Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first (Read 7149 times)

stegosaurus

Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« on: January 11, 2011, 11:27:37 AM »
http://mlnurl.com/7w50

I know there's not much details but for the sake of discussion, let's assume their parent's house was their "place of sojourn" and the mob of guys were angry but unarmed. Would lethal force be justified in this situation? From what I understand, if you fear death or serious bodily harm, lethal force is justified regardless if the mob was armed or not. Obviously a 10 on 2 situation could cause serious injuries. The only reason I ask is because I'm a small guy and I don't think I could take on multiple attackers. What does the law say I do instead? Run? Call the cops?

I think what the brother did wrong was to pull the gun out just to scare them off. Because now the other person is justified in pulling their gun out and using it for self-defense. I think that's the point the defense lawyer was trying to make. In my opinion, never fake it because the other guy might not. When the gun comes out, be prepared to take a life and that you would be justified in doing so.

Do we have a thread where we can discuss real scenarios where lethal force would or would not be justified?
"When you outlaw guns, only the outlaws have guns."

Heavies

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #1 on: January 11, 2011, 02:39:08 PM »
Quote
let's assume their parent's house was their "place of sojourn" and the mob of guys were angry but unarmed. Would lethal force be justified in this situation?

From what I gather, if you are able to retreat, you are not justified in using leathal force.  If they were to follow you into your home and you have no other option you would be able to use force.  That is if you did not aggravate the mob and start the disurbance.  i.e 'come and get me!' etc.

Quote
http://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=405.0
 
   
COMMENTARY ON §703-304
   
 
...actor can  avoid using it with complete safety by retreating, by surrendering   possession  of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right to it, or by complying   with a  demand that he refrain from taking an action which he has no legal duty   to  take.  In any of these cases, the Code may seem to be opting for   cowardice. 
 
 

Hawaii don't have a 'stand your ground' law, as far as I know. :(
 
Because the brother started the altercation, fired the first shot, and lied to the police, the killer will probably get off the murder rap.

Dregs

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #2 on: January 11, 2011, 04:22:45 PM »
Just to throw some thoughts up there, I thought Hawaii did not have a duty to retreat? Actually hmm now I remember reading the, "if there's a reasonable chance to escape.", line.

Perhaps knowing that there's 3 cars following him to the house is sufficient fear of life? I can imagine not being able to escape from that kind of situation. The brother did leave the altercation he started, but they were pursued home. Also, the way I read it, both parties were carrying illegally. Unless the brother ran into the house, grabbed the gun, and left the house to confront them. Which I didn't see mentioned anywhere so I doubt that's what happened.

The way it sounds like, no one should walk away unpunished. Both sides did stupid. Manslaughter for shooter and manslaughter for brother!.........Guess this is why I'm not cut out to be a lawyer O_o.

I think the brother's liability stopped at the bar after the fight he started. After he "escaped" the situation but then was pursued to his home/mother's home, he's no longer the aggressor.

Justified use of lethal force though? Proper escalation of force?

 :popcorn:

Old Guy

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #3 on: January 11, 2011, 06:54:06 PM »
For the brothers shooter, looks like he could plead Self Defense.

For the brother that Started the whole thing, his testimony from now is totally suspect.  He LIED once and the Jury will Always have questions on All his
further testimony.
Sure sounds like he was thinking with the "small head" and wanting a confrontation with Collins.  Admits to starting something at the bar, both get ejected
and then they take it home.   

Firing the "one boolit"  trying to "scare" didn't work and resulted in return fire which got his brother killed.  His fault, no gun, no shooting, just fists, maybe.

Now the Prosecutor or defense attorney has to bring out WHY collins brought or had a gun.   

Not sure how or if new Hawaii Castle Law can or may apply, if at all.

Smart thing to do when the cars with Collins drove up, was to call 911 ASAP and decare an Emergency, get inside and then go from there. 

Maybe the new  Castle Law could apply. 

We will just see how this case unfold and how good the opposing attorneys are or aren't.

All over a woman, 

raudi

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #4 on: January 11, 2011, 07:42:43 PM »
I hope she was hot.

808shooter

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #5 on: January 11, 2011, 07:51:37 PM »
the thing that got me thinking was i read somewhere that he went into the yard and "dug up" his rifle.  WTH is up with that??  Why did he have a burried rifle?  Do the cops frequent his house?  I know this really has not much to do with the main issue, but it's what stood out to me... ???

kaneohegrown

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #6 on: January 12, 2011, 07:48:22 AM »
If you look at the HI court docs (http://hoohiki1.courts.state.hi.us/jud/Hoohiki/main.htm?spawn=1), you can look up the two guys. If the information is correct Collins had a TRO (don't know if it was still active at the time of the shooting). But Botelho on the other hand (if it's the same Leon "Bubba" Botelho), has a whole list of crap against him. From what I saw, he is barred from owning any firearm. So his rifle that was buried in the backyard was illegal, unless he can claim it was a family member's firearm (though I'm willing to bet it'll show up as stolen).

ren

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #7 on: January 12, 2011, 09:10:11 AM »
If you look at the HI court docs (http://hoohiki1.courts.state.hi.us/jud/Hoohiki/main.htm?spawn=1), you can look up the two guys. If the information is correct Collins had a TRO (don't know if it was still active at the time of the shooting). But Botelho on the other hand (if it's the same Leon "Bubba" Botelho), has a whole list of crap against him. From what I saw, he is barred from owning any firearm. So his rifle that was buried in the backyard was illegal, unless he can claim it was a family member's firearm (though I'm willing to bet it'll show up as stolen).

Leon was in court for promoting a dangerous drug.  Crap gets deeper
Deeds Not Words

Old Guy

Re: Brother of slain Kaneohe man admits he fired first
« Reply #8 on: January 12, 2011, 11:46:31 AM »
Maybe they could make a TV show out of this story........