Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork (Read 11818 times)

Bunker

Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« on: March 15, 2015, 05:54:14 PM »
Thought I'd share this as it's pretty disturbing to me. A guy on another forum from Washington state was filling out a mandatory form at his doctor's office. The first part asks about all the family history...ok normal stuff. However, the second part asks three specific questions related to firearms. Others in this state confirmed this as well.

First question: Do you support the 2nd amendment?
Second question: Do you have any guns in your house?
Third Question: Do you keep your guns loaded?

Yes to all you sorry fucks...this shit is getting out of hand! Asking "Do you support the 2nd Amendment?"...WTF, yes I support the Constitution of the United States and it's none of their damn business.




ren

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #1 on: March 15, 2015, 05:57:29 PM »
those questions are not mandatory. I would leave those blank. They have no business asking those questions. Not health related at all. They should ask you if you are a US citizen who pays taxes and ask if you came here legally.
Deeds Not Words

Bunker

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #2 on: March 15, 2015, 06:03:38 PM »
I think more disturbing is what are they doing with that info. A few of the health care people chimed in saying a no answer is recorded as well.

macsak

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #3 on: March 15, 2015, 06:47:59 PM »
I think more disturbing is what are they doing with that info. A few of the health care people chimed in saying a no answer is recorded as well.

...i refuse to answer on the grounds that i may incriminate myself...

dogman

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #4 on: March 15, 2015, 07:13:10 PM »
...i refuse to answer on the grounds that i may incriminate myself...
But of course "no one on this forum does anything illegal..."    :)

macsak

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #5 on: March 15, 2015, 07:28:39 PM »
But of course "no one on this forum does anything illegal..."    :)

the emphasis is on MAY incriminate
 :wave:

eyeeatingfish

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #6 on: March 16, 2015, 11:08:24 AM »
Just guessing here but it is possible that this is just an attempt to gather information so as to have a better idea of how many guns there are in the state.

From a simple data gathering aspect it makes sense. Rather than having to spend lots of time and money mailing out forms it is just included on a form already given to a large portion of the population. Also since it is in a doctor's setting I think people would be more likely to answer it than from some random person an individual might not know. Just saying it makes sense from a data gathering standpoint and need not be some government tracking it's citizens evil plan.

They should check for disclaimers on the form to see whether the information would be shared and to what extent. For example it might be that doctors just add up the numbers and submit the numbers as a piece of data without any personal information. I don't know if the doctors would even be allowed to share the names of their patients with the government. A doctor can share that X% of his patients suffer from this or that but he cannot say that Tom and Shelly suffer from this or that. If the data is compiled and remains anonymous I would not worry. My kid's pediatrician did ask whether I owned firearms and I hesitatnly said yes. She then stressed the importance of keeping firearms secure from kids. Don't know if she tabulated anything but she did seem to have a sincere interest in keeping the kids safe so I was not too bothered.

mauidog

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #7 on: March 16, 2015, 12:34:51 PM »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Heavies

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #8 on: March 16, 2015, 01:34:11 PM »
IMO, they are trying to make gun ownership classified as some sort of disease.   Then, no problem taking your stuff. You know... cause you're sick.... it's for the children!   


Didn't o bola's surgeon general already say some such?  I wouldn't be surprised this is a requirement in o bola care, to ask these questions.

mauidog

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #9 on: March 16, 2015, 02:24:36 PM »
IMO, they are trying to make gun ownership classified as some sort of disease.   Then, no problem taking your stuff. You know... cause you're sick.... it's for the children!   


Didn't o bola's surgeon general already say some such?  I wouldn't be surprised this is a requirement in o bola care, to ask these questions.

Actually, it's the reverse, then that was reversed!

The NRA fought to have a firearm clause in Obolacare to prevent this exact thing from happening.  Physicians are not firearm safety experts, and neither are they firearm statistic or ownership data-gatherers for the Feds.

So, the original OCare had language that prevented doctrors from asking these questions UNLESS of course the doc had reason to believe, through conversations, the information had a direct relationship with the patient's safety or the saffety of others.

After Sandy Hook, Oblamo took his infamous pen and signed an executive order that made it okay for doctors to voluntarily ask these questions of their patients in order to assess the safety of children in their patients' homes.  The information is not to be released to any Fed agencies, including health and human services, law enforcement, CDC, or organizations doing studies.  The information is supposed to be governed under doctor-patient confidentiality.  In fact, the guidance says they should not even record the answers in their records, but we all know if you fill out a form, the HMO has a place in their database to enter the answers so the doctor can pull it up on their computer screen.

Now comes the backdoor into this information.  You go apply for a permit, and to do so, YOU GIVE YOUR CONSENT for your doctor to share your information with law enforcement.  Once they have that permission, it's ambiguous how much information a doctor might be inclined to divulge.  Now your data is in the hands of an agency that has no ethical responsibility to keep your data private.

Never take a data-collection survey at face value.  At some point, you'll knowingly or unknowingly allow that information to fall into the very hands you hoped to keep it out of!
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

BigBlue

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #10 on: April 03, 2015, 11:27:23 PM »
Doctors could always ask questions of their patients. If they ask you and you don't want to discuss it - don't!

This really isn't as shadow government conspiracy as you're making it out to be. In the real world if your mission is health, then asking questions about risks is just sensible. If someone's fat then asking questions about diet and exercise are reasonable. Lots of sunburns? Buy a hat. Own firearms? Use them safely.

Honestly if you worked with any level of government and knew how stovepiped their databases are you'd find this notion of doctors acting as sensors for a giant firearms database hilarious.

edster48

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #11 on: April 04, 2015, 06:32:46 AM »
Doctors could always ask questions of their patients. If they ask you and you don't want to discuss it - don't!

This really isn't as shadow government conspiracy as you're making it out to be. In the real world if your mission is health, then asking questions about risks is just sensible. If someone's fat then asking questions about diet and exercise are reasonable. Lots of sunburns? Buy a hat. Own firearms? Use them safely.

Honestly if you worked with any level of government and knew how stovepiped their databases are you'd find this notion of doctors acting as sensors for a giant firearms database hilarious.

Then why aren't they asking if I own and drive a car? My chances of being injured in an automobile accident are far greater than an incident involving firearms.

Why aren't they asking if I surf or hike? Again, activities that are more likely to lead to injury than firearms { 50 hiking rescues in HI so far this year, and I believe 2 deaths }

Not coincidentally, the question of whether or not one supports the second amendment can only be construed as being politically motivated. There is simply no other reason to ask about it.

Sorry, but this is an all too obvious attempt to gain information on a specific subset of individuals because of their support of the Constitution and gun rights.

If the NSA can track millions of phone conversations and internet data I'm sure they can correlate and store this kind of information for future use.

What they want to use it for is the relevant question.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

punaperson

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #12 on: April 04, 2015, 07:10:40 AM »
Then why aren't they asking if I own and drive a car? My chances of being injured in an automobile accident are far greater than an incident involving firearms.

Why aren't they asking if I surf or hike? Again, activities that are more likely to lead to injury than firearms { 50 hiking rescues in HI so far this year, and I believe 2 deaths }

Not coincidentally, the question of whether or not one supports the second amendment can only be construed as being politically motivated. There is simply no other reason to ask about it.

Sorry, but this is an all too obvious attempt to gain information on a specific subset of individuals because of their support of the Constitution and gun rights.

If the NSA can track millions of phone conversations and internet data I'm sure they can correlate and store this kind of information for future use.

What they want to use it for is the relevant question.
Exactly. Not to mention asking about whether you have and use a ladder, or swimming pool, or bathtub, or stairs. etc. The idea that asking about the Second Amendment in any way is health-related is preposterous... unless they're allowing for the possibility that the information might be used for a 4 AM no-knock confiscation raid, in which case your health will definitely be in jeopardy.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #13 on: April 04, 2015, 09:30:49 AM »
Then why aren't they asking if I own and drive a car? My chances of being injured in an automobile accident are far greater than an incident involving firearms.

Why aren't they asking if I surf or hike? Again, activities that are more likely to lead to injury than firearms { 50 hiking rescues in HI so far this year, and I believe 2 deaths }

Not coincidentally, the question of whether or not one supports the second amendment can only be construed as being politically motivated. There is simply no other reason to ask about it.

Sorry, but this is an all too obvious attempt to gain information on a specific subset of individuals because of their support of the Constitution and gun rights.

If the NSA can track millions of phone conversations and internet data I'm sure they can correlate and store this kind of information for future use.

What they want to use it for is the relevant question.

Bigblue has a good point. Whether prompted by the government or by some sort of doctors association your doctor is more concerned about your health than a government watchlist. My kid's pediatrician asked if we own guns, why? Perhaps it had soemthing to do with children who die because their parents didn't store their guns safely? Likewise if a doctor knew you rode a motorcycle and didn't see a helmet he/she might suggest a helmet.

Sure it is possibly a way of gathering gun ownership data but this isn't some kind of secret list so the government can take all your guns. If you are that worried just don't answer or better yet ask what the doctor is going to do with that information. Chances are it is protected information. Data gathering doesn't always have to be sinister.

mauidog

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #14 on: April 04, 2015, 11:51:37 AM »
Bigblue has a good point. Whether prompted by the government or by some sort of doctors association your doctor is more concerned about your health than a government watchlist. My kid's pediatrician asked if we own guns, why? Perhaps it had soemthing to do with children who die because their parents didn't store their guns safely? Likewise if a doctor knew you rode a motorcycle and didn't see a helmet he/she might suggest a helmet.

Sure it is possibly a way of gathering gun ownership data but this isn't some kind of secret list so the government can take all your guns. If you are that worried just don't answer or better yet ask what the doctor is going to do with that information. Chances are it is protected information. Data gathering doesn't always have to be sinister.

If this was a SECRET LIST, what makes you think you would know about it?  It's SECRET!!   :crazy:

And when you say "Chances are it is protected information," I get worried.  All doctor-patient information is supposed to be protected.  If I have to rely on some CHANCE that it's protected, then I'm not going to volunteer anything.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #15 on: April 04, 2015, 12:22:50 PM »
If this was a SECRET LIST, what makes you think you would know about it?  It's SECRET!!   :crazy:

And when you say "Chances are it is protected information," I get worried.  All doctor-patient information is supposed to be protected.  If I have to rely on some CHANCE that it's protected, then I'm not going to volunteer anything.

Don't you think there would be at least one Washington doctor who liked guns who would stand up and say if something fishy was going on? At least one gun loving doctor who would tell everyone that if the government was requiring him to collect data on gun ownership and 2A opinions?

I am not a doctor so I cannot speak from experience but from having read through what doctors are allowed to share I have discovered that they can share anecdotal stories so as to be able to teach or converse about a medical issue however they are not allowed to share details that would identify the patient. Thus a doctor couldn't say john and jack have cancer but he could say two of his patients have cancer. So if a doctor compiled data on his patient's opinions about firearms he could share that x% have guns but not say john has a gun and jack doesn't. That is my understanding but I don't know if there are any technicalities that would allow for otherwise thus I said chances are because I don't want to give an absolute and be wrong.

Bottom line is if you don't want to answer then don't. If you want to know why they asked then just ask.

mauidog

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #16 on: April 04, 2015, 12:39:35 PM »
Don't you think there would be at least one Washington doctor who liked guns who would stand up and say if something fishy was going on? At least one gun loving doctor who would tell everyone that if the government was requiring him to collect data on gun ownership and 2A opinions?

I am not a doctor so I cannot speak from experience but from having read through what doctors are allowed to share I have discovered that they can share anecdotal stories so as to be able to teach or converse about a medical issue however they are not allowed to share details that would identify the patient. Thus a doctor couldn't say john and jack have cancer but he could say two of his patients have cancer. So if a doctor compiled data on his patient's opinions about firearms he could share that x% have guns but not say john has a gun and jack doesn't. That is my understanding but I don't know if there are any technicalities that would allow for otherwise thus I said chances are because I don't want to give an absolute and be wrong.

Bottom line is if you don't want to answer then don't. If you want to know why they asked then just ask.

I don't care how much one doctor in Washington loves guns.

1.  Doctors are not firearm safety professionals.

2.  Doctors are not supposed to counsel you on all your hobbies and other activities.  They are not experts on motorcycle safety, skateboard safety, auto safety, etc.  Doctors have no special information giving them keener insight into safety than anyone else.  Their specialties are general & internal medicine, pediatrics, podiatry, etc.  They may have personal opinions about what's safe and what's not, but that's not for them to try and impose on their patients.  Suppose hang gliding comes up in conversation.  Hang gliding is inherently dangerous.  Would the doctor have safety tips for the hang glider?  Or would the doctor feel obligated to try and talk the patient out of continuing that sport? 

I contend it is not the doctor's area or place to be giving me advice on firearm safety.  If I have to hear it from a doctor, then I'm probably not going to rush out and buy a gun safe to protect the kids.  I will have already learned what is required and what is recommended and acted when I acquired the firearm.  If I haven't acted by the time the doctor tells me I'm a danger to my kids, his words will likely change nothing.

3.  The government is taking over our healthcare unless someone stops it.  The way things are headed, there will be no difference between the VA, Medicaid, Medicare, and your personal health coverage.  The government WILL know your medical information, whether you give permission or not.

There are laws to protect private information, but there are also requirements (like acquiring firearms) which force you to give permission to access your health information or be denied a permit.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

edster48

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #17 on: April 04, 2015, 01:19:33 PM »
Bigblue has a good point. Whether prompted by the government or by some sort of doctors association your doctor is more concerned about your health than a government watchlist. My kid's pediatrician asked if we own guns, why? Perhaps it had soemthing to do with children who die because their parents didn't store their guns safely? Likewise if a doctor knew you rode a motorcycle and didn't see a helmet he/she might suggest a helmet.

Sure it is possibly a way of gathering gun ownership data but this isn't some kind of secret list so the government can take all your guns. If you are that worried just don't answer or better yet ask what the doctor is going to do with that information. Chances are it is protected information. Data gathering doesn't always have to be sinister.

Pure Crap.

So, please explain WHY they aren't asking about whether or not I own a motor cycle, or whether I have protective covers on the electrical outlets in my home, or if I have a swimming pool.

WHY???

These questions are directed towards a specific goal: Do you have guns? Further, they want to know if I support the Second Amendment. It doesn't even have to mean I own guns, just that I support the IDEA of free gun ownership as a RIGHT. What, other than identifying me as a supporter of the Constitution, has that got to do with my health?

WHY??

Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #18 on: April 04, 2015, 01:58:15 PM »
Edster, any attempt to answer why would just be speculating.

It is possible that physicians rotate issues they talk about. For example maybe one year all physicians talk about helmets, the next year physicians talk about locking up drugs, and this year was guns?

It raises some red flags but I don't think the truth is that sinsister so I am not that worried. Rest assured though that if the doctor prys into that chunk of my life I will pry back into why he is asking.

edster48

Re: Disturbing WA State Doctor Paperwork
« Reply #19 on: April 04, 2015, 02:09:34 PM »
Edster, any attempt to answer why would just be speculating.

It is possible that physicians rotate issues they talk about. For example maybe one year all physicians talk about helmets, the next year physicians talk about locking up drugs, and this year was guns?

It raises some red flags but I don't think the truth is that sinsister so I am not that worried. Rest assured though that if the doctor prys into that chunk of my life I will pry back into why he is asking.

{ insert annoying buzzer noise } Wrong answer!!

Had you read the OP you would know that we are discussing a MANDATORY FORM being filled out in WA state doctors office.

As the Federal government, through Obamacare { or the ACA if you prefer } is about to become the nations de facto HMO, this is cause for concern.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.