Ok, lets clarify then, are you talking about pure socialism or are we including systems with socialist elements?
Once again, it makes no difference in any discussion whatsoever. Because once Socialism starts in any society (Pure or Elemental) it continues to grow. It only matters to you (Not anyone else here) at what point in the growth curve of Socialism you want to talk about. Because even if it takes 50, 100, 200 or 300 years more or less it is going to fail. So any example you give will only be applicable for a microcosm of time and will fail at a later point in time. So there is no use even discussing this as Socialism is a huge failure and you have not provided proof otherwise. I am finished discussing this subject with you as you don't provide any content to a discussion. You only provide conclusions based on your limited understandings and then try to debate those conclusions. That is not a discussion.
I have also been wanting to clarify an earlier issue. When you explained the school system that was around when you were younger, the type that was very locally controlled by the PTA and city council and funded with only local city funds, do you consider this socialistic at all?
The problem here EEF is YOUR definition of Socialism is so off base that you really can't see the forest through the trees. Your brainwashing, uh I mean schooling is doing its job. So again for the third and final clear as a bell time the answer to your question is no no no absolutely not!! I don't know how many more times I have to say NO before you stop asking the question. It cannot be and can never be even with your lame attempt at trying to redefine socialism it can never be. Here is why. I keep telling you that in order to understand what democracy was before socialism you need to study our history. Prior to socialism being a part of our democracy the people decided what they wanted the government to do and how they wanted it to be. And the people of Long Beach (But you can insert
any and every city in the U.S. here) decided they wanted schools built for their children and they wanted their own school district. So by the direction of the people the city and county governments set up the taxation program on property owners the way the people scripted it. This is what the people wanted and how the people wanted it to be. The local people gladly and happily paid property taxes in order to gain schools, districts, teachers, etc. Their tax dollars stayed local and was used ONLY to provide for what the people wanted. This is not in any way socialism. This is government of the people, by the people and for the people. A true democracy. There is not even one iota of socialism in this method of government. PERIOD. I don't care how you want to redefine it.
Just because the people ordered the government to actually bill property owners, collect taxes and distribute (
NOT REDISTRIBUTE) the taxes the way they wanted does not make this socialism in any way shape form or manner. It is called democracy. Obviously you don't understand what a true democracy is. Socialism is when the government
redistributes the money taken from the people of one city and/or gives it to another city/county/agency for use other than in their city and for the purpose it was earmarked for. Also, the raising of the same property tax by the government without a vote of the people in order to raise more funding to grow government by
redistributing the money to other parts of the government is socialism. And the government just adding a tax without the consent of the people for general use is socialism. Also, if the people vote for a specific tax to be levied and to be used solely for one purpose and 20 years later those tax dollars get dumped into the general fund and is no longer used exclusively for the purpose that is socialism.
Socialism is
NOT the act of collecting taxes and
distributing the money strictly for its intended purposes. It is only a function of government. It is the ability of the government to control the money without the express permission of the people and the
redistribution of that money that is the difference. You are oversimplifying the definition of socialism in order to make it fit into your understanding.
I know you don't agree with this as it violates everything you have been taught. So I am going to call this discussion quits as I no longer feel is worth my time since you don't provide any content, just conclusions based on your limited understandings. And then you attempt to debate those conclusions. That is not a discussion.
I ask because I am wondering if we are disagreeing not on how the system should be run but on a technicality. I would consider any public school that is funded and controlled by the government to technically be socialistic in that it takes money from people and controls and redistributes it, even if done at the most local of levels.
See my comment above. I am done with this one sided conversation.
In our last go around you tried to patronize me by saying I didn't understand when I never even came close to saying anything like that. You just plain made that up. Just because I don't care (And I was clear as a bell about it) doesn't mean you have to resort to tying to patronize me for whatever your reason was. Now here in this post all you are doing is rehashing all your old questions and trying to reengage and I won't do it anymore. Don't even bother to answer any of this as I no longer care. I tried to give you numerous chances to engage in a two way conversation and you continue to not provide any content. You just try and debate from your own conclusions which so far from my perspective are quite wrong.