Poll

Are you waiting for the resolution of Peruta v. San Diego and subsequently the Baker decision before you decide to apply for CCW?

Yes
75%
No
8.3%
Why even bother at this point.
16.7%
Total Members Voted
24

CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand? (Read 10185 times)

Drakiir84

CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« on: December 22, 2014, 10:57:05 AM »
Pretty self explanatory.  It's disheartening that it's practically impossible to get a CCW in Hawaii despite being able to prove that there's a basis for it.  Personally, both my neighborhood and work area has seen an uptake in crime and violence since the homeless population was displaced first from Ala Moana beachpark and then from Waikiki. 

It has gotten so bad that they're now going into my garage to steal things and even approach me at night when I'm walking my dog, a situation where I had to pull out my knife on the guy.  In Kailua where I work there have been 2 stabbings on my street but I'm afraid that even with the clear possibility of danger that I will most likely not be able to acquire CCW.

So basically I'm wondering if I should even bother trying to get one or if I should be as much of a pain in the ass as I possibly can and if I get denied, wait until I'm attacked in public before suing the state for what should be our right.  Just want to know where everyone here stands.
"The rifle is a weapon. Let there be no mistake about that. It is a tool of power, and thus dependent completely upon the moral stature of its user. It is equally useful in securing meat for the table, destroying group enemies on the battlefield, and resisting tyranny. In fact, it is the only means of resisting tyranny, since a citizenry armed with rifles simply cannot be tyrannized."
-Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #1 on: December 22, 2014, 11:11:36 AM »
First, on what legal basis would you sue the state should you be attacked and injured?

I think it will be beneficial to apply, but for political purposes, even though you will almost certainly be denied. One of the reasons given by HPD in the past when questioned about not issuing permits was that there wasn't a need because almost no one applied. We know that the AG's report does not accurately reflect the actual numbers of applications made or denied. HRA is going to push a CCW bill this year. I have, through working with the Hawaii chapter of the ACLU, obtained all the documents needed to apply for a CCW and will post them on the HRA and LIFE websites as well as their respective Facebook pages. We are going to encourage everybody to apply even if we know they will all get denied. But, the issue is that we are going to ask those who get denied to send those denials to HRA so we can keep an independent accounting of the numbers. I will be posting the documents later today or this evening depending on when I get the chance. So, look for more information soon. 

eyeeatingfish

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #2 on: December 22, 2014, 12:52:38 PM »
Hicarry, let me see if I can beat you to it when I get home.

Heavies

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #3 on: December 22, 2014, 12:55:06 PM »
First, on what legal basis would you sue the state should you be attacked and injured?

I think it will be beneficial to apply, but for political purposes, even though you will almost certainly be denied. One of the reasons given by HPD in the past when questioned about not issuing permits was that there wasn't a need because almost no one applied. We know that the AG's report does not accurately reflect the actual numbers of applications made or denied. HRA is going to push a CCW bill this year. I have, through working with the Hawaii chapter of the ACLU, obtained all the documents needed to apply for a CCW and will post them on the HRA and LIFE websites as well as their respective Facebook pages. We are going to encourage everybody to apply even if we know they will all get denied. But, the issue is that we are going to ask those who get denied to send those denials to HRA so we can keep an independent accounting of the numbers. I will be posting the documents later today or this evening depending on when I get the chance. So, look for more information soon. 

Thank you HiCarry.  Would be cool if everyone did a organized "Permit Day" and went all at the same time to apply.  That would be fun.  When Funtimes had that application drive, I wonder how many people really applied/denied?  Had to be more than what was posted in a previous thread.  Is there no repercussions that the numbers they state are inaccurate? 

mauidog

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #4 on: December 22, 2014, 01:15:31 PM »
First, on what legal basis would you sue the state should you be attacked and injured?

I think it will be beneficial to apply, but for political purposes, even though you will almost certainly be denied. One of the reasons given by HPD in the past when questioned about not issuing permits was that there wasn't a need because almost no one applied. We know that the AG's report does not accurately reflect the actual numbers of applications made or denied. HRA is going to push a CCW bill this year. I have, through working with the Hawaii chapter of the ACLU, obtained all the documents needed to apply for a CCW and will post them on the HRA and LIFE websites as well as their respective Facebook pages. We are going to encourage everybody to apply even if we know they will all get denied. But, the issue is that we are going to ask those who get denied to send those denials to HRA so we can keep an independent accounting of the numbers. I will be posting the documents later today or this evening depending on when I get the chance. So, look for more information soon.

If the courts have the opinion that the police have no duty to protect the individuals who pay their salary and are therefore immune from prosecution for failure to protect, I can't see how the police department refusing to allow concealed carry in public would be any more liable. 

Unless you have special circumstances which rise to the level of evidence the Chief of Police requires for a CCW permit, it could be argued there was no evidence to support the accusation that the police could have reasonably predicted their actions would lead to your injuries or death.

I'm not a lawyer, but makes sense to me!   >:D

An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Drakiir84

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #5 on: December 22, 2014, 01:16:30 PM »
First, on what legal basis would you sue the state should you be attacked and injured?

I would sue them on the basis that had I been allowed to carry a weapon I would not have been injured.  Let me be clear that I wouldn't be suing for monetary compensation, just for the right to be armed.  Regardless of whether or not it would be winnable the word just needs to get out there. 

I agree with Heavies, we should have a permit application day and I'm totally down to apply for CCW even though I'll get denied... gonna look up all the paperwork asap.
"The rifle is a weapon. Let there be no mistake about that. It is a tool of power, and thus dependent completely upon the moral stature of its user. It is equally useful in securing meat for the table, destroying group enemies on the battlefield, and resisting tyranny. In fact, it is the only means of resisting tyranny, since a citizenry armed with rifles simply cannot be tyrannized."
-Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #6 on: December 22, 2014, 02:30:50 PM »
Thank you HiCarry.  Would be cool if everyone did a organized "Permit Day" and went all at the same time to apply.  That would be fun.  When Funtimes had that application drive, I wonder how many people really applied/denied?  Had to be more than what was posted in a previous thread.  Is there no repercussions that the numbers they state are inaccurate? 
After speaking to Chris (rather recently) about the numbers that applied and were denied, it was very clear that the "official" numbers did not match that of Chris' recollection. Unfortunately, there was no formal record keeping of those denials, so using those to expose whatever misdeeds may be occurring was impossible. Any repercussions would have to be based on an investigation of the facts surrounding the allegations. Without a proper accounting of all those that applied and were denied, there can be no real investigation. 

HiCarry

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #7 on: December 22, 2014, 03:15:08 PM »
I would sue them on the basis that had I been allowed to carry a weapon I would not have been injured.  Let me be clear that I wouldn't be suing for monetary compensation, just for the right to be armed.  Regardless of whether or not it would be winnable the word just needs to get out there. 

I agree with Heavies, we should have a permit application day and I'm totally down to apply for CCW even though I'll get denied... gonna look up all the paperwork asap.

You cannot sue a government official who has discretionary powers to issue permits and such. They have immunity. If they didn't, then others that were harmed by, say a concealed carry permittee, would be able to sue the official as well. The system has to work both ways, hence the liability protections. It matters not that you would not be suing for monetary damages. Without standing your "case" would not make it past the most preliminary processes let alone have a chance to be argued based on any perceived merits.

Here's a little primer on absolute and qualified immunity: http://federalpracticemanual.org/node/48

As for the permit application day, I think it would be a great idea, but it would be best to see how many permits we got in before the end of the year so it would have to be included in the yearly AG's report for 2014....

Drakiir84

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #8 on: December 22, 2014, 04:03:28 PM »
You cannot sue a government official who has discretionary powers to issue permits and such. They have immunity. If they didn't, then others that were harmed by, say a concealed carry permittee, would be able to sue the official as well. The system has to work both ways, hence the liability protections. It matters not that you would not be suing for monetary damages. Without standing your "case" would not make it past the most preliminary processes let alone have a chance to be argued based on any perceived merits.

Here's a little primer on absolute and qualified immunity: http://federalpracticemanual.org/node/48

As for the permit application day, I think it would be a great idea, but it would be best to see how many permits we got in before the end of the year so it would have to be included in the yearly AG's report for 2014....

Yeah I understand your point.  Just pissy with our states "may issue" bullshit and have to vent lol.......
"The rifle is a weapon. Let there be no mistake about that. It is a tool of power, and thus dependent completely upon the moral stature of its user. It is equally useful in securing meat for the table, destroying group enemies on the battlefield, and resisting tyranny. In fact, it is the only means of resisting tyranny, since a citizenry armed with rifles simply cannot be tyrannized."
-Jeff Cooper

Falken Hawke

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #9 on: December 22, 2014, 04:12:53 PM »
Originally I felt it would be a waste of time to apply but upon reading about the suggested "Permit Day" as well as for data validation, I would have to change my decision towards applying.

HiCarry

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #10 on: December 22, 2014, 04:18:36 PM »
Yeah I understand your point.  Just pissy with our states "may issue" bullshit and have to vent lol.......
I understand your "pissy-ness"...I think a lot of folks are kinda fed up with this nonsense.

On a completely unrelated note, were you at Honolulu Firearms using the range this Sunday? I can't tell from the picture ('cause my technical ineptness won't allow me to make it bigger....) but you look like the guy that was there with his wife/GF shooting the S&W Shield.....

edster48

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #11 on: December 22, 2014, 04:44:07 PM »
Since the 9th circuit found in favor of Peruta, yes I've been waiting.

However, if we do organize a day or week or whatever to go down and apply, in the interest of data collection, I'm in.   :thumbsup:
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #12 on: December 22, 2014, 05:03:11 PM »
Here is the form to apply for CCW as promised.

punaperson

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #13 on: December 22, 2014, 05:36:30 PM »
Here is the form to apply for CCW as promised.
I asked once again last week at Hilo PD about whether any forms were available for CCW License application, and was told, once again, that there is no form, you just write a letter to the chief and explain the basis of your application. Of course the problem could also be that that "plain 82" by 11" paper" is probably really hard to find in Hilo... gotta go to the big city to find paper that size!

Anyone on Hilo side interested in a group hand delivering our applications to the chief? Maybe contact some media? Any interest in an "empty holster" event? Not sure how many hoops we'd have to jump through to get a permit to demonstrate against no licensing! The "I will not comply" rally in Washington re I-594 two weekends ago refused to ask government permission (apply for a political speech permit) and were not hassled at all... even had a state legislator speak there. Of course if we got arrested for political speech without having been granted government permission it would possibly revoke our possibility of being granted a bear arms license by the same government. That makes my head hurt!  :wacko:

Lifer

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #14 on: December 22, 2014, 07:16:58 PM »
I was ready to apply for a CCW a month or two ago and using threats against the military (ISIS) as a reason. Right before my application I got some advice that the denial for CCW could be used against you in a subsequent application for a firearm; the question of  ( paraphrasing) "have you been denied a permit previously"

Now I know that a CCW denial shouldnt affect a standard permit, but this is HPD and didn't want to risk it.

Based on some posts here and my recent drama, I'm not putting a CCW denial past them to mess with a permit application later on..

one2boost

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #15 on: December 23, 2014, 06:02:15 AM »
I want to apply.  But at this point, I have no clue what is actually required.  I never really dug myself deep into the info.  I noticed a few instructors offering a CCW permit class for other states.  Generically, speaking what are the other requirements other than owning and receiving a pistol permit?

Drakiir84

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #16 on: December 23, 2014, 07:03:11 AM »
I understand your "pissy-ness"...I think a lot of folks are kinda fed up with this nonsense.

On a completely unrelated note, were you at Honolulu Firearms using the range this Sunday? I can't tell from the picture ('cause my technical ineptness won't allow me to make it bigger....) but you look like the guy that was there with his wife/GF shooting the S&W Shield.....

Nah wasn't me.  I was over at Koko Head on Friday with my wife and dad.  Funny story actually.  I was zeroing in the new scope and my dad was shooting at the target we designated as mine.  It's safe to say that a few rounds were wasted that day lol....
"The rifle is a weapon. Let there be no mistake about that. It is a tool of power, and thus dependent completely upon the moral stature of its user. It is equally useful in securing meat for the table, destroying group enemies on the battlefield, and resisting tyranny. In fact, it is the only means of resisting tyranny, since a citizenry armed with rifles simply cannot be tyrannized."
-Jeff Cooper

808lupine

Re: CCW, to apply or not to apply? Where do you guys stand?
« Reply #17 on: December 24, 2014, 01:01:45 PM »
I asked once again last week at Hilo PD about whether any forms were available for CCW License application, and was told, once again, that there is no form, you just write a letter to the chief and explain the basis of your application. Of course the problem could also be that that "plain 82" by 11" paper" is probably really hard to find in Hilo... gotta go to the big city to find paper that size!

Anyone on Hilo side interested in a group hand delivering our applications to the chief? Maybe contact some media? Any interest in an "empty holster" event? Not sure how many hoops we'd have to jump through to get a permit to demonstrate against no licensing! The "I will not comply" rally in Washington re I-594 two weekends ago refused to ask government permission (apply for a political speech permit) and were not hassled at all... even had a state legislator speak there. Of course if we got arrested for political speech without having been granted government permission it would possibly revoke our possibility of being granted a bear arms license by the same government. That makes my head hurt!  :wacko:
im in hilo, and would attend an empty holster/ group ccw app