I think my biggest qualm with these types of "peaceful" resolutions is the tax paying public gets screwed three fold:
1. Everybody around the situation has their life disrupted. People who live in the area cannot go home. People inside their homes cannot get out. People need to pay extra to stay at a hotel, or to make accomodations to stay at a friend's house.
2. The police and swat put in extra hours, this added expense is directly passed on to the taxpaying public. Even if the MPD already budgeted these types of situations into their payroll, the oppertunity cost of all the MPD and swat at this location, means they will not be at other locations preventing crimes and serving the general public. All for one man.
3. The criminal goes to jail, gets a bed and a roof over his head and three square meals a day for however long he is in there.
The taxpayers are essentially screwed three times by one man's selfish actions. Now, if this criminal were to spend his time in incarseration doing hard labor, building roads, digging ditches and doing work that benefits society, or if he were to be used as a test subject for cancer and disease research... then hey maybe his stay in prison can be written off as "repaying his debt" Or if we did something more aligned with Asian countries, where the families pay for the expenses created by the criminal, then yeah fine throw him in jail and make the family pay for it. But for the most part, his family will pay for nothing and whine and moan about how "he waz such a gud boy and nevah ment to hurt no 1" he'll sit in a room and cost us money and when/if he gets out he'll just do the same thing again or worse.
So yeah, prisoners are expensive but ammunition is cheap. Swat should've shot him when they had the chance. I know that's some cold cut-throat ideology, but hey I'm tired of paying for criminals, aren't you?