Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators (Read 4729 times)

punaperson

Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« on: November 25, 2016, 06:06:19 PM »
Something to keep in mind. If enough of us called on all the bills and topics we care about, at least they'd know we're out here... though they (almost assuredly) still wouldn't care enough to get educated and actually do something to legally re-instate our civil rights.

Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/22/us/politics/heres-why-you-should-call-not-email-your-legislators.html

Excerpt:

Kara Waite, an English teacher at Bunker Hill Community College in Charlestown, Mass., made a rule for herself: For every political rant she posts on Facebook, she must pick up the phone and call a legislator.

“It’s kind of a swear jar for political action,” Ms. Waite said recently.

Ms. Waite, who volunteers for liberal causes and who created a widely shared document [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/1/d/174f0WBSVNSdcQ5_S6rWPGB3pNCsruyyM_ZRQ6QUhGmo/htmlview?usp=sharing&sle=true] last week to teach others her methods, figures that a phone ringing off the hook is more difficult for a lawmaker to ignore than a flooded inbox.

Activists of all political stripes recommend calling legislators, not just emailing — and certainly not just venting on social media. Several lawmakers, along with those who work for them, said in interviews that Ms. Waite is right: A phone call from a constituent can, indeed, hold more weight than an email, and far outweighs a Facebook post or a tweet.

To understand why, it helps to know what happens when someone answers the phone at a legislator’s office.

zippz

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #1 on: November 26, 2016, 12:36:00 AM »
Better yet, visit and talk to them in person.  I've done that with Espero, Kong, and Slom.

FBI

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #2 on: November 26, 2016, 01:26:39 PM »
The problem we have here in Hawaii,
is committee chairCritters.
My representative introduced legislation, at my
request, the chairman of the review committee
never scheduled it for hearings, and so it died.
Your guns rights in Hawaii are probably dead
this next session.  I expect confiscation legislation
to be introduced.
Our only hope is national reciprocity of concealed
handgun licenses presently in congress. I think
we now have a president that will sign that one.
I'll gladly dump my Hawaii citizenship as my
vote here is a waste of time anyway and become
a citizen of a state that doesn't throttle your rights
or charge you income taxes.  I will continue to live
here and your Hawaii Democrats and union
cops can soil themselves when I legally open carry at
Walmart.
Aloha.


zippz

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #3 on: November 26, 2016, 10:42:21 PM »
All of the representatives I've.talked to stated that we need to get the support of the gun Community And the general community.  We've been focusing on the legislators which is the wrong way to go.

punaperson

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #4 on: November 27, 2016, 11:19:28 AM »
All of the representatives I've.talked to stated that we need to get the support of the gun Community And the general community.  We've been focusing on the legislators which is the wrong way to go.
1. Are those politicians asserting that they are FOR, or would be FOR restoring our constitutionally-guaranteed rights if only (or "only if") a larger segment of the populous spoke up? (Exactly what would that percentage have to be?) That they can't do the right thing unless and until opinion polls/focus groups verify the political utility (assuring re-election) of adopting a position on a proposed law? That seems rather "self-serving", no? Oh, wait, we're talking about politicians. Never mind.

2. Please provide a concrete, detailed, specific plan of actions that will "get the support of the gun Community And the general community". Maybe you can ask the "representatives" how to implement their "suggestion".

3. When it is time to introduce legislation, schedule committee hearings for proposed legislation, and for committees and the legislature as a whole to vote on proposed legislation, there is only one group who votes, and could be influenced by presenting them with rational arguments and supporting evidence: legislators. The "gun Community And the general community" have nothing to do with those determining events, and while it sounds like a "good idea" to marshal a large segment of the populous in order to influence legislators (afraid of losing re-election in light of public opinion), thus far there is no such sentiment among those groups, nor any practical real-life plan likely to secure such a sentiment (see: No. 2 above).
« Last Edit: November 27, 2016, 12:04:18 PM by punaperson »

Heavies

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #5 on: November 27, 2016, 12:39:01 PM »
1. Are those politicians asserting that they are FOR, or would be FOR restoring our constitutionally-guaranteed rights if only (or "only if") a larger segment of the populous spoke up? (Exactly what would that percentage have to be?) That they can't do the right thing unless and until opinion polls/focus groups verify the political utility (assuring re-election) of adopting a position on a proposed law? That seems rather "self-serving", no? Oh, wait, we're talking about politicians. Never mind.

2. Please provide a concrete, detailed, specific plan of actions that will "get the support of the gun Community And the general community". Maybe you can ask the "representatives" how to implement their "suggestion".

3. When it is time to introduce legislation, schedule committee hearings for proposed legislation, and for committees and the legislature as a whole to vote on proposed legislation, there is only one group who votes, and could be influenced by presenting them with rational arguments and supporting evidence: legislators. The "gun Community And the general community" have nothing to do with those determining events, and while it sounds like a "good idea" to marshal a large segment of the populous in order to influence legislators (afraid of losing re-election in light of public opinion), thus far there is no such sentiment among those groups, nor any practical real-life plan likely to secure such a sentiment (see: No. 2 above).
Um..  if you are following along I think zippz has been very much proactive in your number 2.

Numbers one and three will have to follow, IF and only IF, the number two's come together and actually elect people that can make a change, or make enough noise to pause the current powers.

Right now they don't give an eff, about us or the populous as a whole. Because, why should they, they have the ideal that they are the ruling class. No need listen to us peons, they say, you do.

punaperson

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #6 on: November 28, 2016, 08:24:19 AM »
Um..  if you are following along I think zippz has been very much proactive in your number 2.

[2. Please provide a concrete, detailed, specific plan of actions that will "get the support of the gun Community And the general community". Maybe you can ask the "representatives" how to implement their "suggestion".]
Actually, I haven't been "following along". Could you please provide me with a link to the action plans? Also, when were they instituted, how is efficacy being measured, what are the results so far, and when is it expected to result in an actual shift in legislative orientation to restoring our civil rights? Thanks.

Heavies

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #7 on: November 28, 2016, 08:59:30 AM »
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=22998.msg205669#msg205669

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=24268.msg217435#msg217435

http://www.meetup.com/HawaiiGGG/

Start with the people and culture.  A shift in the culture is needed to effect change, and the public only sees one side of the issue (the bad side).  How is it measured?  Who knows, it will take some time to reap benefits gained by a more active and informed community.

punaperson

Re: Here’s Why You Should Call, Not Email, Your Legislators
« Reply #8 on: November 28, 2016, 09:57:44 AM »
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=22998.msg205669#msg205669

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=24268.msg217435#msg217435

http://www.meetup.com/HawaiiGGG/

Start with the people and culture.  A shift in the culture is needed to effect change, and the public only sees one side of the issue (the bad side).  How is it measured?  Who knows, it will take some time to reap benefits gained by a more active and informed community.
Thanks for the links. I applaud zippz and others who volunteer their valuable time to help educate our fellow citizens. "Realistically" though (sorry about that), I suspect such efforts would not bear any fruit in terms of changing the political will of the state legislators and law enforcement, well, forever... given the overwhelming statistical advantage of the anti-firearm civil rights populous and legislators in Hawaii. Don't get me wrong, every minute fraction of a percentage of citizens that are educated about our cause is worthwhile, but in terms of actual "change" coming to our state, I'm pretty sure we'd be looking at an infinite amount of time required (and even then we'd likely get further behind given all the new "progressive" births). And thus my frustration, I don't know of any "plan" that would actually change things here (in terms of legislation and court decisions).

As I've written before, the only thing that would have a chance at really changing the "balance" is "someone" spending many millions of dollars during political campaigns (ala Bloomberg and Soros for the other side) to get pro 2A politicians elected. And with Hawaii being monumentally unimportant and insignificant politically or economically, that will never happen (Please note the lack of significant financial support for Hawaii lawsuits from the major "guns rights" organization (NRA, GOA, etc.)). Those organizations have basically written off Hawaii as a "lost cause" and spend their money more strategically where it can actually make a difference given the amounts they have to spend (they spent 1/3 of what Bloomberg spent in Nevada ($19,720,674.58 to $6,628,275.09) and LOST on the "universal background checks" initiative law just passed. As an aside, look at the map of how counties in Nevada voted. Every single county voted against the law, EXCEPT Clark county (aka Las Vegas) where it passed by a large enough margin to "overrule" the entire rest of the state: state total vote 50.45% to 49.55%). Our only other hope is for federal legislation that would somehow require Hawaii to conform to the Constitutiion (i.e. "bear" does not mean "exlcusively in the home", etc.) by withholding significant federal funding until the state complies. At least with Trump we have a slim chance of some such event occurring. Maybe.