Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG? (Read 11620 times)

Q

Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« on: March 11, 2016, 11:57:04 PM »
Can't find Small Magnum Pistol Primers anywhere. Called WGS, J Hara, Prime Sports....nothing.

I read that you can sub Small Rifle Primers for SMPPs, so long as you start of on lower loads and work your way back up. In fact, most people claim that they prefer to use SRPs in general so that they can load both rifle and pistol without having to have multiple sizes of primer.

Another common thing I have heard is that the CCI SRP is the exact same thing as the CCI SMPP.





I need clarification on this, preferably with someone who has loaded or continues to load .357 MAG with SRPs. If I can't find primers, my recent reloading purchase will be completely worthless.

dustoff003

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #1 on: March 12, 2016, 03:52:26 AM »
PM'ed

Heavies

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #2 on: March 12, 2016, 08:17:39 AM »
I've done it.  Work your load up from the bottom. My loads are light anyway so I never had to look for pressure signs.  Rifle primers are harder than pistol primers so that causes some problems.  1. your pistol may not ignite them consistently. 2. pressure signs can be masked looking at the primer. (it won't flatten and flow as easily as a pistol primer)

These two problems are not problems for me as I have very light target loads for range target shooting where I don't have a need to depend on these loads.

Don't blow yourself up!

Inspector

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #3 on: March 14, 2016, 12:04:03 PM »
I don't want this to tell you what to do. I am only giving you my experiences here with loading .357 magnums using 125gr JHP only as these are the only bullets I load for any more. I load for only one gun and that is my S&W 627 PC with 5" barrel.

I have loaded 357 magnums with CCI SPP and CCI SPMP over the years and have not noticed a difference. I load very light loads using just SPP and I have loaded very heavy loads using both CCI SPP and CCI SPMP. Mostly it has been my mistake as I caught the CCI SPP in my magnum loads after loading. I tried shooting them and I see no signs of OP or flatness of the primers. I read my manuals very carefully and I use H110 almost exclusively for my magnum loads. And Hodgdons and my other books mention using SPMP with H110 because H110 is supposedly a hard to ignite powder. They don't specifically state to use a SPMP just for pressure purposes. Never had a problem either way. I have never used SRP in exchange for SPP or SPMP.

My friend loads the same high power 357 magnum loads I do and has not bought a SPMP in the last few years. He uses SPP almost exclusively. Mostly CCI but he uses magtechs as well. He has a 2" snubby S&W and a 5" Ruger. Again, no signs of OP or flatness on his primers.

Those are my experiences interchanging primers in a 357 magnum. YMMV
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

whynow?

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #4 on: March 14, 2016, 06:04:41 PM »
If SMPP not available, another option is to use SPP with Vihtavuori powder.   VV reload data states to use SPP with their powders for .357 mag. such as N110.
I reload N110 with SPP for a 1894C rifle.  VV might be in stock at WGS, SEC or YG.   

oldfart

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #5 on: March 14, 2016, 07:00:30 PM »
No mag primers??
Just use faster powder.
Lots of possibilities.
What, Me Worry?

Q

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #6 on: March 14, 2016, 09:39:53 PM »
I don't want this to tell you what to do. I am only giving you my experiences here with loading .357 magnums using 125gr JHP only as these are the only bullets I load for any more. I load for only one gun and that is my S&W 627 PC with 5" barrel.

I have loaded 357 magnums with CCI SPP and CCI SPMP over the years and have not noticed a difference. I load very light loads using just SPP and I have loaded very heavy loads using both CCI SPP and CCI SPMP. Mostly it has been my mistake as I caught the CCI SPP in my magnum loads after loading. I tried shooting them and I see no signs of OP or flatness of the primers. I read my manuals very carefully and I use H110 almost exclusively for my magnum loads. And Hodgdons and my other books mention using SPMP with H110 because H110 is supposedly a hard to ignite powder. They don't specifically state to use a SPMP just for pressure purposes. Never had a problem either way. I have never used SRP in exchange for SPP or SPMP.

My friend loads the same high power 357 magnum loads I do and has not bought a SPMP in the last few years. He uses SPP almost exclusively. Mostly CCI but he uses magtechs as well. He has a 2" snubby S&W and a 5" Ruger. Again, no signs of OP or flatness on his primers.

Those are my experiences interchanging primers in a 357 magnum. YMMV

Thanks for the input, Inspector.

I will be loading exclusively casted Lee 125 gr. RNFs w/ powder coating because thats what was available and I read that 125 gr is a better option than 158 fr for self-defense, taking into account the speed at which 125 gr travels (think Force = mass x acceleration, with 125 gr traveling significantly faster than 158 gr.)

I'm hoping to get this problem solved soon, because my .38 and .357 brass just arrived. Luckily, I still need to wait for my Lee mold to arrive, so no rush at the moment.

Q

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #7 on: March 14, 2016, 09:40:39 PM »
If SMPP not available, another option is to use SPP with Vihtavuori powder.   VV reload data states to use SPP with their powders for .357 mag. such as N110.
I reload N110 with SPP for a 1894C rifle.  VV might be in stock at WGS, SEC or YG.

Not sure if I saw it at Prime Sports, but hopefully they have it too so I can save a trip. If not, hopefully WGS has it.

Q

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #8 on: March 14, 2016, 09:41:21 PM »
No mag primers??
Just use faster powder.
Lots of possibilities.

I've never worked with powders for reloading, so I have no idea about the different brands or variations.

oldfart

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #9 on: March 15, 2016, 02:53:56 AM »
I've never worked with powders for reloading, so I have no idea about the different brands or variations.
...
You said you cast your own shotgun slugs so that means you already reload shotshells.
Many shotgun powders are very usable in pistol ammunition. See my article from 2014...

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=13595.0

Look at whatever shotgun powder you have on the shelf and see if the mfg has pistol data for it.
« Last Edit: March 15, 2016, 07:12:14 AM by oldfart »
What, Me Worry?

Q

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #10 on: March 15, 2016, 06:29:41 AM »
...
You said cast your own shotgun slugs so that means you already reload shotshells.
Many shotgun powders are very usable in pistol ammunition. See my article from 2014...

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=13595.0

Look at whatever shotgun powder you have on the shelf and see if the mfg has pistol data for it.

I don't reload shot shells yet.

Inspector

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #11 on: March 15, 2016, 07:38:50 AM »
Thanks for the input, Inspector.

I will be loading exclusively casted Lee 125 gr. RNFs w/ powder coating because thats what was available and I read that 125 gr is a better option than 158 fr for self-defense, taking into account the speed at which 125 gr travels (think Force = mass x acceleration, with 125 gr traveling significantly faster than 158 gr.)

I'm hoping to get this problem solved soon, because my .38 and .357 brass just arrived. Luckily, I still need to wait for my Lee mold to arrive, so no rush at the moment.
Are you going to use gas checks on your cast boolits? If not, do you intend to push these boolits to magnum pressures? If you are not installing gas checks I would recommend keeping your speeds down to 38 Special or 38 +P speeds. Otherwise barrel leading (even with the coating) may be a problem for you. If this is the case then you should not have to worry about SPP compared to SPMP. Only when you start pushing the boolits into the magnum realm (Let's just say above 1,000fps) would you even want to consider a magnum primer.

Unless you choose a magnum pistol powder (slow burning) your speed and pressures will remain well below the magnum realm and will hover around the 38 Special to +P area. Unless you intend to use a magnum pistol powder you will not need to worry about gas checks and leading and SPMP at this point.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Q

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #12 on: March 15, 2016, 07:46:04 AM »
Are you going to use gas checks on your cast boolits? If not, do you intend to push these boolits to magnum pressures? If you are not installing gas checks I would recommend keeping your speeds down to 38 Special or 38 +P speeds. Otherwise barrel leading (even with the coating) may be a problem for you. If this is the case then you should not have to worry about SPP compared to SPMP. Only when you start pushing the boolits into the magnum realm (Let's just say above 1,000fps) would you even want to consider a magnum primer.

Unless you choose a magnum pistol powder (slow burning) your speed and pressures will remain well below the magnum realm and will hover around the 38 Special to +P area. Unless you intend to use a magnum pistol powder you will not need to worry about gas checks and leading and SPMP at this point.

From what I've read, powder coating the boolits eliminates the need for gas checks, even at magnum pressures. This is because the PC forms a protective layer around the lead, which, in a way, acts as a jacket for the boolit.

I was concerned about gas checks as well, which is what got me interested in PC as a cheaper alternative.


I still haven't decided if I want to focus on +P loads or medium magnum loads. My intentions are to have a load that I can easily use for both training and SD, something that won't aggravate my arthritis over time while trianing yet still have enough stopping power to be a theoretical one-stop shot in SD. (Yes, I know that nothing really is a one-stop shot, but I'm just using the terminology).

drck1000

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #13 on: March 15, 2016, 08:00:30 AM »
Thanks for the input, Inspector.

I will be loading exclusively casted Lee 125 gr. RNFs w/ powder coating because thats what was available and I read that 125 gr is a better option than 158 fr for self-defense, taking into account the speed at which 125 gr travels (think Force = mass x acceleration, with 125 gr traveling significantly faster than 158 gr.)

I'm hoping to get this problem solved soon, because my .38 and .357 brass just arrived. Luckily, I still need to wait for my Lee mold to arrive, so no rush at the moment.
Indeed Force = mass x acceleration.  But in this case, the key relationship is Force = 1/2 (mass) x (velocity squared), where the energy gains are magnified by increases in velocity.  I can typically feel the differences in recoil, but the velocity difference has to be in the 200 fps range or more.

That said, that's assuming the bullet can transfer all of that energy.  But that's the same consideration with all self-defense bullets. 

oldfart

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #14 on: March 15, 2016, 08:13:44 AM »
From what I've read, powder coating the boolits eliminates the need for gas checks, even at magnum pressures. This is because the PC forms a protective layer around the lead, which, in a way, acts as a jacket for the boolit.

I was concerned about gas checks as well, which is what got me interested in PC as a cheaper alternative.


I still haven't decided if I want to focus on +P loads or medium magnum loads. My intentions are to have a load that I can easily use for both training and SD, something that won't aggravate my arthritis over time while trianing yet still have enough stopping power to be a theoretical one-stop shot in SD. (Yes, I know that nothing really is a one-stop shot, but I'm just using the terminology).
...
I strongly suggest learning how to reload first, using commercially manufactured bullets.
I have 1 pound of cfe pistol available for sale as a fundraiser. That would be excellent for medium and hot 38 ammo with standard primers.
Since you will cast 125 gr bullets, try these for now..

http://www.xtremebullets.com/38-125-FP-p/xc38-125fpcan-b0500.htm

Rocky started with these and I shot some of his first reloads. :thumbsup:
I think that would be an excellent way to start.
What, Me Worry?

Inspector

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #15 on: March 15, 2016, 09:12:08 AM »
...
I strongly suggest learning how to reload first, using commercially manufactured bullets.
I have 1 pound of cfe pistol available for sale as a fundraiser. That would be excellent for medium and hot 38 ammo with standard primers.
Since you will cast 125 gr bullets, try these for now..

http://www.xtremebullets.com/38-125-FP-p/xc38-125fpcan-b0500.htm

Rocky started with these and I shot some of his first reloads. :thumbsup:
I think that would be an excellent way to start.
+1 For what OF says here.  :thumbsup:
CFE Pistol is a good intermediate burning powder that will give you good results in the 38 Special to +P range. You won't have to deal with the different primers. And at $0.13 per bullet it is a hard price to beat. Especially since using these bullets will eliminate a lot of different variables you will need to deal with when casting your own.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

astroboy

Re: Small Rifle Primers in .357 MAG?
« Reply #16 on: March 16, 2016, 01:54:29 PM »
From what I've read, powder coating the boolits eliminates the need for gas checks, even at magnum pressures. This is because the PC forms a protective layer around the lead, which, in a way, acts as a jacket for the boolit.

I was concerned about gas checks as well, which is what got me interested in PC as a cheaper alternative.


I still haven't decided if I want to focus on +P loads or medium magnum loads. My intentions are to have a load that I can easily use for both training and SD, something that won't aggravate my arthritis over time while trianing yet still have enough stopping power to be a theoretical one-stop shot in SD. (Yes, I know that nothing really is a one-stop shot, but I'm just using the terminology).

If the bullet is designed for a gas check, you can still shoot it with out the gas check. Group size will very likely increase with out the gas check.