How are Nitro piston type airguns? (Read 4125 times)

oldfart

How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« on: October 19, 2013, 01:22:23 PM »
How are Nitro piston type airguns? Are they as good as the advertising claims?
What, Me Worry?

robtmc

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #1 on: October 20, 2013, 08:09:46 PM »
How are Nitro piston type airguns? Are they as good as the advertising claims?

No. At least in my limited experience.

I have spent far too much time and effort getting a .22 Benjamin Trail NP to shoot worth a damn.  If it was made in Germany, it probably would have been a fine gun ( with triple the price tag), but it is Chinese built to a price point and devoid of QC.  The crudeness and lack of finish are startling if you have handled European airguns.  Took mine completely apart to clean up burrs, etc.

All the crap about how quiet they are is just that, crap.  I have a RWS 48 that hits far harder and is a bit less loud, and if anything, is less hold sensitive as well. 

Extremely hard to shoot the Benji Trail NP accurately.  It also had a nasty habit of throwing the first few shots of the day well off the point of aim.  Once it settles down, it is not bad.  This first shot erratically going of aim is something discussed a bit on airgun forums.  At 29 yards when new, it was a shotgun as far as patterns went.  Now I can get 1/2" on a good day.

Hatsan has some NP guns now, no idea how they are.  I think the NP idea is fine, but the hype is just that.  They are not quieter, not smoother, not easier to shoot well.  High power spring guns are a bear to shoot well, the NP has a sharp shot cycle and recoil that takes time to master.

oldfart

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #2 on: October 20, 2013, 11:21:10 PM »
Thanks for your review. It was helpful.
What, Me Worry?

robtmc

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #3 on: October 21, 2013, 07:47:10 AM »
You are welcome, sorry for the poor sentences structure, typed too late before bed.

A few of the Crosman NP guns have gotten decent reviews, but are not sold here as far as I know.  The Sport Auth, Walmart stuff is the cruder end of their NP line.

The Remington NPS and Summit were supposed to be fairly good if you ever ran across them.

Since I got the RWS and a Benji Discovery PCP, the NP has been left in the closet mostly.

oldfart

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #4 on: October 21, 2013, 08:11:14 AM »
Thanks for the info. I do own a rather beautiful German air rifle but I was hoping that modern technology had produced something better at a lower price. I guess not.
Actually I was looking for a cheap 22 air rifle that I could experiment with loading bb's. Something like a little shotgun.
I have numerous ugly black lizards all over my yard. They are skittish. They are FAST. They have a small K-zone. I was thinking that a little air powered shot load load would be just the ticket for hunting these invasive creatures.
What, Me Worry?

stangzilla

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #5 on: October 21, 2013, 10:17:52 AM »
Thanks for the info. I do own a rather beautiful German air rifle but I was hoping that modern technology had produced something better at a lower price. I guess not.
Actually I was looking for a cheap 22 air rifle that I could experiment with loading bb's. Something like a little shotgun.
I have numerous ugly black lizards all over my yard. They are skittish. They are FAST. They have a small K-zone. I was thinking that a little air powered shot load load would be just the ticket for hunting these invasive creatures.

i used to use a crosman 760 powermaster with a 3 shot BB load wrapped in tissue paper
worked great at close range
my friend used a crosman american classic, it had a magnetized bolt, so the BB's would hold without the tissue paper

for your purpose, why not use an american classic pump handgun or rifle
i think the handgun is about $60

oldfart

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #6 on: October 21, 2013, 10:51:19 AM »
i used to use a crosman 760 powermaster with a 3 shot BB load wrapped in tissue paper
worked great at close range
my friend used a crosman american classic, it had a magnetized bolt, so the BB's would hold without the tissue paper

for your purpose, why not use an american classic pump handgun or rifle
i think the handgun is about $60
===============
I will try the 3bb tissue load in my Webley Hurricane. But I don't think the Hurricane has enough horsepower to do the job.
What, Me Worry?

stangzilla

Re: How are Nitro piston type airguns?
« Reply #7 on: October 21, 2013, 12:06:51 PM »
===============
I will try the 3bb tissue load in my Webley Hurricane. But I don't think the Hurricane has enough horsepower to do the job.

I also have a Hurricane from back in the 80's.
yea, its not that powerful.