Columbine Massacre Survivor Introduces Bill To Allow Concealed Carry In Schools (Read 7312 times)

punaperson

After seeing firsthand what a "Gun Free Zone" can produce, he suggests one possible defensive strrategy.

http://bearingarms.com/columbine-massacre-survivor-introduces-bill-allow-concealed-carry-schools/

Excerpt:

Patrick Neville survived the infamous school shooting at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, in 1999. Like the other students, faculty, staff and administrators that day, he learned firsthand the futility of gun control laws, including the futility of the practice of declaring schools “gun free zones.”

92-percent of all mass shootings in the United States since 2009 have taken place in these so-called “gun-free zones.”

Now an elected official, Rep. Neville (R-Castle Rock) is introducing a bill to allow anyone with a concealed carry permit to carry firearms in public schools.

“This bill will allow honest law-abiding citizens to carry a concealed firearm for protection if they choose to,” Neville said in a news release. “But most importantly, it will give them the right to be equipped to defend our children from the most dangerous situations.”

eyeeatingfish

After seeing firsthand what a "Gun Free Zone" can produce, he suggests one possible defensive strrategy.

http://bearingarms.com/columbine-massacre-survivor-introduces-bill-allow-concealed-carry-schools/

Excerpt:

Patrick Neville survived the infamous school shooting at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, in 1999. Like the other students, faculty, staff and administrators that day, he learned firsthand the futility of gun control laws, including the futility of the practice of declaring schools “gun free zones.”

92-percent of all mass shootings in the United States since 2009 have taken place in these so-called “gun-free zones.”

Now an elected official, Rep. Neville (R-Castle Rock) is introducing a bill to allow anyone with a concealed carry permit to carry firearms in public schools.

“This bill will allow honest law-abiding citizens to carry a concealed firearm for protection if they choose to,” Neville said in a news release. “But most importantly, it will give them the right to be equipped to defend our children from the most dangerous situations.”

I think it is a fallacy to suggest that the designation of gun free zone is what caused Columbine and many other mass shootings to occur. Making a law that allows CCW in a school is no guarantee that you will have people carrying. On top of that in the Columbine case there was an armed officer regularly on duty at the school and it didn't deter the shooters.

Many mass shooters do end up killing themselves when they meet armed resistance and I do believe the presence of a CCW holder can stop someone on a mass shooting rampage. However I don't think that someone planning a mass shooting will be seriously deterred by whether a zone is declared gun free or not.

Just to clarify, you aren't suggesting that students be allowed to carry, only the staff and other adults allowed on campus right?

Even in Hawaii a person is allowed to carry a firearm at their place of work but some companies have rules prohibiting weapons. In these cases I am not sure whether I would support a law that took away the power of an employer to control what goes on in their private business.

mauidog

I think it is a fallacy to suggest that the designation of gun free zone is what caused Columbine and many other mass shootings to occur. Making a law that allows CCW in a school is no guarantee that you will have people carrying. On top of that in the Columbine case there was an armed officer regularly on duty at the school and it didn't deter the shooters.

Many mass shooters do end up killing themselves when they meet armed resistance and I do believe the presence of a CCW holder can stop someone on a mass shooting rampage. However I don't think that someone planning a mass shooting will be seriously deterred by whether a zone is declared gun free or not.

Just to clarify, you aren't suggesting that students be allowed to carry, only the staff and other adults allowed on campus right?

Are you seriously trying to say that ONE openly armed officer "regularly on duty" has the same deterrence against armed violence as an uncounted number of staffers, each potentially carrying a concealed weapon?

Part of the power of ALLOWING CCW is that the criminals don't have any idea what number carry and what number do not.  That is, until some "news" agency does a story about how many staffers at schools refuse to arm themselves!!

So, enough with the strawman arguments!  You're equating one armed guard with an entire staff being potentially armed and then saying it won't matter anyway because having one armed officer "was no deterrent".

Ridiculous!!   :wtf:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Are you seriously trying to say that ONE openly armed officer "regularly on duty" has the same deterrence against armed violence as an uncounted number of staffers, each potentially carrying a concealed weapon?

Part of the power of ALLOWING CCW is that the criminals don't have any idea what number carry and what number do not.  That is, until some "news" agency does a story about how many staffers at schools refuse to arm themselves!!

So, enough with the strawman arguments!  You're equating one armed guard with an entire staff being potentially armed and then saying it won't matter anyway because having one armed officer "was no deterrent".

Ridiculous!!   :wtf:

Personally, if I were to go on a shooting rampage at a school, I would be more worried about an on duty police officer on campus than the chance there is an armed teacher or two.

The officer is most likely more heavily armed, has body armor, has training in combat shooting, has instant communication to additional units, has other police related training, and has experience in stressful situations. On the other hand, even though I might not know how many armed teachers are present or who they are, an armed staffer isn't as likely to have the qualifications that the officer has. They likely wont have body armor or as many bullets. I think teachers are also less likely to have an elevated state of alert to look for suspicious signs where as a police officer is more likely to be at this state. I would wager that a female teacher would be more likely to try to protect her classroom because of the protective mother instinct than to venture out in the halls to locate an active shooter as compared to an officer who would go out and seek the target. (An officer wouldn't be attached to a particular room or group of students)  An officer has his firearm within quick reach, a female teacher in a dress might likely keep the firearm stored in a purse or locked area not on her person. I would also wager that even if staff were allowed to CCW there probably wouldn't be that many that actually do. Any idea on how many people CCW in places where it is legal? Lets just hazard a guess of 2 - 4 % In a school with 50 staff you might end up with one or two armed staff. Even if it were more than just one or two teachers I would still take my chances against them than a police officer.

Perhaps you would like to explain with your vast intillect why you would fear a teacher who CCW so much more than a police officer?

Furthermore a lot of these individuals go into these mass shootings end up killing themselves so they clearly the fear of getting shot and dying is not their biggest of concern Thus I don't think it will be a big deterrant. CCW is great but we shouldn't treat it as this miracle cure all of crime.

Bota-CS1

I wouldn't mind if the teachers & administrators at my child's school had obtained their CCW and were using it.  I think it's just a matter of time - unfortunately - before something like this happens here.  People here think of themselves as isolated from the rest of the problems of the world, and while that's true to some extent, it's just a matter of time.  My question to those out there that might be reading this and scoff at it, Would you rather have prepared for a flood knowing that it was coming, or get washed away because you stuck your head in the sand?
No one is coming, it’s up to us.

Legislation should never be about depriving law abiding citizens of something, but rather taking those things away from criminals.

Q

« Last Edit: February 25, 2021, 10:08:34 PM by Q »

punaperson

I think it is a fallacy to suggest that the designation of gun free zone is what caused Columbine and many other mass shootings to occur.

That statement is a fallacy, known as a strawman argument. No one claimed that a gun-free zone caused any shooting. Rather there is strong data (over 90% of mass public shootings have happened in gun-free zones) to suggest that all other factors being equal, the criminal will select a place least likely to face armed resistance (note the rarity of robberies at police stations). The Aurora theater shooter bypassed about 9 other theaters closer to his point of departure, all showing the same movie at the same time... yet the one he selected to commit his crime was the only one of those that was a gun-free zone. Could be a coincidence, but the data suggests otherwise. Certainly some of the criminals who select schools have personal experiences at those schools that lead them to select those particular locations to attempt to "get even" for how they perceived they were treated there, but in those cases where the motive is so emotionally tied to those particular locations, it's possible they would choose those schools anyway whether there was CCW or several "school resource officers" or not, but in those cases it's at least possible they would not be able to commit as much carnage.

Making a law that allows CCW in a school is no guarantee that you will have people carrying.

Another strawman. No one claimed that there is any guarantee about anything. But certainly if school staff are not legally allowed to CCW on school property, there is a much higher probability that no one will be carrying. Having the legal option at least provides for the possibility of one or more CCW holders exercising their rights. I'm sure some school staff carry despite it being illegal, but I'd guess that number is miniscule compared to how many would carry if it were legal.

On top of that in the Columbine case there was an armed officer regularly on duty at the school and it didn't deter the shooters.

Actually he did dieter the shooters. He engaged in an exchange of gunfire with them, during which time they weren't killing any students or staff, and some students were able to get out of range and/or line of sight of the shooters.

Many mass shooters do end up killing themselves when they meet armed resistance and I do believe the presence of a CCW holder can stop someone on a mass shooting rampage. However I don't think that someone planning a mass shooting will be seriously deterred by whether a zone is declared gun free or not.

They may or may not be deterred by the possibility of CCW holders being present, but there is a 100% chance they will not be deterred by a gun-free zone. CCW holders HAVE stopped potential mass shootings. Opponents of civilian firearm ownership like to state that no civilian has ever stopped a mass killer, yet there are numerous cases of civilians stopping people who had killed one or several people and were clearly intent on killing more until they were stopped by the armed civilian. The shooters were then dead or incapacitated so they weren't able to keep killing and reach that magic number of four. Duh!


Just to clarify, you aren't suggesting that students be allowed to carry, only the staff and other adults allowed on campus right?

I'm not sure how many, if any, states allow people of high school age to apply for CCW licenses. If it's legal, and they qualify, I see no reason why not. Or are you suggesting the same arguments used to attempt to defeat CCW on college campuses: that those legal CCW holders, usually 21 and over, are responsible enough to carry a gun everywhere until they walk on campus and then they become a public danger?

Even in Hawaii a person is allowed to carry a firearm at their place of work but some companies have rules prohibiting weapons. In these cases I am not sure whether I would support a law that took away the power of an employer to control what goes on in their private business.

That's definitely a gray area. People should have some say about what takes place on their private property. People should have the ability to exercise their unalienable civil rights with minimum infringement. Would business owners be able to legally prohibit people under their employ from exercising other rights, for instance free speech, due process, freedom from unwarranted searches and seizures, etc.? Perhaps if the policy is long-standing and made clear to all applicants then a person dedicated to carry could look for employment elsewhere. If the policy of no carry is instituted after one has been employed for some time, then I'd suspect a lawsuit might arise.

mauidog

Quote
Even in Hawaii a person is allowed to carry a firearm at their place of work but some companies have rules prohibiting weapons. In these cases I am not sure whether I would support a law that took away the power of an employer to control what goes on in their private business.

That's definitely a gray area. People should have some say about what takes place on their private property. People should have the ability to exercise their unalienable civil rights with minimum infringement. Would business owners be able to legally prohibit people under their employ from exercising other rights, for instance free speech, due process, freedom from unwarranted searches and seizures, etc.? Perhaps if the policy is long-standing and made clear to all applicants then a person dedicated to carry could look for employment elsewhere. If the policy of no carry is instituted after one has been employed for some time, then I'd suspect a lawsuit might arise.


This is already being adjudicated in favor of the individual workers.  If a company decides to have a policy of "no guns carried while at work", in some states the employer can not prevent the gun owners from transporting and storing guns in the parking lot at work.  To deny that is to prevent employees from carrying while commuting to/from work. 

Quote
Perhaps you would like to explain with your vast intillect why you would fear a teacher who CCW so much more than a police officer?

You keep comparing apples and oranges.

One security guard compared to X number of staffers with concealed guns.  Staffers get the check mark.  (covert carry by at least one CCW offers a tactical advantage)

One security guard in an observable location versus X number of staffers in a variety of locations with many in between classrooms for various reasons, creating X number of unknown variables.  Staffers get the check mark.

One security guard against more than one shooter (2 at Columbine) -- guard at a disadvantage.  Multiple shooters against X number of staffers, each potentially armed and able to return fire. Even two CCW staffers makes the fight even versus a single officer.  Staffers get the check mark.

p.s.  If you are going to insult someone's intellect, you might want to learn to spell the word correctly!   :rofl:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Personally, if I were to go on a shooting rampage at a school, I would be more worried about an on duty police officer on campus than the chance there is an armed teacher or two.

The officer is most likely more heavily armed, has body armor, has training in combat shooting, has instant communication to additional units, has other police related training, and has experience in stressful situations. On the other hand, even though I might not know how many armed teachers are present or who they are, an armed staffer isn't as likely to have the qualifications that the officer has. They likely wont have body armor or as many bullets. I think teachers are also less likely to have an elevated state of alert to look for suspicious signs where as a police officer is more likely to be at this state. I would wager that a female teacher would be more likely to try to protect her classroom because of the protective mother instinct than to venture out in the halls to locate an active shooter as compared to an officer who would go out and seek the target. (An officer wouldn't be attached to a particular room or group of students)  An officer has his firearm within quick reach, a female teacher in a dress might likely keep the firearm stored in a purse or locked area not on her person. I would also wager that even if staff were allowed to CCW there probably wouldn't be that many that actually do. Any idea on how many people CCW in places where it is legal? Lets just hazard a guess of 2 - 4 % In a school with 50 staff you might end up with one or two armed staff. Even if it were more than just one or two teachers I would still take my chances against them than a police officer.

Perhaps you would like to explain with your vast intillect why you would fear a teacher who CCW so much more than a police officer?

Furthermore a lot of these individuals go into these mass shootings end up killing themselves so they clearly the fear of getting shot and dying is not their biggest of concern Thus I don't think it will be a big deterrant. CCW is great but we shouldn't treat it as this miracle cure all of crime.

While researching active shooters for a work project, I ran across the story of a School Resource Officer (SRO) I found very informative. He was involved with a kid that had been planning to shoot up his school but was alerted by another kid to the plan. The cops went to the shooter kid's house and found a series of well laid out plans. The first part of the plan was to shoot the SRO. This surprised the SRO and when he was able to talk to the kid, he asked him why he wanted to shoot him first. "Was it something I did" he asked the kid. "Did you think I treated you unfairly or badly" he asked. The kid replied that in fact he thought a lot of the SRO and that he had hoped the officer would not be at school that day because he really didn't want to shoot him. "Why, then, did you want to shoot me first" the SRO asked. "Because" the kid replied, "I knew that if you were at school and I started shooting you would be duty bound to try and stop me and I couldn't let you do that."

I also think you over estimate the training of police in general. Many only qualify with their service pistol once a year. Are there cops who shoot really well? Yes, but there are also cops who are not shooters and only the gun on their hip as another tool and the only practice they get are their annual (or semi-annual) qualifications.

The reason to "fear" an armed teacher more than an officer is exactly the reason I illustrated in the story above. If you're planning to shoot up a school that has an armed officer, you know who that officer is and will likely plan to take them out first or not storm the school when they are there. The shooter will not likely know which teachers are armed and therefore the armed teachers have the benefit of surprise. As for teachers not being alert to what's going on, I beg to differ. They are constantly responsible for the well being of many children. It is their job to be alert and ready to protect the kids, be it from a fire or an active shooter. Furthermore, most CCW holders train pretty well, knowing that proficiency with their firearm is critical to the primary goal of carrying a firearm in the first place: to protect them and their loved ones.

You know which state allows those with a CCW to carry at schools and has never had a school shooting? Utah. So sure, letting teachers carry won't be the "miracle cure" to prevent all school shootings, but as was pointed out by another poster (and as illustrated by the story above) these guys do plan out their attack and they do not want confrontations. They want to kill as many people as possible in as short as time as possible so that they can go down in historical infamy. Gun free zones embolden these guys. Allowing CCW in schools would give the shooters pause, knowing that there was possibly someone there that could prevent them from completing their grisly task and gaining the notoriety that they so desperately desire.

Rocky

Keeps sounding more and more like ...
 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.”
                                                           Franklin D. Roosevelt

eyeeatingfish

This is already being adjudicated in favor of the individual workers.  If a company decides to have a policy of "no guns carried while at work", in some states the employer can not prevent the gun owners from transporting and storing guns in the parking lot at work.  To deny that is to prevent employees from carrying while commuting to/from work. 

You keep comparing apples and oranges.
One security guard compared to X number of staffers with concealed guns.  Staffers get the check mark.  (covert carry by at least one CCW offers a tactical advantage)
One security guard in an observable location versus X number of staffers in a variety of locations with many in between classrooms for various reasons, creating X number of unknown variables.  Staffers get the check mark.
One security guard against more than one shooter (2 at Columbine) -- guard at a disadvantage.  Multiple shooters against X number of staffers, each potentially armed and able to return fire. Even two CCW staffers makes the fight even versus a single officer.  Staffers get the check mark.
p.s.  If you are going to insult someone's intellect, you might want to learn to spell the word correctly!   :rofl:

Dang, you beat my whole argument by pointing out I had a typo! Surely spelling ability trumps all other forms of intelligence.

Like I said, if I were going to go on a mass shooting I would take my chances against a school where teachers might be armed over a school where I know a police officer is present. We will never (hopefully) test which theory would produce a better outcome. I suppose in the end it doesn't matter, a lot of the people going on mass shootings aren't right in the head, conventional deterrents might not mean anything to them.

eyeeatingfish



The beginning of the initial post started by saying:
"After seeing firsthand what a "Gun Free Zone" can produce, he suggests one possible defensive strategy."

To me this suggests that the label of "gun free zone" is partially responsible for the shooting. I do agree that all things being equal a shooter would choose a gun free zone however I think in most cases not having the label of gun free zone would not stop them. A lot of these shooters pick certain locations because of specific targets. The columbine shooters wanted to kill people they knew. The Sandy Hook shooter wanted to kill people that were dear to his mothers heart IIRC. People who shoot up their workplace do it not because it is a gun free zone but because that is where the targets of their aggressions are. 

I don't think students should be allowed to take guns to school but as far as adults go I think it is pointless to have places labeled as gun free zones (except for airports, mental hospitals, court rooms, etc.)

eyeeatingfish

While researching active shooters for a work project, I ran across the story of a School Resource Officer (SRO) I found very informative. He was involved with a kid that had been planning to shoot up his school but was alerted by another kid to the plan. The cops went to the shooter kid's house and found a series of well laid out plans. The first part of the plan was to shoot the SRO. This surprised the SRO and when he was able to talk to the kid, he asked him why he wanted to shoot him first. "Was it something I did" he asked the kid. "Did you think I treated you unfairly or badly" he asked. The kid replied that in fact he thought a lot of the SRO and that he had hoped the officer would not be at school that day because he really didn't want to shoot him. "Why, then, did you want to shoot me first" the SRO asked. "Because" the kid replied, "I knew that if you were at school and I started shooting you would be duty bound to try and stop me and I couldn't let you do that."

I also think you over estimate the training of police in general. Many only qualify with their service pistol once a year. Are there cops who shoot really well? Yes, but there are also cops who are not shooters and only the gun on their hip as another tool and the only practice they get are their annual (or semi-annual) qualifications.

The reason to "fear" an armed teacher more than an officer is exactly the reason I illustrated in the story above. If you're planning to shoot up a school that has an armed officer, you know who that officer is and will likely plan to take them out first or not storm the school when they are there. The shooter will not likely know which teachers are armed and therefore the armed teachers have the benefit of surprise. As for teachers not being alert to what's going on, I beg to differ. They are constantly responsible for the well being of many children. It is their job to be alert and ready to protect the kids, be it from a fire or an active shooter. Furthermore, most CCW holders train pretty well, knowing that proficiency with their firearm is critical to the primary goal of carrying a firearm in the first place: to protect them and their loved ones.

You know which state allows those with a CCW to carry at schools and has never had a school shooting? Utah. So sure, letting teachers carry won't be the "miracle cure" to prevent all school shootings, but as was pointed out by another poster (and as illustrated by the story above) these guys do plan out their attack and they do not want confrontations. They want to kill as many people as possible in as short as time as possible so that they can go down in historical infamy. Gun free zones embolden these guys. Allowing CCW in schools would give the shooters pause, knowing that there was possibly someone there that could prevent them from completing their grisly task and gaining the notoriety that they so desperately desire.
''


I agree with all your points, I was just mentioning that if all things were equal I would take my chances against a potentially armed teacher than a armed officer/guard who I can identify readily. Being uniformed is a double edged sword really, it has some added benefits and some draw backs when it comes to dealing with an aggressive person.

On a side note I am sure that a lot of CCW individuals practice more often than officers but I have to question whether they practice the same types of close proximity, rapid, high stress shooting drills as officers do. That is sort of a side issue though. I think anyone who wants to CCW should have at least some training in that type of shooting because when the adrenaline starts pumping accuracy can plummet.

mauidog

The beginning of the initial post started by saying:
"After seeing firsthand what a "Gun Free Zone" can produce, he suggests one possible defensive strategy."

To me this suggests that the label of "gun free zone" is partially responsible for the shooting. I do agree that all things being equal a shooter would choose a gun free zone however I think in most cases not having the label of gun free zone would not stop them. A lot of these shooters pick certain locations because of specific targets. The columbine shooters wanted to kill people they knew. The Sandy Hook shooter wanted to kill people that were dear to his mothers heart IIRC. People who shoot up their workplace do it not because it is a gun free zone but because that is where the targets of their aggressions are. 

I don't think students should be allowed to take guns to school but as far as adults go I think it is pointless to have places labeled as gun free zones (except for airports, mental hospitals, court rooms, etc.)

Not sure where you got that tidbit. I've yet to see any reports that clarified the mother's connection to the school at all.  Some said she was on staff, others said she was a substitute, and still more said there was no connection anyone can find. 

The reports I read said the son was obsessed with prior mass shootings as well as FPS video games.  He may have seen himself in a real life game trying to become the record holder with the highest number of kills.

However, that, too, is speculation.  There has been no information released that includes why he went on the shooting spree to begin with, nor why he chose a school, much less that particular school. 

Using this school shooting to illustrate your point that he chose the location for reasons other than it being an unprotected facility full of easy, soft targets would be unfounded.

An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Not sure where you got that tidbit. I've yet to see any reports that clarified the mother's connection to the school at all.  Some said she was on staff, others said she was a substitute, and still more said there was no connection anyone can find. 

The reports I read said the son was obsessed with prior mass shootings as well as FPS video games.  He may have seen himself in a real life game trying to become the record holder with the highest number of kills.

However, that, too, is speculation.  There has been no information released that includes why he went on the shooting spree to begin with, nor why he chose a school, much less that particular school. 

Using this school shooting to illustrate your point that he chose the location for reasons other than it being an unprotected facility full of easy, soft targets would be unfounded.

It was in one of the early news reports. It is possible that it is not accurate given new information. Many other crazy shooters are targeting certain people such as coworkers or fellow students this would explain why many of them are done at school.