Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings (Read 12490 times)

ren

Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« on: February 12, 2014, 08:54:18 PM »
Deeds Not Words

K30l4

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #1 on: February 12, 2014, 09:00:58 PM »
The church is a very large organization (corporation). They chose to pay off the other party to avoid a much larger legal battle.

Seems that new hope just may have made it harder for the smaller churches that also utilize public school cafes. If Kahle and his attorneys pursue the smaller churches, a large payoff may not be as easy as it was for NH.

K30l4

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #2 on: February 12, 2014, 09:04:12 PM »
Some of the other things that Kahle fails to recognize is the wonderful things that happen as the church members serve in the community. NH did a lot of public service at Farrington HS.

MMM

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #3 on: February 12, 2014, 09:33:32 PM »
SMH. mitch has it in for christians. maybe he should focus all his energy on muslims and see what happens.  :(

Heavies

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #4 on: February 13, 2014, 12:04:53 AM »
Sad that this guy has nothing better to do than to harass these churches.  Even if the churches pay only a little, that little is more than the zero that would be accrued if the school grounds sit empty on Sundays.   Freaking stupid. 

Jl808

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #5 on: February 13, 2014, 06:42:31 AM »
It's not just churches that use school facilities. There are many many many nonprofit organizations that use various school grounds that would have their backs broken if they had to pay the rent that Kahle demanded.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

jaynick

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #6 on: February 13, 2014, 09:18:03 AM »
kahle seems greedy and definitely has an atheist agenda, but i think he's mostly right. i just dont think he should keep 20% as a finders fee  :o
if anyone really read into it, they would see that the board of education CHAIR, don horner, is also a PASTOR at new hope. he magically helped the 5 year lease term disappear and helped negotiate lower hourly rates. the $63 an hour they were previously charging is the states break even point. wear n tear, air conditioning, security, and janitors all cost money. ive been to new hope and one love ministries with friends that go regularly(2 of the 3 organizations being sued) and they seem to be doing quite well financially, especially new hope.


"Bickerton(kahle's lawyer) also said Horner's involvement with New Hope Diamond Head raises a serious question of conflict of interest.

The executive pastor at New Hope Oahu wrote to Horner in October requesting that he lower rental fee rates and eliminate a long-standing provision that barred the churches from leasing facilities for more than five years, according to the memo which was forwarded to Civil Beat. (The provision aimed to prevent churches from using school facilities on a permanent basis.)

Less than three weeks later, DOE Superintendent Kathryn Matayoshi announced that she had deleted the five-year rule from application forms.

“I’m sure a lot of parents wish they had their complaints addressed this quickly by the Board of Education,” Bickerton said."

Heavies

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #7 on: February 13, 2014, 09:43:18 AM »
States break even point is what needs to be charged....  I don't see why the state needs to make a profit over the use of the public facilities.  Our taxes already pay for it and if the churches are breaking it even when they use it then what is the problem with that?

jaynick

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #8 on: February 13, 2014, 09:48:48 AM »
Sad that this guy has nothing better to do than to harass these churches.  Even if the churches pay only a little, that little is more than the zero that would be accrued if the school grounds sit empty on Sundays.   Freaking stupid.

the whole point is the state(read:us taxpayers) is losing money from these churches. they use air conditioning , electricity, water, and campus security while there and when theyre done the janitors gotta sweep,rewax the floors, change the trash liners etc. to prepare it for class on monday.
 even if they paid the original asking price for every single hour they are on campus using facilities the state would only BREAK EVEN, according to the lawsuit. the guy who started the lawsuit is claiming that they use it for more than 7.5 hours weekly because they go early to set up and stay late on sunday, plus occasionally have special events and youth group meetings etc on friday nights n saturdays which wasnt in the agreement.





Heavies

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #9 on: February 13, 2014, 09:55:19 AM »
the whole point is the state(read:us taxpayers) is losing money from these churches. they use air conditioning , electricity, water, and campus security while there and when theyre done the janitors gotta sweep,rewax the floors, change the trash liners etc. to prepare it for class on monday.
 even if they paid the original asking price for every single hour they are on campus using facilities the state would only BREAK EVEN, according to the lawsuit. the guy who started the lawsuit is claiming that they use it for more than 7.5 hours weekly because they go early to set up and stay late on sunday, plus occasionally have special events and youth group meetings etc on friday nights n saturdays which wasnt in the agreement.







All the church I ever went to at a public school never had ac, never had set up break down assistance from janitors, never had campus security except to maybe unlock/lock the door.  Generally we left the place better than we had found it.  This was a while back, I don't know how it is now.  Which schools have ac?

jaynick

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #10 on: February 13, 2014, 09:59:13 AM »
All the church I ever went to at a public school never had ac, never had set up break down assistance from janitors, never had campus security except to maybe unlock/lock the door.  Generally we left the place better than we had found it.  This was a while back, I don't know how it is now.  Which schools have ac?
haha yea i was like wow a/c?

farrington and kapolei are the ones named.

when i went to kalani only the principals office was air conditioned.  :grrr:  oh and the computer lab

MMM

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #11 on: February 13, 2014, 10:10:35 AM »
haha yea i was like wow a/c?

farrington and kapolei are the ones named.

when i went to kalani only the principals office was air conditioned.  :grrr:  oh and the computer lab

hey, new hope paid for all the upgrades to everything they used which leaves the schools in a better position to have for its' students and staff. air-con, sound,upgrades, etc. they ain't asking for it back or taking it with them. in fact, they clean up after themselves as well as maintain things better than it was left for them. jus' saying.......

Jl808

Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #12 on: February 13, 2014, 10:11:42 AM »
Jaynick:  there are tons of non-religious nonprofits that use school facilities, auditoriums, cafeterias, storage rooms, electricity, air conditioning, lights, etc FOR FREE or a nominal token dollar amount (whatever token dollar amount they want to give to the school) because of their nonprofit status. 

Sorry I don't mean to rant at you jaynick.  This is just me ranting about the anti-church agenda of Kahle. I believe he and his partner do a disservice to our community by their actions.  Besides that, if he was really looking out for other people's interests, he should give his $200k cut to DOE.

Why single out churches? I would think that New Hope probably pays more to DOE than many of these nonprofit organizations even before the settlement.

There are many nonprofit board members that sit in various school boards as volunteers because of the expertise, fundraising ability and experience they bring.
« Last Edit: February 13, 2014, 10:24:25 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

jaynick

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #13 on: February 13, 2014, 10:25:50 AM »
hey, new hope paid for all the upgrades to everything they used which leaves the schools in a better position to have for its' students and staff. air-con, sound,upgrades, etc. they ain't asking for it back or taking it with them. in fact, they clean up after themselves as well as maintain things better than it was left for them. jus' saying.......

i didnt write the below statement but i saw it in a comment below one of the news articles and agree with this.

"New Hope has enough money to build it's own churches but chooses to pay the schools as a form of 'supporting' the DOE. But if they are not paying the going rate, they are just making money. New Hope is hardly a poor institution and Kahle is giving most of the money to DOE. The rest will probably cover his costs. (dont agree with that part) New Hope can avoid this bad press by paying the proper amount and keeping better records for "gifts in kind" such as labor. Many of us help maintain schools without writing it off as payment but calling it was it is:an act of community charity."

p.s. buying air conditioners is cheap. running them is expensive.
p.p.s. they only pay $9 for utilities per month so of course they stocked up on big air conditioners!
« Last Edit: February 13, 2014, 10:43:15 AM by jaynick »

jaynick

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #14 on: February 13, 2014, 10:41:04 AM »
Jaynick:  there are tons of non-religious nonprofits that use school facilities, auditoriums, cafeterias, storage rooms, electricity, air conditioning, lights, etc FOR FREE or a nominal token dollar amount (whatever token dollar amount they want to give to the school) because of their nonprofit status.     from what ive been reading i dont think anyone uses it for free, there seems to be a fairly standard rental policy to refer to if you want to use their facilities.

Sorry I don't mean to rant at you jaynick.  This is just me ranting about the anti-church agenda of Kahle. I believe he and his partner do a disservice to our community by their actions.  Besides that, if he was really looking out for other people's interests, he should give his $200k cut to DOE.      no problem, i knew people would be angry with me for even suggesting he has a point. also i agree he should only take a couple grand for his time and gas money and give the rest to the school. that whole whistleblower finders fee is bs and will drive others to do similar things to turn a profit

Why single out churches? I would think that New Hope probably pays more to DOE than many of these nonprofit organizations even before the settlement.   well because he had a previous atheist agenda before he stumbled onto these findings of underpayment

There are many nonprofit board members that sit in various school boards as volunteers because of the expertise, fundraising ability and experience they bring.
again i agree, but its still a strong conflict of interest. he obviously used his power to sway things heavily in their favor and thats not right. if it was a muslim or scientologist sitting on the board im sure some of you members would have some choice words and a different attitude towards all of this.

MMM

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #15 on: February 13, 2014, 11:02:16 AM »
the state for one, is liable in this case. it is the one that entered into such an agreement with new hope. it is up to them enforce, change, uphold all its' policies and standards to the lessee. even to the point of having one of it's(new hope) members (don horner) at the helm of making those decisions/influence. yes, there could have been improprieties made but, isn't there supposed to be a check and balance in place?

hasn't it always been buyer beware? it should always be a win-win on both sides of any negotiation or contract with both parties agreeing to the terms. so this 3rd party clown finds a way to make a few $$ on everyones dime?   ???

GTEC

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #16 on: February 13, 2014, 11:17:55 AM »
what bothers me the most is many FOR PROFIT businesses wouldn't have 775k lying around to settle a lawsuit
but then again, ever see what kind of cars these pastors push around?
kinda hard to preach about not gathering treasures on earth - but store your wealth in heaven when you're rolling a bi-turbo s class...

Jl808

Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #17 on: February 13, 2014, 11:20:50 AM »
Thanks jaynick. 

Really though...  There are other nonprofits (that do a lot of good work on a tiny budget) that use DOE / school facilities but don't pay close to the kind of rent that New Hope does.  This sets a bad precedent for other lawsuit scums that affects those nonprofits and not just religious organizations.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

aieahound

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #18 on: February 13, 2014, 11:36:58 AM »
My experience with renting School facilities for non-profits is that there was a set fee schedule for all schools depending on what facility you rent, e.g. Parking lot, auditorium, cafeteria, gymnasium etc.
We used to rent a parking lot from a public shool for UH football parking and were charged a set hourly fee based on the fee schedule.
Only the use of the outdoor fields was free.
I could be wrong though.

I also think there must be a smoking gun somewhere for New Hope for them to settle for $775,000.
They could have fought it for less than that amount, claimed the State was liable, as stated previously in this thread, and if they prevailed, hit Kahle with a fees and costs judgement that would have shut him down for good.
If they won the court would most likely award them the hundreds of thousands the spent defending the lawsuit.

A lot of people don't know that if you're a plaintiff and you lose a lawsuit, it is very common that not only do you lose, but you must pay the defendant's fees and costs.

MMM

Re: Mitch Kahle's payday from tidings
« Reply #19 on: February 13, 2014, 11:39:42 AM »
what bothers me the most is many FOR PROFIT businesses wouldn't have 775k lying around to settle a lawsuit
but then again, ever see what kind of cars these pastors push around?
kinda hard to preach about not gathering treasures on earth - but store your wealth in heaven when you're rolling a bi-turbo s class...

lol! a lot of people think churches and its' staff should be groveling, begging fools that have no money. God never said you have to be stupid and poor. in fact, what benefit would that be? what is the right amount of pay? $25K? $50K?, $300K? unfortunately, we live in this world and it's run by $$. without it, there would be no growth for anything trying to move forward. what a man makes is of no consequence to anyone because posing that question(and hearing the answer) will obviously result in a backlash from envious fools if that amount does not seem reasonable in their eyes.