2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: ren on June 02, 2026, 09:11:40 AM

Title: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: ren on June 02, 2026, 09:11:40 AM
is alive and well....
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2026/06/02/torture-honolulu-police-look-mob-that-attacked-lifeguard-15-year-old/

the same spirit that told the court we don't need firearms to protect ourselves....because Aloha!
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 02, 2026, 09:34:38 AM
is alive and well....
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2026/06/02/torture-honolulu-police-look-mob-that-attacked-lifeguard-15-year-old/

the same spirit that told the court we don't need firearms to protect ourselves....because Aloha!

The mob must have knew that one on one with the boy or lifeguard, none of them would have a fricken chance in hell.

Hence the "Aloha Mob".

By the way, my guess is nothing going happen.  Nothing does in this banana republik.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: hvybarrels on June 02, 2026, 07:11:35 PM
That's called a Chimp Out. It's been popularized on social media by certain degenerate welfare-addicted ethnic groups and communist rent-a-riots in blue cities with revolving door justice systems.
The attackers are all fairly certain they will get off because if it ever goes before a judge they will say the magic social justice words that grant them leniency and a license for mayhem.

This video made me reconsider my plans for a wheel gun. Small frames are much more convenient to carry, but five shots are clearly not enough to escape/rescue a love one from a Chimp Out.
The chimps abandon honor and humanity, preferring to attack from the back like wild animals. Surviving without someone else on 6 could likely involve rolling like Rittenhouse.



Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: ren on June 02, 2026, 07:29:30 PM
if you were a father witnessing your son getting pummeled like that and you were armed...justified?
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: hvybarrels on June 02, 2026, 07:52:09 PM
if you were a father witnessing your son getting pummeled like that and you were armed...justified?

Or daughter. Plenty of bystander females are getting reconstructive surgery and brain damage lately.

https://www.gbnews.com/news/us/cincinnati-jazz-festival-fourth-man-arrested-dominique-kittle

(https://www.gbnews.com/media-library/holly-injuries.jpg?id=61421424&width=1000&quality=85)
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 02, 2026, 09:40:06 PM
if you were a father witnessing your son getting pummeled like that and you were armed...justified?
Lemesee…..,

1. Immediate and unavoidable ✅ (yep, already happening),

2. danger of death or grave bodily injury ✅ (yep, victim restrained on the ground while being beaten by a mob),

3. to yourself or an innocent. ✅ (obviously).

Seems like yeah, justified.

But let’s look at it the other way, and say that, for fear of wrongful prosecution by the local Khmer Rouge, you don’t, and they kill your son (or anyone, for that matter).

You forever own the guilt of letting an innocent be killed via inaction in compliance with an unlawful and evil regime.  Some people can live with that, and some people just. will. not. - like the Lifeguard friend.

Good you asked the question - I’m sure all of us ponder this scenario at times, given the degenerate nature of our society today.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: ren on June 02, 2026, 09:57:30 PM
Lemesee…..,

1. Immediate and unavoidable ✅ (yep, already happening),

2. danger of death or grave bodily injury ✅ (yep, victim restrained on the ground while being beaten by a mob),

3. to yourself or an innocent. ✅ (obviously).

Seems like yeah, justified.

But let’s look at it the other way, and say that, for fear of wrongful prosecution by the local Khmer Rouge, you don’t, and they kill your son (or anyone, for that matter).

You forever own the guilt of letting an innocent be killed via inaction in compliance with an unlawful and evil regime.  Some people can live with that, and some people just. will. not. - like the Lifeguard friend.

Good you asked the question - I’m sure all of us ponder this scenario at times, given the degenerate nature of our society today.

I'm sure somewhere in that mob were "good boys" that hung around the "wrong crowd" or made "wrong decision" but overall were good guys....
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 02, 2026, 10:21:56 PM
I'm sure somewhere in that mob were "good boys" that hung around the "wrong crowd" or made "wrong decision" but overall were good guys....
Yah sure, I know exactly what you mean.

I routinely target others for violence when I feel like it, and I consider myself to be decent chap once you get to know me ;)

P.S. Never been in a one-on-one fight here.  It was always at least 4 who jumped me - so some things never change here.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Rocky on June 03, 2026, 06:03:27 AM
That's called a Chimp Out. It's been popularized on social media by certain degenerate welfare-addicted ethnic groups and communist rent-a-riots in blue cities with revolving door justice systems.
The attackers are all fairly certain they will get off because if it ever goes before a judge they will say the magic social justice words that grant them leniency and a license for mayhem.

This video made me reconsider my plans for a wheel gun. Small frames are much more convenient to carry, but five shots are clearly not enough to escape/rescue a love one from a Chimp Out.
The chimps abandon honor and humanity, preferring to attack from the back like wild animals. Surviving without someone else on 6 could likely involve rolling like Rittenhouse.

Somewhat agree.
Unless one of them were armed, I think they would scatter like the cockroaches they are when the first flash of "loud light" came on.

   My local  (Kahalu'u  to Northshore) facebook is on fire with this almost as much as the rock chucker.
Photos are out, some identified three arrested. CRU assisted in the identification and arrest of three juvenile suspects for Kidnapping and Assault offenses.
Additional arrests are anticipated.
My question is whose determined that they be charged with “assault” vs 2nd degree attempted murder?
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: hvybarrels on June 03, 2026, 09:09:03 AM
My local  (Kahalu'u  to Northshore) facebook is on fire with this almost as much as the rock chucker.
Photos are out, some identified three arrested. CRU assisted in the identification and arrest of three juvenile suspects for Kidnapping and Assault offenses.
Additional arrests are anticipated.
My question is whose determined that they be charged with “assault” vs 2nd degree attempted murder?

Certain high profile cases get attention like the California road rage guy, but it's the steady beat of "decline to prosecute" violent assaults give a green light to the chimps.

https://www.kitv.com/news/crime/honolulu-prosecutors-office-declines-to-file-charges-against-suspect-in-laie-assault-case/article_c9298706-11d9-11ed-a74f-d3717fde00d3.html
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Westside_Redneck on June 03, 2026, 11:20:26 AM
That's called a Chimp Out. It's been popularized on social media by certain degenerate welfare-addicted ethnic groups and communist rent-a-riots in blue cities with revolving door justice systems.
The attackers are all fairly certain they will get off because if it ever goes before a judge they will say the magic social justice words that grant them leniency and a license for mayhem.

This video made me reconsider my plans for a wheel gun. Small frames are much more convenient to carry, but five shots are clearly not enough to escape/rescue a love one from a Chimp Out.
The chimps abandon honor and humanity, preferring to attack from the back like wild animals. Surviving without someone else on 6 could likely involve rolling like Rittenhouse.

This incident, and the ongoing trend of this "chimping out" crap has got me thinking. If we are in a society that doesn't permit or makes it "difficult" for us to carry our firearms, as well as the prospect of
ammo capacity vs likelihood of jamming during a wrestling match with more than five individuals; its got me thinking we need a different type of weapon for this type of scenario. What if we could carry
smoke bombs, ie like ninjas. It doesn't have to have an explosive component just has to burst quickly, disperse a thick vision-distorting smoke on demand that could fill a room, work in all lighting
conditions and blind a group of attackers long enough for you to wrestle, shove, punch, kick etc. your way out of danger. It could have potential for getting out of political riot situations as well.

No noxious fumes to backfire on you as you are making your escape and if the enemies cant see they can't harm you effectively.


Certain high profile cases get attention like the California road rage guy, but it's the steady beat of "decline to prosecute" violent assaults give a green light to the chimps.

https://www.kitv.com/news/crime/honolulu-prosecutors-office-declines-to-file-charges-against-suspect-in-laie-assault-case/article_c9298706-11d9-11ed-a74f-d3717fde00d3.html


This, this is the reason crime is getting out of control! If they punish these youths and punish them severely. Lock em up throw away the key, let the cops baton them in the nose while in custody,
let the resident inmates have free reign to brutally beat them down etc. then you will see fear enter their souls and make them think twice before they decide to engage in anti-social behavior.

This liberal approach to "criminal justice reform" might as well be called "criminal justice empowerment" Pass federal legislation that allows the federal government (no meddling crooked state boards)
to disbar judges who release violent criminals back on the streets and commit more violent crime. Example; If a murderer gets out and murders again, that judge could be disbarred and arrested for being
an accessory to another murder! Put these liberal f@#%wits in the hotseat and force them to take accountability for every God d@mned case they oversee!




...that and start criminally charging the folks who stand by and videotape the assault with their phones for social media clout, charge them with accessory to the assault! That will give the spineless wimps
something to think about before they reach into their pockets for likes and 5 minutes of fame!

Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: ren on June 03, 2026, 11:55:29 AM
if the mob was attacking a monk seal guaranz all of them would be in jail by now.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 03, 2026, 01:21:07 PM
Did something happen prior to the 15 yr. old getting mob attacked?

Or is this a thing nowadays.  Pick somebody, anybody, then do a tik tok attack post.

if you were a father witnessing your son getting pummeled like that and you were armed...justified?

I don't care if it was justified or not.  It's happening.  People are going down.  I'll worry about the justification later.  Especially here in Hawaii.  Justice doesn't exist.  My loved one's lives are worth more than mine.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: macsak on June 03, 2026, 01:34:36 PM
it's ok to attack a monk seal to protect a sea turtle...

if the mob was attacking a monk seal guaranz all of them would be in jail by now.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 03, 2026, 01:55:57 PM
Quote
I cringe when I hear this case described as one of road rage. It gives the term a bad name.
What occurred in that Waikele parking lot was purely and simply evil. The assault was a
reminder of the darkness in the hearts and souls of those who live among us. The only option
is for our law enforcement officials to do their No. 1 job and separate these lawless rogues
from the law-abiding public.

Anything short of that is to sanction such behavior.
https://archives.midweek.com/content/columns/ace_article/a_vicious_attack_not_road_rage/

Quote
A man already infamous for violent road rage attacks has learned his fate after a frightening
confrontation in Hawaii, where he attacked a mother and her teenage daughter while they
were practicing parallel parking.
https://thedailycrime.org/2026/05/23/road-rage-driver-attacked-mom-and-teen-daughter-during-parking-lesson/

Quote
A jury has found the man accused in a triple stabbing on the H-1 Freeway in 2016 guilty of
attempted murder and two counts of assault.

Mark Char was accused of attacking the victims following a road rage incident.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/03/01/suspect-triple-stabbing-h-freeway-found-guilty-attempted-murder-assault/

There is literally no end to the number of stories in Hawaii where people inflict serious injury on others for no reason other than being yelled at after they almost cause an accident, or because they get pissed that someone accidentally damaged their vehicle.

If you know this, it's justifiable to believe that someone threatening or engaging in violence is potentially going to do the same to you.

If you add the mob element, it's a well-known fact that most people will be incited to act in a group who share the same feelings than an individual acting alone will.

Someone doesn't have to try to kill you or someone else for self defense to be justified.  Potentially causing severe injury is enough to use lethal force.  This is not a sporting event where having an "unfair" advantage over the attacker must be penalized.  I think a fair warning like, "Stop or I WILL shoot you!" is sporting enough.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: zippz on June 03, 2026, 02:53:46 PM
The continued kicks to the head by the mob was a clear sign that deadly force could be used to save the person.  But you may not know who started the fight, possibly hit the victim, and you could be subject to lawsuits even if you're right.

 A better option would be to use the large can of pepper spray to hose down the area when the fight started and have a gun incase they draw a gun or knife on you.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: zippz on June 03, 2026, 03:03:49 PM
I wonder what the motive for the fight was.  If it was a disagreement then normally past practice was two people fight it out one on one and they'd stop fighting when someone gave up.  There would be respect on both sides.  If it was a robbery they'd beat someone up, steal stuff, then take off.   I guess this was a gang related fight as they posted it online to use it as an example for their competition.

For the other stories, I don't like the term road rage as it makes an excuse for their behavior.  Same is true for hate crimes, crimes against police and old people, etc.  It should be treated equally and just called violence or assault.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 03, 2026, 04:25:08 PM
The continued kicks to the head by the mob was a clear sign that deadly force could be used to save the person.  But you may not know who started the fight, possibly hit the victim, and you could be subject to lawsuits even if you're right.

 A better option would be to use the large can of pepper spray to hose down the area when the fight started and have a gun incase they draw a gun or knife on you.
Why does it matter who started the attack?  Anyone participating becomes a threat.

Take out the one who's the most immediate threat and the others will likely scatter.

The person shot may not have instigated it, but they sure could be the one that inflicts the fatal blow/kick.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: ren on June 03, 2026, 05:43:45 PM
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/video/2026/06/04/covering-cost-cost-incarceration-hawaiis-prison-system/

According to DCR, 6.7 percent of the state’s jail population describe themselves as homeless or having no permanent address. About 30% of those held in OCCC are Native Hawaiian. One in five are held for technical parole violations, not new crimes.

Every legislative session, Brady lobbies lawmakers and other officials to address system inequities and push for policies that ensure humane treatment of those in jails and prisons. Among those lawmakers passed this past session involve SNAP benefits for certain releasees, criminal record expungement for those convicted of violations, and keeping those convicted of non-violent misdemeanors out of deportation proceedings.

She believes officials should fund programs that address the root problems that lead to incarceration, such as homelessness and mental health issues.


those people will never lear.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 03, 2026, 06:52:26 PM
Why does it matter who started the attack?  Anyone participating becomes a threat.

Take out the one who's the most immediate threat and the others will likely scatter.

The person shot may not have instigated it, but they sure could be the one that inflicts the fatal blow/kick.
Makes a lot of sense.

Another possibility is to come in hot in your vehicle (assuming this is an option), brights on, horn blaring, to disperse them, or at least distract them from their victim.

Exit armed ordering them to disperse.

If some continue the assault, then proceed with what you suggest.

Since these are real events on our island that any one of us could be witness to, I believe it’s of benefit to throw out suggestions with respect to how to best respond.

We’re all just regular guys here, not John Wick (and John Wick isn’t even John Wick, for that matter….).
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: hvybarrels on June 03, 2026, 11:34:35 PM
Younger men are really fast and good at attacking the blind spots of someone who is distracted. Getting older makes it more difficult  to whip around and solve problems coming from all different directions. Also assisting someone who is unconscious/immobilized creates another series of vulnerabilities.

The security guys who escort journalists through riot zones are typically younger and have specialized training. Then again the more experienced security guys are probably like “this is a bad idea and the risk isn’t worth the money”.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 04, 2026, 08:57:48 AM
There is completely understandable reservation on the part of folks thinking about confronting a violent mob attacking some guy.

Many practical considerations and cautions with respect to the use of deadly force (which appears justified here).

I wonder how police would handle - would they rely on respect for the uniform/blue lights & sirens to cause dispersement?  Wish I was familiar with that training.

What if, instead of a guy(s) being beaten, it was a girl or woman being gang-raped? - and you were there.

Would that change anyone so reasonably reticent to intervene into one compelled to act?

How many would lay their lives down for another.

If not, what are you here for?

Not being confrontational or holier than thou by this whatsoever - last guy in the world to wear that mantle.

It’s the nature of this world that poses the question to us here.

********
Update:

Sorry guys - forget that drivel above.

I’d just shoot this Mf*+#~r, dead.

(https://www.staradvertiser.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/web1_060326-WEB-suspect.jpg)

https://www.staradvertiser.com/2026/06/03/breaking-news/hpd-releases-photo-of-another-suspect-in-waialee-beach-assault/

Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Westside_Redneck on June 04, 2026, 01:06:48 PM
I’d just shoot this Mf*+#~r, dead.

(https://www.staradvertiser.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/web1_060326-WEB-suspect.jpg)

https://www.staradvertiser.com/2026/06/03/breaking-news/hpd-releases-photo-of-another-suspect-in-waialee-beach-assault/

How much you wanna wager this guy is the gang leader? The "groomer" who's got a mob of depraved lost losers around his finger
whom he could entice to be his "foot soldiers" to aid him in his anti-social antics?
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 04, 2026, 01:40:05 PM
How much you wanna wager this guy is the gang leader? The "groomer" who's got a mob of depraved lost losers around his finger
whom he could entice to be his "foot soldiers" to aid him in his anti-social antics?
Could be.

All I can say is I know some .357 Magnum JHP’s who see him as the end of a very short and satisfying trip.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Rocky on June 04, 2026, 02:17:41 PM

Lets play D A.
 
''Another possi.bility is to come in hot in your vehicle (assuming this is an option), brights on, horn blaring, to disperse them, or at least distract them from their victim.''
YOU HAVE JUST INSERTED YOURSELF INTO THE SITUATION POSSIBLY LOSING YOUR JUSTIFICATION FOR JUSTIFIABLE DEADLY FORCE

''Exit armed ordering them to disperse. ''
YOU HAVE NOW JUST COMMITTED TERRORISTIC THREATENING

''If some continue the assault, then proceed with what you suggest.''
 SEE MY FIRST COMMENT

Since these are real events on our island that any one of us could be witness to, I believe it’s of benefit to throw out suggestions with respect to how to best respond.
I  HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT THIS ALSO AND CONSIDERED DISCHARGING ROUNDS IN AIR, OVER OCEAN, IN SAND TO HOPEFULLY DISPERSE THE CROWD WITHOUT LOSS OF LIFE BUT THEN IT GOES BACK TO CHARGES OF TERRORISTIC THREATENING AND POSSIBLE ATTEMPTED MANSLAUGHTER EVEN IF SUCESSFUL. IF UNSUCCESSFUL, I'VE JUST EXPOSED MYSELF AND WASTED SEVERAL OF 10 ROUNDS IN A GROUP OF ALREADY VIOLENT POSSIBLY ARMED INDIVIDUALS.

   I tend to discuss the defense of others in my classes fairly heavily.
Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your  interacting is a crap shoot.
Pun intended.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: hvybarrels on June 04, 2026, 02:25:09 PM
Gangs use child soldiers for a variety of reasons. One is the leniency in prosecution. Another is that people who still have a shred of humanity tend to hesitate when shooting at kids. If the cops show up and you are surrounded by a bunch of 15yo corpses it’s probably going to take a few years and hundreds of thousands of dollars to unpack. Sure they were trying to murder you like a pack of rabid chimps, but in front of a jury they transform into choirboys who helped old ladies across the street.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 04, 2026, 02:27:35 PM

Lets play D A.
 
''Another possi.bility is to come in hot in your vehicle (assuming this is an option), brights on, horn blaring, to disperse them, or at least distract them from their victim.''
YOU HAVE JUST INSERTED YOURSELF INTO THE SITUATION POSSIBLY LOSING YOUR JUSTIFICATION FOR JUSTIFIABLE DEADLY FORCE

''Exit armed ordering them to disperse. ''
YOU HAVE NOW JUST COMMITTED TERRORISTIC THREATENING

''If some continue the assault, then proceed with what you suggest.''
 SEE MY FIRST COMMENT

Since these are real events on our island that any one of us could be witness to, I believe it’s of benefit to throw out suggestions with respect to how to best respond.
I  HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT THIS ALSO AND CONSIDERED DISCHARGING ROUNDS IN AIR, OVER OCEAN, IN SAND TO HOPEFULLY DISPERSE THE CROWD WITHOUT LOSS OF LIFE BUT THEN IT GOES BACK TO CHARGES OF TERRORISTIC THREATENING AND POSSIBLE ATTEMPTED MANSLAUGHTER EVEN IF SUCESSFUL. IF UNSUCCESSFUL, I'VE JUST EXPOSED MYSELF AND WASTED SEVERAL OF 10 ROUNDS IN A GROUP OF ALREADY VIOLENT POSSIBLY ARMED INDIVIDUALS.

   I tend to discuss the defense of others in my classes fairly heavily.
Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your  interacting is a crap shoot.
Pun intended.


Assuming you are serious here, I included this comment above, for guys like you:

“But let’s look at it the other way, and say that, for fear of wrongful prosecution by the local Khmer Rouge, you don’t, and they kill your son (or anyone, for that matter).

You forever own the guilt of letting an innocent be killed via inaction in compliance with an unlawful and evil regime.  Some people can live with that, and some people just. will. not. - like the Lifeguard friend.”

No DA is is a substitute for God, my friend.


…. oh, also, your comments seem to indicate we’re talking about a bunch of guys having a beer in a parking lot.

Mine relate to a mob in the act of trying to beat someone to death.

Maybe that’s the disconnect.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Rocky on June 04, 2026, 03:14:38 PM
       Assuming you are serious here, I included this comment above, for guys like you:
I see no "comment above" and yes I was serious regarding the possible legal repercussions

      “But let’s look at it the other way, and say that, for fear of wrongful prosecution by the local Khmer Rouge, you don’t, and they kill your son (or anyone, for that matter).
My comment was on the topic of another unknown individual, not my son. My family and friends are a given as I  am already personally knowledgeable of them.
"anyone, for that matter" falls under "Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events"

      You forever own the guilt of letting an innocent be killed via inaction in compliance with an unlawful and evil regime. 
 Upon arriving at the scene, do I know who is innocent ? Do I know who's guilty ?
What if it's some father beating the $#1t outta some punk that he just caught raping his 12 yr old daughter. Would shooting him be right in my (or your) eyes ?
Or I'm walking past an alley and there is a women screaming rape as a disheveled figure restrains her and he has a gun. I shoot him dead only to find out he is (was) an undercover cop arresting a drug dealer/prostitute ?

Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your  interacting is a crap shoot.

     Some people can live with that, and some people just. will. not. - like the Lifeguard friend.”
As you have noted and as is discussed elsewhere, the "Lifeguard friend'  and the 15yr old were acquaintances' so there was personally knowledge between those two participants with some possible history ? (Don't know for sure the story is still evolving.)
You asked us  "to throw out suggestions with respect to how to best respond." and I did after listing the possible repercussions of your suggested actions.
In no way did I infer I would do nothing in that particular situation.

     No DA is is a substitute for God, my friend.
To even consider comparing a DA to God is bordering Blasphemy
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 04, 2026, 03:51:29 PM

Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your interacting is a crap shoot.

This type standard ensures a nice personal safe-harbor for justifiable inaction, however it’s not an expectation of the code:

“§703-305  Use of force for the protection of other persons.


(1)  Subject to the provisions of this section and of section 703-310, the use of force upon or toward the person of another is justifiable to protect a third person when:
     (a)  Under the circumstances as the actor believes them to be, the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be justified in using such protective force; and
     (b)  The actor believes that the actor's intervention is necessary for the protection of the other person.
(2)  Notwithstanding subsection (1):
     (a)  When the actor would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing, or to comply with a demand before using force in self-protection, the actor is not obliged to do so before using force for the protection of another person, unless the actor knows that the actor can thereby secure the complete safety of such other person;
     (b)  When the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing or to comply with a demand if the person knew that the person could obtain complete safety by so doing, the actor is obliged to try to cause the person to do so before using force in the person's protection if the actor knows that the actor can obtain the other's complete safety in that way; and
     (c)  Neither the actor nor the person whom the actor seeks to protect is obliged to retreat when in the other's dwelling or place of work to any greater extent than in the actor's or the person's own. [L 1972, c 9, pt of §1; gen ch 1993]”

Let’s just leave it where it stands: The code, and one’s conscience.

“To even consider comparing a DA to God is bordering Blasphemy” - Good, then you are in the right frame of reference for determining the standards of your personal conduct.  Fear of wrongful prosecution for doing what you believe is right cannot be the governing standard then.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Rocky on June 05, 2026, 12:32:18 PM
This type standard ensures a nice personal safe-harbor for justifiable inaction, however it’s not an expectation of the code:

“§703-305  Use of force for the protection of other persons.

(1)  Subject to the provisions of this section and of section 703-310, the use of force upon or toward the person of another is justifiable to protect a third person when:
     (a)  Under the circumstances as the actor believes them to be, the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be justified in using such protective force; and
     (b)  The actor believes that the actor's intervention is necessary for the protection of the other person.
(2)  Notwithstanding subsection (1):
     (a)  When the actor would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing, or to comply with a demand before using force in self-protection, the actor is not obliged to do so before using force for the protection of another person, unless the actor knows that the actor can thereby secure the complete safety of such other person;
     (b)  When the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing or to comply with a demand if the person knew that the person could obtain complete safety by so doing, the actor is obliged to try to cause the person to do so before using force in the person's protection if the actor knows that the actor can obtain the other's complete safety in that way; and
     (c)  Neither the actor nor the person whom the actor seeks to protect is obliged to retreat when in the other's dwelling or place of work to any greater extent than in the actor's or the person's own. [L 1972, c 9, pt of §1; gen ch 1993]”

My comment "Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your interacting is a crap shoot."  in no way insinuates "inaction", it simply states to know the facts before jumping in. Did you not read my entire post including "In no way did I infer I would do nothing in that particular situation."?  My "Playing DA" was simply  "expectations" that may well occur due to the actions you had submitted even under §703-305.

Let’s just leave it where it stands: The code, and one’s conscience.
No response to my examples ?  My conscience said save the lady in the alley but I killed a cop instead.

“To even consider comparing a DA to God is bordering Blasphemy” -
Good, then you are in the right frame of reference for determining the standards of your personal conduct. 
So you judge me to be in the "Right frame of mind for determining the standards of your (my) personal conduct" even though we have never met and we have no history together other than a few words exchanged on a blog. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

Fear of wrongful prosecution for doing what you believe is right cannot be the governing standard then.
Prosecution right or wrong is mentally, emotionally and financially taxing.
Quite the price to pay along with possible jailtime for doing what I believed was right but was wrong because I DID NOT KNOW ALL THE FACTS !


…. oh, also, your comments seem to indicate we’re talking about a bunch of guys having a beer in a parking lot.
Mine relate to a mob in the act of trying to beat someone to death.
Maybe that’s the disconnect.
I also see you have modified your post to include the above.
How does my responding to quotes from YOUR post indicate we're talking about anything other than the topic "a mob in the act of trying to beat someone to death." ?
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Kalihi Uka on June 05, 2026, 02:07:20 PM
I also see you have modified your post to include the above.
How does my responding to quotes from YOUR post indicate we're talking about anything other than the topic "a mob in the act of trying to beat someone to death." ?

Seems I hit a nerve.

Good.

Hopefully, if you’re ever on the ground being beaten to death, the onlookers will not be people like you, who might think “oh, that guy must have really pissed them off,” and go on their way.

This is all you -

“ Upon arriving at the scene, do I know who is innocent ? Do I know who's guilty ?
What if it's some father beating the $#1t outta some punk that he just caught raping his 12 yr old daughter. Would shooting him be right in my (or your) eyes ?
Or I'm walking past an alley and there is a women screaming rape as a disheveled figure restrains her and he has a gun. I shoot him dead only to find out he is (was) an undercover cop arresting a drug dealer/prostitute ?
Unless you are personally knowledgeable of all participants, history and events, your  interacting is a crap shoot.”

You’re fighting with yourself bro, not me.

Before I forget, the reason I posted the code is because you keep on with this nonsense:

“Prosecution right or wrong is mentally, emotionally and financially taxing.  Quite the price to pay along with possible jailtime for doing what I believed was right but was wrong because I DID NOT KNOW ALL THE FACTS !”

Since you like caps: THAT IS NOT THE STANDARD YOU WOULD BE HELD TO.

The relevant part of the code is

(a)  Under the circumstances as the actor believes them to be, the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be justified in using such protective force; and

Needed to add this lest anyone believe your argument in this regard accurate.  It is wrong.

In this case - coming to the aid of another - the State does not erect such barriers to discourage action on the part of citizens.

Maybe you need to update your class notes.
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: zippz on June 06, 2026, 09:34:09 AM
There's several videos on HHHNewz on FB/Instagram of the incident.  It was a teenage girls party with alcohol.  Couldn't tell what was being said, but it appeared the 2 victims were taunting the others and the lifeguard may have thrown the first punch.  I didn't get the impression that the mobbing would've happened if not for the taunting, nor that it was a planned or coordinated fight. Also, it appeared like the 2 victims could have escaped or left the party before the mobbing occurred. 
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 06, 2026, 09:38:17 AM
There's several videos on HHHNewz on FB/Instagram of the incident.  It was a teenage girls party with alcohol.  Couldn't tell what was being said, but it appeared the 2 victims were taunting the others and the lifeguard may have thrown the first punch.  I didn't get the impression that the mobbing would've happened if not for the taunting, and that it was a planned or coordinated fight. Also, it appeared like the 2 victims could have escaped or left the party before the mobbing occurred.

With very few exceptions, nothing happens "for nothing".
Title: Re: the Aloha spirit....
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 06, 2026, 02:00:35 PM
With very few exceptions, nothing happens "for nothing".

Maybe.  But many times the reason is only in the mind of the person who believes they are the aggrieved (offended) party.  It might be a misunderstanding over something said to them, or sometimes it can even be instigated by something they heard from someone else who's trying to stir the pot.

Something can in all reality happen for nothing -- even when the "nothing" has the smallest amount of importance.

I think road rage is the ultimate example of something happening for nothing.  Someone doesn't check their mirrors and does a lane change, and the guy in their blind spot goes into a rage which manifests in some of the worst kinds of behavior.  The driver who changed lanes didn't do anything to intentionally piss off the other driver.