something's not right? (Read 11840 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #20 on: September 10, 2016, 09:35:06 PM »
   Yeah, I get to borrow cars from total strangers all the time and in return, I lend them my vehicles. 8)
Perfectly normal behavior in this day and age.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Why would anyone think there was something amiss ?  :wacko:

Sure, it's not likely but it can happen. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt, not what is most likely.

Doesn't have to be a stranger. It could be a casual acquaintance you know only by first name. Say the suspect is a drug user and hangs out with some shady friends. The shady friend lets the suspect borrow a car that the suspect doesn't know is stolen. Sure, the guy may be guilty of having criminal friends and using drugs, but that doesn't mean he knowingly drove a stolen car.

It could even be the girlfriend of the person who stole the car. Maybe she says, "my boyfriend John Smith let me drive the car but didn't tell me it was stolen." Then you gotta find John Smith and hope he confesses to it because absent that, pretty lacking in the evidence department.

All_rice

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #21 on: September 12, 2016, 08:05:00 PM »
Sure, it's not likely but it can happen. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt, not what is most likely.

Doesn't have to be a stranger. It could be a casual acquaintance you know only by first name. Say the suspect is a drug user and hangs out with some shady friends. The shady friend lets the suspect borrow a car that the suspect doesn't know is stolen. Sure, the guy may be guilty of having criminal friends and using drugs, but that doesn't mean he knowingly drove a stolen car.

It could even be the girlfriend of the person who stole the car. Maybe she says, "my boyfriend John Smith let me drive the car but didn't tell me it was stolen." Then you gotta find John Smith and hope he confesses to it because absent that, pretty lacking in the evidence department.

Isn't it the persons responsibility to check if the vehicle is stolen before driving it? Same as its that persons responsibility to make sure the vehicle has current insurance and tags?  I've seen judges in traffic court find them guilty and didn't take their defense of " I didn't know?".
Land of the free, because of the Brave!

aieahound

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #22 on: September 13, 2016, 08:47:56 AM »
Isn't it the persons responsibility to check if the vehicle is stolen before driving it? Same as its that persons responsibility to make sure the vehicle has current insurance and tags?  I've seen judges in traffic court find them guilty and didn't take their defense of " I didn't know?".

Nope. Gotta be knowingly or intentionally under this statute.


   Yeah, I get to borrow cars from total strangers all the time and in return, I lend them my vehicles. 8)
Perfectly normal behavior in this day and age.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Why would anyone think there was something amiss ?  :wacko:

Juniors not a stranger. I've known him a long time.
We always meet up at the Mall or the beach park.
But I think he moved to the BI recently. (Maybe to live with Auntie Rose Makuakane)

ren

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #23 on: September 13, 2016, 09:14:52 AM »
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #24 on: September 13, 2016, 09:21:24 AM »
Isn't it the persons responsibility to check if the vehicle is stolen before driving it? Same as its that persons responsibility to make sure the vehicle has current insurance and tags?  I've seen judges in traffic court find them guilty and didn't take their defense of " I didn't know?".
While I am not aware of any responsibility, but that was the root of the case that I was on a jury for. 

Dis "average height, local braddah" wen loan me his cah.  I nevah question and I wen ahhhsoooom was his cah, so me and mah fren when drive'em ladat. 

Wow, that was tougher than I thought to write.  Anyways, the family that had their car stolen had their statement admitted that they did not authorize the use of the vehicle by the defendant.  The only people who testified were the officer that responded to the report of stolen vehicle and took their statement and the officer who pulled over the defendant, and the defendant herself.  That was it.  The whole case was simply whether or not she was aware that the car was stolen and the "local bruddah" that loaned her the car. 

And one doesn't have to prove guilt beyond doubt, just beyond reasonable doubt. 

I actually was surprised that I was kept on the jury.  I had my first car stolen when I live in WA.  They asked if anyone had their car stolen and I raised my hand.  Answered questions from the judge, from the prosecutor, and the defense attorney.  To my surprise, they kept me on the jury. 

aieahound

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #25 on: September 13, 2016, 09:46:22 AM »
Curious.
Did she have the keys or was the ignition punched ?
That can make a big difference.

drck1000

Re: something's not right?
« Reply #26 on: September 13, 2016, 10:18:36 AM »
Curious.
Did she have the keys or was the ignition punched ?
That can make a big difference.
I assume you are referring to my jury trial.  If not, pls ignore.   ;D

Anyways, I don't recall.  It's been a while.  I actually thought about that fact when this thread came up and I can't remember.  I want to say that it wasn't brought up during the trial. 

There definitely was reasonable doubt in this case.