NEXT!

To turn it around, what if someone takes my brass and puts it in the bucket, and I want to get it back? From a legal standpoint, I don't know or feel that you are 100% correct on the "who owns the bucket theory." I don't really care *that* much about it. My general thing, is if I sweep it -- I keep it. I do ask others around me if they are using the brass. I think what some people want to know is where does the brass go, and to whom does it benefit? If it really goes to the club I really doubt anyone would get all huffy puffy about it if there was something posted. I think the range is due for a big overhaul in management policies. Things must be fair and equitable; that requires written procedures and available access to rules.
We are wandering into a very murky realm of hypothetical speculation with this "what if". A simple, "That is my brass, and I want it" probably would have been more than ample. However given the original post:
...my friend picking brass out of the bucket, a place that was absolutely "OFF LIMITS" to us according to him and you . Why it is his business to even TALK to me, I have no idea. You then backed him up and told us that we could not pick brass up out of the bucket, but it was okay to pick up brass off the ground after ensuring the shooters were not going to keep it. That the buckets were "off limits". I guess this only applies to laziness, as it was okay for you guys to keep them since someone had already picked them up and placed them in the Holy Ark of Brass Containment.
Sounds like he was grabbing other people's brass. My original point still stands: not your brass, not your bucket, not yours to take. However I wasn’t there and hindsight is 20/20, so it’s not my place to pass judgment. Also, since the bucket is not clearly marked, I could see myself or anyone else easily making the same mistake. Not trying to point any fingers or lay any blame on you Voodoo.
The real question is, why don't they just make a sign saying " Feel free to collect your spent brass or brass you have permission to collect. Unclaimed brass in bucket is property of xxxx association. Proceeds from brass go to support range operations." How hard is that? We have also heard of guys taking the brass so they can reload it at home and use it for personal gain. Anyone could see that if the last statement is true, that is a huge no-no.
I agree this could be easily clarified and rectified with clearly marked signs. Hopefully they will do that in the future. Maybe this is just a reflection of the times. We live in such a tightly wound and litigious society, that a person simply telling another person "that is not yours don't touch" is not enough.
This reminds me of a few years ago when I used to work retail. My store had just lost about $300+ due to a woman carelessly knocking her drink into a bin of merchandise, ruining all the products inside. After that, no food or drinks were allowed into the store. So a few days later another woman comes into the store with a drink and I politely tell her:
“I’m sorry miss, you can’t have your drink in the storeâ€
“Why not?†she snaps
“It is against our store policy to have food or drinks in the storeâ€
“why, where’s the sign?â€
“There is no sign. Which is why I am telling you…â€
“Well there should be a sign! How else am I supposed to know?†she is incredulous
“Yes there is no sign, which is why I am telling youâ€
She arches her arm backwards and flings her drink at me. Instinctively I dodge to the side and the drink narrowly misses me hitting the ground, splattering my pants and my shoes in iced coffee.
“No f****ing sign!†she screams and then storms off.
Security chases her down and bans her from the premises. I had the option to press charges against her, but hell, it was just coffee and not a concussion. Had she thrown hot coffee on me that might've been a different story.

My point is twofold: 1. don’t work retail because people act like wild animals. And 2. do you really need a sign, when there’s a guy right in front of you telling you the rules?