Right on the correction; Cheytac doesn't make a .50 BMG rifle, I was thinking of the EDM Windrunner which uses .50 BMG and .408.
While I agree ammo quality makes a big difference in accuracy, any rifle will suffer if its shooting ammo from the 1940's versus current production match or handloads. The person with the Barrett, who just bought a $10,000 rifle, a $4,000 scope, probably won't be shooting old corrosive .50 bmg's through it.
I'm skeptical about a long range range being opened in Hawaii especially since Hawaii has been trying to ban the .50 cal a few times now (thankfully defeated). Not everyone is fortunate to shoot on a Marine Core range, not everyone has vast amounts of private land, and not everyone has a second home on the mainland to keep all the fun toys not allowed in Hawaii. A few years ago I got to hunt on private Hawaiian homes land owned by my uncle's close friend, there was enough space and range to use a .50 but its a nearly 2hr drive on non-paved mountain roads.
In terms of practicality; most rifles in Hawaii are chambered in .223, .308, 30-06, 30-30 or various hunting calibers. 200 yards, which I think is the max range for the range here on Maui, isn't out of bounds in terms of practical ranges, it's within reasonable hunting ranges. I don't know any regular hunters who go out with a off the shelf bolt-action and hunt at 800 yards or more. Fellow here on Maui has a genuine HK PSG-1 and he shoots amazing groups at .100 rounds because the caliber is already stabilizing at that range, versus the .50 where 100 yards isn't going to be enough to stabilize it for the accuracy the rifle is capable of. His $14,000 PSG-1 is as capable at 100 yards as it is 800 yards, versus any .50 where the further it goes the better the potential.
I don't mind a good debate and I appreciate the info, pros and cons and so forth.
