Sen. Gabbard's bill to change handgun mag limit to 15 (Edit 12/6 -> 17) (Read 6072 times)

punaperson

I submitted 1. my repeal any handgun magazine limit bill, 2. the repeal the suppressor ban bill, and the permitless carry bill to senator Gabbard.

He wrote back:

"Given that the suppressor legalization bill will be considered at the federal level,  I'm going to pass on introducing that bill."

"You’re welcome to make my introduction of the magazine capacity bill public. It would be a reintroduction of SB 702 from 2007: http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2007/status/SB702.htm"

"I’d be willing to reintroduce this concealed carry bill, SB 95, from 2015: http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=95&year=2016"

* * * * *
I wrote back re SB95 "shall issue" CCW with these suggestions:

My minor objections to SB95 would be: 1. Why a minimum age of 23 rather than 21? Also, it should read "or over 18 and a member of the United State military". 2. One hundred dollars is prohibitively expensive when added to the training fee, especially for people of low incomes, who may be the mostly likely to have to defend themselves outside their homes given low income area crime rates. 3. The training requirement(s) needs to be clearly specified, and should be kept minimal in cost, which, honestly the state should pay for, and/or there should be an "equivalency/competence" test which could be taken to demonstrate competence that would be minimal in time and financial cost.

Senator Gabbard wrote back that he would incorporate those changes in the bill, but he wasn't specific.

* * * * *
The actual 15 round mag limit bill is here (it just substitutes "fifteen" for "ten" in the currently existing HRS):

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2007/bills/SB702_SD1_.htm

A BILL FOR AN ACT

relating to firearms.

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF HAWAII:

     SECTION 1.  Section 134-8, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended by amending subsection (c) to read as follows:

     "(c)  The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of [ten] fifteen rounds which are designed for or capable of use with a pistol is prohibited.  This subsection shall not apply to magazines originally designed to accept more than [ten] fifteen rounds of ammunition which have been modified to accept no more than [ten] fifteen rounds and which are not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than [ten] fifteen rounds."

     SECTION 2.  Statutory material to be repealed is bracketed and stricken.  New statutory material is underscored.

     SECTION 3.  This Act shall take effect on July, 2059.[That date is just a "placeholder". The actual date would be negotiated by the committees.]


Okay, so 15 is better than 10, but not as good as unlimited. I'm tempted to ask him for 11, just so I can hear what the arguments are for why 10 is so much better for "public safety" than 11. That would be a truly "fact"-filled presentation (the same facts as to why 10 is "safer" than 15: none). At least the 15 limit would allow for the purchase of many factory standard handguns, including used ones found online. I often salivate over some of those "police trade-ins" that are listed in excellent condition and may never have been fired... at deep discounts. We can't buy those here because the accompanying mags are illegal (Huh. Wonder why the cops need more than 10?). Most of those companies won't bother to sell without the mags, and if they do you lose any savings by having to purchase new 10 round mags.

If I can't find a succinct annotated article summarizing the arguments and the research, I will write one myself and send it to every legislator, as well as submit if for testimony. I haven't really looked yet, maybe John Lott has written something, but if any of you know of such an article please post a link to it. I do already have the National Institute of Justice paper concluding that the 10 round magazine limit had no effect on crime during the 10 year assault weapons ban 1994-2003. Christopher S. Koper (Principal Investigator), With Daniel J. Woods and Jeffrey A. Roth, An Updated Assessment of the Federal Assault Weapons Ban: Impacts on Gun Markets and Gun Violence, 1994-2003, Report to the National Institute of Justice, United States Department of Justice, June 2004
https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/204431.pdf

If we could start a serious email campaign to all legislators, but especially those on the committees that would hear the bill, and extra especially to the chairpersons of those committees, who have the sole discretion whether to give a bill a hearing or not (and all the chairpersons are Democrats, of course), perhaps, perhaps, we could get the bill to come up for at least a committee vote.

P.S. Sent all the same material to Espero and haven't heard a single word back.
« Last Edit: December 06, 2016, 05:56:27 PM by punaperson »

zippz

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #1 on: December 05, 2016, 08:55:42 PM »
Those are good suggestions.  However I think the age should be the same whether you're military or not.  I think everything should be reduced to the age of adulthood, 18 to include drinking, smoking, gun ownership, etc.  Fee should be whatever the cost to administer the program, which should be kept as low as possible and reasonable.  I wouldn't want other people to pay for my gun rights just as how I wouldn't want to pay money for other peoples stuff.   But for now just keep it at 21 to make things easier.  Change it later.

For training requirements, it could be kept simple like pass a standard written test on lethal force and state laws and a live fire test.  Live fire test could be simple like draw safely from a holster and put all 20 hits on a silhouette target at 15 yards or whatever level of difficulty is needed.  Instructors can then create their classes based on the test requirements.  Instructors can be certified to give the test themselves.

I'd just remove the capacity limit on magazines.

omnigun

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #2 on: December 06, 2016, 06:37:02 AM »
Honestly It should say
"(c)  The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of fifteen rounds which are designed for or capable of use with a pistol is prohibited.  This subsection shall not apply to magazines originally designed to accept more than fifteen rounds of ammunition which have been modified to accept no more than fifteen rounds and which are not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than fifteen rounds."

Many handguns have 16 or 17 rounds now so you still wouldnt be able to purchase.  IE rex zero hand gun I want. If you really wanted to change the law might I suggest instead of listing an arbitrary number use the wording like Factory magazine are allowed and not aftermarket extended magazine.  Liberals might accept that. 

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #3 on: December 06, 2016, 07:51:21 AM »
Those are good suggestions.  However I think the age should be the same whether you're military or not.  I think everything should be reduced to the age of adulthood, 18 to include drinking, smoking, gun ownership, etc.  Fee should be whatever the cost to administer the program, which should be kept as low as possible and reasonable.  I wouldn't want other people to pay for my gun rights just as how I wouldn't want to pay money for other peoples stuff.   But for now just keep it at 21 to make things easier.  Change it later.

For training requirements, it could be kept simple like pass a standard written test on lethal force and state laws and a live fire test.  Live fire test could be simple like draw safely from a holster and put all 20 hits on a silhouette target at 15 yards or whatever level of difficulty is needed.  Instructors can then create their classes based on the test requirements.  Instructors can be certified to give the test themselves.

I'd just remove the capacity limit on magazines.
The suggested bills I submitted to senators Gabbard (and Espero... hahahahaha), as I said, were permitless carry (no restrictions or requirements except "adult"), repeal of ANY magazine restriction, and repeal ban on suppressors. Senator Gabbard sent back two bills he was willing to sponsor. I wrote back with suggestions to change one, and he said he would incorporate some of those suggestions. Anyone else in the state, including everyone on this forum and thread, is, and has been, totally free to submit any legislation to any state legislator. If you find someone willing to sponsor something that is more expansive of our rights than the bills senator Gabbbard has agreed to sponsor, please let us know so we can support that legislation and that legislator.

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #4 on: December 06, 2016, 07:53:32 AM »
Honestly It should say
"(c)  The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of fifteen rounds which are designed for or capable of use with a pistol is prohibited.  This subsection shall not apply to magazines originally designed to accept more than fifteen rounds of ammunition which have been modified to accept no more than fifteen rounds and which are not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than fifteen rounds."

Many handguns have 16 or 17 rounds now so you still wouldnt be able to purchase.  IE rex zero hand gun I want. If you really wanted to change the law might I suggest instead of listing an arbitrary number use the wording like Factory magazine are allowed and not aftermarket extended magazine.  Liberals might accept that.
So what are you waiting for? Do it.

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #5 on: December 06, 2016, 08:33:15 AM »
I just got that notice from senator Gabbard yesterday afternoon re his willingness to re-submit the 2007 bill (worth a try every ten years?!) to raise the magazine restriction from 10 to 15 rounds. I immediately realized that that number eliminated a large number of currently popular self-defense handguns.

I just wrote him:

Senator Gabbard,

Thank you for being willing to introduce a bill changing the handgun magazine limit from 10 to 15 rounds. When will we see the new bill with it's new number? Is there anything specific that we can do to help this bill make its way through the legislature?

I'd just like to point out that many popular handguns (millions sold and possessed by citizens of "free states") owned for self defense, including those manufactured by Beretta, Glock, SIG Sauer, and Smith & Wesson, etc., come from the factory with standard capacity magazines of 16 and 17 rounds (for example the (formerly?) most popular police handgun the Glock 17 9mm has a 17 round magazine).

I know people like "round" numbers, but how severely would the chances of the bill being heard/passed be harmed by changing that number from 15 to 17?

We all (who are informed and read all the literature) know that magazine restrictions have no impact on crime, and thus whatever number is designated in any magazine restriction law is really an arbitrary and capricious number having no real relationship to any falsely claimed "public safety" benefit. We saw this with the New York state "SAFE Act" that restricted magazines to a capacity (for some unrevealed reason) to seven (7) rounds. It was only a year after the act was passed that legislators finally acknowledged the reality that no one manufactures 7 round magazines for the vast majority of the handguns covered by the law, and then re-wrote the law to state that it would be legal to possess and use a 10 round magazine but it would be illegal to place more than 7 rounds in the magazine! What was that phrase from Forrest Gump? I'm pretty sure no criminal ever considered following any aspect of that law ever. All it did was place a burden on law-abiding gun owners.

Please change the magazine limitation to 17 rounds (even though a number of those manufacturers produce handguns with 20 to 25 rounds factory standard magazines, so it's still a "compromise"), unless you really believe that a completely real-world meaningless number change form 15 to 17 (or 10 to 15) will dissuade legislators. (I considered asking you to change the number to 11 just so I could hear the arguments claiming that 11 was "dangerous" but 10 wasn't... or why 11 was significantly "more dangerous" to merit nonpassage...).

thank you,
[punaperson]

All you other "Legal and Activism" readers be sure to let us all know when you have any sponsors of other bills expanding our rights. Let the email and call avalanche begin.

zippz

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #6 on: December 06, 2016, 01:11:25 PM »
Don't include a number.  It could still screw with rifle magazines used in handguns.

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #7 on: December 06, 2016, 01:39:07 PM »
Don't include a number.  It could still screw with rifle magazines used in handguns.
Which legislator did you persuade to write, sponsor, and submit that bill?

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #8 on: December 06, 2016, 04:22:44 PM »
Reply to my email from Senator Gabbard:

"We’ll change the ammunition limit to 17 in the bill. Senator Clarence Nishihara, Chair of the Public Safety, Intergovernmental, and Military Affairs Committee, will be key in getting the bill heard in committee.

* * * * *
I will soon begin requesting that Chair Nishihara hold a hearing for this bill in his committee.

drck1000

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #9 on: December 06, 2016, 04:34:29 PM »
Quote
(I considered asking you to change the number to 11 just so I could hear the arguments claiming that 11 was "dangerous" but 10 wasn't... or why 11 was significantly "more dangerous" to merit nonpassage...).
Now that would've been pretty good to hear them argue.  ??? ;D

Thank you for all your efforts!  As well as everyone else who put in the time, thought, effort, etc. 

I'd have to research what verbiage other states have with respect to "standard capacity" magazines. As in as the original gun manufacturer designed it.  Just wondering how the laws were worded.

That said, again, good on ya for getting this ball rolling and seems like there's at least someone willing to listen.  As you mentioned, key is to show support.  Even if they don't listen, like RapBack, hopefully it can be documented on how many people supported the proposed legislation as well as how others argued, both for or against. 

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard bill to change handgun mag limit to 15
« Reply #10 on: December 06, 2016, 05:09:25 PM »
I'd have to research what verbiage other states have with respect to "standard capacity" magazines. As in as the original gun manufacturer designed it.  Just wondering how the laws were worded.
The laws all use a specific number to define "large capacity". California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, New York, and the District of Columbia define a large capacity magazine as a magazine that is capable of holding more than 10 rounds. Colorado and New Jersey define a large capacity magazine as a magazine capable of holding more than 15 rounds. All those states but Hawaii (handgun ban only) ban use of larger magazines with any firearm (long gun or handgun).

changemyoil66

Re: Sen. Gabbard's bill to change handgun mag limit to 15 (Edit 12/6 -> 17)
« Reply #11 on: December 06, 2016, 08:55:32 PM »
Again how non firearm owning people write laws. Normal size for ar would.be 30rds. "Large" should be 50 or so.

I hope this magazine bill passes, but just became a handgun owner 2 months ago and bought 6 10rd mags. Waste money, but ill be willing to sacrafice.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

punaperson

Re: Sen. Gabbard's bill to change handgun mag limit to 15 (Edit 12/6 -> 17)
« Reply #12 on: December 07, 2016, 12:12:46 PM »
Update from senator Gabbard today, December 7, 2016:

"I’ll keep you posted on the bill numbers for both the concealed carry and magazine limit bills. Just so you know, it will be sometime between Opening Day of the 2017 Legislative Session on January 18th and January 25th."

That leaves citizens roughly five more weeks to lobby any legislators for any legislation they would like to see introduced. The sooner the better, especially if they would have to have a bill written and vetted by attorneys.

We could start lobbying on the above bills now just my stating the content and the previous bill numbers. I'll post the new numbers when I get them from senator Gabbard.