Poll

What best describes your familiarity with First Person Shooters?

I play them competitively in a hardcore manner
6.3%
I play them a lot, but not competitively
25%
I play them once in a while
43.8%
I know almost nothing about them, but I do play other kinds of video games
6.3%
I've never really played video games much at all
18.8%
Total Members Voted
16

Who here plays FPS games, and do they help for real life firearms combat? (Read 13471 times)

PeaShooter

I play video games, or at least I used to, but I've never been interested in FPS games. I played DOOM a little bit when it came out, but that's about it. I have no idea what that FPS game I see everyone playing now is...Call of Duty or something like that? Just curious how firearm enthusiasts view these kinds of games.

And do people think that these games help significantly for real life combat tactics? I wonder if I am missing anything useful by ignoring these kinds of video games?

I am only talking about FPS games for the poll, not all video games with guns in them. Games where you hold a plastic gun in real life and aim it at the TV aren't in this genre. Games like Resident Evil where you just kind of tell some girl or guy to run around and shoot, in a third person view, don't count either.

ren

There's so much missing from a FPS game like COD or Halo.  With current technology there's no way to replicate muscle memory, exercising peripheral vision etc.  Sure there are some somewhat talented people out there with a joystick or controller and they can kick your ass in a 2D world but get them out off the couch and give them a real steel weapon and they would do worse than the chimp w/ an AK video.
We were just talking about this at the range this past weekend with the new gen of shooters coming out. They tend to gravitate to the "tactical" run and gun stuff w/o ever learning the basics.  I see it on the line, elbows straight out (Magpul style) and just slapping the trigger.  Most of these shooters lose the fundamentals.  Trying to focus on the target instead of the front sight. Trigger finger outside the well, not flagging someone next you, shooting with your head canted down to the weapon. 
In all fairness to the game developers they do have consultant who are the real deal operators but again, there is so much factors missing from games.  The ultimate feeling a game can not replicate is the reality of getting killed when a slight mistake is made.
Deeds Not Words

stegosaurus

I was hardcore into Call of Duty (Modern Warfare and Black Ops) but I stopped playing since we downgraded our internet service from Roadrunner to DSL (can you say lagfest?) I might just have to bring the 'Box to the office though because Battlefield 3 looks CRAZY. Do I think they help with real life tactics? Probably not. When I'm playing, I'm not really paying attention to that stuff. Mostly busy having fun and cursing out 10 year old kids, haha.
"When you outlaw guns, only the outlaws have guns."

Dregs

You wanna know what I believe has actually helped me as a shooter? All those years spent at Fun Factory (Since single digit age to late teens, and some early 20's @ Dave & Buster's) only playing games like Point Blank, Time Crisis, House of the Dead, Deer Hunter, etc. You NEVER aim down the sight of a plastic gun. It's all instinct shooting. You mentally point at where you want the shot, and your arms bring up the gun and makes it happen.
My friends would play fighting games, or racing games, or "ticket" games. I would always be playing the shooters.
I can't say FPS games help much in rl. One of the most frustrating limitations of FPS games is the fact that you have no neck or core joints. There's no quick check to the sides. You swing your entire body towards what you're looking at. Gun and all. There's no walking in one direction while your upper torso is aiming at another direction. Sure you can press forwards and a side movement at the same time, and aim, but that's not the same thing. Also, grenades only get tossed forwards.
As for tactics, I've played FPS games since childhood til even now occasionally, and the several days I spent MOUT training in rl blew me away. For example....if you and your entry team are silently walking along the building you're about to kick in, you stay a foot or so away from the building so you don't scrape the walls with your equipment and give yourself away.

Cougar8045

I'm no SEAL, but I know that when I decide to look through my scope/down my sights, the gun doesn't automatically "snap" to the nearest enemy.  Also, I've never been shot, but I assume that if I ever take three or four rounds of 7.62 to the chest, I'm going to need to do something other than drop back behind cover and wait about 20 seconds to just get over it.  FPS games are a lot of fun, but you're not going to learn anything about tactics from them.  If you wanted to make it real, you could always do this:  if you get hit while playing CoD, go stick your finger in a light socket and don't play again for a month while you recover.  If you get killed, do the light socket thing again, but this time take your X-Box outside  and burn it. 

I think the only game that might teach you a thing or two about tactics would be that America's Army game that came out a while back.  IIRC, it was developed by the Army to help drive home small-unit tactics; how to position yourself and your squad to keep from getting killed.  That game got a little old, though, because it was too realistic.  You had three guys, and if one got shot shot (which happened often, if you're not a Marine Corps Staff Sergeant...) you'd have to carry him to an aid station; which meant the guy doing the carrying was sloooooow, and couldn't shoot.  And naturally the aid station was about ten country miles away! 
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

PeaShooter

Nice, informative responses so far. Thanks guys.

I've played shooting games somewhat, like Point Blank and Time Crisis, although I mostly played fighting games and other kinds of games. I do think that fighting games helped me a lot for real life sword fighting. With no real life experience I could beat most guys, even people who had been practicing martial arts or fencing for years. It depends on the person what you can take away from the game. Of course the games are nothing like real life, but sometimes you can learn abstract skills from a game. So I was worried that my total unfamiliarity with FPS games was causing me to miss something. If not, great.

I was always horrible at shooting games, especially Point Blank, the game we played the most because it requires the most shooting skill. My friends always used to play them with me to make fun of me and get revenge for the fighting games. The only shooting game in which I was better than a normal person was Police 911, and that was only because I was fast at moving my body to dodge the fake, slow bullets.

Dregs

No one liked playing Point Blank with me because I'd always win. lol. I did mostly alright-not good in Time Crisis, since the dodge mechanism is so important...and I'm a uncoordinated beast. Same with Police 911. Very fun game btw. lol.

ren

I used to fix all those games while in college.  Point Blank, Time Crisis 1,2 etc. Those guns were a headache.
Deeds Not Words

Colt808

I believe in hands-on parenting. So when my kids started playing, I did too. Everything from MW, MW2, Battlefield 2, and now Black Ops.

Does it help in "real life" combat? Not specifically. (People who believe that it does are usually under the age of 10 or flat out delusional.  :wacko:) In general, those with the sh*t wired right, know that it's a game and play for fun. That said, players can learn how to work as a team.




Reason obeys itself; and ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it. ~Thomas Paine


And I still see stupid people.

nf9648

I play Bad Company 2 a lot and Medal or Honor, thats about it.  Zero training factor, but tons of fun on a good server.  When Im broke from buying gun stuff I can burn off the rest of the week playing a game and drinking cheap beer.

Tom_G

There's one lesson that I think applies to the FPS skillset as it overlaps into real life combat.  If it works in a video game, DON'T TRY IT IN REAL LIFE!  ;)

Now, if anyone wants to meet online for some free FPS action, we should talk.  I'm pretty easy prey, but I still like to play!
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

Dregs

Oooh which free FPS do you have in mind? =Op

Tom_G

Oooh which free FPS do you have in mind? =Op

There are many to choose from!  I like to "research" that topic periodically, finding free multiplayer games that are cross-platform.  I use them to "test" performance and connectivity in my lab at work.  But, for this crowd, perhaps Wolfenstein Enemy Territory would be most appropriate.  WWII carnage, but the boards tend to be pretty large.  For something more up-close and personal, I am a fan of Open Arena. 

Again, though, there are several choices out there.  I'm all Mac (except for one small Linux box), so they do need to be cross-platform, but that's really my sole criteria.  We can also look at turn-based strategy, such as Battle for Wesnoth, or vehicle sims, like BZFlag.
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

Dregs

Dude.......Wolfenstein ET is my all time favorite FPS. There hasn't been a game that good since.

GZire

Used to be addicted to Call of Duty.  Haven't turned on my machine in a year.

Funtimes

From a science standpoint, video games have been proven to improve hand-eye coordination, as well as multi-tasking abilities. In many games now, people are listening for footsteps, reloads, certain sounds or functions which can all be practically applied to the real word.  However, this doesn't mean because you got your 25 kill streak and dropped a nuke in MW2 that you are going to be running around like a Navy SEAL.  Training your eyes to scan and detect very slight movements out of the ordinary is another thing very useful stemming from a video game (gets even better when your TV is this huge 60" thing in your face lol).

There are many games that are or where at the time quite realistic in their tactics (Rainbox Six). Additionally,  the military uses video games to test and run scenarios, as well as improve soldiers and agents reaction times.  Video games can promote team work and communication, which, outside of a virtual world -- are actually skills hard to develop.  Video games are a great skill builder for real combat.  However, I don't think anything beats on the range training.


TLDR:  There are many benefits to video games; Prestiging in MW2 doesn't mean your ass won't die on a battlefield.
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

vooduchikn

Used to be addicted to Call of Duty.  Haven't turned on my machine in a year.
:worship:

Stronger man than me!  :geekdanc:
Relax, I've banned myself..

PeaShooter

...And we have our first response in the other direction (that video games can have some indirect benefits on real life performance). Now I'm worried again, because I know absolutely nothing about FPS games. Really general skills though I've probably acquired, since I'm quite good at video games overall, just never found the FPS games attractive. Part of the reason is that I was never interested in guns. (I wouldn't be surprised if I'm the only one on this forum who was like that). Even on the day I did my handgun safety class, I pretty much only recognized two kinds of guns...a "black gun" or a "silver gun". :D Naturally, I've moved beyond that stage since then.

Someone should make an analogue of this thread asking the same thing about paintball, airsoft, or lasertag activities. I can't be the one though, since I've got less than zero experience with those, so I wouldn't know how to structure the poll or raise the question.

Dregs

With FPS games, you will develop ADD. Playing small map games as is prevalent in COD, you will defo get ADD. Not as fast for open land warfare games like Battlefield. It may not be scientifically provable yet, but I know that's right.

nktrnl


Someone should make an analogue of this thread asking the same thing about paintball, airsoft, or lasertag activities. I can't be the one though, since I've got less than zero experience with those, so I wouldn't know how to structure the poll or raise the question.

I've been playing FPS games for quite a while. I also used to play airsoft allot. I can shoot a hell of allot better with my airsoft guns then I can with my real guns. I was really disappointed the first time I went to the range with my new handgun. I hope I'm never in a situation where I think my airsoft skills will save my life. There are some good things about things like airsoft/paintball ,you learn to stalk and hide better, work with a team.  Learn how much noise you actually make walking around in the woods or in the buildings at night. Or even how quickly you run out of breath and how hard it is to calm your self down while trying to remain silent.
But again it's a game. Who knows how much would get applied to a real world situation. I hope I won't find out. I have been thinking about picking up another airsoft hand gun, just to do some small drills at home. But I won't get back into it like in was before. It's almost just as expensive. My sig551 ran me a little over $800 (but I could get away with shooting people  :D )