Maui,
I guess it comes down to some technical definitions. Is a slug that is jacketed the same thing as a core or is a core separate from the slug? If the lead slug itself does not count as the core then the steel inside the lead slug of the M855 could be seen as armor piercing whereas if the jacket of the bullet turns anything inside the jacket into the "core" then it obviously does not apply to M855 ammo.
As for the second section does the 5.56 count as a round larger than .22? I would think that if we look at this section by itself then 5.56 or .223 would never be subject to regulation since they are .22 rounds.
So do you think the M855A1 round would qualify under the law since we are not talking about a combo of lead and some other metal?
The new 62-grain (4 g) projectile or bullet used in the M855A1 round has a copper core with a 19-grain (1.2 g) steel "stacked-cone" penetrating tip. The M855A1 cartridge is sometimes referred to as "green ammo" because it fires a lead free projectile
Since those 2 elements are in the list, they qualify as armor piercing under section B(i).
As for the .22 or larger criteria, in math, the insignificant decimal digits are dropped. The value .22 is the same as .220 or .2200. Since .223 > .220, mathematically the .556/.223 round exceeds the .22 limit. However, neither that clause nor the 25% jacket weight limit matter if the round is designed and intended for use in something other than a handgun. My guess is that B(ii) section was added to prevent someone from skirting the regulation by claiming a bullet with a tiny lead core and thick hardened jacket is not AP.
Let's look at this using common sense. How many pistols larger than .22 caliber can you name that use what is ordinarily defined as "rifle ammunition?" I submit the lines between rifle and handgun designs have always been blurred. What ammo does the Tommy Gun normally use? .45. How many lever action rifles use .44 Magum? .357 Magnum? Long Colt .45? How about 9mm and .40 caliber carbines? Uzi pistols in 9MM?
So the introduction of a pistol that can fire rifle ammo is not something the ATF had never seen before since lots of pistols and rifles exist which can share ammo. What's different in this case? Two things. This is a round that was deigned and intended for rifles first not a pistol round being used in a carbine, and, more importantly to the anit-gun whackos, the M855 round is one of the most used types of ammo for the most commonly purchased rifle in the US. If they take a bite out of the AR-15's ammo supply, they are another step closer to their goal of getting rid of these "assault weapons".
We're basically discussing unicorns and leprechauns. I've not been able to find anyone who's ever reported/heard reported that an AR pistol using green tipped ammo was used to defeat law enforcement armor. This is a made-up problem with no footing in reality. Theoretically, anything is possible. But banning a type of ammunition that doesn't even meet the AP criteria is a MAJOR ISSUE. It demonstrates we can not trust government to follow their own guidance or processes. If they are willing to take this route "for safety," then there is really nothing they won't try to do whether it violates the Constitution, infringes on our freedoms, or is blatantly illegal as long as they get their way!