Federal CCW? (Read 9943 times)

clshade

Federal CCW?
« on: July 06, 2014, 03:41:24 PM »
I tried this idea out in a national forum a while back, around the time of the Newton school shooting, and got pretty much what I expected:

"Your state isn't shall issue so you just want a federal bypass. My state IS a shall issue so I don't want the fed's grubby fingers on my right to bear arms!"

Except the fed's grubby fingers are already all over your right to keep and bear arms. Try buying a machine gun or an SBR. What I'm thinking about is introducing legislation to specifically allow for and protect aspects of that right at a federal level instead of doing what we've been doing for a long time: running defense and interference. Despite a public fundatmentalist interpretation of "shall not be infringed" precedent clearly shows that the Supreme Court sees it otherwise so we are in a long, loosing battle if we rest on the idea that the 2nd amendment will defend itself.

Here's the idea. A federal CCW permit that supersedes but does NOT replace state CCW. Requires training and certifications that are NOT government provided - meaning that they'll likely be NRA and other third party courses - and background checks. But anyone who is a proven good guy who passes the cert training and tests gets the right to carry concealed pretty much everywhere with local prohibitions not withstanding. That would include airports, airplanes, schools, "gun free" theaters and and shopping malls, etc.

You see where that is going?

There is something in there for everyone. The libs get training requirements and background checks and the certain knowledge that federal ccw permitees are "good guys" and can point to the "well regulated" part of the second amendment. Before too long I'd guess that school districts would start publishing the number of staff members that have FCCW's and school shootings would stop happening as frequently.  And we get to prove the theory that trained good guys with guns actually make people safer. Not necessarily by having shoot outs with criminals but by making violent crime less likely in the first place. No one except a burglar is afraid of the guns tucked away in the gun safe.

And on a national scale where crime data can be compared across many different political, economic and social zones. That would give us REAL data for making the case that most local level gun control laws are silly. And a few moderates and moderate lefties might go along with the idea because they think the data will prove the opposite.

To me this seems like a near perfect way to address the idea that carried guns = safety that follows the 2nd amendment wording. I'm just concerned that if the pro-gun elements don't start legislating protections into Federal law then the antis will continue to legislate more and more restrictions. Depending on how the midterms go this year, 2015 might be the ideal time to try it.

Thoughts? I'm ~sure~ I'm not seeing this from all angles.

clshade

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #1 on: July 06, 2014, 08:23:13 PM »
Oh - I should add that I'm aware bills do get introduced to this affect. What I don't understand is why gun owners and the NRA don't throw their weight behind it.

mauidog

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #2 on: July 07, 2014, 08:44:37 AM »
Oh - I should add that I'm aware bills do get introduced to this affect. What I don't understand is why gun owners and the NRA don't throw their weight behind it.

Explain how a federal training course & test would cover the myriad of Federal, state and local laws.  Since states have the power to create laws, it would be nearly impossible to properly train and license anyone to carry legally in all 50 states and our territories.

Think about it.  Training is not just when, where and how to shoot.  It's also about the laws governing places that might be restricted (School zones, bars or restaurants with alcohol, hospitals, etc.).  You learn about printing, brandishing, storing in the car when driving and when leaving a gun in the car, and so on.

Different states allow or deny the license holder to carry in these places or drive with a  loaded gun either visibly or in a closed compartment.

Until all laws across the nation conform to the same standards for training requirements and other restrictions, requiring specific training for a federal CCW/CHL/CPL is not feasible.

The best solution is to require all states to reciprocate with all other states, just like NC.  They honor a CCW from any other state, whether you live in the issuing state or not.  Then it'll be up to the issuing state to set the standards for training and testing.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

clshade

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #3 on: July 07, 2014, 10:39:20 AM »
How are differences in local law handled for retired law officers who are allowed CCW per the Law Enforcement Officers Safety Act?

That's the point of a federal law: if it is done properly the varying state laws do not apply. Who cares if they are uniform if they are irrelevant? Federal law applies and that's it. Easier to handle with transportation and carrying rules than it is with handling what happens if the firearm is actually used, but the same applies to retired law officers. I don't think its insurmountable.

mauidog

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #4 on: July 07, 2014, 12:00:39 PM »
How are differences in local law handled for retired law officers who are allowed CCW per the Law Enforcement Officers Safety Act?

That's the point of a federal law: if it is done properly the varying state laws do not apply. Who cares if they are uniform if they are irrelevant? Federal law applies and that's it. Easier to handle with transportation and carrying rules than it is with handling what happens if the firearm is actually used, but the same applies to retired law officers. I don't think its insurmountable.

I agree there is a need for reciprocity and uniformity, but NOT on the side of being MORE restrictive.  Background checks are one thing, but if I'm being stalked by a maniac, and I have to wait a week or more for a "cooling off" period, and then schedule and pass a certification test, and then apply & maybe wait  for a CCW license, I'm not going to feel very safe.  There is no "right to bare bear arms IF 1.  and  2.   and  3.  and  ....".  The right exists whether you pass a test or not.  To try and placate the anti's with things to make them feel better is futile.  They will only stop adding to those demands when all guns are banned.  Only then will they "feel safe."

I'm more concerned about ME feeling safe.  No one has a right to place restrictions on others just because something that might happen makes you uncomfortable.  Spend that money on psychotherapy, not passing and administering restrictive gun laws.
« Last Edit: July 07, 2014, 12:15:26 PM by mauidog »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

BUD

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #5 on: July 07, 2014, 12:12:43 PM »
I agree there is a need for reciprocity and uniformity, but NOT on the side of being MORE restrictive.  Background checks are one thing, but if I'm being stalked by a maniac, and I have to wait a week or more for a "cooling off" period, and then schedule and pass a certification test, and then apply & maybe wait  for a CCW license, I'm not going to feel very safe.  There is no "right to bare arms IF 1.  and  2.   and  3.  and  ....".  The right exists whether you pass a test or not.  To try and placate the anti's with things to make them feel better is futile.  They will only stop adding to those demands when all guns are banned.  Only then will they "feel safe."

I'm more concerned about ME feeling safe.  No one has a right to place restrictions on others just because something that might happen makes you uncomfortable.  Spend that money on psychotherapy, not passing and administering restrictive gun laws.

I would never "bare" an arm.  But I certainly would bear one..... :shaka:
It is what it is.

mauidog

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #6 on: July 07, 2014, 12:14:49 PM »
I would never "bare" an arm.  But I certainly would bear one..... :shaka:

Thanks for that intelligent contribution to the topic. Bud.

Next time I need a Grammar or Spelling Nazi, I know who to ask...

 :sleeping:

An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

clshade

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #7 on: July 07, 2014, 12:23:16 PM »
Why does federal CCW restrict freedom any more than state level CCW?

Its not like open carry is illegal in states with CCW. Its not Federal CCW or nothing.

But I have the answer to my larger question. Pretty much no point in trying to find a mutually productive middle ground with fundamentalists. The same is true with most of the anti's that I know.

edit: Oh, I don't mean fundamentalist in a bad way. I agree with a fundamental interpretation of the 2nd amendment. I'm just realistic in noting that the Fed and the Supreme court have NEVER seen it that way.

mauidog

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #8 on: July 07, 2014, 12:40:07 PM »
Why does federal CCW restrict freedom any more than state level CCW?

Its not like open carry is illegal in states with CCW. Its not Federal CCW or nothing.

But I have the answer to my larger question. Pretty much no point in trying to find a mutually productive middle ground with fundamentalists. The same is true with most of the anti's that I know.

edit: Oh, I don't mean fundamentalist in a bad way. I agree with a fundamental interpretation of the 2nd amendment. I'm just realistic in noting that the Fed and the Supreme court have NEVER seen it that way.

Do a search on Constitutional Carry.  Many states have it.  In fact, many of these states only issue CCW licenses for the convenience of travelers who go to reciprocating states.

Middle ground?  That's a myth when it comes to gun control.

Ask yourself what Middle Ground means?  Compromise!  What does compromise mean?  To give up something in order to get something else. 

Tell me what the anti's are giving up?  As I see it, they  have nothing to lose and everything  to gain.  The 2A supporters are the only ones who lose when they compromise.

This is a tactic of the left.  They say "Let's compromise."  But in actuality , they are only giving up on a fraction of what they are asking for, not something they already have.

For instance, a thief is in your house when you come home.  You confront him and he says he will leave peacefully if he can take 50% of what he was about to leave with.

Did the thief compromise?  No, the only person that lost anything they already possessed was you.  He merely gave up the chance for more by agreeing to take less.  All you did was appease the thief and give up a little less than you would have by not negotiating.

That's not middle ground.  That's manipulation and stupidity.  Never compromise your values or rights in order to prevent losing more of  them.  It only takes a finite number of those times for you to realize you have none of them left.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

BUD

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #9 on: July 07, 2014, 02:03:48 PM »
Thanks for that intelligent contribution to the topic. Bud.

Next time I need a Grammar or Spelling Nazi, I know who to ask...

 :sleeping:



Will do Doug.   :thumbsup:
It is what it is.

Tom_G

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #10 on: July 07, 2014, 02:40:14 PM »
Do a search on Constitutional Carry.  Many states have it. 


According to Wikipedia, there are only 4: Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Vermont.
There are two more "limited" constitutional carry states: Wyoming & Oklahoma.  Although, since there are limitations in place, I'd contest the use of the term.
And four more states that allow some form of carry without licensing, albeit with restrictions: Idaho, Montana, New Hampshire, New Mexico. 

Gunlaws.com only acknowledges 6 states: Vermont, Montana, Alaska, Texas (partial), Arizona, Wyoming. 

OpenCarry.org also recognizes 6 states: Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Wyoming, New Hampshire, Vermont.

So, depending on how you define "Constitutional carry," there are between 4 and 10 states.  That's between 8% and 20% of the total country.  "Many" is not a word I'd choose.
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

mauidog

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #11 on: July 07, 2014, 08:31:23 PM »
According to Wikipedia, there are only 4: Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Vermont.
There are two more "limited" constitutional carry states: Wyoming & Oklahoma.  Although, since there are limitations in place, I'd contest the use of the term.
And four more states that allow some form of carry without licensing, albeit with restrictions: Idaho, Montana, New Hampshire, New Mexico. 

Gunlaws.com only acknowledges 6 states: Vermont, Montana, Alaska, Texas (partial), Arizona, Wyoming. 

OpenCarry.org also recognizes 6 states: Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Wyoming, New Hampshire, Vermont.

So, depending on how you define "Constitutional carry," there are between 4 and 10 states.  That's between 8% and 20% of the total country.  "Many" is not a word I'd choose.

Okay, then a FEW do.  Does that make the rest of my comment incorrect? 

I was merely pointing out that the concept and implementation already exist for carrying arms without the restrictions being discussed by CLSHADE.

My point is, the more conditions we allow the government to place on the right to carry, the more the anti-gun crowd will cry for.   

I have no problem with requiring a background check and NRA handgun safety course, the same restrictions we already require here for purchase of a handgun. 

Anything more intensive should be incentivized, but not mandated.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Tom_G

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #12 on: July 07, 2014, 09:18:31 PM »
Ask yourself what Middle Ground means?  Compromise!  What does compromise mean?  To give up something in order to get something else. 

Tell me what the anti's are giving up?  As I see it, they  have nothing to lose and everything  to gain.  The 2A supporters are the only ones who lose when they compromise.


You have several issues in your original post, so I'm trying to respond to them individually in the interests of clarity and brevity.

In this case, your bias is coloring your perspective (as it does with us all).  What the antis "have" is an appalling country that they share with 300 million guns.  What they want is a country with 0 guns.  From their perspective, accepting an intermediate number certainly is a compromise.  What they are giving up is the sense of security they would have from an unarmed society.  They want to feel safe, to enjoy their Constitutionally-protected inalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, and your position threatens that.
« Last Edit: July 08, 2014, 12:31:16 PM by Tom_G »
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

Tom_G

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #13 on: July 07, 2014, 09:25:47 PM »

My point is, the more conditions we allow the government to place on the right to carry, the more the anti-gun crowd will cry for.   


Ignoring the specifics of the proposal clshade floated, the concept of a federally-issued CCW does not inherently mean more conditions.  Admittedly, the government is acquisitive, but there have been a few examples in recent years of the feds doing things that made like easier for gun owners.  The law enforcement CCW and carry in national parks come to mind. 
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

punaperson

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #14 on: July 07, 2014, 10:32:09 PM »
They want to feel safe, to enjoy their Constitutionally-protected rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, and your position threatens that.
For the sake of clarity and accuracy, there are no "Constitutionally-protected rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness". Those terms are from the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution, so they couldn't be "Constitutionally-protected" (except as some arguable indirect legal extrapolation from the actual rights enumerated in the Bill of Rights or other Amendments to the Constitution).

Tom_G

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #15 on: July 08, 2014, 06:29:48 AM »
For the sake of clarity and accuracy, there are no "Constitutionally-protected rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness". Those terms are from the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution, so they couldn't be "Constitutionally-protected" (except as some arguable indirect legal extrapolation from the actual rights enumerated in the Bill of Rights or other Amendments to the Constitution).

I was wondering if anyone would call me on that!
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

punaperson

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #16 on: July 08, 2014, 07:18:49 AM »
I was wondering if anyone would call me on that!
If I had a "Constitutionally-protected right to liberty" I doubt the government could "legally" force me, under penalty of financial fine, imprisonment, and ultimately confiscation of my property, to install double-pane windows (supposedly for "energy efficiency" required to lessen environmental impacts (aka "anthropogenic global warming", now known as "climate change" etc.)) in a home that has NO heating or cooling systems. I won't list the other 83,749 preposterous and capricious and arbitrary laws that violate my "liberty" despite no known public benefit (due to my personal "bias" I here exclude the additional profit reaped by the corporation selling the more expensive double-pane windows as a "public benefit"). Hell, even if the Constitution itself had some statement about a natural, fundamental, individual, civil "right" that, for example, "shall not be infringed", I bet the f***ing government/legislators/bureaucrats would infringe the hell out of it anyway. Just sayin'. 

:stopjack:

I believe that the words "to keep and bear arms" as written in the Constitution already constitute a federal CCW policy: the right to bear arms. They also constitute a federal open carry (OC) policy: the right to bear arms. Then there's what the legislators/bureaucrats (including judges) tell us those words actually mean (in Hawaii): "You have NO right to bear arms outside your home or place of work unless you go directly (and only) to a gun store, place of repair, shooting range, hunting area, or to tell law enforcement all about yourself and your firearms.  :wtf:

Tom_G

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #17 on: July 08, 2014, 12:39:43 PM »
Anything more intensive should be incentivized, but not mandated.

Now THIS, THIS is excellent.  And here is a place where the government, be it federal or state, could intervene: legislation that authorizes gun dealers to collect an X% surcharge on any sales to people who don't have proof of current training.  Just like it's legal for car repair places to charge different rates for insurance vs non-insurance claims, or to offer a discount to customers not using credit cards. 
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

BigBlue

Re: Federal CCW?
« Reply #18 on: July 16, 2014, 12:29:47 AM »
Federal CCW is a bad idea because it endorses the notion that CCW permits should be required at all.