Background checks are unconstitutional (Read 6307 times)

punaperson

Background checks are unconstitutional
« on: January 13, 2015, 09:09:48 AM »
One of the things I will be lobbying Hawaii state legislators for this session will be to end registration, including the "permit to acquire" which includes signing away your rights to privacy for your medical records as a condition to be allowed by government to legally obtain a firearm. [Please note that I do not expect any Hawaii legislators to take action on this particular issue... I'm not THAT crazy!  :geekdanc:]

Here is a brief letter by Donald L. Cline which outlines the unconstitutionality of background checks.

http://www.paysonroundup.com/news/2015/jan/09/background-checks-guns/  [You have to answer whether you own or rent your home to view the letter...]

Excerpts:

In 1993, a federal law was passed for the stated purpose of preventing or reducing access by criminals and the mentally ill to firearms. The Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act of 1993 instituted, for the first time in our history, a compelled interrogation under penalty of perjury and a search of a citizen’s private papers and effects on public record as a precondition to receiving (or being denied) permission to exercise a fundamental right guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.

The purchase of a firearm is not probable cause of criminal conduct, yet this interrogation and search is compelled in violation of our Fourth Amendment right to be secure from search in the absence of probable cause of criminal conduct.

A compelled written interrogation under penalty of perjury and a compelled search of otherwise private records on public databases is not due process, yet this interrogation and search is compelled in violation of our Fifth Amendment right to be secure from deprivation of rights in the absence of due process.
....

Our rights under the U.S. Constitution are not subject to voter initiatives or unconstitutional fiat masquerading as law.

Background checks cannot be lawfully compelled as a precondition to receiving permission to exercise a right no government, at any level, has the authority to issue or withhold.

I urge all to examine these issues and our Constitution very carefully, and vote to ban all government interference in our fundamental and guaranteed rights.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2015, 12:50:46 PM by punaperson »

edster48

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #1 on: January 13, 2015, 08:25:25 PM »
I don't see any flaws in his logic. This should be challenged in court as unconstitutional.
 If the Brady Act were to be overturned in court, all the state laws would fall like dominoes.

Has someone tried this before? If so, I don't remember it.

Edit: OK a quick search revealed that this was taken to the SCOTUS on 10th amendment grounds and the court decided that the interim provisions in the law were unconstitutional. It also appears that it could be covered under our old friend, the Commerce Clause.

I still feel it could be worth the effort to challenge it via the 4th and 5th amendment. Assuming the court would hear it.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2015, 09:12:04 PM by edster48 »
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

punaperson

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #2 on: January 14, 2015, 06:47:13 AM »
Here is a slightly longer article by Donald Cline that I found this morning, for those of you who might like more detail on the issue:

http://jpfo.org/articles-2015/cline-atf-flouts-constitution.htm

ATF is not authorized by the U.S. Constitution to make
      rulings or regulations pertaining to the right
       of private citizens to keep and bear arms

Excerpts:

First, it is not beyond the pale to consider background checks not only the death of our right to keep and bear arms, it is also the death of our Bill of Rights. I’ll show you why.

Second, do you know the difference between a “right” and a “privilege”? A right is something the citizen may exercise without government knowledge, consent, interference, or oversight. It is beyond the lawful reach of government at any level. A privilege, on the other hand, is something the citizen may do if government permits it, and if government permits it, government may revoke the permission at any time of its choosing, for any reason or no reason, and the citizen has nothing to say about it. (Nothing binding, anyway.) Anyone who tells you different is trying to sell you something.
...

In conclusion, let me point out that background checks have never prevented the criminal misuse of firearms in the history of the planet, and they were never intended to. The backers of the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act of 1993 knew background checks would never accomplish that stated goal, but they knew it would eventually accomplish something very dear to their hearts: Rendering the Fourth, Fifth, Tenth, and ultimately the Second, Amendments irrelevant.

If you have any desire to see America be restored to a nation founded and perpetuated on principles of personal liberty under the rule of law, do not, ever, vote for any law compelling a background check as a precondition to exercising any right, and let’s mount an effort to repeal the unconstitutional Brady handgun Violence Prevention Act of 1993, and do away with government licensing of gun dealers and background checks. Then we can repeal the unconstitutional Gun Control Act of 1968 that made the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (and now Explosives) the most powerful gun control tyrants in the history of the planet.
...

You cannot arm slaves and expect them to remain slaves.
Nor can you disarm a free people and expect them to remain free.
« Last Edit: January 14, 2015, 06:57:25 AM by punaperson »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #3 on: January 15, 2015, 01:09:49 PM »
I guess the biggest challenge to that argument is going to be the argument that no right is absolute and it can be minimally regulated in certain circumstances. The grey are is whether the public need compared to the level of intrusion. A regulation that is minimally intrusive, such as a voter ID law, has more chance than a law which is more intrusive.
More specifically is the intrusion and inconvenience involved in a particular firearm regulation worth the good that the law is trying to do. I believe that this is where a gun regulation will suceed or fail.

So in the case of trying to stop crazies from owning guns, how can this be done while being as least intrusive as possible? I think if we say that it cannot be done so lets not try isn't going to get us much support. We have to present some articulate suggestion on how this problem can be addressed. If we are agreeing that the seriously mentally ill should not have firearms but insisting that any legal remedy to prevent this is impossible then it is almost like saying that we are fine with the seriously mentally ill owning firearms.

I think it should also be repeatedly mentioned that the seriously mentally ill are not responsible for large numbers of firearm murders/assaults so we need to focus on the bigger issue rather than the blown up smaller issue.

BigBlue

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #4 on: January 29, 2015, 01:45:48 PM »


Second, do you know the difference between a “right” and a “privilege”? A right is something the citizen may exercise without government knowledge, consent, interference, or oversight. It is beyond the lawful reach of government at any level. A privilege, on the other hand, is something the citizen may do if government permits it, and if government permits it, government may revoke the permission at any time of its choosing, for any reason or no reason, and the citizen has nothing to say about it. (Nothing binding, anyway.) Anyone who tells you different is trying to sell you something.

Rights can be taken away. Go read the 5th amendment. Specifically go read Lewis vs. US (1980) where SCOTUS addresses loss of 2A rights after felony conviction, et al.

Now, personally I will say that some sort of sunset on such restrictions is beneficial (for a wider variety of societal reasons to re-integrate felons into society); but that's a whole other conversation. However the notion that no rights can or should ever be taken away is patently absurd unless you sincerely endorse a society without law whatsoever (doubtful amongst even the most staunch Libertarians).

I won't pretend to have all the answers on this matter; but rationally to me it makes sense that someone who is convicted of using firearms for say.. robbing a bank, should have his right to bear arms revoked for a pretty long time (how long? not sure!) - vice someone that say.. illegally dumps oil into surface water or violates customs/importation laws.

mauidog

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #5 on: January 29, 2015, 03:07:11 PM »
Rights can be taken away. Go read the 5th amendment. Specifically go read Lewis vs. US (1980) where SCOTUS addresses loss of 2A rights after felony conviction, et al.

Now, personally I will say that some sort of sunset on such restrictions is beneficial (for a wider variety of societal reasons to re-integrate felons into society); but that's a whole other conversation. However the notion that no rights can or should ever be taken away is patently absurd unless you sincerely endorse a society without law whatsoever (doubtful amongst even the most staunch Libertarians).

I won't pretend to have all the answers on this matter; but rationally to me it makes sense that someone who is convicted of using firearms for say.. robbing a bank, should have his right to bear arms revoked for a pretty long time (how long? not sure!) - vice someone that say.. illegally dumps oil into surface water or violates customs/importation laws.

So, let's say you are convicted of securities fraud.  The evidence is circumstantial, but you're convicted anyway.

Non-violent crime (white collar), but still a felony.

Does that warrant ANY loss  of voting, firearms, or any other Constitutional rights?  Does this curtail any future crimes by that person?  What is it about a felony conviction that makes us want to segregate this group of people from society for the rest of their lives?

Finally, what if the conviction was unjust -- the person was innocent but unable to convince a jury?  Seems like we go to a lot of trouble to pigeon-hole people based on something they may have done, but offer no opportunity for them to redeem themselves no matter how hard they try.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

BigBlue

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #6 on: January 29, 2015, 07:34:12 PM »
So, let's say you are convicted of securities fraud.  The evidence is circumstantial, but you're convicted anyway.

Non-violent crime (white collar), but still a felony.

Does that warrant ANY loss  of voting, firearms, or any other Constitutional rights?  Does this curtail any future crimes by that person?  What is it about a felony conviction that makes us want to segregate this group of people from society for the rest of their lives?

Finally, what if the conviction was unjust -- the person was innocent but unable to convince a jury?  Seems like we go to a lot of trouble to pigeon-hole people based on something they may have done, but offer no opportunity for them to redeem themselves no matter how hard they try.

Honestly if you're convicted of securities fraud on circumstantial evidence you should have ponied up for a real defence attorney and been more competent at hiding your tracks.

Anyway, I guess you didn't actually bother to read my comment since you're basically repeating my point that there are degrees of felonious conduct and privileges should be rescinded variably on some kind of sliding scale and sunset over time.

So yes, I think it's totally ridiculous to rescind such rights at even the slightest felony particularly given that it's impossible to comply with all laws nowadays.

Edit: to be clear, I don't even believe all violent crimes should result in revocation of 2A rights. But again, I'm not really interested in developing a list for forum's sake.

kong

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #7 on: January 30, 2015, 09:42:38 AM »
Either way the registration with respect to Hawaii is ridiculous and I thought at one point the feds were pushing to have any firearm registration city, counties, state loose some federal funding.

mauidog

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #8 on: January 30, 2015, 01:18:13 PM »
Honestly if you're convicted of securities fraud on circumstantial evidence you should have ponied up for a real defence attorney and been more competent at hiding your tracks.

Anyway, I guess you didn't actually bother to read my comment since you're basically repeating my point that there are degrees of felonious conduct and privileges should be rescinded variably on some kind of sliding scale and sunset over time.

So yes, I think it's totally ridiculous to rescind such rights at even the slightest felony particularly given that it's impossible to comply with all laws nowadays.

Edit: to be clear, I don't even believe all violent crimes should result in revocation of 2A rights. But again, I'm not really interested in developing a list for forum's sake.

Martha Stewart was convicted for hindering an investigation even though the original SEC investigation determined she had done nothing wrong.  So, it's not a matter of having a good enough lawyer.  It's about WHAT ELSE they find out when looking into allegations based on nothing but circumstantial evidence.

Same thing happened with Bill Clinton.  Didn't get in trouble for Lewinsky, but was impeached for lying about it under oath.  This is why every lawyer tells you not to say a word to police or investigators unless you have to.  One statement can create enough "reasonable suspicion" to allow them to get a warrant and find whatever you have done they  can get you on.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

BigBlue

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #9 on: February 03, 2015, 11:01:36 PM »
Martha Stewart's mistake was lying to the FBI and SEC over a $40k trade (peanuts to her).

Anyway this is way off topic and you obviously are not interested in a back and forth discussion; pretty clear you just like reading your own words.

mauidog

Re: Background checks are unconstitutional
« Reply #10 on: February 03, 2015, 11:13:36 PM »
Maybe I don't understand your words well enough....

Can you please explain in English why your comment is so different than what I said?

Martha Stewart's mistake was lying to the FBI and SEC ...

Anyway this is way off topic and you obviously are not interested in a back and forth discussion; pretty clear you just like reading your own words.
Martha Stewart was convicted for hindering an investigation
Quote
After a highly publicized six-week jury trial, Stewart was found guilty in March 2004 of felony charges of conspiracy, obstruction of an agency proceeding, and making false statements to federal investigators, and was sentenced in July 2004 to serve a five-month term in a federal correctional facility and a two-year period of supervised release (to include five months of electronic monitoring).[45]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martha_Stewart

By the way, a mistake is when you wear 2 socks to work that don't match.  What she did wasn't a mistake.  It was a willful and unlawful act that she knew could have consequences.
« Last Edit: February 03, 2015, 11:19:22 PM by mauidog »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper