Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing (Read 37090 times)

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #180 on: December 15, 2023, 08:25:47 AM »


Why do you think the Bruen decision makes red flag laws unconstitutional.



My prior posting already mentioned shows why. No amnesia, must be something else.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #181 on: December 15, 2023, 08:26:31 AM »

I am no more a constitutional expert than you are, all we can do is read and listen to people who are more knowledgeable than us to try to form a more supporter opinion. I have read and listened to a number of such people and they don't know which way the court is going to rule or how exactly the text history and tradition framework would apply to the Rahimi case. That should tell you something about all of this. Like I said earlier, for practical purposes, until the SCOTUS rules on this very issue there is no practical answer, only ideological ones. The fact that legal experts aren't even sure how this one will go down alone should inform you that this is not a case where the constitutionality is something so plain and obvious as you claim it to be. I don't have such a solid answer or prediction of how the court will rule on this. If something is obviously unconstitutional it is a much easier answer, but when things are in the gray area the answer is not so obvious. I illustrated to you how there are so many rights that aren't recognized until a court interpreted the constitution a certain way that enshrined them into case law. Take for example a Terry Stop. It wasn't obvious the cop was within his power when he stopped those men, he just did what he thought he could and it was challenged in court which lead to the framework that shapes police detention to this day. There are numerous cases where someone had to do something that was challenged before anyone knew whether it was constitutional or not.


Here it is again.

added:

"CMO, I was wrong because like you requested, I cannot post anything under the Bruen test to support my feelings.  This means by default, since the burden is on me, I was wrong.  Same would go if the state ignored to show any relevant history and tradition. I apologize for wasting everyones time since day 1 when Red Flag law have been bills to then law.  I also apologize for ignoring your request to post any Red Flag laws of the 23 states that are constitutional since I claimed there "may" be one that is.  I change my statement to say "there are no constitutional red flag laws.  Have a Merry Christmas".
« Last Edit: December 15, 2023, 09:25:57 AM by changemyoil66 »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #182 on: December 15, 2023, 10:59:09 PM »
My prior posting already mentioned shows why. No amnesia, must be something else.

All you keep saying is that taking the guns before a hearing isn't due process and therefore unconstitutional, you never go much deeper than that.

I gave you examples both criminal where your rights get taken away before you get a hearing but you haven't explained why those aren't unconstitutional but red flag laws are. I can get arrested for a crime without first having a hearing to represent myself. I can be taken in for a mental health evaluation without first having a hearing to represent myself. Why are those constitutional but red flag laws are unconstitutional?

Furthermore just because I say a constitutional red flag law can exist doesn't mean I have a burden to prove it does exist. I can tell you that it is possible to put pig ears on a pizza, doesn't mean I have to find a restaurant that actually offers that option. Someone could create a red flag law which has a hearing with the defendant present before firearms are actually taken.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2023, 11:11:48 PM by eyeeatingfish »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #183 on: December 15, 2023, 11:06:45 PM »

Here it is again.

added:

"CMO, I was wrong because like you requested, I cannot post anything under the Bruen test to support my feelings.  This means by default, since the burden is on me, I was wrong.  Same would go if the state ignored to show any relevant history and tradition. I apologize for wasting everyones time since day 1 when Red Flag law have been bills to then law.  I also apologize for ignoring your request to post any Red Flag laws of the 23 states that are constitutional since I claimed there "may" be one that is.  I change my statement to say "there are no constitutional red flag laws.  Have a Merry Christmas".

Your premise is flawed. You simply state that I must prove under Buren that something is constitutional, that is BS. You have just as much duty to prove your claim as I do to prove mine. You don't simply get to escape supporting your claim by saying only I have the duty to do so. You also shot holes in your own argument, you say that SCOTUS doesn't make something constitutional but then demand I justify a position based on a methodology the SCOTUS used. So does the SCOTUS decide whether something is constitutional or not?

So you want me to apologize to you? By your logic that means you think the world revolves around you and you just want your ego stroked.

The original claim I made was about due process being present, and you turned it into a question about constitutionality. I illustrated that there is due process present but I have stated that the constitutionality of red flag laws is not so obvious. Is it clearly constitutional? No. Is it clearly unconstitutional? No. If the court decides they are unconstitutional then we have a clear answer. Acting as if we already have a clear answer is refusing to hear any side you don't like.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #184 on: December 15, 2023, 11:09:07 PM »
Any why do you think it isn't resolvable? We call this a clue.

Because there is no clear answer. Duh

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #185 on: December 16, 2023, 07:39:24 AM »
All you keep saying is that taking the guns before a hearing isn't due process and therefore unconstitutional, you never go much deeper than that.

I gave you examples both criminal where your rights get taken away before you get a hearing but you haven't explained why those aren't unconstitutional but red flag laws are. I can get arrested for a crime without first having a hearing to represent myself. I can be taken in for a mental health evaluation without first having a hearing to represent myself. Why are those constitutional but red flag laws are unconstitutional?

Furthermore just because I say a constitutional red flag law can exist doesn't mean I have a burden to prove it does exist. I can tell you that it is possible to put pig ears on a pizza, doesn't mean I have to find a restaurant that actually offers that option. Someone could create a red flag law which has a hearing with the defendant present before firearms are actually taken.
1+1=2

Please go deeper on why its doesnt equal 7 like how i feel it can.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #186 on: December 16, 2023, 07:41:15 AM »
Your premise is flawed. You simply state that I must prove under Buren that something is constitutional, that is BS. You have just as much duty to prove your claim as I do to prove mine. You don't simply get to escape supporting your claim by saying only I have the duty to do so. You also shot holes in your own argument, you say that SCOTUS doesn't make something constitutional but then demand I justify a position based on a methodology the SCOTUS used. So does the SCOTUS decide whether something is constitutional or not?

So you want me to apologize to you? By your logic that means you think the world revolves around you and you just want your ego stroked.

The original claim I made was about due process being present, and you turned it into a question about constitutionality. I illustrated that there is due process present but I have stated that the constitutionality of red flag laws is not so obvious. Is it clearly constitutional? No. Is it clearly unconstitutional? No. If the court decides they are unconstitutional then we have a clear answer. Acting as if we already have a clear answer is refusing to hear any side you don't like.
So no historical analogies. Thanks for proving im right. This will go in the colum of u not posting a constitutional red flag.


CMO 2
EEF 0
Goalpost moving 10

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #187 on: December 16, 2023, 07:41:27 AM »
Because there is no clear answer. Duh
In ur mind only.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #188 on: December 16, 2023, 04:11:22 PM »
1+1=2

Please go deeper on why its doesnt equal 7 like how i feel it can.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

You are going to compare rudimentary math to constitutional law? No wonder you are so confused.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #189 on: December 16, 2023, 04:12:19 PM »
So no historical analogies. Thanks for proving im right. This will go in the colum of u not posting a constitutional red flag.


CMO 2
EEF 0
Goalpost moving 10

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #190 on: December 16, 2023, 05:27:21 PM »
You are going to compare rudimentary math to constitutional law? No wonder you are so confused.
Of course, u would feel this way. Makes sense.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #191 on: December 16, 2023, 05:28:13 PM »
So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:
Someone further shows he doesnt understand how bruen is applied. Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #192 on: December 16, 2023, 05:39:28 PM »
So you are making the case that spouse abuse shouldn't be illegal then because there was no historical analogies?

 :crazy:

Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #193 on: December 16, 2023, 06:35:05 PM »
Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.
At least u understand how to apply Bruen.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #194 on: December 16, 2023, 07:14:10 PM »
At least u understand how to apply Bruen.

YouTube can be educational!

Washington Gun Law beat that Bruen test into my skull over and over ... !

 :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :crazy:
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #195 on: December 17, 2023, 10:05:39 AM »
YouTube can be educational!

Washington Gun Law beat that Bruen test into my skull over and over ... !

  :geekdanc: :crazy:
4 boxes diner is good too. He wrote a brief to support Wolfard in the sensitive places lawsuit.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #196 on: December 17, 2023, 12:07:54 PM »
4 boxes diner is good too. He wrote a brief to support Wolfard in the sensitive places lawsuit.

I can't watch his videos. Too long for the most part, and his voice is grating.  it's like he's yelling the whole time, and it really makes listening difficult.

JHMO
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #197 on: December 17, 2023, 05:24:59 PM »
I can't watch his videos. Too long for the most part, and his voice is grating.  it's like he's yelling the whole time, and it really makes listening difficult.

JHMO
This is true.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #198 on: December 17, 2023, 11:09:53 PM »
Totally wrong.

Please point to the SCOTUS ruling which requires that all laws must use the Bruen test.

What's the first step in the Bruen test?

Ans:  Does the law in question fall under the Second Amendment and the right to keep & bear arms? 

If the answer to that is "no" (spousal abuse is not a 2A issue), then there's no need to go to the second question, which deals with historical analogues.

I was not saying the Bruen test had to be applied to everything, I was trying to make the point that the Buren test is a methodology they used but not something that has to be used for everything.

Listen to the podcast I posted, they go into it a lot better than I can explain.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #199 on: December 18, 2023, 09:02:30 AM »
I was not saying the Bruen test had to be applied to everything, I was trying to make the point that the Buren test is a methodology they used but not something that has to be used for everything.

Listen to the podcast I posted, they go into it a lot better than I can explain.

A useless example to make himself sound right in his head. I like oreo cookies with milk and not with orange juice. #relevant