? Longer than I would want but don't think I can argue it is unconstitutional.

You have stated that if the person is so dangerous then they should be locked up instead of just having their guns taken away but would you really support that law if enacted? I suspect not due to the same reasons that someone could make false reports, but then if that is the main concern, would anything really change if the order had a hearing first with the respondent present and then the firearms were seized? I think the outcome would be the same in terms of angry ex-spouses lying on the forms to get you in trouble. Would you consider it constitutional if the hearing (with the respondent present) happened prior to any firearm revocation order?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 28, 2023, 08:07:45 AM

An absence of substantive due process does not mean an absence of procedural due process. Yes, they both matter, but I never said they didn't.

If you think there is no gray area in substantive due process you might want to take that up with the justices who disagree significantly about it.

If the law states 2 weeks to the hearing, for example, but they are backed up and it takes 2 months then I do think that is a big problem because then the government isn't even following the rules it is supposed to and I do think there would be grounds to file a suit over due process violations there. Personally I think 2 weeks is longer than I would like to see, I would like to see something much shorter, like 3 days. But if we use criminal charges as any parallel by which to measure, people are often held much longer waiting for trial when they are arrested upon accusation of a crime. Even if there was no crime and you were taken in on an involuntary mental health evaluation, you aren't going to get an immediate hearing if you are detained longer than a day or two. Furthermore a judge doesn't make the initial detention call, a doctor does. So whether you look at it from a criminal lens or a mental health lens, taking the firearms only, with a hearing in 2 weeks, is still less restriction on a person's rights than physically locking them away.

Ideally I would prefer to see a system where there is a hearing before any revocation of rights instead of an initial order followed by a hearing soon after but I do not think that an initial revocation followed by a 2 week wait is in and of iteself unconstitutional. Honestly I do not know exactly where I would draw the line between a constitutional time and an unconstitutional time, 3 days would be allowable in my opinion, 3 months would be too long. 2 weeks? Longer than I would want but don't think I can argue it is unconstitutional.

You have stated that if the person is so dangerous then they should be locked up instead of just having their guns taken away but would you really support that law if enacted? I suspect not due to the same reasons that someone could make false reports, but then if that is the main concern, would anything really change if the order had a hearing first with the respondent present and then the firearms were seized? I think the outcome would be the same in terms of angry ex-spouses lying on the forms to get you in trouble. Would you consider it constitutional if the hearing (with the respondent present) happened prior to any firearm revocation order?

Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 28, 2023, 09:00:35 AM
Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.

Sounds like he would be okay with having his car or truck taken during a traffic stop because the Cops suspected he might be using it in the commission of a crime -- a crime that hasn't happened yet, but based simply on his wife calling 911 saying he was using it to transport illegal gambling money from cock fights.

As long as he gets a hearing while his vehicle is impounded and has to pay for storage AND a lawyer, it's all good -- no rights violated.

The trial takes an extra long time due to backlogs and postponements by the prosecutor, so now he's been without his vehicle for months.  Not having transportation also lost him his primary job which is 3rd shift when busses are not running, plus his side gig delivering for Door Dash.

The hardships only begin there.  Everything in his life becomes an impossible task without his vehicle, which he still has to make monthly payments on and can't afford to buy another vehicle -- hard to make payments without income, can't sell it while it's being held under asset forfeiture laws, and so on.  All this can crash his credit rating .... and the downward spiral continues.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 28, 2023, 09:25:51 AM
Sounds like he would be okay with having his car or truck taken during a traffic stop because the Cops suspected he might be using it in the commission of a crime -- a crime that hasn't happened yet, but based simply on his wife calling 911 saying he was using it to transport illegal gambling money from cock fights.

As long as he gets a hearing while his vehicle is impounded and has to pay for storage AND a lawyer, it's all good -- no rights violated.

The trial takes an extra long time due to backlogs and postponements by the prosecutor, so now he's been without his vehicle for months.  Not having transportation also lost him his primary job which is 3rd shift when busses are not running, plus his side gig delivering for Door Dash.

The hardships only begin there.  Everything in his life becomes an impossible task without his vehicle, which he still has to make monthly payments on and can't afford to buy another vehicle -- hard to make payments without income, can't sell it while it's being held under asset forfeiture laws, and so on.  All this can crash his credit rating .... and the downward spiral continues.

And unlike the 2nd amendment, a car or mode of transportation isn't specifically listed like how the right to bear arms is.  I mean, there is the property mention, but not specifically like the 2A.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 30, 2023, 06:11:01 AM
Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.

You keep telling yourself that.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 30, 2023, 08:03:10 AM
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.

And I posted to you getting your guns (2A right) taken away BEFORE the hearing is not due process. We covered this also in the OG red flag law thread. 

Thanks for not admitting you're wrong. Thanks for playing.

Not enough=none.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 30, 2023, 08:04:06 AM
You keep telling yourself that.

Everyone can see this, well, everyone but you.

Does the goal post mover know they're moving goal post?  Does the ego driven person know they have an ego?  Does an incompetent person know they're incompetent? Does a HPD rights violator know they're violating someone's right?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 01, 2023, 09:26:16 PM
And I posted to you getting your guns (2A right) taken away BEFORE the hearing is not due process. We covered this also in the OG red flag law thread. 

Thanks for not admitting you're wrong. Thanks for playing.

Not enough=none.

So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 01, 2023, 10:08:34 PM
So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.

Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 02, 2023, 08:05:50 AM
So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.
Please show me where i said "arrested".

Nice goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 02, 2023, 08:06:31 AM
Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.
Its goal post moving. Thats all he has for his wrong arguments.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 02, 2023, 08:19:01 AM
Its goal post moving. Thats all he has for his wrong arguments.

And his whataboutism game is weak (what about CRIMINALS being arrested before trial?  Was their due process right violated?).

#FruitSalad
#Apples&Oranges
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on December 02, 2023, 09:07:22 AM
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 02, 2023, 09:50:00 AM
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

But, it's Constitutional as long as they give you a hearing ... a week or two later.

 :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 02, 2023, 10:02:36 PM
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

Not really the best comparison because this isn't a criminal issue, this is a civil issue. Sometimes a crime is involved (like domestic violence) but the process is a civil one. You can have your rights taken away from you in mental health cases prior to having a hearing.
Also, someone actually does make allegations against you for this type of order to take place.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 02, 2023, 10:07:34 PM
Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.

I already agreed with you that if the judge thinks someone is that dangerous then they should bring him in for a mental health examination.

As for your pointing out he hasn't been accused of committing any crime I already pointed out to you that people are taken into medical custody for mental health evaluations without committing a crime.

The point I was making to you is that having a hearing for the accused to be present doesn't have to occur before they lose their rights, whether in criminal or civil procedures.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 02, 2023, 10:10:47 PM
Please show me where i said "arrested".

Nice goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't say you said arrested, focus. I was giving you an example where someone's rights are taken away before a hearing.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 02, 2023, 10:38:28 PM
I already agreed with you that if the judge thinks someone is that dangerous then they should bring him in for a mental health examination.

As for your pointing out he hasn't been accused of committing any crime I already pointed out to you that people are taken into medical custody for mental health evaluations without committing a crime.

The point I was making to you is that having a hearing for the accused to be present doesn't have to occur before they lose their rights, whether in criminal or civil procedures.

Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2023, 07:04:52 AM
I didn't say you said arrested, focus. I was giving you an example where someone's rights are taken away before a hearing.
Thanks for admitting goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2023, 07:09:33 AM
Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
He has no logic to his answer. Like when Charlie Kirk debates someone. Fact vs. feelings. And in this case ego.

He keeps repeating things that arent true, in hopes no one calls him out on it, thus making what he said is true.

Then there is only so many ways to show hes wrong, but he requires even more evidence. So its simpler to stop explaining after a certain point. Like talking to a retarded person, sometimes u can only explain so much.

Someone else does on TV this often, which is where he gets his new nickname from.

Red flag laws dont even have enough to even arrest the person.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 03, 2023, 09:23:49 PM
Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.

What do you mean no such standard exists for red flag laws? If you think someone simply says "I don't like Flapp having guns" that is not enough for the judge to go take your guns.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0064.htm
According to the HRS
(d)  In determining whether sufficient grounds for an ex parte gun violence protective order exist, the court shall consider all relevant evidence presented by the petitioner, and may also consider other relevant evidence, including evidence of facts relating to the respondent's:

     (1)  Unlawful, reckless, or negligent use, display, storage, possession, or brandishing of a firearm;
     (2)  Act or threat of violence against the respondent's self or another person, regardless of whether the violence involves a firearm;
     (3)  Violation of a protective order or restraining order issued pursuant to chapter 586 or section 604-10.5, or a similar law in another state;
     (4)  Abuse of controlled substances or alcohol or commission of any criminal offense that involves controlled substances or alcohol; and
     (5)  Recent acquisition of any firearms, ammunition, or other deadly weapons.

Look at 1-5, those are "SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others" as you put it.

And the HRS even sets a standard of proof
(f)  If the court finds probable cause to believe that the respondent poses an imminent danger of causing bodily injury to the respondent's self or another person by owning, purchasing, possessing, receiving, or having in the respondent's custody or control any firearm or ammunition, the court shall issue an ex parte gun violence protective order.

Then in the next section, look a standard!
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0065.htm
(c)  If the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence at the hearing that the respondent poses a significant danger of causing bodily injury to the respondent's self or another person by owning, purchasing, possessing, receiving, or having in the respondent's custody or control any firearm or ammunition, the court shall issue a one-year gun violence protective order.

Holding someone for a mental eval is still restricting your constitutional rights, and as I pointed out to you, it is a greater restriction than restricting firearm ownership. If you are in a mental facility for an evaluation your freedom to do many things is restricted.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 03, 2023, 09:26:12 PM
Thanks for admitting goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 03, 2023, 09:33:28 PM
Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?

You are so dumb:
Quote
United States v. Rahimi is a pending United States Supreme Court case
regarding the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution and
whether it confers the government's ability to prohibit firearm possession
by a person with a domestic violence restraining order.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 03, 2023, 09:41:15 PM
You are so dumb:


Someone clearly doesn't understand this case

Rahimi AGREED to the stipulation that he not have firearms. That is why this case is different than a challenge to a normal restraining order.

How does your foot taste?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 03, 2023, 10:03:44 PM

Someone clearly doesn't understand this case

Rahimi AGREED to the stipulation that he not have firearms. That is why this case is different than a challenge to a normal restraining order.

How does your foot taste?

Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 08:26:43 AM
Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?

So you're arguments is that unless SCOTUS takes it up, it's not unconstitutional?  Guess HI chief of police denying people their CCW all these decades is constitutional cause until Bruen and Young vs. Hawaii, it was OK cause the courts didn't decide it.  Same with HI's mag limit and SBR restrictions.  Please tell me how many lawsuits HI won in the past 8 years about 2A stuff...the answer is ZERO. Which means they were on the books and violating peoples right until someone had the $ to challenge it.  So to answer your question, there is no SCOTUS case yet.  Are you now trying to make yourself sound right about something since you've been wrong a lot. Why not ask me what 1+1 equals.

I don't have to imagine law makers modifying or making laws that lack due process, they already have done so, most recent with Red Flag law. We discussed this already.

Now you're asking if other than red flag restraing orders are constitutional, I reply with a no as they too lack due process.  I know a guy who used to work in a judges chamber and he saw all the time how TRO's are abused for custody battles.  Long story short, the 1st person to file one wins.

But lets keep the focus on red flag law and how you have yet to post a constitutional one. Are you having trouble finding it?

Heres one of the 1st that you cannot use since it's unconstitutional. WA, a man was inside his home and had his firearm holstered. Thru his window, he was "looking at his neighbors funny". So he got his guns taken away. When asked about any prior interaction, the neighbors said they never interacted with him, but he looked at them funny. He got his guns taken away. IDK what the outcome later was, but his 2A right was taken away without due process first. Cops showed up at his door and consfiscsated his guns. Court later.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 08:28:10 AM
Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

Or maybe he did, but doesn't understand it. There is no one near him to explain stuff with a chalkboard.

Tism awareness month.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 04, 2023, 02:28:06 PM
Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to listen to the podcast.

Hypocrite much?

You didn't even address where you claimed there was no standard but I pointed it out to you in the law.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 04, 2023, 02:54:25 PM
So you're arguments is that unless SCOTUS takes it up, it's not unconstitutional?  Guess HI chief of police denying people their CCW all these decades is constitutional cause until Bruen and Young vs. Hawaii, it was OK cause the courts didn't decide it.  Same with HI's mag limit and SBR restrictions.  Please tell me how many lawsuits HI won in the past 8 years about 2A stuff...the answer is ZERO. Which means they were on the books and violating peoples right until someone had the $ to challenge it.  So to answer your question, there is no SCOTUS case yet.  Are you now trying to make yourself sound right about something since you've been wrong a lot. Why not ask me what 1+1 equals.

I don't have to imagine law makers modifying or making laws that lack due process, they already have done so, most recent with Red Flag law. We discussed this already.

Now you're asking if other than red flag restraing orders are constitutional, I reply with a no as they too lack due process.  I know a guy who used to work in a judges chamber and he saw all the time how TRO's are abused for custody battles.  Long story short, the 1st person to file one wins.

But lets keep the focus on red flag law and how you have yet to post a constitutional one. Are you having trouble finding it?

Heres one of the 1st that you cannot use since it's unconstitutional. WA, a man was inside his home and had his firearm holstered. Thru his window, he was "looking at his neighbors funny". So he got his guns taken away. When asked about any prior interaction, the neighbors said they never interacted with him, but he looked at them funny. He got his guns taken away. IDK what the outcome later was, but his 2A right was taken away without due process first. Cops showed up at his door and consfiscsated his guns. Court later.


Strawman. My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended.

Now you can, and did, say there was no SCOTUS case on it, which is fine, and honest of you, but what you have to recognize is that means this issue is in dispute. Now you and I and every other joe blow on the internet can argue to we are blue in the face about whether some particular thing is constitutional but that is hardly a decisive answer on the topic. We can take it up a step and cite videos from youtube lawyers that we agree, and that gives us a better understanding of the issues, but we are still left with no decisive answer to the question because you can get 5 experts who say one thing and 5 experts who say another. If I gave you 5 experts who say red flag laws are constitutional are you actually going to change your mind? Ideas of constitutional rights evolve, it took 200+ years for us to arrive at our current understanding of freedom of speech. Someone can claim that the 1st amendment is as clear as day from the text but they would be fundamentally wrong given how it ebbed and flowed over time. All of this is to say that the constitutionality of this question is not a clear obvious one. You can say "i think it is unconstitutional because...." and I can said "I think it is constitutional because..." but we are both just stating our opinions and feelings on the matter. For either to act as if we speak with some divine truth is unwarranted. Because of this I would never insult someone if they thought there wasn't due process when I think there is, I would only make the case for due process being present without climbing on some high horse.

I have seen TROs abused but that is not the fault of the law rather the people making false claims. If I lied and told a cop you hit me you would get arrested the same. Doesn't make assault a bad law, it is just a fact of life that people will take advantage of laws and abuse them sometimes. In fact, I would argue that a TRO taking away firearm gets closer to the line of unconstitutionality than do red flag laws since red flag laws try to target a specific area of danger instead of just saying "my ex harassed me so take away his guns as well". But that is another topic.

The example you gave of WA, if as simple as you say, would be unconstitutional, in my opinion. Not for a lack of a pre-seizure hearing but for lack of any evidence to conclude he is dangerous. However this is where judges and petitioners need to be held accountable. If a law, like ours, says that you must have a certain level of proof but a judge grants the order without sufficient proof then that is the fault of the judge, just like any other case where a judge makes a bad decision.



So, if you can answer my other question, if the system were changed so that a hearing with the respondent being present was required before any seizure, would you then feel this would be a constitutional revocation or at least sufficient due process?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 04:22:46 PM

Strawman. My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended.

Now you can, and did, say there was no SCOTUS case on it, which is fine, and honest of you, but what you have to recognize is that means this issue is in dispute. Now you and I and every other joe blow on the internet can argue to we are blue in the face about whether some particular thing is constitutional but that is hardly a decisive answer on the topic. We can take it up a step and cite videos from youtube lawyers that we agree, and that gives us a better understanding of the issues, but we are still left with no decisive answer to the question because you can get 5 experts who say one thing and 5 experts who say another. If I gave you 5 experts who say red flag laws are constitutional are you actually going to change your mind? Ideas of constitutional rights evolve, it took 200+ years for us to arrive at our current understanding of freedom of speech. Someone can claim that the 1st amendment is as clear as day from the text but they would be fundamentally wrong given how it ebbed and flowed over time. All of this is to say that the constitutionality of this question is not a clear obvious one. You can say "i think it is unconstitutional because...." and I can said "I think it is constitutional because..." but we are both just stating our opinions and feelings on the matter. For either to act as if we speak with some divine truth is unwarranted. Because of this I would never insult someone if they thought there wasn't due process when I think there is, I would only make the case for due process being present without climbing on some high horse.

I have seen TROs abused but that is not the fault of the law rather the people making false claims. If I lied and told a cop you hit me you would get arrested the same. Doesn't make assault a bad law, it is just a fact of life that people will take advantage of laws and abuse them sometimes. In fact, I would argue that a TRO taking away firearm gets closer to the line of unconstitutionality than do red flag laws since red flag laws try to target a specific area of danger instead of just saying "my ex harassed me so take away his guns as well". But that is another topic.

The example you gave of WA, if as simple as you say, would be unconstitutional, in my opinion. Not for a lack of a pre-seizure hearing but for lack of any evidence to conclude he is dangerous. However this is where judges and petitioners need to be held accountable. If a law, like ours, says that you must have a certain level of proof but a judge grants the order without sufficient proof then that is the fault of the judge, just like any other case where a judge makes a bad decision.



So, if you can answer my other question, if the system were changed so that a hearing with the respondent being present was required before any seizure, would you then feel this would be a constitutional revocation or at least sufficient due process?

So much Newsom in this post.  Re-read what I posted already to your post

"My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended. "

This is exactly what your argument is saying. Do you even remember what you post?

Since there is no ruling that a 10rd mag ban is not unconstitutional by SCOTUS, then it must be constitutional right?  Same almost all of HI's HRS134, exlcuding Tasers which was just amened recently only cause someone sued HI.

Newson-Tism. Thanks for playing. Will get to the other stuff later that is probaby wrong too. But I'm busy right now.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Wchiro on December 04, 2023, 04:40:40 PM
 :popcorn:  ::) :popcorn:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 04:40:46 PM


Now you can, and did, say there was no SCOTUS case on it, which is fine, and honest of you, but what you have to recognize is that means this issue is in dispute. Now you and I and every other joe blow on the internet can argue to we are blue in the face about whether some particular thing is constitutional but that is hardly a decisive answer on the topic. We can take it up a step and cite videos from youtube lawyers that we agree, and that gives us a better understanding of the issues, but we are still left with no decisive answer to the question because you can get 5 experts who say one thing and 5 experts who say another. If I gave you 5 experts who say red flag laws are constitutional are you actually going to change your mind? Ideas of constitutional rights evolve, it took 200+ years for us to arrive at our current understanding of freedom of speech. Someone can claim that the 1st amendment is as clear as day from the text but they would be fundamentally wrong given how it ebbed and flowed over time. All of this is to say that the constitutionality of this question is not a clear obvious one. You can say "i think it is unconstitutional because...." and I can said "I think it is constitutional because..." but we are both just stating our opinions and feelings on the matter. For either to act as if we speak with some divine truth is unwarranted. Because of this I would never insult someone if they thought there wasn't due process when I think there is, I would only make the case for due process being present without climbing on some high horse.

I have seen TROs abused but that is not the fault of the law rather the people making false claims. If I lied and told a cop you hit me you would get arrested the same. Doesn't make assault a bad law, it is just a fact of life that people will take advantage of laws and abuse them sometimes. In fact, I would argue that a TRO taking away firearm gets closer to the line of unconstitutionality than do red flag laws since red flag laws try to target a specific area of danger instead of just saying "my ex harassed me so take away his guns as well". But that is another topic.

The example you gave of WA, if as simple as you say, would be unconstitutional, in my opinion. Not for a lack of a pre-seizure hearing but for lack of any evidence to conclude he is dangerous. However this is where judges and petitioners need to be held accountable. If a law, like ours, says that you must have a certain level of proof but a judge grants the order without sufficient proof then that is the fault of the judge, just like any other case where a judge makes a bad decision.




So much wrong in here and goal post moving. So to sum it up, you've now earned a rep of being wrong most of the time. I've had others mention you who do not care to post replies that waste their time.  Thanks for playing.  April is coming soon.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 04:44:59 PM




So, if you can answer my other question, if the system were changed so that a hearing with the respondent being present was required before any seizure, would you then feel this would be a constitutional revocation or at least sufficient due process?

It's like you've been told this from day 1 many, many months ago. Are you only now beginning to understand what due process is.  But also add in with a seizure also comes incarceration for what ever crime the person is being accused of.  So not a take the guns, but the person is free to be out as no law was broken.

You asking to show a non-existant SCOTUS case is like you asking for me to post a constitutional red flag law that doesn't exist. 4got to add this in the other post.  Also just because SCOTUS makes a ruling, still doesn't mean it's constutional. Look at the judges who voted against Bruen as an example. Those judges are all corrupt as they aren't incompentant.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 04, 2023, 06:09:37 PM
It's like you've been told this from day 1 many, many months ago. Are you only now beginning to understand what due process is.  But also add in with a seizure also comes incarceration for what ever crime the person is being accused of.  So not a take the guns, but the person is free to be out as no law was broken.

You asking to show a non-existant SCOTUS case is like you asking for me to post a constitutional red flag law that doesn't exist. 4got to add this in the other post.  Also just because SCOTUS makes a ruling, still doesn't mean it's constutional. Look at the judges who voted against Bruen as an example. Those judges are all corrupt as they aren't incompentant.

Q:  What's the purpose of the red flag laws?
A:   To stop a violent crime before it happens.

Where in the Constitution does it say the government is responsible for stopping crime?  Where does it say it has the authority to interfere in citizens' lives before even being accused of a crime?

In my opinion, there is no way a Red Flag law will ever be constitutional.  It gives the government the power to go after a protected right (2A) without a single crime having been committed and without reasonable evidence one is being planned. 

if we are going to treat gun owners like mental cases, then just use the same laws as we use for mental evaluations and stop taking people's guns as if if's a solution.

AGAIN for the 500th time:  If they are too risky to have guns, then they are too risky to allow out on their own.

Period.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Sodie on December 05, 2023, 06:38:18 PM
Tism awareness month.

I assume you’re referring to autism?

We’re making fun of people with disabilities now?

Classy.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 08:32:07 PM
I assume you’re referring to autism?

We’re making fun of people with disabilities now?

Classy.  :thumbsup:

World Autism Month is in April.

US Autism Awareness Month is also in April.

This is not April.

I don't think he's referring to Autism.

Urban dictionary:  TISM includes failure to comprehend sarcasm, rhetorical questions, and other benignly deceptive linguistic devices.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 05, 2023, 09:05:56 PM
So much Newsom in this post.  Re-read what I posted already to your post

"My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended. "

This is exactly what your argument is saying. Do you even remember what you post?

Since there is no ruling that a 10rd mag ban is not unconstitutional by SCOTUS, then it must be constitutional right?  Same almost all of HI's HRS134, exlcuding Tasers which was just amened recently only cause someone sued HI.

Newson-Tism. Thanks for playing. Will get to the other stuff later that is probaby wrong too. But I'm busy right now.

Swoosh

I am not going to keep going in cirlces with you, I articulated points to you multiple times and your replies are basically claiming I am wrong. You have not proven me wrong with anything, just claim I am wrong.

We might as well drop it and save both of ourselves time, you believe you are right, I believe I am, agree to disagree, nothing more to say that can settle this disagreement. I mentioned instances where people have their rights taken away without a hearing before the revocation (both criminal and civil) yet there is still considered to be considered due process present. If you want to find legal experts who explain how this is somehow different then be my guest and we can continue the debate in light of new information but absent that we are going in circles.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Sodie on December 05, 2023, 09:32:46 PM
World Autism Month is in April.

US Autism Awareness Month is also in April.

This is not April.

I don't think he's referring to Autism.

Urban dictionary:  TISM includes failure to comprehend sarcasm, rhetorical questions, and other benignly deceptive linguistic devices.

Really?

Goally.com: “The term ‘Touch of the ‘Tism’ is slang used to characterize individuals displaying signs of autism, a disorder influencing communication, interaction, behavior, and interests.”

Also Urban Dictionary: “Tism: Short for autism.”

Knowyourmeme.com: “Touch Of The 'Tism is a catchphrase and euphemism used online when saying that someone is "a little autistic" or has symptoms or characteristics associated with autism.”

Stay classy!  ::)



Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 10:36:37 PM
Really?

Goally.com: “The term ‘Touch of the ‘Tism’ is slang used to characterize individuals displaying signs of autism, a disorder influencing communication, interaction, behavior, and interests.”

Also Urban Dictionary: “Tism: Short for autism.”

Knowyourmeme.com: “Touch Of The 'Tism is a catchphrase and euphemism used online when saying that someone is "a little autistic" or has symptoms or characteristics associated with autism.”

Stay classy!  ::)

Context matters.

Words can, and do, have more than one meaning.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 06, 2023, 07:42:38 AM
Swoosh

I am not going to keep going in cirlces with you, I articulated points to you multiple times and your replies are basically claiming I am wrong. You have not proven me wrong with anything, just claim I am wrong.

We might as well drop it and save both of ourselves time, you believe you are right, I believe I am, agree to disagree, nothing more to say that can settle this disagreement. I mentioned instances where people have their rights taken away without a hearing before the revocation (both criminal and civil) yet there is still considered to be considered due process present. If you want to find legal experts who explain how this is somehow different then be my guest and we can continue the debate in light of new information but absent that we are going in circles.


IWROOONNGGGG. I keep saying this because you're wrong. I have proven you're wrong, but you refuse to accept it. Whether this is ego or some other factor is affecting your logic.  I don't need a legal expert to explain this and I too have provided examples of unconstitutional stuff that SCOTUS hasn't touched yet. Thanks for playing.  YOU might as well drop it and accept being wrong.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 06, 2023, 10:05:47 AM

IWROOONNGGGG. I keep saying this because you're wrong. I have proven you're wrong, but you refuse to accept it. Whether this is ego or some other factor is affecting your logic.  I don't need a legal expert to explain this and I too have provided examples of unconstitutional stuff that SCOTUS hasn't touched yet. Thanks for playing.  YOU might as well drop it and accept being wrong.

Isn't that what the Flat Earthers say?

"You believe you're right, and i believe I'm right.  Why keep arguing?"

That, after providing proof positive that only one of you is right.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 07, 2023, 09:57:03 PM

IWROOONNGGGG. I keep saying this because you're wrong. I have proven you're wrong, but you refuse to accept it. Whether this is ego or some other factor is affecting your logic.  I don't need a legal expert to explain this and I too have provided examples of unconstitutional stuff that SCOTUS hasn't touched yet. Thanks for playing.  YOU might as well drop it and accept being wrong.

Freudian slip? "Iwrong"

What you keep missing is that this isn't a hard set obvious thing. I watched a bunch of things from the Washington Gun law youtube channel, and I noticed how he often he stated something as his belief or his position. He didn't speak as if he was on some high horse, he didn't say his interpretation was the correct one, he stated where he came down on an issue. Notice how he, an actual lawyer, qualified his statements with such comments, compared to your comments where you state something as if your interpretation is the only obvious correct one. Call it gray area, nuance, interpretation, etc but he recognized where something was unsettled, even though he had a certain opinion on the subject.

I would like more due process protections in our red flag laws just as much as you.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: ren on December 07, 2023, 10:13:58 PM
Idiocracy of arguing for the dissolution of gun rights on a pro 2a website. Its like delivering a pro abortion speech at a Catholic mass. 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 08, 2023, 08:10:49 AM
Freudian slip? "Iwrong"

What you keep missing is that this isn't a hard set obvious thing. I watched a bunch of things from the Washington Gun law youtube channel, and I noticed how he often he stated something as his belief or his position. He didn't speak as if he was on some high horse, he didn't say his interpretation was the correct one, he stated where he came down on an issue. Notice how he, an actual lawyer, qualified his statements with such comments, compared to your comments where you state something as if your interpretation is the only obvious correct one. Call it gray area, nuance, interpretation, etc but he recognized where something was unsettled, even though he had a certain opinion on the subject.

I would like more due process protections in our red flag laws just as much as you.

Wrong. Moms Demand and ET experts also say banning mags and "assault rifles" are constitutional. See, I can find wrong "experts" too.  Thanks for playing.

If this "expert" is right, why haven't you posted the WA red flag law when I asked you to post a constitutional one? 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 08, 2023, 10:37:56 AM
Wrong. Moms Demand and ET experts also say banning mags and "assault rifles" are constitutional. See, I can find wrong "experts" too.  Thanks for playing.

If this "expert" is right, why haven't you posted the WA red flag law when I asked you to post a constitutional one?

Because he believes the current red flag laws already encompass "due process," but now that he's been educated here, he's altered that opinion to "I think there needs to be MORE due process."

LOL!  Talk about refusing to acknowledge when you're wrong!  There aren't degrees of civil rights.  Either they are protected, or they are being violated.  There's no ratio involved.

"We only took away his ability to publish what he thinks of government.  He's still able to speak about it."
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 11, 2023, 09:37:09 PM
Wrong. Moms Demand and ET experts also say banning mags and "assault rifles" are constitutional. See, I can find wrong "experts" too.  Thanks for playing.

If this "expert" is right, why haven't you posted the WA red flag law when I asked you to post a constitutional one?

So by your logic, we don't need experts and case law doesn't matter, we must submit to whatever CMO says is constitutional?

Don't get me wrong, I do not like Hawaii's red flag law.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 11, 2023, 09:38:25 PM
Because he believes the current red flag laws already encompass "due process," but now that he's been educated here, he's altered that opinion to "I think there needs to be MORE due process."


A Mcdonalds hamburger has ketchup on it. Maybe you would like more ketchup but that doesn't mean there is no ketchup just because you want more.
It is not that complicated.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 11, 2023, 10:38:46 PM
A Mcdonalds hamburger has ketchup on it. Maybe you would like more ketchup but that doesn't mean there is no ketchup just because you want more.
It is not that complicated.

So, you think understanding Constitutional rights are as simple as ordering extra condiments?

LOL!!  That explains a lot.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on December 11, 2023, 10:41:47 PM
So, you think understanding Constitutional rights are as simple as ordering extra condiments?

LOL!!  That explains a lot.

By his logic cake batter = cake
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 11, 2023, 10:56:39 PM
By his logic cake batter = cake

He thinks if McDonald's gives him a burger with no ketchup but hands him a coupon for ketchup on a future visit, McDonald's is giving him the ketchup he ordered.

You can't get "more" until you get "some."
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 12, 2023, 08:36:02 AM
So by your logic, we don't need experts and case law doesn't matter, we must submit to whatever CMO says is constitutional?

Don't get me wrong, I do not like Hawaii's red flag law.

SWOOOSSSH. That is all as I'm not allowed to post what i really want to.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 12, 2023, 08:36:52 AM
A Mcdonalds hamburger has ketchup on it. Maybe you would like more ketchup but that doesn't mean there is no ketchup just because you want more.
It is not that complicated.


Hahahahahahhaha

I'm Jack....Lame. (Anchorman 2 reference)
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Brystont1 on December 12, 2023, 08:44:48 AM
He thinks if McDonald's gives him a burger with no ketchup but hands him a coupon for ketchup on a future visit, McDonald's is giving him the ketchup he ordered.

You can't get "more" until you get "some."

If the definition of a burger requires 3 squirts of ketchup yet there is only 1 squirt can you call it a burger?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 12, 2023, 08:50:39 AM
If the definition of a burger requires 3 squirts of ketchup yet there is only 1 squirt can you call it a burger?

What if you get your burger "plain"?  So no lettuce, condiments, onions, etc...Is it still a burger?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 12, 2023, 11:16:32 AM
What if you get your burger "plain"?  So no lettuce, condiments, onions, etc...Is it still a burger?

A hamburger was originally just the samidge:  Bun and ground beef.

Now ground beef is labeled "hamburger," too.

All about the context in today's food world.

Quote
Evidence suggests that either the United States or Germany (the city of Hamburg)
was the first country where two slices of bread and a ground beef patty were
combined into a "hamburger sandwich" and sold.
There is some controversy over the origin of the hamburger because its two basic
ingredients, bread and beef, had been prepared and consumed separately for many
years in both countries before their combination. Shortly after its creation, the
hamburger quickly included all of its currently typically characteristic trimmings,
including onions, lettuce, and sliced pickles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_hamburger
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 12, 2023, 10:11:37 PM
So, you think understanding Constitutional rights are as simple as ordering extra condiments?

LOL!!  That explains a lot.

Swoosh

Not comparing the two, I am giving you a simple example that not enough of something is not the same thing as none. Thats a non sequitur
Hawaii red flag law has due process. You think if doesn't have enough, and that is fine, I would like to see more due process protections as well, but that does not mean there is no due process. If there was no due process at all then it would be obviously unconstitutional. If there is some due process but you feel there needs to be more then it is not so clear whether it is unconstitutional or not.


Another thing to keep in mind in all of this is that unlike normal cases where an officer decides to arrest a person, a TRO, a warrant, and a red flag order are orders from a judge. When a cop receives such an order there is not much room for the cop to make a decision on the merit of the judge's order. A cop often has no idea about the case associated with an arrest warrant, the judge makes the order to have the person arrested and the cop follows the order not knowing whether the judge was correct in finding cause to make the arrest.


We should attack TROs before red flag laws since TROs can revoke your firearm rights without even finding cause you are a threat.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 13, 2023, 08:23:01 AM
Swoosh

Not comparing the two, I am giving you a simple example that not enough of something is not the same thing as none. Thats a non sequitur
Hawaii red flag law has due process. You think if doesn't have enough, and that is fine, I would like to see more due process protections as well, but that does not mean there is no due process. If there was no due process at all then it would be obviously unconstitutional. If there is some due process but you feel there needs to be more then it is not so clear whether it is unconstitutional or not.


Another thing to keep in mind in all of this is that unlike normal cases where an officer decides to arrest a person, a TRO, a warrant, and a red flag order are orders from a judge. When a cop receives such an order there is not much room for the cop to make a decision on the merit of the judge's order. A cop often has no idea about the case associated with an arrest warrant, the judge makes the order to have the person arrested and the cop follows the order not knowing whether the judge was correct in finding cause to make the arrest.


We should attack TROs before red flag laws since TROs can revoke your firearm rights without even finding cause you are a threat.

Re-read everything we posted. I cannot comment any further as I'm not allowed to go deeper into it for you about red flags.

But yes, TRO's are also unconstitutional as they take your guns first before you get a chance to defend any allegations in court.  Re-read my post about custody battles. I have a friend who was served a TRO because his ex claimed he hit her on X date. Turns out he was in and was still in Vegas. So when the cops showed up to his parents home, where he lived, they got him on the phone and verified he was in Vegas and unable to present him with the TRO.  Imagine if he was a gun owner, he would also have his guns taken away.  He had to fight this in court on the assigned date and proved he wasn't even in state on the day she claimed he hit her. TRO dismissed. 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 13, 2023, 07:45:52 PM
Re-read everything we posted. I cannot comment any further as I'm not allowed to go deeper into it for you about red flags.

But yes, TRO's are also unconstitutional as they take your guns first before you get a chance to defend any allegations in court.  Re-read my post about custody battles. I have a friend who was served a TRO because his ex claimed he hit her on X date. Turns out he was in and was still in Vegas. So when the cops showed up to his parents home, where he lived, they got him on the phone and verified he was in Vegas and unable to present him with the TRO.  Imagine if he was a gun owner, he would also have his guns taken away.  He had to fight this in court on the assigned date and proved he wasn't even in state on the day she claimed he hit her. TRO dismissed.

I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 13, 2023, 07:49:46 PM
I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

...

Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: macsak on December 13, 2023, 09:27:05 PM
i love how he repeats his stance, while also trying to get people to "agree to disagree"
goalposts moved...

Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: macsak on December 13, 2023, 09:28:29 PM
so "reiterating" is of, but "repeating" is not?
which one is subjective and which one is objective?

I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 14, 2023, 08:30:58 AM
Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:

Like Jean, the more he repeats wrong information, the more he thinks hes no longer wrong.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 14, 2023, 08:34:05 AM
I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.

I'm glad you don't have amnesia, so that eliminates 1 theory about things.

Flapp already mentioned something like this, but rights don't have gray areas.  Also, you again mention your SCOTUS ruling and see my mag ban example (no amnesia right?). No SCOTUS ruling, so must be constitutional right? And other anti-2A un-SCOTUS rulings.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 14, 2023, 11:54:45 AM
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 14, 2023, 12:11:18 PM
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.

I anticipate a cricket serenade...
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 14, 2023, 04:12:29 PM
I anticipate a cricket serenade...

I anticipate goal post moving or deflection.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 14, 2023, 10:51:40 PM
i love how he repeats his stance, while also trying to get people to "agree to disagree"

What else am I supposed to do if there is an unresolvable disagreement?

Flapp and CMO both repeated their positions multiple times as well. I am just suggesting we move on because it isn't resolveable.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 14, 2023, 11:22:25 PM
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.

You misquote me, purposefully I can't help but wonder.

I never said "red flag laws are constitutional" in fact I criticized you for making blanket statements of that nature. I said red flag laws CAN be constitutional, that it depended on the specifics of each individual law.

If by the Bruen test you mean using text, history, and tradition, that is a methodology, but it isn't a completely binding one, not is it one that gives a clear answer. The History and tradition (redundant) portion creates its own problems, traditionally you could beat you wife, it wasn't a crime way back then so how would you incorporate any history and tradition into a question of punishment for spouse abuse? If you require history and tradition then laws banning spouse abuse would be unconstitutional would they not? Before laws that allowed women to vote they couldn't vote, again, you couldn't satisfy the history test if there was no prior history of women voting. I think you are over-estimating the application of the Buren test. I posted a podcast that went into a lot of these issues, did you even listen to it yet? You ignored where I pointed out to you multiple times that Rahimi is unique because unlike other TRO/Red flag law situations, Rahimi agreed to the stipulation that he not have firearms which means he doesn't have the same due process challenge compared to your average red flag/TRO case.

Why do you think the Bruen decision makes red flag laws unconstitutional.

I am no more a constitutional expert than you are, all we can do is read and listen to people who are more knowledgeable than us to try to form a more supporter opinion. I have read and listened to a number of such people and they don't know which way the court is going to rule or how exactly the text history and tradition framework would apply to the Rahimi case. That should tell you something about all of this. Like I said earlier, for practical purposes, until the SCOTUS rules on this very issue there is no practical answer, only ideological ones. The fact that legal experts aren't even sure how this one will go down alone should inform you that this is not a case where the constitutionality is something so plain and obvious as you claim it to be. I don't have such a solid answer or prediction of how the court will rule on this. If something is obviously unconstitutional it is a much easier answer, but when things are in the gray area the answer is not so obvious. I illustrated to you how there are so many rights that aren't recognized until a court interpreted the constitution a certain way that enshrined them into case law. Take for example a Terry Stop. It wasn't obvious the cop was within his power when he stopped those men, he just did what he thought he could and it was challenged in court which lead to the framework that shapes police detention to this day. There are numerous cases where someone had to do something that was challenged before anyone knew whether it was constitutional or not. 
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 15, 2023, 08:21:42 AM
What else am I supposed to do if there is an unresolvable disagreement?

Flapp and CMO both repeated their positions multiple times as well. I am just suggesting we move on because it isn't resolveable.

Any why do you think it isn't resolvable? We call this a clue.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 15, 2023, 08:23:05 AM
You misquote me, purposefully I can't help but wonder.

I never said "red flag laws are constitutional" in fact I criticized you for making blanket statements of that nature. I said red flag laws CAN be constitutional, that it depended on the specifics of each individual law.



And my reply to you was to post one that "can" be constitutional and u posted only 1 part of HI's one, leaving out all the other sections of it that shows take the guns first.  Damn, I'm thirty (Training Day reference)
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 15, 2023, 08:24:49 AM


If by the Bruen test you mean using text, history, and tradition, that is a methodology, but it isn't a completely binding one, not is it one that gives a clear answer. The History and tradition (redundant) portion creates its own problems, traditionally you could beat you wife, it wasn't a crime way back then so how would you incorporate any history and tradition into a question of punishment for spouse abuse? If you require history and tradition then laws banning spouse abuse would be unconstitutional would they not? Before laws that allowed women to vote they couldn't vote, again, you couldn't satisfy the history test if there was no prior history of women voting. I think you are over-estimating the application of the Buren test. I posted a podcast that went into a lot of these issues, did you even listen to it yet? You ignored where I pointed out to you multiple times that Rahimi is unique because unlike other TRO/Red flag law situations, Rahimi agreed to the stipulation that he not have firearms which means he doesn't have the same due process challenge compared to your average red flag/TRO case.




AANNNNNNDDDDD here's the goal post moving.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 15, 2023, 08:25:47 AM


Why do you think the Bruen decision makes red flag laws unconstitutional.



My prior posting already mentioned shows why. No amnesia, must be something else.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 15, 2023, 08:26:31 AM

I am no more a constitutional expert than you are, all we can do is read and listen to people who are more knowledgeable than us to try to form a more supporter opinion. I have read and listened to a number of such people and they don't know which way the court is going to rule or how exactly the text history and tradition framework would apply to the Rahimi case. That should tell you something about all of this. Like I said earlier, for practical purposes, until the SCOTUS rules on this very issue there is no practical answer, only ideological ones. The fact that legal experts aren't even sure how this one will go down alone should inform you that this is not a case where the constitutionality is something so plain and obvious as you claim it to be. I don't have such a solid answer or prediction of how the court will rule on this. If something is obviously unconstitutional it is a much easier answer, but when things are in the gray area the answer is not so obvious. I illustrated to you how there are so many rights that aren't recognized until a court interpreted the constitution a certain way that enshrined them into case law. Take for example a Terry Stop. It wasn't obvious the cop was within his power when he stopped those men, he just did what he thought he could and it was challenged in court which lead to the framework that shapes police detention to this day. There are numerous cases where someone had to do something that was challenged before anyone knew whether it was constitutional or not.


Here it is again.

added:

"CMO, I was wrong because like you requested, I cannot post anything under the Bruen test to support my feelings.  This means by default, since the burden is on me, I was wrong.  Same would go if the state ignored to show any relevant history and tradition. I apologize for wasting everyones time since day 1 when Red Flag law have been bills to then law.  I also apologize for ignoring your request to post any Red Flag laws of the 23 states that are constitutional since I claimed there "may" be one that is.  I change my statement to say "there are no constitutional red flag laws.  Have a Merry Christmas".
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 15, 2023, 10:59:09 PM
My prior posting already mentioned shows why. No amnesia, must be something else.

All you keep saying is that taking the guns before a hearing isn't due process and therefore unconstitutional, you never go much deeper than that.

I gave you examples both criminal where your rights get taken away before you get a hearing but you haven't explained why those aren't unconstitutional but red flag laws are. I can get arrested for a crime without first having a hearing to represent myself. I can be taken in for a mental health evaluation without first having a hearing to represent myself. Why are those constitutional but red flag laws are unconstitutional?

Furthermore just because I say a constitutional red flag law can exist doesn't mean I have a burden to prove it does exist. I can tell you that it is possible to put pig ears on a pizza, doesn't mean I have to find a restaurant that actually offers that option. Someone could create a red flag law which has a hearing with the defendant present before firearms are actually taken.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 15, 2023, 11:06:45 PM

Here it is again.

added:

"CMO, I was wrong because like you requested, I cannot post anything under the Bruen test to support my feelings.  This means by default, since the burden is on me, I was wrong.  Same would go if the state ignored to show any relevant history and tradition. I apologize for wasting everyones time since day 1 when Red Flag law have been bills to then law.  I also apologize for ignoring your request to post any Red Flag laws of the 23 states that are constitutional since I claimed there "may" be one that is.  I change my statement to say "there are no constitutional red flag laws.  Have a Merry Christmas".

Your premise is flawed. You simply state that I must prove under Buren that something is constitutional, that is BS. You have just as much duty to prove your claim as I do to prove mine. You don't simply get to escape supporting your claim by saying only I have the duty to do so. You also shot holes in your own argument, you say that SCOTUS doesn't make something constitutional but then demand I justify a position based on a methodology the SCOTUS used. So does the SCOTUS decide whether something is constitutional or not?

So you want me to apologize to you? By your logic that means you think the world revolves around you and you just want your ego stroked.

The original claim I made was about due process being present, and you turned it into a question about constitutionality. I illustrated that there is due process present but I have stated that the constitutionality of red flag laws is not so obvious. Is it clearly constitutional? No. Is it clearly unconstitutional? No. If the court decides they are unconstitutional then we have a clear answer. Acting as if we already have a clear answer is refusing to hear any side you don't like.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 15, 2023, 11:09:07 PM
Any why do you think it isn't resolvable? We call this a clue.

Because there is no clear answer. Duh
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 07:39:24 AM
All you keep saying is that taking the guns before a hearing isn't due process and therefore unconstitutional, you never go much deeper than that.

I gave you examples both criminal where your rights get taken away before you get a hearing but you haven't explained why those aren't unconstitutional but red flag laws are. I can get arrested for a crime without first having a hearing to represent myself. I can be taken in for a mental health evaluation without first having a hearing to represent myself. Why are those constitutional but red flag laws are unconstitutional?

Furthermore just because I say a constitutional red flag law can exist doesn't mean I have a burden to prove it does exist. I can tell you that it is possible to put pig ears on a pizza, doesn't mean I have to find a restaurant that actually offers that option. Someone could create a red flag law which has a hearing with the defendant present before firearms are actually taken.
1+1=2

Please go deeper on why its doesnt equal 7 like how i feel it can.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 07:41:15 AM
Your premise is flawed. You simply state that I must prove under Buren that something is constitutional, that is BS. You have just as much duty to prove your claim as I do to prove mine. You don't simply get to escape supporting your claim by saying only I have the duty to do so. You also shot holes in your own argument, you say that SCOTUS doesn't make something constitutional but then demand I justify a position based on a methodology the SCOTUS used. So does the SCOTUS decide whether something is constitutional or not?

So you want me to apologize to you? By your logic that means you think the world revolves around you and you just want your ego stroked.

The original claim I made was about due process being present, and you turned it into a question about constitutionality. I illustrated that there is due process present but I have stated that the constitutionality of red flag laws is not so obvious. Is it clearly constitutional? No. Is it clearly unconstitutional? No. If the court decides they are unconstitutional then we have a clear answer. Acting as if we already have a clear answer is refusing to hear any side you don't like.
So no historical analogies. Thanks for proving im right. This will go in the colum of u not posting a constitutional red flag.


CMO 2
EEF 0
Goalpost moving 10

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 07:41:27 AM
Because there is no clear answer. Duh
In ur mind only.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 16, 2023, 04:11:22 PM
1+1=2

Please go deeper on why its doesnt equal 7 like how i feel it can.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

You are going to compare rudimentary math to constitutional law? No wonder you are so confused.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 16, 2023, 04:12:19 PM
So no historical analogies. Thanks for proving im right. This will go in the colum of u not posting a constitutional red flag.


CMO 2
EEF 0
Goalpost moving 10

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 05:27:21 PM
You are going to compare rudimentary math to constitutional law? No wonder you are so confused.
Of course, u would feel this way. Makes sense.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 05:28:13 PM
So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:
Someone further shows he doesnt understand how bruen is applied. Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 16, 2023, 05:39:28 PM
So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:

Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 16, 2023, 06:35:05 PM
Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.
At least u understand how to apply Bruen.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 16, 2023, 07:14:10 PM
At least u understand how to apply Bruen.

YouTube can be educational!

Washington Gun Law beat that Bruen test into my skull over and over ... !

 :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :crazy:
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 17, 2023, 10:05:39 AM
YouTube can be educational!

Washington Gun Law beat that Bruen test into my skull over and over ... !

  :geekdanc: :crazy:
4 boxes diner is good too. He wrote a brief to support Wolfard in the sensitive places lawsuit.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 17, 2023, 12:07:54 PM
4 boxes diner is good too. He wrote a brief to support Wolfard in the sensitive places lawsuit.

I can't watch his videos. Too long for the most part, and his voice is grating.  it's like he's yelling the whole time, and it really makes listening difficult.

JHMO
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 17, 2023, 05:24:59 PM
I can't watch his videos. Too long for the most part, and his voice is grating.  it's like he's yelling the whole time, and it really makes listening difficult.

JHMO
This is true.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 17, 2023, 11:09:53 PM
Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.

I was not saying the Bruen test had to be applied to everything, I was trying to make the point that the Buren test is a methodology they used but not something that has to be used for everything.

Listen to the podcast I posted, they go into it a lot better than I can explain.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 18, 2023, 09:02:30 AM
I was not saying the Bruen test had to be applied to everything, I was trying to make the point that the Buren test is a methodology they used but not something that has to be used for everything.

Listen to the podcast I posted, they go into it a lot better than I can explain.

A useless example to make himself sound right in his head. I like oreo cookies with milk and not with orange juice. #relevant
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 18, 2023, 09:30:37 AM
I was not saying the Bruen test had to be applied to everything, I was trying to make the point that the Buren test is a methodology they used but not something that has to be used for everything.

Listen to the podcast I posted, they go into it a lot better than I can explain.

So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:

**Bruen, not Buren

That's not what you said.  Are you really that dishonest?

Re-read your posts.  I don't need to listen to someone else's words when the ones you posted are right here.

YOU tried to argue against Bruen's test being used by applying it to an unrelated law.  Nobody else did that. 

Now that you see how stupid that was, you're trying to say, "But, someone on a podcast argued something something that was better than how i can put it."

What you are using is a false analogy, and you very well know it.  You do this all the time.

Quote
False Analogy, also called Faulty Analogy, is an informal logical fallacy
in inductive reasoning. It’s a part of Generalizations Fallacies group.
It usually occurs when someone applies or assumes that if two things
or events have similarities in one or more respects, they are similar in
other properties too. Still, the things or events are substantially different,
and those similarities can not be extrapolated to other properties.

Just because both gun laws and domestic abuse laws are statutes doesn't make them similar at all.  Nothing in the Constitution mentions domestic abuse -- prove me wrong.

You are also using a typical straw man argument:
Quote
Straw man argument, or straw man fallacy, is a type of logical fallacy
that occurs when someone deliberately distorts or misrepresents their
opponent’s position to make it easier to defeat. As such, it is commonplace
in a wide variety of situations, such as political debates, journalism, and
debates on any controversial topics.

Show me where anyone other than you said, "...spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies."

If you can't debate honestly, you need to quit.  There's no law that says you have to comment on every post just because you can.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 19, 2023, 08:43:37 PM
**Bruen, not Buren

I know, it was a typo.

Quote
That's not what you said.  Are you really that dishonest?
Re-read your posts.  I don't need to listen to someone else's words when the ones you posted are right here.
YOU tried to argue against Bruen's test being used by applying it to an unrelated law.  Nobody else did that. 
Now that you see how stupid that was, you're trying to say, "But, someone on a podcast argued something something that was better than how i can put it."
What you are using is a false analogy, and you very well know it.  You do this all the time.

Wrong. I was illustrating how Bruen is not a hardfast rule rather a methodology. I was showing how looking at it as a hardfast rule would result in ridiculous rulings.


Quote
Just because both gun laws and domestic abuse laws are statutes doesn't make them similar at all.  Nothing in the Constitution mentions domestic abuse -- prove me wrong.

Fair point, but I was not trying to equate them.


Quote
You are also using a typical straw man argument:
Show me where anyone other than you said, "...spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies."

If you can't debate honestly, you need to quit.  There's no law that says you have to comment on every post just because you can.


Focus!
I didn't say that anyone here claimed this to be the case. It was an example brought up in discussion by attorneys discussing the Rahimi case. Listen to the podcast.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 19, 2023, 08:44:31 PM
A useless example to make himself sound right in his head. I like oreo cookies with milk and not with orange juice. #relevant

Listen to the podcast.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 19, 2023, 10:33:50 PM
I know, it was a typo.

Wrong. I was illustrating how Bruen is not a hardfast rule rather a methodology. I was showing how looking at it as a hardfast rule would result in ridiculous rulings.


Fair point, but I was not trying to equate them.



Focus!
I didn't say that anyone here claimed this to be the case. It was an example brought up in discussion by attorneys discussing the Rahimi case.

Listen to the podcast.

NO.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 20, 2023, 07:59:38 AM
Listen to the podcast.

I have my own sources and said sources actual help HI lawsuits. So, no.

Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 20, 2023, 10:36:39 PM
NO.

Then don't complain
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 20, 2023, 10:38:15 PM
I have my own sources and said sources actual help HI lawsuits. So, no.

Then don't make such a big deal if you aren't even willing to consider their explanation. I listened to your Washington gun lawyer guy.

I'd be happy to listen to your sources who help our lawsuits too.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 20, 2023, 11:46:47 PM
Then don't complain

You're trying to promote that podcast as if you agree with the ideas, but you can't articulate what those arguments are -- so you want to let the podcast do it for you.

Lazy!

You could have just posted the link and not argued with everything we post.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 21, 2023, 08:42:08 AM
Then don't complain

Why not?
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 21, 2023, 08:43:59 AM
Then don't make such a big deal if you aren't even willing to consider their explanation. I listened to your Washington gun lawyer guy.

I'd be happy to listen to your sources who help our lawsuits too.

Did I force you to listen to any of my sources? It's up to you if you want a better source to get information from, even though you will still move goal post and refuse to admit being wrong. Since you have no street credit, I won't spend any or much time at all on your sources as they are bad ones most of the time.  Compared to someone else who has shown to post better stuff, I would give it a review.  It's like if I hear CNN reporting on something, it's probably BS.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 26, 2023, 12:03:52 AM
Did I force you to listen to any of my sources? It's up to you if you want a better source to get information from, even though you will still move goal post and refuse to admit being wrong. Since you have no street credit, I won't spend any or much time at all on your sources as they are bad ones most of the time.  Compared to someone else who has shown to post better stuff, I would give it a review.  It's like if I hear CNN reporting on something, it's probably BS.

Just pointing out your double standard. It's up to you if you want a better source to get information from, even though you will still move goal post and refuse to admit being wrong.

Nice circular reasoning there Mr. street cred.
Title: Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 26, 2023, 08:11:15 AM
Just pointing out your double standard. It's up to you if you want a better source to get information from, even though you will still move goal post and refuse to admit being wrong.

Nice circular reasoning there Mr. street cred.

Wrong.