Gun ownership hits record low? (Read 23551 times)

xer 21

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #20 on: March 12, 2015, 10:53:42 PM »
ok, well the problem is, that statistics regarding the spread of gun ownership or decrease of it are almost always useless for either side in terms of truth.  the only real hard data is sales or background checks.

mauidog

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #21 on: March 12, 2015, 11:41:16 PM »
My quest is really for the truth more than anything else. I wish to develop the strongest and accurate gun rights arguments as well. So if a statistic come out that brings into question the party line of "more guns = less crime" I must address it. And if it is the case that more guns does not equal less crime then I must dispense with that line of arguments or modify it. Because of this, if someone posts a rebuttal but the rebuttal is flawed I must point out the flaw as it does us no good to use flawed arguments to defend the 2nd amendment. So, for example, if science showed that more people owning firearms did contribute to crime then I would have to accept it and evaluate my position on the matter. Or if science showed CCW reduced crime rates I could then use it as a strong argument for firearms.

I did not post an opinion because I don't fully know the whole story on how many people actually own firearms as opposed to how many firearms there are total. Moreover it really is not a matter of opinion, either there are more firearm owners or there aren't. If one man in a town of 100 owned 50 firearms it would seem that half of the town had firearms and someone might say to look at how peaceful that town is with such a high number of firearms. But in reality that 1 person cannot carry 50 firearms at a time, therefore those 49 firearms he isn't carrying isn't making the town more safe. Simply comparing the number of firearms to the crime rate alone is a fairly weak correlation. You need something else to make it stronger such as CCW rates or how many homes had firearms.

I am of the general opinion that the real question is not how many firearms there are but who has those firearms. It is because we are civil that we can own firearms safely and use them for good.

I disagree.  It's not how many guns or who has them, but whether you are comparing short term trends or long term.

While the numbers in the article are showing a drop from last year, look at the article I posted using the same report.  It paints a much different picture and doesn't leave the reader to draw their own inaccurate conclusions.

There is nothing scientific about using a one year, five year, ten year or twenty year period for comparison.  An honest analysis will look for significant changes that affect gun ownership and use that as a demarcation point between periods.  Either that, or they will exclude small periods that contain significant data outliers to avoid unfairly skewing the data.

So, does a slowdown in sales and registrations, or a smaller number of registered guns in one year compared to the previous, really mean shooting interest has dwindled?

I suggest a look at the amount of ammo and reloading components and equipment purchased each year would be a better measure of interest than whether people buy a new gun every year.  Consumables are going to be more indicative of shooting activity, and therefore interest.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

suka

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #22 on: March 13, 2015, 05:04:00 AM »
here

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #23 on: March 13, 2015, 05:57:52 AM »
My quest is really for the truth more than anything else. I wish to develop the strongest and accurate gun rights arguments as well. So if a statistic come out that brings into question the party line of "more guns = less crime" I must address it. And if it is the case that more guns does not equal less crime then I must dispense with that line of arguments or modify it. Because of this, if someone posts a rebuttal but the rebuttal is flawed I must point out the flaw as it does us no good to use flawed arguments to defend the 2nd amendment. So, for example, if science showed that more people owning firearms did contribute to crime then I would have to accept it and evaluate my position on the matter. Or if science showed CCW reduced crime rates I could then use it as a strong argument for firearms.

I did not post an opinion because I don't fully know the whole story on how many people actually own firearms as opposed to how many firearms there are total. Moreover it really is not a matter of opinion, either there are more firearm owners or there aren't. If one man in a town of 100 owned 50 firearms it would seem that half of the town had firearms and someone might say to look at how peaceful that town is with such a high number of firearms. But in reality that 1 person cannot carry 50 firearms at a time, therefore those 49 firearms he isn't carrying isn't making the town more safe. Simply comparing the number of firearms to the crime rate alone is a fairly weak correlation. You need something else to make it stronger such as CCW rates or how many homes had firearms.

I am of the general opinion that the real question is not how many firearms there are but who has those firearms. It is because we are civil that we can own firearms safely and use them for good.
Well, you must know that neither you, nor anyone else, will ever have verifiably accurate data as to exactly how many firearms there are, exactly where they are located, and exactly who owns them and/or has functional access to them (okay, except here in Hawaii where our elitist betters have made sure we all beg them for permission to own an arm and reveal all our personal data to them), nor will you ever know exactly how many people exactly where have and how often and where they carry. Nor will you ever know with full accuracy the deterrent effect on criminal behavior given whatever level of inaccurate statistics there are about gun ownership and CCW in any particular area. So your whole assertion re "the truth" blah blah blah is nothing but a ruse. You will never have either an argument nor a refutation of an argument based on this type of data, if you require 100% "scientific" accuracy and no surmising, speculation, or a priori assumptions. Why do you ask a question that you know can't be answered to the standard of your criteria?

mauidog

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #24 on: March 13, 2015, 06:23:07 AM »
Well, you must know that neither you, nor anyone else, will ever have verifiably accurate data as to exactly how many firearms there are, exactly where they are located, and exactly who owns them and/or has functional access to them (okay, except here in Hawaii where our elitist betters have made sure we all beg them for permission to own an arm and reveal all our personal data to them), nor will you ever know exactly how many people exactly where have and how often and where they carry. Nor will you ever know with full accuracy the deterrent effect on criminal behavior given whatever level of inaccurate statistics there are about gun ownership and CCW in any particular area. So your whole assertion re "the truth" blah blah blah is nothing but a ruse. You will never have either an argument nor a refutation of an argument based on this type of data, if you require 100% "scientific" accuracy and no surmising, speculation, or a priori assumptions. Why do you ask a question that you know can't be answered to the standard of your criteria?

Have you ever studied statistics?  I mean in a classroom where they teach standard deviations, margins of error, Poisson Distribution, and the fallacies associated with statistical analysis in general?

You have to ask these unanswerable questions so you can determine whether your study has any meaning, or if it's just another question that can be added to the Trivial Pursuit games.

The truth is not a ruse.  the truth exists whether or not you ever see it.  It's like the tree falling the forest but nobody is there to hear it.  Does the sound exist in the absence of an observer capable of hearing it?  Does the truth exist even if everyone agrees with the lie instead?

Statistics is never exact, but neither is it useless.  If done properly, it is a good indicator of an ESTIMATE.  That estimate has a margin of error which must be factored in.  If you don't know how to do that, then you might was well just find another topic to discuss.  Statistics is not for you until you learn the basics. 

The margin of error says how wrong, either above or below your estimate, your figures could be.  A wide margin tells you you might as well just pull a number out of your @ss for all the good it is.  A small margin tells us the approximation is useful for basing decisions and conclusions.

You say there is no way to know this or know that.  There are ways to know that for a given population using surveys and observation.  You just have to approach the study scientifically instead of latching onto some arbitrary numbers like the difference in a percentage and trying to make some kind of conclusion with nothing other than that raw percentage.  The kicker is, you don't even know if the percentages are correct!  You're just taking the report in the news at face value!  How accurate is that?  Garbage in = garbage out.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #25 on: March 13, 2015, 06:39:12 AM »
Have you ever studied statistics?  I mean in a classroom where they teach standard deviations, margins of error, Poisson Distribution, and the fallacies associated with statistical analysis in general?

You have to ask these unanswerable questions so you can determine whether your study has any meaning, or if it's just another question that can be added to the Trivial Pursuit games.

The truth is not a ruse.  the truth exists whether or not you ever see it.  It's like the tree falling the forest but nobody is there to hear it.  Does the sound exist in the absence of an observer capable of hearing it?  Does the truth exist even if everyone agrees with the lie instead?

Statistics is never exact, but neither is it useless.  If done properly, it is a good indicator of an ESTIMATE.  That estimate has a margin of error which must be factored in.  If you don't know how to do that, then you might was well just find another topic to discuss.  Statistics is not for you until you learn the basics. 

The margin of error says how wrong, either above or below your estimate, your figures could be.  A wide margin tells you you might as well just pull a number out of your @ss for all the good it is.  A small margin tells us the approximation is useful for basing decisions and conclusions.

You say there is no way to know this or know that.  There are ways to know that for a given population using surveys and observation.  You just have to approach the study scientifically instead of latching onto some arbitrary numbers like the difference in a percentage and trying to make some kind of conclusion with nothing other than that raw percentage.  The kicker is, you don't even know if the percentages are correct!  You're just taking the report in the news at face value!  How accurate is that?  Garbage in = garbage out.
You apparently entirely missed the point of my question to eyeeatingfish, but nevertheless...

Alright, given your vast academic knowledge of statistics, please answer the following questions and give us your margin of error and level of confidence, with references.

How many households in the U.S. have firearms?
How many total firearms are in those households?
What, exactly, is the measurable criminal deterrent effect of those firearms, and how does it vary by region where there are higher vs. lower total guns, total guns vs. guns per household, and CCW rate (please specify how you determined how many people are carrying how often)?

Thanks.

mauidog

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #26 on: March 13, 2015, 07:14:03 AM »
You apparently entirely missed the point of my question to eyeeatingfish, but nevertheless...

Alright, given your vast academic knowledge of statistics, please answer the following questions and give us your margin of error and level of confidence, with references.

How many households in the U.S. have firearms?
How many total firearms are in those households?
What, exactly, is the measurable criminal deterrent effect of those firearms, and how does it vary by region where there are higher vs. lower total guns, total guns vs. guns per household, and CCW rate (please specify how you determined how many people are carrying how often)?

Thanks.

Given my "vast knowledge" of statistics?  Those are good questions to study.

Implying my knowledge of statistical modeling and the science involved in statistical analysis somehow gives me access to data or studies that no one else has collected is obviously not valid.

BTW, my knowledge is not just academic.  I've used statistical studies in real life and helped top management make critical decisions that often involved risking lives.

You would be amazed at how much data is involved in selecting the correct munitions and platform to take out a given hardened target from an estimated altitude/range, in specific weather conditions, speed,  etc, etc,.

That data was updated monthly, and the optimal solution depended on target priorities, service status of available aircraft, crew availability, munitions availability, aircraft-munitions combined performance characteristics, ....

I didn't fly the missions, but I made sure the people who did weren't trying to kill a giant with a BB.

I was a programmer for the AWACS systems that included surveillance and weapons control positions as well as radar and communications.  After that I was a designer and integration lead for the systems that planned the coalition air wars starting with Desert Shield/Desert Storm.  All missions were planned, executed, and evaluated using the systems I helped create and field.  I was in the command centers in S. Korea during more Ulchi Focus Lens and other live exercises than I can remember.  Thailand, Guam, Japan ... always the person tagged to be onsite for Naval, AF and joint exercises.

Please don't assume my comments are purely academic.  I've used these disciplines in the real world for things that really matter.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #27 on: March 13, 2015, 07:39:38 AM »
Please don't assume my comments are purely academic.  I've used these disciplines in the real world for things that really matter.
I didn't assume that. But okay.

You apparently entirely missed the point of my question to eyeeatingfish, but nevertheless...

Alright, given your vast academic knowledge of statistics, please answer the following questions and give us your margin of error and level of confidence, with references.

How many households in the U.S. have firearms?
How many total firearms are in those households?
What, exactly, is the measurable criminal deterrent effect of those firearms, and how does it vary by region where there are higher vs. lower total guns, total guns vs. guns per household, and CCW rate (please specify how you determined how many people are carrying how often)?

Thanks.

aieahound

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #28 on: March 13, 2015, 08:43:47 AM »
There's a huge variable in this whole thing. Honesty.

And that can't be given a margin of error. Or maybe it can if we start a poll on here.

Someone calls you from XYZ polling and asks you if you or anyone in your household owns a gun.
How do you respond ?

I'd tell them either no or none of their got damn business.

new guy

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #29 on: March 13, 2015, 09:20:09 AM »
.
« Last Edit: August 18, 2016, 03:12:14 PM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #30 on: March 13, 2015, 11:31:20 AM »
Or maybe it can if we start a poll on here.
I'm pretty sure polling people viewing a Second Amendment "Legal and Activism" forum won't survive the "random selection of subjects" test. But all polls have "flaws", especially noted by people opposing the results of the poll, so...  :shaka:

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #31 on: March 15, 2015, 06:51:38 AM »
A couple of comments on why the GSS has unusually low numbers of gun owning households.

Guns in America: While ownership falls, sales remain strong

Published Thursday, Mar. 12 2015, 12:01 AM EDT

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/world/a-losing-gun-fight-in-america/article23411490/

Excerpts:

But within the data, there is a more complex story. For years, the General Social Survey tended to show a significantly lower rate of gun ownership in the United States than many other surveys – a discrepancy that may be explained not by statistics, but by the basic mistrust of authority that appears to be a common denominator among the most fervent pro-gun advocates.

“The only thing I know that’s for sure different between the GSS and other polls is that the GSS is an in-home, face-to-face survey,” said Gary Kleck, a professor of criminology and criminal justice at Florida State University. “What that does is make it a non-anonymous survey. You may say gun owners are paranoid for thinking it, but they think governments – and in particular the federal government – are out to get their guns.”
.....
Does everyone agree that it's declining?

Not entirely. “The big challenge for me looking at these numbers is that you have to be confident that people are going to report their gun ownership accurately,” said Samuel Bieler, research associate at the independent and non-partisan think tank Urban Institute in Washington. “And I think it’s an open question as to whether if a gun owner is already suspicious of someone’s motive for collecting firearm information, whether they’d be willing to do that,” he added. There are also Gallup surveys that point to spikes in gun ownership in recent years. “There’s enough noise and enough countervailing explanations that to me, the jury is really still in some ways out on the full amount of gun ownership,” said Mr. Bieler.
.....
The survey also pointed out that an increasing number of Americans believe gun ownership protects people from crime. In December, 2012, 48 per cent held that position. Two years after Newtown, 57 per cent believed guns save people from becoming victims of crime.

The findings present a paradox, according to Ms. Carlson.

“How is it that people are increasingly imagining guns as tools of safety rather than tools of violence? How is that possible even when you see this decline in ownership?” she asked.

“I think it’s because what we’re seeing is not the decline of American gun culture. We’re seeing the transformation of American gun culture from a hunting oriented gun culture to a gun culture where guns are about protection,” she added.

causa mortis

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #32 on: March 15, 2015, 01:15:10 PM »
The last sentence in your post is the underlying point - Americans are becoming more and more urbanized, and as such, they're buying guns for home/self defense rather than hunting purposes. That being the case, I think it's more than likely that the self defense crowd would be more leery of disclosing their ownership in ANY polls.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #33 on: March 15, 2015, 01:44:26 PM »
I didn't assume that. But okay.

You apparently entirely missed the point of my question to eyeeatingfish, but nevertheless...

Alright, given your vast academic knowledge of statistics, please answer the following questions and give us your margin of error and level of confidence, with references.

How many households in the U.S. have firearms?
How many total firearms are in those households?
What, exactly, is the measurable criminal deterrent effect of those firearms, and how does it vary by region where there are higher vs. lower total guns, total guns vs. guns per household, and CCW rate (please specify how you determined how many people are carrying how often)?

Thanks.

Gonna have to back up Maui on this one. What he is talking about is a scientific method of gathering and analyzing data. It is not going to give you a perfectly accurate answer but when done properly you can obtain a fairly accurate measurement even on many questions that seem like you wouldn't be able to answer. The margins of error aren't just made up either, they have been studied and methods have been developed so as to reduce the margin of error as much as possible. I mentioned this earlier when I said that when a study is anonymous people are more likely to answer questions accurately. A face to face interview will leave you with a less accurate number than an anonymous mailed survey. Additionally the way questions are worded can have an effect on the accuracy of questionaire answers.

However just because he is well versed in the science of statistical analyses doesn't mean he is going to know the answer to just any statistical query you might make. These are questions that can be answered using statistical anylses and proper statistics gathering methods.

It is important that when we look at a statistic we analyze the method used to gather the data to ensure that it was gathered in a way that gives us an accurate result. When you learn about statistical analyses, data gathering, and questionaire writing you are able to look statistics and recognize some strengths or weaknesses of the presented data without even going in depth. For example if you asked 10 people a political question about a national issue I can already know that your data set is not going to be reliable because the sample size is too small given the size of the population being studied.

Now if you want those specific questions answered someone would have to do a study that adresses those questions. Such a study might have been done already. Certainly we know by this discussion that at least two sources have attempted to measure how many households have firearms. Whether they are accurate is a separate question. However if they were done properly they are likely accurate to within a few percent.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #34 on: March 15, 2015, 02:01:23 PM »
I disagree.  It's not how many guns or who has them, but whether you are comparing short term trends or long term.

While the numbers in the article are showing a drop from last year, look at the article I posted using the same report.  It paints a much different picture and doesn't leave the reader to draw their own inaccurate conclusions.

There is nothing scientific about using a one year, five year, ten year or twenty year period for comparison.  An honest analysis will look for significant changes that affect gun ownership and use that as a demarcation point between periods.  Either that, or they will exclude small periods that contain significant data outliers to avoid unfairly skewing the data.

So, does a slowdown in sales and registrations, or a smaller number of registered guns in one year compared to the previous, really mean shooting interest has dwindled?

I suggest a look at the amount of ammo and reloading components and equipment purchased each year would be a better measure of interest than whether people buy a new gun every year.  Consumables are going to be more indicative of shooting activity, and therefore interest.

Studying consumables is probably a good way to measure practice and therefore interest in firearms but I don't think it will show an accurate number of how many people own firearms and that is what I am really after. This bit of data is what is going to make or break the validity of the "more guns = less crime" argument.

A study of how many people train regularly and how many people CCW would be useful though when discussing whether firearms prevent crime.

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #35 on: March 15, 2015, 03:03:36 PM »
Gonna have to back up Maui on this one. What he is talking about is a scientific method of gathering and analyzing data. It is not going to give you a perfectly accurate answer but when done properly you can obtain a fairly accurate measurement even on many questions that seem like you wouldn't be able to answer.

So if you believe what you wrote above, then why are you asking any questions about how many people and/or households possess firearms? If those polls you reference are "scientific", then you already have your "fairly accurate measurement". What, "fairly accurate" isn't accurate enough? You seem to want it both ways. If you've studied the methodology of those polls and concluded they are are NOT "scientific", and/or not methodologically sound, then why are you defending polls as being "scientific"?


The margins of error aren't just made up either, they have been studied and methods have been developed so as to reduce the margin of error as much as possible.

Right. So you believe the discrepancy in poll numbers re gun ownership is attributable to what? If you believe that the "margin of error" is "scientific", and polls reach different numbers that are outside the "margin of error" of the other polls, how do you explain that? How do you account for the fact that none of the IPCC referenced studies substantiating anthropogenic global warming yielded anything even close to a "margin of error" that would account for no warming for the past 15 years?

I mentioned this earlier when I said that when a study is anonymous people are more likely to answer questions accurately. A face to face interview will leave you with a less accurate number than an anonymous mailed survey.

Are you sure? Every single question ever asked in anonymous polling has always revealed a more accurate assessment than any face to face polling? How much "more likely"? To what degree under what conditions? References? Or is this some "common sense" conclusion you've reached outside the realm of "science"?

Additionally the way questions are worded can have an effect on the accuracy of questionaire answers.

However just because he is well versed in the science of statistical analyses doesn't mean he is going to know the answer to just any statistical query you might make. These are questions that can be answered using statistical anylses and proper statistics gathering methods.

Given the contradictions in polling numbers, which one(s) are correct/"proper", and which ones "unscientific"/improper/wrong? If the academicians who study the questions involved and statistical analysis cannot agree, how are YOU going to decide?

It is important that when we look at a statistic we analyze the method used to gather the data to ensure that it was gathered in a way that gives us an accurate result. When you learn about statistical analyses, data gathering, and questionaire writing you are able to look statistics and recognize some strengths or weaknesses of the presented data without even going in depth. For example if you asked 10 people a political question about a national issue I can already know that your data set is not going to be reliable because the sample size is too small given the size of the population being studied.

Now if you want those specific questions answered someone would have to do a study that adresses those questions.

Such studies have been quoted above, some by you, yet you don't seem to be satisfied by the answers, even though you defend them as "scientific".

Such a study might have been done already. Certainly we know by this discussion that at least two sources have attempted to measure how many households have firearms. Whether they are accurate is a separate question. However if they were done properly they are likely accurate to within a few percent.

So if those few percent are outside the margin of error for either or both polls, what is your "'scientific" explanation? And please outline why you believe that the polls re firearm ownership CAN be accurate, given all the (unknown?) variables and the fact that many people clearly state that they would not give accurate answers to any such polling questions regardless of how supposedly "anonymous" the poll is. You're just trusting that the polling and statistical analyses were done "scientifically" and accurately without any errors or built-in prejudices? Please give us your scientific assessment of the accuracy of the two main polls cited above.

aieahound

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #36 on: March 15, 2015, 05:30:49 PM »
Scientific margin of error ?

Have you checked the poll on how would you answer ?

The last sentence in your post is the underlying point - Americans are becoming more and more urbanized, and as such, they're buying guns for home/self defense rather than hunting purposes. That being the case, I think it's more than likely that the self defense crowd would be more leery of disclosing their ownership in ANY polls.

+1

Massive variable on disclosure. Calculate the margin of error based on our poll.

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #37 on: March 15, 2015, 06:49:28 PM »
Massive variable on disclosure. Calculate the margin of error based on our poll.
If you count the forum poll answers "No" (34.5%) and "None of your got damn business" 48.3%) as being from gun owners/households that are "reluctant" to reveal their ownership, then added to the 32% of the GSS poll respondents who admitted to being a household with a gun, that means 114.8% of Americans/American households have guns. What's the margin of error and confidence level on that number?  :shaka:

eyeeatingfish

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #38 on: March 16, 2015, 10:45:12 PM »
Puna,
I have not studied the methods used in this particular survey so I don't know how accurate the results are. And I did not defend them as scientific. What I have been trying to explain is that a survey CAN BE designed to effectively minimize margins of error and provide an accurate answer. We shouldn't just dismiss data we don't like by claiming that survey statistics cannot be accurate.

The reason I ask the question is because I don't have all the data. I don't know about every survey done on the topic. By starting this thread we can share information, we can learn about conflicting data and about supporting data.  As for what would account for the differences between two different surveys, I don't know, I haven't seen how the surveys were conducted. Some possible reasons could be anonymity, sample size, how the question was worded, method of collection, etc but I am just speculating. If the data was gathered poorly then we can dismiss the results it but if it was gathered correctly when my original question deserves discussion.

I don't recall how much a lack of anonymity can affect survey results, I just know that it has been shown that people are less likely to answer honestly on questions about sensitive issues. And no, it is not common sense, I studied this in college as part of my sociology degree.

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #39 on: March 17, 2015, 07:27:40 AM »
Puna,
I have not studied the methods used in this particular survey so I don't know how accurate the results are. And I did not defend them as scientific. What I have been trying to explain is that a survey CAN BE designed to effectively minimize margins of error and provide an accurate answer. We shouldn't just dismiss data we don't like by claiming that survey statistics cannot be accurate.

The reason I ask the question is because I don't have all the data. I don't know about every survey done on the topic. By starting this thread we can share information, we can learn about conflicting data and about supporting data.  As for what would account for the differences between two different surveys, I don't know, I haven't seen how the surveys were conducted. Some possible reasons could be anonymity, sample size, how the question was worded, method of collection, etc but I am just speculating. If the data was gathered poorly then we can dismiss the results it but if it was gathered correctly when my original question deserves discussion.

I don't recall how much a lack of anonymity can affect survey results, I just know that it has been shown that people are less likely to answer honestly on questions about sensitive issues. And no, it is not common sense, I studied this in college as part of my sociology degree.
I don't understand why you are discussing this issue and asking about "accurate" and/or "scientific" data and yet admit that you won't take the time to investigate the existing contradictory data (while claiming to have some background in issues that would allow you to make such determinations). Do you want the "truth", as you claim, or do you have some other agenda? Whenever someone presents a point of view about these issues you take a contrary position based upon hypotheticals and then say "I don't know if that is true or not". Well f*cking find out, or shut up.

You obviously must know that there are vast numbers of studies about firearm ownership and/or CCW and the consequence of those rates on defensive gun uses and rates of criminal acts, most famously is John Lott's work, including "More Guns, Less Crime". That book of research by two university professors was published in 1998. You've had almost 17 years to study that book, its revised and updated editions, and the dozens of critical and supportive studies, reports, and papers submitted in response to the information and hypotheses in the book. Yet, in those 17 years you haven't gotten around to looking at the data and coming to some conclusion that will aid you in making sound arguments using that data re the advisability of law-abiding American citizens owning and/or carrying weapons, It appears that you really aren't that interested in finding out the "truth" as you claim. What's the problem?

Or, perhaps you want to claim that since academics, who spend their entire lives conducting research and studying these questions, continue to disagree, that there is no "truth" and all the research is flawed in one way or another or to one degree or another, and therefore no one can draw a reasonably accurate conclusion with any degree of certainty? But, no, you don't. You claim that you (or someone else who you can read and study) have the ability to analyze research methodology and determine the degree of reliability or "accuracy" of particular conclusions. So why don't you do that? I don't get it. Please spare me the "I just want the truth so I can evaluate the arguments for and against implementing Second Amendment rights".