Only one THIRD of scientists actually think climate change is man made (Read 24798 times)

passivekinetic

Note that there is another data point that is commonly omitted.

The high volume of CO2 in the atmosphere has led to a great boost in vegetation growth, including trees!

Yes, simple science: Photosynthesis.

CO2 is food for the plants.

There are areas on planet Earth where there is MORE plant life nowadays, ostensibly due to more CO2 for them to suck out of the air.

So, all that CO2 has actually been "sequestered" in vegetation. Maybe not all of it, or even most of it (or maybe most of it), but the point is CO2 is not necessarily a "bad" thing.

I'm just pointing out that this whole interrelated ecosystem is super hard to pin down.

(IIRC some people run their propane generators near, or inside, their greenhouses, and get a huge boost in plant growth.)

Again, let's by all means reduce or eliminate POLLUTION. I am all for that. But CO2 isn't necessarily pollution. (I'm talking about toxic particulate matter and noxious gases, and of course water and land pollution).
"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous

punaperson

Climate change is real.  I'm sorry folks its true.  Most scientists agree.  Those who don't are paid by fuel companies and pro oil rich folk.
Wow. I was skeptical before, but now, after reading your arguments and that brilliant analysis and all the attendant corroborating evidence you provided, I've been convinced. I guess I just needed to see a set of really coherent cogent arguments that could withstand serious critical thinking analysis. Thanks!

The fact the humankind has pumped out more Co2 then ever before and the climate is changing quicker in the last 100 years than 10,000 years. Its quite obvious we are part of the cause.
I challenge anyone to produce two sentences of the approximate length of the two quoted above with more unstated and fallacious assumptions and references to irrelevant and meaningless statistics and derive unwarranted conclusions from those assumptions and statistics. If you can do that, I suspect you may well be a candidate for the Guinness Book of World Records.

Inspector

GOP Senators complain to DOJ over Push to Stifle Climate Change Debate:

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/05/28/gop-senators-complain-to-doj-over-push-to-stifle-climate-debate.html

If climate change advocates are so sure of themselves of being correct and on the correct side of the argument, then why does shit like this occur? Answer. Because they have to stifle those who could convince people otherwise with truth, facts and common sense.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

punaperson

GOP Senators complain to DOJ over Push to Stifle Climate Change Debate:

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/05/28/gop-senators-complain-to-doj-over-push-to-stifle-climate-debate.html

If climate change advocates are so sure of themselves of being correct and on the correct side of the argument, then why does shit like this occur? Answer. Because they have to stifle those who could convince people otherwise with truth, facts and common sense.
All these thinly-veiled attempts to deprive people of their First Amendment right to free speech, especially "political" speech, are nothing more than "political correctness" run amok. The ultimate endgame incorporates V.I. Lenin's (the standard bearer of modern progressivism) dictum: "Whatever aids our purpose is ethical." I think we all know how that works out.  :stopjack:

omnigun

Without going too deeply into explanation here are some decent sites I found on the front page of google. 

https://www.skepticalscience.com/
http://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/
http://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2014/may/06/top-ten-global-warming-skeptic-arguments-debunked
http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/science_and_impacts/science/human-contribution-to-gw-faq.html


In the end its up to you to decide what you want to believe.  The majority of scientists agree it exists (more than 2/3).  But hey its America you have free speech you can say aliens are causing it for all I care. 

punaperson

But hey its America you have free speech you can say aliens are causing it for all I care.
I guess apparently you are unaware of the attempt to limit, suppress or outright deny the speech of American citizens who question 1. whether global warming exists, 2. whether any global that might exist poses any risk to humans, 3. whether any global warming that might exist is anthropogenic, 4. whether the proposed economic and policy measures suggested to counter any supposed anthropogenic global warming will have any effect on climate, and 5. whether those proposed economic and policy measures suggested and/or implemented to counter supposed anthropogenic global warming will have a net benefit or detriment to humans.

So no, you're wrong, just because it's America people don't necessarily have the ability to exercise their right to political free speech if it antagonizes the "powers that be" in enacting their agenda. Or are you saying that as long as you allow us free speech, what others (like Attorney General of the U.S. Loretta Lynch) do is irrelevant?

edster48

I've read "studies" from both sides and have yet to find anything definitive in any of them regarding humans having an effect on the climate.

If there is definite, undeniable scientific evidence out there it's eluding us. All the studies do is allude to the possibility and attempt to "link" human activity to climate change. This is the new "pseudo science" craze that eschews facts as anecdotal and allows possibility and plausibility to replace empirical evidence.

It goes something like this: Poop smells bad + Humans poop, a lot = All humans can smell like poop. The "scientist" releases this fabulous discovery in a statement to the press. The media immediately releases the headline "SCIENCE PROVES ALL HUMANS SMELL LIKE POOP!" and "TOILET PAPER AND DEODORANT STOCKS SOAR!" The "scientist", after a nationwide wave of armpit sniffing, is accosted by people saying "I don't smell anything." In an interview he states "I only said humans "can" smell like poop. I didn't say it was inevitable, but even if it was, over time our sense of smell would become accustomed to it and we wouldn't smell anything."
The new headline reads: "HUMAN SENSE OF SMELL HAS DETERIORATED, IT'S INEVITABLE THAT WE ALL SMELL LIKE POOP." and "PRESIDENT TO SPEAK TO THE NATION ON ODOR CONTROL LEGISLATION."
And on and on and on...

An exaggeration to be sure, but this really is how this is playing out. The reality is, we can "prove" jack squat. Conclusions have been jumped to without the evidence to fully back them up. Do we pollute the planet? Absolutely. Is that bad? Absolutely. Is the climate changing? Absolutely. Doesn't that mean we're having an effect on the planet's climate? Not necessarily.

Until such a time as indisputable evidence of our influence on the climate comes to light, I shall consider this just more "fleas arguing over who's steering the dog".

BTW, I saw some of you sniffing.   ;)
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

The free speech issue does run into a sort of grey zone. Now on the one hand it is absolutely dangerous for the government to suggest denying speech because they say the issue is settled because the danger exists that opposition could be suppressed. But on the other hand, people's comments given under the banner of free speech could also be harmful to a population as well.

Take for example a medical treatment "known" to cure a disease or expanding epidemic. If I were out there being a "skeptic" and saying the disease isn't real and that people should just take coffee enemas as a treatment, I could be directly responsible for the death of individuals or spread of the epidemic.

In truth science always leaves the door open to anything that is known to be changed by new information so a healthy amount of questioning should always be welcome. But when does the situation cross the line to where possible misinformation is introduced as skepticism? If climate scientists are correct and we are poisoning ourselves with global warming but politically funded doubt castors prevent efforts to save ourselves is there ever a justification to trying to stop them?

If I tell a class kids that HIV/AIDS isn't real, do I have complete immunity under free speech if they catch HIV? Consequently there is actually a debate about that which in some ways parallels this issue, but that is another topic. I recommend the movie House of Numbers on the subject.

eyeeatingfish

Interesting what you wrote, didn't know that about him.

But essentially, over the years, I have heard from and read so much dissenting opinion from smart people, that I have to conclude this is not anywhere cut and dried an issue.

Should we reduce pollution, yes, that seems a no brainer. But going beyond that to restrict other energy usage activities (with cost to those restrictions) is another matter.

I have had some seriously smart friends dig up the climate data themselves and read all the various papers, reports, etc. and tell me they are not convinced it's man-made. They just did it as a hobby, so they have nothing to gain either way, except figuring out the truth.

You know this climate change thing is also related to the "peak oil" issue, which is another whole can of worms.

Above and beyond it all, we must remember there are heavily monied interests involved. This is not a purely scientific and environmental /health issue.

I think pollution is of much more importance than the global warming issue. One thing I notice is that there seems to be similar groups that resist both. By that I mean it seems that the same groups, often corporations, that oppose efforts to limit CO2 production are also the same groups that oppose efforts to limit putting chemicals and poisons into our environment. Back when the dangers of smoking were a new issue, tobacco companies hired spokespersons to try and discredit the scientific studies about the negative effects of smoking. They were charismatic and would use anecdotal examples combined with a few cherry picked data pieces to cast doubt in people's minds.

This appears to be the same pattern with groups that are saying man isn't affecting global climate change and this makes me skeptical. A lot of the arguments I see or have seen are anecdotal or use cherry picked evidence or even don't stand as a scientifically valid line of reasoning. For example they might fight the claim that glaciers are disappearing by pointing to the rare few glaciers that increased in size. Sometimes it is even more dumbed down when you will see people suggesting that they know global warming is fake because it was cold that week during summer in their area, even if records showed an increase in overall temperatures for the whole decade.

I stated just believing all the global warming stuff I heard. Then I went over to the skeptic side with my increased attention to politics and conservatism. But the more I actually looked at the arguments put forth by skeptics, the more I have to lean back towards those claiming man is having some influence. I truly try to look at this objectively, independent of any political ideology and this pushes me back to anthropogenic climate change. Not of the doomsday variety but enough to say that a lot of the "skeptics" seem to really just be misinformation agents hired for a company gain. This particular greenpeace founder certainly fit that bill when I saw the interview of him claiming it was safe to drink but refusing to take a sip. Let me see if I can find a video of the interview.

My current stance is that I think humans may be causing some of the rise of global warming that we see, but I think the science of how much blame we share is not yet known.


edster48

The free speech issue does run into a sort of grey zone. Now on the one hand it is absolutely dangerous for the government to suggest denying speech because they say the issue is settled because the danger exists that opposition could be suppressed. But on the other hand, people's comments given under the banner of free speech could also be harmful to a population as well.

Take for example a medical treatment "known" to cure a disease or expanding epidemic. If I were out there being a "skeptic" and saying the disease isn't real and that people should just take coffee enemas as a treatment, I could be directly responsible for the death of individuals or spread of the epidemic.

In truth science always leaves the door open to anything that is known to be changed by new information so a healthy amount of questioning should always be welcome. But when does the situation cross the line to where possible misinformation is introduced as skepticism? If climate scientists are correct and we are poisoning ourselves with global warming but politically funded doubt castors prevent efforts to save ourselves is there ever a justification to trying to stop them?

If I tell a class kids that HIV/AIDS isn't real, do I have complete immunity under free speech if they catch HIV? Consequently there is actually a debate about that which in some ways parallels this issue, but that is another topic. I recommend the movie House of Numbers on the subject.

I wasn't thinking of this as a freedom of speech issue but a scientific methodology issue. All true science is based on skepticism. Until something is proven as an absolute the result is in doubt.

This isn't to say that we shouldn't be aware of it, open to the possibility, but that isn't what they're doing.

I'm certainly open to the possibility, even the plausibility of humans having an effect on the climate. I just haven't seen proof positive that this is anything more than the planet's normal warming/cooling cycle.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

omnigun

I'm curious where you all believe all this co2 is coming from that isn't us. It seems very straight forward that we are making alot of co2 and co2 is a greenhouse gas.

punaperson

I'm curious where you all believe all this co2 is coming from that isn't us. It seems very straight forward that we are making alot of co2 and co2 is a greenhouse gas.
Please answer the following questions and cite your sources:

What is the total percentage in the atmosphere of CO2 compared to water vapor?
What is the total contribution to the greenhouse effect of CO2 compared to water vapor?
What percentage of the CO2 in the atmosphere is anthropogenic?
What is the total contribution of anthropogenic CO2 compared to water vapor in the overall greenhouse effect?
What is the probability that an "enhanced" greenhouse effect will cause a rise in average global temperature compared to a decrease in average global temperature (due to increased water vapor/clouds)?
What is the cost/benefit analysis of the American economy for the next 80 years of severely restrictive CO2 emission policies, including if the actual enhanced greenhouse effect turns out to be global cooling?

If you ask the wrong question, no matter what the answer is, it doesn't matter (i.e. cow flatulence doesn't really matter in the big picture).

Inspector

I'm curious where you all believe all this co2 is coming from that isn't us. It seems very straight forward that we are making alot of co2 and co2 is a greenhouse gas.
Carbon dioxide is naturally present in the atmosphere as part of the Earth's carbon cycle (the natural circulation of carbon among the atmosphere, oceans, soil, plants, and animals). Sometimes it occurs at higher levels and sometimes it occurs at lower levels, naturally without the addition of Co2 by mankind. There is no doubt that man is adding to it. But for you to say it is causing global warming is absolutely ridiculous. You have no proof and have offered none to support your position. I have offered absolute proof to prove what you believe about Co2 and global warming is incorrect and you have not even acknowledged it. I have asked you to answer my question but you refuse to acknowledge it. And yet you ask us questions and expect us to answer them? And BTW, you should check one of your links you posted. It actually provides proof that there is no global warming.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

omnigun

Carbon dioxide is naturally present in the atmosphere as part of the Earth's carbon cycle (the natural circulation of carbon among the atmosphere, oceans, soil, plants, and animals). Sometimes it occurs at higher levels and sometimes it occurs at lower levels, naturally without the addition of Co2 by mankind. There is no doubt that man is adding to it. But for you to say it is causing global warming is absolutely ridiculous. You have no proof and have offered none to support your position. I have offered absolute proof to prove what you believe about Co2 and global warming is incorrect and you have not even acknowledged it. I have asked you to answer my question but you refuse to acknowledge it. And yet you ask us questions and expect us to answer them? And BTW, you should check one of your links you posted. It actually provides proof that there is no global warming.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

I have looked at your "proof"  but while it does contain some graphs and everything I don't really have the scientific background to thoroughly dissect it.   What information I do believe in is the large majority of scientists agreeing that humans play a large factor in climate change. Co2 may be naturally occurring but not at the levels in present day.  I don't have exact proof but its out there ice core samples of the amount of c02 in the air throughout the decades.

Inspector

I have looked at your "proof"  but while it does contain some graphs and everything I don't really have the scientific background to thoroughly dissect it. 

Co2 may be naturally occurring but not at the levels in present day.

I don't have exact proof but its out there ice core samples of the amount of c02 in the air throughout the decades.

You obviously have me confused with someone else. I have not provided any graphs nor any confusing scientific data that needs to be "thoroughly dissected". I provided you with this post: https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=23289.msg208298#msg208298 And asked you: "Then explain why Co2 was 10-12 times higher (~4400ppm) than it is today (~412ppm) during the Ordovician period and the temperature was similar as it is today?" I got this little tidbit from one of the links YOU provided. The Ordovician period in earth's history is from 485.4 to 443.8 million years ago. And this fact was taken from ice core samples showing the naturally occurring amount of Co2 was 10-12 times higher than it is today and the temperature was about the same as it is now. My question is to explain how we could have naturally occurring Co2 levels 10-12 times higher back then with the same temperature as we have now? By your theory the temperatures back then should have been much higher than they were. So please answer this question.

What information I do believe in is the large majority of scientists agreeing that humans play a large factor in climate change.

Well, this is very strange as the very first post disproves what you just said. So if what you are trying to say is that the original post is a lie, show us some proof. Back up what you are saying.

I also made this post: https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=23289.msg208375#msg208375

This post shows that some GOP senators are complaining that the DOJ is trying to stifle their right to free speech to deny this global warming fallacy. So my next question to you in this post is: "If climate change advocates are so sure of themselves of being correct and on the correct side of the argument, then why does shit like this occur?" Please answer this question. My answer to this question is: "Because they have to stifle those who could convince people otherwise with truth, facts and common sense." But I am sure you will have a different answer.

The bottom line for me to all of this is that most of us agree mankind is putting pollutants into the atmosphere. The problem that occurs is that the scientists have not provided any proof that mankind has enough influence over our atmosphere to cause the temperatures to rise. If and when they can connect the dots between Co2 emissions and increase in temperature then you and I will agree. But until they are able to, then you and I will disagree. You may be right, but right now the scientists are lying. As you said you have not dissected the scientific data. So how can you say with impunity that they are correct and not being paid off by the alternative energy companies and governments to lie? Just like you accused every scientist who disagrees is being paid off by the oil companies. Fact is by your own admittance you can't be certain. You only want to believe what you hear on TV and radio and from the democrat party. In this country that is your right to believe whatever you want no matter whether it is a lie or not. Just don't go around telling us what we have to believe and if we disagree with you, we are wrong.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Heavies

Scientific study has proven 100%, without one shadow of a doubt.........









That it's all about the $$$$$$$$$$$$.

edster48

I have looked at your "proof"  but while it does contain some graphs and everything I don't really have the scientific background to thoroughly dissect it.  What information I do believe in is the large majority of scientists agreeing that humans play a large factor in climate change. Co2 may be naturally occurring but not at the levels in present day.  I don't have exact proof but its out there ice core samples of the amount of c02 in the air throughout the decades.

What scientists "agree" on isn't the same thing as what they can prove.

Back in the day, 5 out of 6 dentists "agreed" that chewing Dentyne chewing gum was good for your teeth. { For a nominal fee }

Just a few years ago they "agreed" that eggs were full of cholesterol and "linked" them to heart disease. It was "generally accepted" that this was true. Until it was proven to be false by proper research.

As far as naturally occurring Co2 levels, I've seen research that shows the ocean, one of the largest sources of naturally occurring Co2, far exceeding the output of humans during years that the earth is closer to the sun. Due to the planets somewhat irregular and elliptical orbit.

The only thing that has been proven as an absolute is the fact that the earth goes through cooling and warming cycles and that Co2 levels have risen and fallen at different periods of time throughout history.

At this time, I'm far more concerned with the great masses of plastic and trash that are building up in the worlds oceans, a verifiable fact, than I am with Co2 output.

Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

robtmc

What information I do believe in is the large majority of scientists agreeing that humans play a large factor in climate change.
" It must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over"

Since this newbie troll is likely a millennial, no way will this quote mean anything.

here are some decent sites I found on the front page of google. 

Yet another troll with Google as the sole source of all wisdom.  I have run into too damn many of these Google debaters in the last decade.  Thought there was only one of these on 2AHawai until now that loved to argue for the sake of arguing, with Google at the ready as a substitute for experience.

Looks like another troll has surfaced.  You guys have fun with the child.
« Last Edit: May 30, 2016, 08:43:55 PM by robtmc »

eyeeatingfish

I wasn't thinking of this as a freedom of speech issue but a scientific methodology issue. All true science is based on skepticism. Until something is proven as an absolute the result is in doubt.

This isn't to say that we shouldn't be aware of it, open to the possibility, but that isn't what they're doing.

I'm certainly open to the possibility, even the plausibility of humans having an effect on the climate. I just haven't seen proof positive that this is anything more than the planet's normal warming/cooling cycle.

Indeed, in science anything that is known is subject to being challenged and changed at some point.

I don't know that any amount of science could ever provide proof positive how much we are affecting the climate though. There are just so many variables that it is difficult to find ways to control for all of them. The best we can do is find correlations in data and use them to support a theory. More data and more studies can result in a stronger argument though.

Pride and arrogance also muddy the water as well. It is hard for people to accept they are wrong, even scientists, but true science has no place for pride.

Medicine seems to be a good parallel to the climate issue. Lots of variables, differing theories, and passionate debates about who is right. Some medical theories will have more support than others and while this does not mean they are right, it does mean they may be chosen as the first choice in treating a medical issue. If you had a terminal illness and 70% of doctors nationwide suggested treatment A while 30% suggested treatment B, which one would you wager on and take? This issue keeps reminding me about the HIV/AIDS skeptics.