I have a few things to add to this. In a shtf situation you need to be as versatile as possible and carry gear as light as possible.
Therefore
First and foremost is a GOOD multi tool. I cannot stress getting a high quality one any more. I recently purchased a leatherman and it is incredibly versatile. You can start fires with it, you can tighten down or loosen screws, adjust optics, make snares,,,, the list goes on. For less than a pound of weight you can't find a more versatile tool.
Second is a Gerber downrange tomahawk. You can pry with it, chop with it, use it as a hammer, and God forbid you ever need to you can use it as a self defense tool. I seriously reccomend you check it out. It elinates the need for a pry bar, Axe, and hammer.
With these two tools, you literally have elimated the need for 20+ tools in your inventory.
They may be expensive, but I have gotten them both for 50% off,new, from the factory.