Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness? (Read 4796 times)

ren

Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« on: February 12, 2016, 10:52:09 AM »
With all these bills targeting lawful, citizen Joe-gun owners for mental illness and domestic violence let's take a look at a case...



Should that person be denied the right to own/possess a firearm?
Deeds Not Words

z06psi

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #1 on: February 12, 2016, 05:28:17 PM »
Nah.... perfectly legal if you are a cop.  In fact he will be pardoned and promoted.

mauiblue

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #2 on: February 12, 2016, 07:49:40 PM »
Anyone else would have been arrested, convicted, and sentenced to the maximum. But not cops. Double standards and hypocrisy prevails with the police.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #3 on: February 12, 2016, 09:02:44 PM »
Anyone else would have been arrested, convicted, and sentenced to the maximum. But not cops. Double standards and hypocrisy prevails with the police.

He was fired FYI.

He was not convicted because his girlfriend refused to cooperate. Kind of important for the victim to cooperate. Not to mention, the video clearly shows her to be aggressive at one point as well.

They probably both should have been arrested, but only the guy was. Double Standard?

z06psi

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #4 on: February 13, 2016, 08:28:47 AM »
He was fired FYI.

He was not convicted because his girlfriend refused to cooperate. Kind of important for the victim to cooperate. Not to mention, the video clearly shows her to be aggressive at one point as well.

They probably both should have been arrested, but only the guy was. Double Standard?

1.  Should be automatic for any police officer.  Any police officer.

2. So the DA has video evidence on both assaulting each other.  So we turn a blind eye to this cause the "victim" didn't want to cooperate?  They are both perps and should be treated as such.  This is the problem with our criminal justice system and why domestic abuse becomes a lifestyle for many couples.

3. Yes it is.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #5 on: February 13, 2016, 09:56:11 PM »
1.  Should be automatic for any police officer.  Any police officer.

2. So the DA has video evidence on both assaulting each other.  So we turn a blind eye to this cause the "victim" didn't want to cooperate?  They are both perps and should be treated as such.  This is the problem with our criminal justice system and why domestic abuse becomes a lifestyle for many couples.

3. Yes it is.

What we saw was only a partial recording. Their decision to not file charges could be based on other evidence. Part of the question for me when it comes to cases where the abuse is both ways is how many times does one side get to abuse the other before they can defend themselves violently?In the context of the vide, I wonder how many times that girl hit that cop before he lost it and struck back? At what point does the law or courts recognize that nearly everyone has a breaking point?

Lack victim cooperation really is a tough one to get around. Sure, you can arrest and prosecute against their will but if they don't answer important questions during the trial then the prosecutors may have trouble fulfilling the beyond a reasonable doubt requirement. I have heard of the state issuing arrest warrants for victims who refuse to cooperate but one on the stand, they can still obfuscate.

There are many times where lack of victim cooperation is an issue. I have heard of many times where the officers had the robbery/car break in/burglary suspect arrested with a strong case but the victim didn't want to prosecute.

z06psi

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #6 on: February 13, 2016, 10:31:43 PM »
What we saw was only a partial recording. Their decision to not file charges could be based on other evidence. Part of the question for me when it comes to cases where the abuse is both ways is how many times does one side get to abuse the other before they can defend themselves violently?In the context of the vide, I wonder how many times that girl hit that cop before he lost it and struck back? At what point does the law or courts recognize that nearly everyone has a breaking point?

Lack victim cooperation really is a tough one to get around. Sure, you can arrest and prosecute against their will but if they don't answer important questions during the trial then the prosecutors may have trouble fulfilling the beyond a reasonable doubt requirement. I have heard of the state issuing arrest warrants for victims who refuse to cooperate but one on the stand, they can still obfuscate.

There are many times where lack of victim cooperation is an issue. I have heard of many times where the officers had the robbery/car break in/burglary suspect arrested with a strong case but the victim didn't want to prosecute.

You are just making excuses for a weak DA's office that at minimum should have prosecuted both for assault and both should have went to some classes.  Those two slugging it out only lends itself to more violence.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #7 on: February 13, 2016, 10:45:35 PM »
You are just making excuses for a weak DA's office that at minimum should have prosecuted both for assault and both should have went to some classes.  Those two slugging it out only lends itself to more violence.

I agree that some domestic violence classes is in order for both of them, but no I am not making excuses, I am explaining the reality of the legal system. I don't like it either but that is the way the legal system is set up.

z06psi

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #8 on: February 13, 2016, 10:56:06 PM »
That is not the way the legal system is setup.  That is how it is being executed in this city, county, state.


Two people clearly beating the crap out of each other on video with injuries and police units showing up can be prosecuted.  The Prosecutor is not by choice.  Hence the reason why we have what we have. 

eyeeatingfish

Re: Is this domestic violence and/or mental illness?
« Reply #9 on: February 13, 2016, 11:13:21 PM »
That is not the way the legal system is setup.  That is how it is being executed in this city, county, state.


Two people clearly beating the crap out of each other on video with injuries and police units showing up can be prosecuted.  The Prosecutor is not by choice.  Hence the reason why we have what we have.

Yes, they can prosecute without consent of the victim however winning the case is not so simple. Should the prosecutors try the case even if they know they cannot win due to an uncooperative victim? On the principle I would say yes, but that does take time and money and is arguably a waste if they know they cannot win.