Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant) (Read 86978 times)

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #160 on: March 01, 2016, 10:10:32 AM »
You offer a system that has more flaws to replace a system that has fewer flaws.

Taxes are necessary to run a government, there is no beating around that bush. Whether the government abuses its power or its spending of the taxes is a separate issue. At least some level of government is necessary in today's age and it has to be funded somehow.

I wouldn't consider taxes to be theft as long as the taxes are spent on services available to all. So paying for a road, for example, provides a service to everyone, it does not take from one and give to another. You are getting a service in exchange for your property.
What problems? What can possibly show up that isn't already a problem faced by a tax based society?

So if i rob your house and let you watch your tv every now and then it's not theft?

Lets just dismiss your terrible argument concerning roads outright, by asking if you have even driven on the roads made by the government here in hawaii?

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #161 on: March 01, 2016, 10:41:43 AM »


eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #162 on: March 01, 2016, 04:13:29 PM »
What problems? What can possibly show up that isn't already a problem faced by a tax based society?

All the arguments in my previous posts that you ignored. I gave you multiple problems that do not exist under government control.

Under a system where roads are entirely private, you have no freedom to travel. The person who owns the roads can keep you from traveling if they so feel like it.

Quote
Lets just dismiss your terrible argument concerning roads outright, by asking if you have even driven on the roads made by the government here in hawaii?

Your meme is inaccurate. Most people cannot fix the cars in their own garages. The roads are also built by private companies under contract by the government.

Kuleana

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #163 on: March 01, 2016, 06:51:29 PM »
"So You Want To Be a Socialist?"
Video message from Gabe Suarez



First of all, let me say Gabe Suarez is one of the most knowledgeable firearm instructors in the industry, especially being one of the earliest pioneers teaching how to run the AK Platform of rifles.  I am a great admirer of his accomplishments.

However, although I respect his opinion, I would have to disagree with his assessment of socialism and particularly how he equates socialism and communism as being one and the same.  First of all, they are not the same.  They may share certain characteristics, but are very different in final theoretical outcomes.  More importantly, as he justifies his position against socialism by citing socialist/communist nations that he feels failed in their attempts, like most other critics of socialism, he explicitly does not mention CHINA, which is the only socialist country soon to overtake the US in GDP in the upcoming years.

Does he have a point?  Yes.     Is his views of socialism accurate?  Not for all cases.


Kuleana

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #164 on: March 02, 2016, 12:06:17 AM »
All the arguments in my previous posts that you ignored. I gave you multiple problems that do not exist under government control.

Under a system where roads are entirely private, you have no freedom to travel. The person who owns the roads can keep you from traveling if they so feel like it.

Your meme is inaccurate. Most people cannot fix the cars in their own garages. The roads are also built by private companies under contract by the government.

What arguments? Which argument have you brought up that don't already exist as a problem with taxation?

most people can't make the TV's in their homes either, should the government be the one in charge of buying tv's for everyone?
so you're saying the government lets you travel freely without any form of permit, license, and payment?
you should probably look at the image again, who is paying for the roads? who is being held accountable for the shitty roads?

how many more poor excuses are you going to make for theft?

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #165 on: March 02, 2016, 02:45:55 AM »
What arguments? Which argument have you brought up that don't already exist as a problem with taxation?

most people can't make the TV's in their homes either, should the government be the one in charge of buying tv's for everyone?
so you're saying the government lets you travel freely without any form of permit, license, and payment?
you should probably look at the image again, who is paying for the roads? who is being held accountable for the shitty roads?

how many more poor excuses are you going to make for theft?

Read the last two pages, I gave multiple examples.

Ok, I will mention a road example again. Lets say we are in a small community that decide to pave our road and we all chip in. What if one or more does not want to participate in maintaining the road? The rest of you have to pay more. Or lets say one neighbor lets his tree grow too much which in turn breaks up or blocks the road. Too bad for everyone else, its a private road.

If you privatize roads then you take away the ability of people to travel freely. The government does not stop you from traveling freely, public roads ensure people are free to travel. It means that they cannot restrict you from traveling, it does not mean they pay for your means/method of traveling.

The water example I mentioned earlier, and you did not address, was what to do about someone who soils a water source. Say a river runs through our community and part of it cuts through my land. I decide to take a dump in the river contaminating your drinking water supply. Now you have to buy a water treatment system because, hey its a private system.

I also repeatedly pointed out that justice services that serve everyone would cease to exist under your system.

These problems can be eliminated or reduced by a government that is tax funded. Sure, you can find an anecdote story where some administration failed in this or that aspect, but that is not to say that all governments suffer from these problems.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #166 on: March 02, 2016, 10:43:49 AM »
Read the last two pages, I gave multiple examples.

Ok, I will mention a road example again. Lets say we are in a small community that decide to pave our road and we all chip in. What if one or more does not want to participate in maintaining the road? The rest of you have to pay more. Or lets say one neighbor lets his tree grow too much which in turn breaks up or blocks the road. Too bad for everyone else, its a private road.

If you privatize roads then you take away the ability of people to travel freely. The government does not stop you from traveling freely, public roads ensure people are free to travel. It means that they cannot restrict you from traveling, it does not mean they pay for your means/method of traveling.

The water example I mentioned earlier, and you did not address, was what to do about someone who soils a water source. Say a river runs through our community and part of it cuts through my land. I decide to take a dump in the river contaminating your drinking water supply. Now you have to buy a water treatment system because, hey its a private system.

I also repeatedly pointed out that justice services that serve everyone would cease to exist under your system.

These problems can be eliminated or reduced by a government that is tax funded. Sure, you can find an anecdote story where some administration failed in this or that aspect, but that is not to say that all governments suffer from these problems.

All of your problems that only happen in a no tax situation already happen in the current world.

Now you want to talk about government monopoly on water? After Flint, Michigan?
Just how deep in denial are you?

The US doesn't have a justice system; it has a legal system. A legal system that treats people unequally depending on their race, gender, religion, and income levels.

The failures of government aren't anecdotal, they are an everyday occurrence. Compounded by the fact that the way government gets money is through extortion.
To you it's perfectly fine that people be threatened with death for not paying for things you want . You would rather use slavery to avoid the inconvenience of consent and cooperation.



aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #167 on: March 02, 2016, 11:03:46 AM »
First and foremost: Would a private system be cheaper and equitable ?

(All private (read no public) schools, roads, law enforcement, fire dept. Legal system. even private legislation for laws. We would have to pay to vote. And pay our legislator or else we would all have to vote on every piece of legislation/law, for which we would have to pay to vote and have results tallied. )

how would common expenses be billed and dispersed ? How would common contracts be bid and chosen ?
Who would the companies submit the bids to ?

Can everyone opt out of anything they don't want ? Would there then be a private system of enforcement to ensure they don't try to utilize services opted out of ?

These are very specific questions. The rhetoric sounds good but the specifics still not answered.

It seems you have a utopian ideal that people are honorable.
Again, sounds like Karl Marx in reverse.

But I'm still interested on the specifics. Could it actually work ?
« Last Edit: March 02, 2016, 11:21:08 AM by aieahound »

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #168 on: March 02, 2016, 01:15:02 PM »
First and foremost: Would a private system be cheaper and equitable ?

(All private (read no public) schools, roads, law enforcement, fire dept. Legal system. even private legislation for laws. We would have to pay to vote. And pay our legislator or else we would all have to vote on every piece of legislation/law, for which we would have to pay to vote and have results tallied. )

how would common expenses be billed and dispersed ? How would common contracts be bid and chosen ?
Who would the companies submit the bids to ?

Can everyone opt out of anything they don't want ? Would there then be a private system of enforcement to ensure they don't try to utilize services opted out of ?

These are very specific questions. The rhetoric sounds good but the specifics still not answered.

It seems you have a utopian ideal that people are honorable.
Again, sounds like Karl Marx in reverse.

But I'm still interested on the specifics. Could it actually work ?

Are government services equitable? If walmart decides to make a new rule are you forced to use walmart and follow their rules?
What is more equitable than everyone getting what they paid for?
How is anything paid for when bought on the private market?
How do companies advertise their goods and services?

How does any business ensure only paying customers get access to their services?

A Utopian ideal is thinking that because people can't be honorable we should have a system of government that lets those very same dishonorable people vote on who gets to have all the power over everyone. It is Utopian to think that we can just give a select few the power to point guns at everyone and rob us to pay for services that we supposedly need but can't find a way to pay for them without taxes, even though we seem perfectly able to find a way to pay for trillions of dollars worth of other things without taxes directly paying for them.

There is no perfect answer for how everything will work, because there is no way for any one person to have perfect knowledge. I can tell you that using the threat of violence to get things done isn't by any means a good system, especially when the very ones the promise to do violence to us are the ones that are supposed to keep themselves in check.

« Last Edit: March 02, 2016, 01:27:21 PM by Aegis808 »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #169 on: March 02, 2016, 05:40:02 PM »
All of your problems that only happen in a no tax situation already happen in the current world.

No, they don't and I have already pointed out many examples. Anyone from the richest to the poorest can call 911 and get police service. Anyone from the richest to the poorest can walk down a public street.
You didn't address any of my specific scenarios. Take the example of my tree growing and blocking or damaging the road. The government can do many things in response, from fining the individual, regulating the types of trees that are planted close to the street, requiring the owner to keep the tree trimmed, etc.

Quote
Now you want to talk about government monopoly on water? After Flint, Michigan?
Just how deep in denial are you?

Anecdote.

Quote
The US doesn't have a justice system; it has a legal system. A legal system that treats people unequally depending on their race, gender, religion, and income levels.

Sometimes, yes, but a private system will ensure you get far worse treatment (unless you are rich). If you cannot afford a police service you essentially get no justice. You are complaining about the current system by suggesting a system that will be worse.

Quote
The failures of government aren't anecdotal, they are an everyday occurrence. Compounded by the fact that the way government gets money is through extortion.
To you it's perfectly fine that people be threatened with death for not paying for things you want . You would rather use slavery to avoid the inconvenience of consent and cooperation.

Last I checked no one was executed for not paying their taxes. The government is necessary for a large society and it costs money to run so some amount of taxation is necessary. If you think your completely private system will be free of people taking your money then you are not thinking it through. A private system will take your money against your will whether by limiting your freedom or by sheer force of something akin to the mafia or street gang offering "protection." At least in our current situation we have a voice.

You continue to refuse to answer any of the actual criticisms that multiple people have brought up. Your only argument for your system is that there are problems in our current system. You don't have to have all the knowledge of how such a system will work but you should be able to answer the most basic of criticisms that we have brought up.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #170 on: March 02, 2016, 06:25:36 PM »
No, they don't and I have already pointed out many examples. Anyone from the richest to the poorest can call 911 and get police service. Anyone from the richest to the poorest can walk down a public street.
You didn't address any of my specific scenarios. Take the example of my tree growing and blocking or damaging the road. The government can do many things in response, from fining the individual, regulating the types of trees that are planted close to the street, requiring the owner to keep the tree trimmed, etc.

Anecdote.

Sometimes, yes, but a private system will ensure you get far worse treatment (unless you are rich). If you cannot afford a police service you essentially get no justice. You are complaining about the current system by suggesting a system that will be worse.

Last I checked no one was executed for not paying their taxes. The government is necessary for a large society and it costs money to run so some amount of taxation is necessary. If you think your completely private system will be free of people taking your money then you are not thinking it through. A private system will take your money against your will whether by limiting your freedom or by sheer force of something akin to the mafia or street gang offering "protection." At least in our current situation we have a voice.

You continue to refuse to answer any of the actual criticisms that multiple people have brought up. Your only argument for your system is that there are problems in our current system. You don't have to have all the knowledge of how such a system will work but you should be able to answer the most basic of criticisms that we have brought up.

the government isn't necessary for anything. Name one thing the government provides that isn't a good or service offered in the market.
Why is it that any evidence I show is an anecdote and everything that you imagine will happen is hard fact?
Your voice means nothing if there are more people that vote against your voice.

You want to be a slave that's your choice, don't go around forcing your opinions on everyone else. Don't go advocating to making everyone a slave for your desires.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #171 on: March 02, 2016, 06:37:29 PM »
i would also like to add that every single one of your "problems" of my no tax system is pure speculation.
Making my evidence that you consider "anecdotal"the only form of valid argumentation brought to the table.
Merely stating something is necessary isn't proof of it being necessary. Point out why government is necessary.
Last I saw, the police were being called to hospitals to pull out sick people and watch them die on the streets.
so much for equity through taxation.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #172 on: March 03, 2016, 06:34:28 AM »
the government isn't necessary for anything. Name one thing the government provides that isn't a good or service offered in the market.
Why is it that any evidence I show is an anecdote and everything that you imagine will happen is hard fact?
Your voice means nothing if there are more people that vote against your voice.

You want to be a slave that's your choice, don't go around forcing your opinions on everyone else. Don't go advocating to making everyone a slave for your desires.

I would also like to add that every single one of your "problems" of my no tax system is pure speculation.
Making my evidence that you consider "anecdotal"the only form of valid argumentation brought to the table.
Merely stating something is necessary isn't proof of it being necessary. Point out why government is necessary.
Last I saw, the police were being called to hospitals to pull out sick people and watch them die on the streets.
so much for equity through taxation.

You use the example of Flint as evidence that the government cannot run the water system. This is an anecdote because it is a single example that doesn't necessarily represent any sort of widespread problem. You ignore all the successful government run water systems. And you also ignore that a completely free market would have no problem selling you polluted water if it thought it could make a profit.

Justice and law and order are not things that the market can effectively provide. Sure, you can hire private security but who will put a thief behind bars? Your privately hired police? What happens when your privately hired police force attempts to arrest an individual who is being protected by another privately hired police force? What happens if you cannot afford a private police service?

You still did not address any of the specific problems I pointed out. Take the road maintenance issue and actually try to explain how your system would deal with it. Try to answer any of the 3 examples I gave you. Answer them directly by saying how your proposed system would address these issues. Till now your answers have all been vague. You sound like a politician who has no answers about how their system will work but just points out the problems of other people's plans. Reality is that no system is perfect but you are not doing anything to sell your plan as being better than what we have now.

Police pulling people out of hospitals and letting them die on the street, if actually true, would absolutely happen under a completely private system. No payment, no service. Why do you expect that your anarchy system would not face this problem?

Your utopia is not possible, not in a large community. Sure, keep your income so that no government "steals" it through taxation, but watch as others actually steal it in your anarchy system.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #173 on: March 03, 2016, 10:56:55 AM »
You use the example of Flint as evidence that the government cannot run the water system. This is an anecdote because it is a single example that doesn't necessarily represent any sort of widespread problem. You ignore all the successful government run water systems. And you also ignore that a completely free market would have no problem selling you polluted water if it thought it could make a profit.

Justice and law and order are not things that the market can effectively provide. Sure, you can hire private security but who will put a thief behind bars? Your privately hired police? What happens when your privately hired police force attempts to arrest an individual who is being protected by another privately hired police force? What happens if you cannot afford a private police service?

You still did not address any of the specific problems I pointed out. Take the road maintenance issue and actually try to explain how your system would deal with it. Try to answer any of the 3 examples I gave you. Answer them directly by saying how your proposed system would address these issues. Till now your answers have all been vague. You sound like a politician who has no answers about how their system will work but just points out the problems of other people's plans. Reality is that no system is perfect but you are not doing anything to sell your plan as being better than what we have now.

Police pulling people out of hospitals and letting them die on the street, if actually true, would absolutely happen under a completely private system. No payment, no service. Why do you expect that your anarchy system would not face this problem?

Your utopia is not possible, not in a large community. Sure, keep your income so that no government "steals" it through taxation, but watch as others actually steal it in your anarchy system.

Is California not in a massive drought due to government mismanagement? Did the EPA not ruin the Colorado River by destroying mine runoff containment pools? Let's not ignore the wonders government has done for lake mead. Don't ignore the water problems that we have in our own state that loves to pump millions of gallons of water to private companies while leaving everyone else on Maui stuck with the bill.

My system doesn't rely on government to provide the solution. I'm not pretending to claim government is the answer. Private goods and services are better able to serve everyone than any amount of government can. It's not up to me to decide how things will get fixed. How does any business take care of the problems of maintenance and ensuring paying customers get what they paid for?

I'm not the one claiming utopia, you are. It's Utopian to think everything will be perfect just because you can use violence and slavery to get everyone else to pay for the things you want.

There's no more use in trying to explain it further. If you are for taxation you are for slavery and theft.

aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #174 on: March 03, 2016, 11:19:29 AM »
I agree aegis, this discussion has run it's course.

I'm just bummed you couldn't answer any of my specific questions.
I would have liked to have known the answers.  :(

Jl808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #175 on: March 03, 2016, 11:37:42 AM »
The horse is dead.  Let's agree to disagree.  Thank you for keeping this discussion civil and not resorting to any name calling.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Mauivigilance

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 58
  • Total likes: 11
  • I prefer dangerous freedom over peaceful slavery
  • Referrals: 0
    • View Profile
Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #176 on: March 03, 2016, 05:14:54 PM »
Politics......... Smh....... I have an opinion but ill keep it peacefully to myself.  Lol  :shaka:
The only ism that has not failed me yet is skepticism.....

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #177 on: March 04, 2016, 01:02:06 AM »
I agree aegis, this discussion has run it's course.

I'm just bummed you couldn't answer any of my specific questions.
I would have liked to have known the answers.  :(

I can't give a direct  answer because I don't have perfect knowledge of how everything will work. People get services that they want and can afford. Companies, Coops, mutual trust associations will provide services and good for things that people need and want. IF there is anything to gleam from my stance it's to google Voluntaryism.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #178 on: March 04, 2016, 03:06:14 AM »
Is California not in a massive drought due to government mismanagement? Did the EPA not ruin the Colorado River by destroying mine runoff containment pools? Let's not ignore the wonders government has done for lake mead. Don't ignore the water problems that we have in our own state that loves to pump millions of gallons of water to private companies while leaving everyone else on Maui stuck with the bill.

My system doesn't rely on government to provide the solution. I'm not pretending to claim government is the answer. Private goods and services are better able to serve everyone than any amount of government can. It's not up to me to decide how things will get fixed. How does any business take care of the problems of maintenance and ensuring paying customers get what they paid for?

I'm not the one claiming utopia, you are. It's Utopian to think everything will be perfect just because you can use violence and slavery to get everyone else to pay for the things you want.

There's no more use in trying to explain it further. If you are for taxation you are for slavery and theft.

I try to have an open mind and consider that maybe the plan you propose could in fact work. The thing is that your proposed plan immediately brings up some difficult issues that I don't see how your proposed system could tackle. So I point out these problems genuinely interested in how these more basic obstacles could be overcome.

If you, or anyone, is going to try and change the system, you have to sell it to us and convince us it will work. You cannot just expect us all to eliminate taxes and eliminate government without having any substantial answers to the questions of how the system will work. You don't need to have all the answers but you need to have some answers.

I am not going to repeat my points anymore or make new points that don't get answered. I guess we will have to agree to disagree

Jl808

Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #179 on: March 04, 2016, 08:29:25 AM »
Aegis808, I too was curious like aieahound.

The guy in the video you posted said a statement that stuck to my mind: "government is a monopoly of power".

What this meant to me is that power is placed in the hands of the government to ultimately be the final arbiter of an unresolved issue between individuals using the threat of force.

The constitution, bill of rights, due process, the separation of government powers into 3 branches were put into place to restrain and provide a check and balance against this monopoly of power. (Unfortunately, these restraints are being eroded and ignored, but that is another topic.)

Operating under a common set of laws and having a supposedly neutral judicial system to interpret it, individuals have one arbiter and can find justice through this system.

Without a common law of the land and a single final arbiter, it would be hard to get resolution if one party decides to operate under one set of laws, and the other party operating under another.  If there are 2 private arbiters and they disagree, how could issues be resolved?  If they cannot resolve an issue, then the party with the bigger set of guns, goons and gold wins.

My takeaway from this is that government has a "monopoly" on guns, goons and gold.

That is why the second amendment is in place to provide the collective governed a recourse in the event that the government ultimately becomes oppressive.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.