Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing (Read 37112 times)

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #100 on: November 26, 2023, 09:59:05 AM »
He thinks a hearing within 2 weeks AFTER the guns and ammo are confiscated constitutes "fairness" for the respondent.
This is the 2nd time in this thread that this was mentioned. And again in the prior red flag thread.

But hey, i guess as long as "due process" is applied at some point, even after a right is taken away, its all G.

How come red flags dont also take knives, hammers, etc...away?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #101 on: November 26, 2023, 01:54:25 PM »
This is the 2nd time in this thread that this was mentioned. And again in the prior red flag thread.

But hey, i guess as long as "due process" is applied at some point, even after a right is taken away, its all G.

How come red flags dont also take knives, hammers, etc...away?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #102 on: November 26, 2023, 04:21:13 PM »
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.

Name the 2 categories of Due Process in the US, and then maybe you'll see why your comment above is wrong.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #103 on: November 26, 2023, 05:33:44 PM »
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.
I sense goal post moving....

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #104 on: November 26, 2023, 05:34:32 PM »
Still waiting for u to post a red flag law that has due process....

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #105 on: November 26, 2023, 10:26:13 PM »
Name the 2 categories of Due Process in the US, and then maybe you'll see why your comment above is wrong.

Substantive due process and procedural due process.

Hawaii red flag law clearly has procedural due process, so no, I wasn't wrong in there.

Substantive due process is more of a gray area and is subject to more interpretation. Some justices, Clarence Thomas included, reject the substantive due process concept. Within this concept there is more room where you could make that Hawaii's red flag law does not have/does not have enough due process protections. Not really any definitive answers on this one, not until a court rules on it and sets precedence.

Red flag laws aren't the only times rights are taken away prior to a hearing though so why do you think red flag laws are unique from others?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #106 on: November 26, 2023, 10:49:56 PM »
Substantive due process and procedural due process.

Hawaii red flag law clearly has procedural due process, so no, I wasn't wrong in there.

Substantive due process is more of a gray area and is subject to more interpretation. Some justices, Clarence Thomas included, reject the substantive due process concept. Within this concept there is more room where you could make that Hawaii's red flag law does not have/does not have enough due process protections. Not really any definitive answers on this one, not until a court rules on it and sets precedence.

Red flag laws aren't the only times rights are taken away prior to a hearing though so why do you think red flag laws are unique from others?

Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
Quote
"substantive due process protects individuals against majoritarian policy
enactments that exceed the limits of governmental authority: courts may
find that a majority's enactment is not law and cannot be enforced as such,
even if the processes of enactment and enforcement were actually fair.[3]
...
Much substantive due process litigation involves legal challenges to the validity
of unenumerated rights and seek particular outcomes instead of merely contesting
procedures and their effects.

In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #107 on: November 27, 2023, 07:43:34 AM »
Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.

IDK how many times you or me have to spell it out for EEF. Ego is probably getting in the way of logical thinking at this point.  Or incompetence, but at this point, because it was spelled out, one cannot blame that anymore really.  Versus not being told the why he's wrong.

BRB, HPD is locking someone up for 5 years and then giving them their trial to "prove their innocence". #dueprocess cause it was given at some point along the way.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #108 on: November 27, 2023, 10:07:46 AM »
IDK how many times you or me have to spell it out for EEF. Ego is probably getting in the way of logical thinking at this point.  Or incompetence, but at this point, because it was spelled out, one cannot blame that anymore really.  Versus not being told the why he's wrong.

BRB, HPD is locking someone up for 5 years and then giving them their trial to "prove their innocence". #dueprocess cause it was given at some point along the way.

There was a case that perfectly demonstrates the due process concept.

A person who was ineligible to possess firearms was found to have an unregistered gun.  He was charged with a registration infraction.

That charge was thrown out on due process violations, because the laws infringed on the defendant's 5th amendment protections.

Since he was not legally allowed guns, registration would have constituted confessing to having guns he shouldn't.  So, the law to register was deemed unconstitutional IN THAT CASE.

It had nothing to do with the law being applied fairly or correctly in general.  Nor did it turn on any procedural mistakes or improprieties.  It was about violating the man's RIGHTS, which falls under Substantive Due Process. 

The state passing a law may make its enforcement legal, but not when it violates the rights of the individual.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #109 on: November 27, 2023, 11:58:18 PM »
Very good, Googler.  But you are still wrong.

Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated.  In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate.  You must also have Substantive Due Process.

Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.

Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area." 
In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed.  There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.

Example:  if the law says you get punished  by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers

... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...

i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.

We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now.  Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.

I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.


An absence of substantive due process does not mean an absence of procedural due process. Yes, they both matter, but I never said they didn't.

If you think there is no gray area in substantive due process you might want to take that up with the justices who disagree significantly about it.

If the law states 2 weeks to the hearing, for example, but they are backed up and it takes 2 months then I do think that is a big problem because then the government isn't even following the rules it is supposed to and I do think there would be grounds to file a suit over due process violations there. Personally I think 2 weeks is longer than I would like to see, I would like to see something much shorter, like 3 days. But if we use criminal charges as any parallel by which to measure, people are often held much longer waiting for trial when they are arrested upon accusation of a crime. Even if there was no crime and you were taken in on an involuntary mental health evaluation, you aren't going to get an immediate hearing if you are detained longer than a day or two. Furthermore a judge doesn't make the initial detention call, a doctor does. So whether you look at it from a criminal lens or a mental health lens, taking the firearms only, with a hearing in 2 weeks, is still less restriction on a person's rights than physically locking them away.

Ideally I would prefer to see a system where there is a hearing before any revocation of rights instead of an initial order followed by a hearing soon after but I do not think that an initial revocation followed by a 2 week wait is in and of iteself unconstitutional. Honestly I do not know exactly where I would draw the line between a constitutional time and an unconstitutional time, 3 days would be allowable in my opinion, 3 months would be too long. 2 weeks? Longer than I would want but don't think I can argue it is unconstitutional.

You have stated that if the person is so dangerous then they should be locked up instead of just having their guns taken away but would you really support that law if enacted? I suspect not due to the same reasons that someone could make false reports, but then if that is the main concern, would anything really change if the order had a hearing first with the respondent present and then the firearms were seized? I think the outcome would be the same in terms of angry ex-spouses lying on the forms to get you in trouble. Would you consider it constitutional if the hearing (with the respondent present) happened prior to any firearm revocation order?

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #110 on: November 28, 2023, 08:07:45 AM »

An absence of substantive due process does not mean an absence of procedural due process. Yes, they both matter, but I never said they didn't.

If you think there is no gray area in substantive due process you might want to take that up with the justices who disagree significantly about it.

If the law states 2 weeks to the hearing, for example, but they are backed up and it takes 2 months then I do think that is a big problem because then the government isn't even following the rules it is supposed to and I do think there would be grounds to file a suit over due process violations there. Personally I think 2 weeks is longer than I would like to see, I would like to see something much shorter, like 3 days. But if we use criminal charges as any parallel by which to measure, people are often held much longer waiting for trial when they are arrested upon accusation of a crime. Even if there was no crime and you were taken in on an involuntary mental health evaluation, you aren't going to get an immediate hearing if you are detained longer than a day or two. Furthermore a judge doesn't make the initial detention call, a doctor does. So whether you look at it from a criminal lens or a mental health lens, taking the firearms only, with a hearing in 2 weeks, is still less restriction on a person's rights than physically locking them away.

Ideally I would prefer to see a system where there is a hearing before any revocation of rights instead of an initial order followed by a hearing soon after but I do not think that an initial revocation followed by a 2 week wait is in and of iteself unconstitutional. Honestly I do not know exactly where I would draw the line between a constitutional time and an unconstitutional time, 3 days would be allowable in my opinion, 3 months would be too long. 2 weeks? Longer than I would want but don't think I can argue it is unconstitutional.

You have stated that if the person is so dangerous then they should be locked up instead of just having their guns taken away but would you really support that law if enacted? I suspect not due to the same reasons that someone could make false reports, but then if that is the main concern, would anything really change if the order had a hearing first with the respondent present and then the firearms were seized? I think the outcome would be the same in terms of angry ex-spouses lying on the forms to get you in trouble. Would you consider it constitutional if the hearing (with the respondent present) happened prior to any firearm revocation order?

Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #111 on: November 28, 2023, 09:00:35 AM »
Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.

Sounds like he would be okay with having his car or truck taken during a traffic stop because the Cops suspected he might be using it in the commission of a crime -- a crime that hasn't happened yet, but based simply on his wife calling 911 saying he was using it to transport illegal gambling money from cock fights.

As long as he gets a hearing while his vehicle is impounded and has to pay for storage AND a lawyer, it's all good -- no rights violated.

The trial takes an extra long time due to backlogs and postponements by the prosecutor, so now he's been without his vehicle for months.  Not having transportation also lost him his primary job which is 3rd shift when busses are not running, plus his side gig delivering for Door Dash.

The hardships only begin there.  Everything in his life becomes an impossible task without his vehicle, which he still has to make monthly payments on and can't afford to buy another vehicle -- hard to make payments without income, can't sell it while it's being held under asset forfeiture laws, and so on.  All this can crash his credit rating .... and the downward spiral continues.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #112 on: November 28, 2023, 09:25:51 AM »
Sounds like he would be okay with having his car or truck taken during a traffic stop because the Cops suspected he might be using it in the commission of a crime -- a crime that hasn't happened yet, but based simply on his wife calling 911 saying he was using it to transport illegal gambling money from cock fights.

As long as he gets a hearing while his vehicle is impounded and has to pay for storage AND a lawyer, it's all good -- no rights violated.

The trial takes an extra long time due to backlogs and postponements by the prosecutor, so now he's been without his vehicle for months.  Not having transportation also lost him his primary job which is 3rd shift when busses are not running, plus his side gig delivering for Door Dash.

The hardships only begin there.  Everything in his life becomes an impossible task without his vehicle, which he still has to make monthly payments on and can't afford to buy another vehicle -- hard to make payments without income, can't sell it while it's being held under asset forfeiture laws, and so on.  All this can crash his credit rating .... and the downward spiral continues.

And unlike the 2nd amendment, a car or mode of transportation isn't specifically listed like how the right to bear arms is.  I mean, there is the property mention, but not specifically like the 2A.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #113 on: November 30, 2023, 06:11:01 AM »
Annnnddddd goal post is moved.

BTW, you're still wrong. That's not how due process/the constitution works.

Still waiting on you to post a constitutional red flag law.

You keep telling yourself that.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #114 on: November 30, 2023, 08:03:10 AM »
I didn't that say as long as there is a hearing at some point everything is fine. I said that a hearing is part of due process. I illustrated that to you multiple times, just because you don't think the law has enough protections doesn't mean there is no due process. Pointing out the due process contained within the law does not mean I like the law as written. Not enough is not the same thing as none.

And I posted to you getting your guns (2A right) taken away BEFORE the hearing is not due process. We covered this also in the OG red flag law thread. 

Thanks for not admitting you're wrong. Thanks for playing.

Not enough=none.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #115 on: November 30, 2023, 08:04:06 AM »
You keep telling yourself that.

Everyone can see this, well, everyone but you.

Does the goal post mover know they're moving goal post?  Does the ego driven person know they have an ego?  Does an incompetent person know they're incompetent? Does a HPD rights violator know they're violating someone's right?

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #116 on: December 01, 2023, 09:26:16 PM »
And I posted to you getting your guns (2A right) taken away BEFORE the hearing is not due process. We covered this also in the OG red flag law thread. 

Thanks for not admitting you're wrong. Thanks for playing.

Not enough=none.

So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #117 on: December 01, 2023, 10:08:34 PM »
So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.

Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #118 on: December 02, 2023, 08:05:50 AM »
So getting arrested before a court hearing when being accused of a crime means there is no due process? Your reasoning is flawed and your understanding of due process is flawed.
Please show me where i said "arrested".

Nice goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #119 on: December 02, 2023, 08:06:31 AM »
Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.
Its goal post moving. Thats all he has for his wrong arguments.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk