Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915 (Read 6094 times)

Heavies

Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« on: February 22, 2015, 05:39:43 AM »
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=473&year=2015

(from HRA)
Quote
SB 473, SD1, proposing carry permit issue rules under the Federal retired Law Enforcement Officers Safety Act (LEOSA), has a hearing, Tuesday, 02-24 at 9:15AM. The Senate Public Safety Committee gutted the original version and replaced it with the language proposed by the Hawaii Attorney General's office, renewing the AG's complete authority over the administration of the permit process.  The onerous qualification requirements currently established by the AG, like a perfect score on the shooting practical examination and a complete physical examination at the expense of the applicant, are why only about 40 retired officers in the whole of Hawaii have carry licenses at present. PLEASE GO TO THE HEARING NOTICE BELOW, SUBMIT TESTIMONY IN OPPOSITION to the current bill, and ask the Senate Judiciary Committee to instead write into Hawaii Statute a reasonable qualification process that fulfills the intent of this 12 year old Federal Act.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/hearingnotices/
HEARING_JDL_02-24-15_DM_.HTM

macsak

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #1 on: February 22, 2015, 07:45:14 AM »
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=473&year=2015

(from HRA)

here's what i wrote in the comments:
i OPPOSE the amended bill
i SUPPORTED the original wording
the substitution of rules and regulations that basically make it next to impossible to fulfill the requirements is an effort to effectively kill/neuter the bill
the state of HI MUST comply with LEOSA
the state may face fines and penalties for not complying
please reinstate original language that the vast majority of testimony supported

William Smith

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #2 on: February 22, 2015, 09:30:58 AM »
Yea I saw the PSM amendments to original draft.  Basically it made it very difficult for retired LEO to be vetted to conceal carry, and I felt it almost defeats the intent of LEOSA.  I submitted new testimony in opposition to the SD1 draft, noting I would again be in support if the original wording was replaced.  Its only a public decision meeting this Tuesday, so no oral testimony will be heard. 

I actually went into the public records of testimony submitted before the changes in SD1 and emailed most of the individuals and groups who were previously in support- to give them a heads-up to the changes.  I bet some of the folks here got this unsolicited email from me last night.  At first, I though this might be a little rude or intrusive of me, but also realized that when folks submit testimony, it becomes part of the public record, and I felt it my obligation to do so. 

Believe me, this was not altruism on my part.  It's very self serving as well as for the common good. I don't even own any firearms, nor do I plan on applying to acquire any time soon.  But I do feel myself, my family, our community and our society would be a safer place if qualified folks who do own firearms have the right to concealed carry if they desire- especially retired LEO!  By protecting themselves and their families, they also protect my family and our community.  I live next door to two current LEO, and across the street from a retired LEO.  Since I don't own any firearms, these neighbors are the first line of defense for our neighborhood.  I really  appreciate their presence.  Personally, I'd like everyone who is qualified and so desires to concealed carry. I feel it would make our world a much safer place.

I hope the JDL committee realizes much of the previous support may now be invalid, and i also hope those previously in support voice their current stance with new written testimony.

macsak

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #3 on: February 22, 2015, 10:04:29 AM »
Yea I saw the PSM amendments to original draft.  Basically it made it very difficult for retired LEO to be vetted to conceal carry, and I felt it almost defeats the intent of LEOSA.  I submitted new testimony in opposition to the SD1 draft, noting I would again be in support if the original wording was replaced.  Its only a public decision meeting this Tuesday, so no oral testimony will be heard. 

I actually went into the public records of testimony submitted before the changes in SD1 and emailed most of the individuals and groups who were previously in support- to give them a heads-up to the changes.  I bet some of the folks here got this unsolicited email from me last night.  At first, I though this might be a little rude or intrusive of me, but also realized that when folks submit testimony, it becomes part of the public record, and I felt it my obligation to do so. 

Believe me, this was not altruism on my part.  It's very self serving as well as for the common good. I don't even own any firearms, nor do I plan on applying to acquire any time soon.  But I do feel myself, my family, our community and our society would be a safer place if qualified folks who do own firearms have the right to concealed carry if they desire- especially retired LEO!  By protecting themselves and their families, they also protect my family and our community.  I live next door to two current LEO, and across the street from a retired LEO.  Since I don't own any firearms, these neighbors are the first line of defense for our neighborhood.  I really  appreciate their presence.  Personally, I'd like everyone who is qualified and so desires to concealed carry. I feel it would make our world a much safer place.

I hope the JDL committee realizes much of the previous support may now be invalid, and i also hope those previously in support voice their current stance with new written testimony.

aloha william
i must admit i was initially taken aback upon receiving your email this morning, but it was the right thing to do
i didn't read the posts regarding this initially, nor the email from HRA
i just ASSumed that everything was ok when it passed out of committee
i appreciate your diligence

aloha

steve
« Last Edit: February 22, 2015, 10:10:29 AM by macsak »

Heavies

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #4 on: February 23, 2015, 07:00:39 AM »

Citizens have the right to armed self protection.  ALL citizens.  Government has no right to make the means of this self protection exceedingly difficult to qualify or obtain.  Courts have consistently ruled IN FAVOR of the 2nd Amendment to the Constitution.  Hawaii legislature needs to revise their staunch opposition to this RIGHT, and come up with reasonable laws for the carrying of concealed firearms on one's person.  This means ALL citizens LEO and Law abiding Citizens.

likecarry808

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #5 on: February 23, 2015, 03:46:28 PM »
sorry did not see this till just now. But i did still submit not in favor of new wording and should go back to the original wording.
For  what is worth i did submit first time new to doing this.

William Smith

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #6 on: February 24, 2015, 07:11:29 AM »
Channel 2 news just had a spot on this public decision making meeting happening this morning.  Of course, they interviewed one of the two groups which were in Opposition to implementing some workable version of LEOAS, and one LEO in Support.  Neither one of them mentioned the wording was changed in the SD1 draft, which is the topic of todays meeting. They also didn't mention that the overwhelming majority of the testimony submitted was in support- at least before SD1, but that doesn't surprise me.

punaperson

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #7 on: February 24, 2015, 07:52:46 AM »
Channel 2 news just had a spot on this public decision making meeting happening this morning.  Of course, they interviewed one of the two groups which were in Opposition to implementing some workable version of LEOAS, and one LEO in Support.  Neither one of them mentioned the wording was changed in the SD1 draft, which is the topic of todays meeting. They also didn't mention that the overwhelming majority of the testimony submitted was in support- at least before SD1, but that doesn't surprise me.
The quote from CEO Kriedman sums it all up:

"It seems logical to us that possession and access to firearms is bad enough. Carry them concealed just increases the danger to potential victims, bystanders, law enforcement. We say absolutely not,” said Nanci Kriedman, CEO, Domestic Violence Action Center."

The obvious "logical" answer to domestic violence is for a total prohibition on firearm ownership (well, maybe exempting the "Only Ones" while actively on duty). I wonder how Ms. Kriedman suggests people like the woman and her two young children stabbed yesterday in Kalihi defend themselves against violent criminals? Oh, yeah, the state will implement more stringent measures to restrict anyone but residents from public housing complexes,,, and we all know that no one who lives in public housing would ever commit a crime against another resident. Even the Hawaii Public Housing Authority states "we cannot prevent every incident that may occur on our properties." In other words, as we all "logically" know, we are all on our own to protect ourselves and our families, but by Ms. Kriedman's "logic" those 760,000 to 2.5 million Defensive Gun Uses per year in which people thwart criminal assaults... well, you're better off just taking it, like the woman in Kalihi and her stabbed children.  :stopjack:

punaperson

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #8 on: February 24, 2015, 05:52:53 PM »
Passed unanimously 6-0, with senator Slom excused. I guess they really want to make it impossible for anyone to carry concealed, even ex-cops. Even Gabbard, who introduced (with Slom) a bill for ordinary civilian CCW, voted for it. The public testimony overwhelmingly opposed the changes made to the original bill, but the committee members didn't care. Go figure.

suka

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #9 on: February 25, 2015, 02:26:58 AM »
LEOSA from other states can legally carry in Hawaii on vacation , but local retired LEOs cannot carry in their own state.

punaperson

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #10 on: February 25, 2015, 07:09:41 AM »
LEOSA from other states can legally carry in Hawaii on vacation , but local retired LEOs cannot carry in their own state.
I just wish even ONE government bureaucrat, be they legislator, governor, attorney general or police chief, would just come out and clearly state what it is they know (and HOW they know it) about Hawaii residents (including ex-LEO) that makes them by far the most irresponsible, incompetent and untrustworthy citizens incapable of CCWing in all of the United States. We are definitely special, but they won't say why or how.  :wtf:

Heavies

Re: Testimony needed by 2-23-15 0915
« Reply #11 on: February 25, 2015, 12:46:17 PM »
I just wish even ONE government bureaucrat, be they legislator, governor, attorney general or police chief, would just come out and clearly state what it is they know (and HOW they know it) about Hawaii residents (including ex-LEO) that makes them by far the most irresponsible, incompetent and untrustworthy citizens incapable of CCWing in all of the United States. We are definitely special, but they won't say why or how.  :wtf:

We alwayz get snockered das why!