This is a topic that is too much of a headache to discuss and I almost always avoid it, but I will give a quick, or maybe not so quick down and dirty.
1) The LE / defensive world, driven by LE, dictates that you must have tritium night sights or you will die. It is so strongly held in LE, that most people will preach it, even if they very little or even no credible low light training. It is one of those indoctrinated beliefs that is firmly entrenched. There is only very very limited situations where one might be benefited by the use of tritium sights and in those instances, we really should have a white light deployed anyway.
2) With modern light technology / reliability, between the possibility of the weapon mounted light in conjunction with a handheld light, the instances are so statistically low for how I might deploy a weapon in a low light situation, that when I personally do risk vs reward assessment, I find the benefits from the fiber optic to be the deciding factor. The tritium inserts are not visible when you deploy a white light source and when the tritium is full glow you can't properly identify or maintain good target ID as it is too dark. This includes the target surroundings especially when things are kinetically dynamic so to speak and people start moving. We cannot just trust our trits and shoot hoping to hit our target as it moves, as we are accountable for all rounds fired with confirmed ID. When the trits do provide a good sight picture / alignment on a target under the correct low lux level (dim lighting), we should really be using a white light anyway, to ensure confirmation, especially this day in age.
3) I have heard all the arguments both ways ad-nauseam and had discussions with IP, SME types and I pretty much avoid the topic like the plague. If one has good modern equipment, combined with good modern technique and tactics it is a wash in low / no light. Then we need to assess what benefits do I get from my sights in other situations when outside light sources exist or in daylight. I don't discount other professionals opinions, but I must base my decisions off of my own experience which does include a lot of low light training on a regular basis.
4) You are starting to see a bit of change on this topic with some well respected people, but most of us who hold this opinion often don't find it worth arguing over. Sorry, I don't mean to imply that I am respected, just there are those that others may respect who share this opinion. But again, there are many who are steadfast and that is OK also and I am not one to preach to others that they should switch to a fiber optic sight.
Edited to add - I have a video from the past that I may upload. It is on my choices on Glock modifications and I talk about the sights that I like to use.
Thank you for the insightful feedback. For me, I try to get at the background and how people came about to their preferences, recommendations, etc. So many people will recommend this or that and either don't have a good reasoning (just regurgitation) or their reasoning doesn't match the needs of the person asking. Certainly appreciate you taking the time to provide feedback!

1) Yeah, that's where most of why I chose a tritium on front sight. From instructors (one in particular) in the past who have steered me that way. My progression on sight preference started with three dots, which came with my first handgun. So for a long time, that's what I was used to. Then I went to the plain/serrated rear sight and where the dots on the rear sight were actually distracting to me. I know for sure one instructor has lots of low/no light training and instruction, but not sure on the others. I personally don't have much. However, I certainly see a lot of "that's how we've always done it" kind of thinking. When I switched from the three tritium dot sights to the tritium front and serrated rear, it was after quite a bit of time going back and forth between the two and deciding for myself.
2) I've done some classes where you doing things with dry guns and very little time with actual shooting. In most of those cases, I recall the only time I really noticed the tritium dot was in low light situation, like just enough light to barely ID something, but not exactly bright. When using white light, I recall only really seeing the silhouette of the sights on the white light background. To the point where I started wondering if I wasn't "doing it right" and wasn't utilizing the tritium dot "feature" properly.
3) I can see how getting into those discussions can be difficult. Up until my recent venture into the fiber optic front sight, I avoided them due to previous experience/reports of the fibers cracking, falling out, etc. Like any technology, seems like it has improved to address those concerns of durability of the sights. While I quietly wondered about their effectiveness in defensive situations, including no/low light, I hadn't had that much first hand experience with them, so I try to maintain an open mind.
4) Now that I've been doing more research on handgun sights, I have noticed more than a few "known SMEs" have posted, articles, videos, etc on benefits/preferences for fiber optic front sights where I recall in the past that their preferences were tritium dot front. Things change, technology gets better and I would hope that people stay current and at least try other stuff on the market. Nowadays, I've come to the realization that while I am open minded on many things, including the finer details in firearms sights, setups, etc, that if someone is deadfast on "their way", so be it. If someone asks me about my preferences, I will certainly share and try to give as much background information on why I chose that way. If you're sure that what you chose is working for you, then awesome. I think much of the butthurt comes when people are looking for confirmation of their preferences, but where it's based more on passed on information as opposed to personal experience. That and there's always those who just like to argue/troll and there's always at least one.
I recall your Glock mods video from back in the day (well, maybe like 2-3 years ago, haha).