For about 15 years, I subscribed to Oceanic cable for my cable television and also RoadRunner internet, and I also paid HawaiianTel for my home phone.
A year or two ago, we decided that we didn't need cable, and that we also didn't need to be paying two different providers. Feeling pissy (don't ask why) I called Oceanic and told them to end my service. "Ok," they said, "we'll cut you off at the end of the month." Then I called HawaiianTel and told them to make me a DSL customer.
So, for that intervening month, I had both services in my home. And here's what I found out.
First, from a financial viewpoint, there was no reason to prefer one company over another. The difference in price for like packages was negligible.
Second, Oceanic provided what they promised. I was paying for 15 Mb/s and consistently getting over 13, with peaks as high as 18 (between 87% and 120% of what I was paying for).
Third, HawaiianTel could not deliver. I was paying them for 12 Mb/s, and consistently getting 7, with common lows of 3 (between 25% and 58% of what I was paying for).
I did, of course, call HawaiianTel to give them a chance to resolve the issue. They connected me to a service tech who said "you need to move the wireless router we sent you." Really? Move the router? I obliged, and of course, it had no effect. They offered to let me exchange the router, mailing it to the mainland and waiting 6-8 weeks for a replacement. They also offered to charge me $75 to send a service tech to my house.
Needless to say, I dropped HawaiianTel and cancelled my cancellation of Oceanic. And, since that day, I still check my bandwidth regularly, and Oceanic still delivers, commonly providing me with more bandwidth than I pay for.
Recently HawaiianTel was in the neighborhood, installing new fiber optic lines. They knocked on my door, but I turned them away. C couple of years ago, they had an inferior product and rotten customer service. Now they were fixing one of those problems. Not really incentive to reconsider, in my book.
Of course, YMMV!