My letter to every Hawaii state legislator (Read 4735 times)

punaperson

My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« on: January 07, 2014, 05:07:41 PM »
I'll be sending this email shortly to every Hawaii state legislator. It's long, it's repetitious, it's kinda ugly. But I thought it was important to make each point individually and repeat that there is no evidence to support each existing law, and that in fact there is evidence to support abolishing such laws (from the "public safety" viewpoint that the government argues in court cases is their "compelling interest" for imposing unconstitutional laws upon the citizens of Hawaii). There are of course more absurd laws than those I have asked to be repealed/amended, but I doubt any legislators (or even their staff) will even read a letter this long. I got an email from Senator Slom after I emailed him an earlier informal list of suggestions for legislation for this year and his reply stated that (apparently) his only legislation re firearms this session will be: "I will reintroduce concealed carry and open carry legislation as well as support for the Koko Head Firing Range."

Dear Legislator,

I urge you to create, sponsor, co-sponsor or at the very least support legislation as listed below that would allow law-abiding citizens of Hawaii to exercise their full rights to choose their preferred mode of self-defense as guaranteed in both the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the state of Hawaii.

Repeal/Amend/End the current so-called “may issue” concealed carry permit system (which is de facto “shall not issue”) for firearms, and replace with legislation issuing such permits on a “shall issue” basis if the applicant is not on the prohibited persons list as defined by NICS. The new law ought not be burdensome financially nor time-wise nor in any other manner. In fact, my preference would be that government remove itself entirely from the question and simply allow citizens to carry without undergoing any government “approval” process, as per the states of Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Vermont and Wyoming.

Reasons: There is no evidence that prohibiting law-abiding citizens from carrying concealed weapons lowers the crime rate. There is no evidence that allowing law-abiding citizens to carry concealed weapons increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to prohibit law-abiding citizens from carrying concealed weapons in public. There is at least some correlation, if not causation, indicating that states and localities initiating concealed carry permits experience a decrease in many crimes following the enactment of such legislation. Doesn't Hawaii deserve to experience a possible drop in crime rates? In fact, studies have shown that people with concealed carry permits are 13 TIMES LESS likely to commit crimes that the average citizen. Such responsible concealed carry citizens are also less likely to commit crimes than law enforcement officers, and the state allows said law enforcement officers to carry weapons both on and off duty. The only rational and logical course is to allow law-abiding citizens to carry concealed weapons as a public safety measure, if not on mere Constitutional grounds re “bear(ing) arms”.

Repeal/Amend/End the current restriction on Open Carry (aka “Constitutional Carry”).

Reasons: There is no evidence that prohibiting law-abiding citizens from openly carrying weapons lowers the crime rate. There is no evidence that allowing law-abiding citizens to openly carry weapons increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to prohibit law-abiding citizens from openly carrying weapons in public.

Repeal/Amend/End the current restriction on suppressors.

Reasons: There is no evidence that prohibiting law-abiding citizens from using suppressors on weapons lowers the crime rate. There is no evidence that allowing law-abiding citizens to use suppressors on weapons weapons increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to prohibit law-abiding citizens from openly carrying weapons in public. Suppressors serve to significantly lessen auditory damage to both shooters and anyone in the vicinity of shooting activities.

Repeal/Amend/End handgun magazine capacity limits.

Reasons: There is no evidence that bans of handgun magazines of greater than 10 rounds capacity  lessen the crime rate. There is no evidence that legality of handgun magazines of greater than 10 rounds capacity increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to ban handgun magazines of greater than 10 rounds capacity. Most semi-automatic handguns other than the largest calibers normally come from the factory with magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds. It is only due to restrictive laws of several states, including Hawaii, that manufacturers have made such limited magazines for their firearms. Since Hawaii makes an exception for law enforcement, please tell me why an ordinary law-abiding citizen does not have the same right to defend themselves as law enforcement? How do you justify that discrimination?

Repeal/Amend/End Registration.

Reasons: There is no evidence that firearm registration lessens the crime rate. There is no evidence that jurisdictions without firearm registration requirements experience an increased the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to require law-abiding citizens to register their firearms. The system in Hawaii is absurd in having to make three separate trips to the police department during weekday work hours to be “allowed” to purchase a handgun. Registration information has apparently NEVER been used to solve a crime. In fact, apparently no one even keeps statistics on how many legally registered firearms, versus illegal unregistered firearms, are used in crimes. So what's the point, and how does that registration and record keeping not violate Constitutional guarantees? End registration.

Repeal/Amend/End the minimum 14 day waiting period for a permit to acquire a handgun.

Reasons: There is no evidence that minimum 14 day waiting period for a permit to acquire a handgun lessen the crime rate. There is no evidence that no waiting period at all increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to maintain any waiting period at all, much less a minimum 14 day waiting period. Most states only require the NICS instant check when buying from a FFL, and there is no criminological justification for such a waiting period as imposed by the state of Hawaii. Nor is there sound Constitutional grounds for such a waiting period. End the waiting period.

Repeal/Amend/End the ban on so-called “assault pistols”.

Reasons:  There is no evidence that banning so-called “assault pistols” lessens the crime rate. There is no evidence that law-abiding citizens legally owning so-called “assault pistols” increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to prohibit law-abiding citizens from owning so-called “assault pistols”.

Repeal/Amend/End the “marriage” requirement for co-registration of firearms.

Reasons: There is no evidence that the “marriage” requirement for co-registration of firearms lessens the crime rate. There is no evidence that unmarried people co-registering firearms increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to require marriage as a prerequisite for co-registration of firearms. There is no rational reason nor evidence as to why a government-sanctioned legal relationship (aka “marriage”) ought to be required for co-registration. End the marriage requirement for co-registration.

Repeal/Amend/End any and all prohibitions/restrictions on possession, use and public concealed or open carry of pepper spray or similar chemical self-defense weapons, extendable batons, knives, electric guns (“stun guns”, “tasers”, etc.) or any other non-firearm by law-abiding citizens.

Reasons: There is no evidence that prohibitions/restrictions on possession, use and public concealed or open carry of the above listed weapons lessens the crime rate. There is no evidence that legal possession, use and public concealed or open carry of the above listed weapons increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to impose  prohibitions/restrictions on possession, use and public concealed or open carry of the above listed weapons by law-abiding citizens.

Repeal/Amend/End the requirement to register “unusable, unserviceable” firearms.

Reasons: There is no evidence that the requirement to register “unusable, unserviceable” firearms lessens the crime rate. There is no evidence that not registering “unusable, unserviceable” firearms increases the crime rate. Therefore there is no government “compelling interest” in the name of “public safety” to the require the registration of “unusable, unserviceable” firearms. “Unserviceable” by definition means “incapable of being repaired to working order”. Why the need to register a permanently disabled firearm?

Thank you for your consideration,
« Last Edit: January 07, 2014, 07:48:16 PM by punaperson »

suka

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #1 on: January 07, 2014, 05:23:45 PM »
It's too long, They nor their aids will even read it.
If at all you'll get a canned response.
 I wrote in the past and got the same cold shoulder from every rep.

Heavies

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #2 on: January 07, 2014, 07:02:18 PM »
I would also save this for the future, and submit it for testimony when new bills are brought up for discussion.  They must look over it, at those times, and every person that submits must be counted.  Don't be discouraged with the form letter responses.  If we keep on 'em they will know that we are watching their every move and legislate accordinly.  Votes matter to them, and if they know that we are a large voting force, they will comply.

punaperson

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #3 on: January 08, 2014, 08:19:06 AM »
It's too long, They nor their aids will even read it.
If at all you'll get a canned response.
 I wrote in the past and got the same cold shoulder from every rep.
I've written and called quite a few legislators over the years and am quite familiar with their "cold shoulder" and "canned responses", but I still want to communicate with them and see what happens. At least they can't say "no one informed me". Well, they could and do, but I know better. I think it's POSSIBLE that if enough people (and I don't think it has to be 50% of their constituents or anywhere close to that) communicated with them about a particular issue that they would start to pay attention, the so-called "grassroots" effect. Otherwise someone has to raise huge sums of money and give it to them... and that wouldn't be me.

The two people in the Hawaii legislature that have actually apparently read and specifically responded to my communications are Senator Sam Slom and Representative Cynthia Thielen. Ms. Thielen took an active interest in my comments about SB69 last year but ended up supporting the bill after consulting with HRA's Max Cooper who also supported the bill even though it was opposed by the NRA-ILA (why do people with "unusable, unserviceable" firearms need to register (fingerprint, photograph, sign away medical privacy rights) them?). I was hoping Senator Slom would at least introduce another bill or two addressing the handgun magazine capacity limit or the suppressor ban.

punaperson

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #4 on: January 08, 2014, 08:35:57 AM »
I would also save this for the future, and submit it for testimony when new bills are brought up for discussion.  They must look over it, at those times, and every person that submits must be counted.  Don't be discouraged with the form letter responses.  If we keep on 'em they will know that we are watching their every move and legislate accordinly.  Votes matter to them, and if they know that we are a large voting force, they will comply.
I'm hoping at some point that they will get enough contacts from citizens to make them take notice of an issue, but all I can do is send my email or call them (and work for or against their next election). I heard an interview (on NRA news 12/27/13) with Valinda Rowe, who is on the board of directors of the Illinois Carry group wherein she said that after Missouri got "shall issue" legislation her group went and talked to them about how they achieved their goal. They said it took 10 years and was a total grassroots effort. The Illinois group adopted most of the Missouri strategies and it did take exactly 10 years, but as of this week Illinois has a shall issue concealed carry law. She admits that the law isn't the best (the legislators tried to make things as difficult as possible for would-be licensees despite the court order mandating licensing) but they are still working to change it for the better. Now Hawaii is one of the few remaining states with "may issue" concealed carry that is de facto "shall not issue". It's hard to imagine, given the political landscape here, how this will ever change other than by court order. But I still want to write these people and let them know that they are enacting and supporting irrational and illogical laws that have no evidentiary basis. Not that they care.

punaperson

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #5 on: January 08, 2014, 08:45:33 AM »
As I was writing my response to Heavies comment, I had received this email from Ms. Gabby Giffords of Americans for Responsible Solutions (sic) (I'm signed up for several anti-gun mailing lists to keep up with what they are doing) about her efforts to establish more gun control. I think her comments apply to those of us on the other side too:

"Every day, we must wake up resolved and determined. We pay attention to the details, looking for opportunities for progress, even when the pace is slow. And every day we recruit a few more allies, talk to a few more people, and convince a few more voters. Some days it comes easy, and we feel the wind at our backs. Other times, we tire of the burden.
 
This year, I resolve to draw strength from the Americans who have joined our fight, and cede no ground to those who would convince us the path is too steep, or we too weak."

She, and her ilk, make me want to spend more time and energy fighting for my/our rights.

macsak

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #6 on: January 08, 2014, 09:18:16 AM »
looking for opportunities for progress

this is the scariest part of that email
the fact that they use tragedy for their gain at every chance

and then they throw it in our faces repeatedly

this is what we are up against, people
it's gonna be a tough fight even to tread water
but it's a fight we must fight

paulb3

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #7 on: January 08, 2014, 12:13:41 PM »
I wrote a letter a few days ago to Shatz and Gabbard.  Gabbard is in support of an assault weapons ban and Shatz is no 2nd amendment hero either you prob all know this but figure I'd throw in my .02

Mahalo
pb

HiCarry

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #8 on: January 08, 2014, 02:09:25 PM »
I would also save this for the future, and submit it for testimony when new bills are brought up for discussion.  They must look over it, at those times, and every person that submits must be counted.  Don't be discouraged with the form letter responses.  If we keep on 'em they will know that we are watching their every move and legislate accordinly.  Votes matter to them, and if they know that we are a large voting force, they will comply.
You would think so, but unfortunately, most testimony that is submitted (rather than delivered in-person) is never actually read. If you doubt this, just go to any hearing where there is a lot of submitted testimony. They'll take the one off the top, read if it is "for" or "against" whatever is being heard, and move to #2......

That's not to discourage submitting testimony, because we really need folks to do that, but if you think your well researched and footnoted multi-paragraph masterpiece carries any more weight than a single line stating "I'm for" or "I'm against" you're an idealist.....and that comes from me, a guy who submits footnoted testimony.....

punaperson

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #9 on: January 09, 2014, 06:55:33 AM »
...but if you think your well researched and footnoted multi-paragraph masterpiece carries any more weight than a single line stating "I'm for" or "I'm against" you're an idealist.....and that comes from me, a guy who submits footnoted testimony.....
I was hoping that since there are no bills that even exist yet prior to the actual legislative session beginning, that maybe, just maybe someone in the office who was bored with nothing to do would read at least a paragraph or two and note the existence of a person (probably labeled "gun nut") opposing these unconstitutional Hawaii state laws that deprive citizens of their right to self-defense.

The idea that these legislators could read all their emails, much less research all the issues they have to vote on is absurd. It's one problem with "the system"... no one could possibly even know the intricacies and details of even a couple of issues, much less everything they have to vote on. So I guess it's good for them that they are basically, for the most part, voting based upon some general ideology ("government knows best how to handle the people's business") as they don't really have the time or staff to adequately research each issue before them. Or they turn to "the experts", in our case, that'd be law enforcement and the attorney generals office. I know Ms. Thielen consulted HRA who promptly told her that despite the opposition of the NRA-ILA, HRA supported SB69 wherein "unusable, unserviceable" firearms needed to be registered. Go figure.

punaperson

Re: My letter to every Hawaii state legislator
« Reply #10 on: January 10, 2014, 08:58:21 AM »
I got a response from Senator Mike Gabbard:

"Thanks for your suggestions on gun related legislation. I’ll be introducing a “concealed carry” bill this legislative session."

I'll be curious to see if/how his bill is different from Senator Slom's bill. I've asked both to inform me when the bill is available to view and submit testimony, as well as call/email the appropriate committee members.