Should try many shotgun before you buy. Don't get any that says Magnum. It most likely will not handle light load.
Remington 870, 1100, 1187 are great also. I would buy any Benelli sporting, or M2 for 3 gun, easy shooter and will use any light load. Another thing, the proper stock fitting is important to feel comfortable. I have short arms so I had to shorten several stocks. Have not shot for a long while, currently using my Citori 725 Sporting, shorten stock with recoil system. Keep practicing, you will hit something. Keep both eyes open and follow through with the swing.