"If you feel like you need an AR-15 you are not mentally fit to own an AR-15." (Read 5568 times)

punaperson

From Joe Huffman's blog: http://blog.joehuffman.org/2018/02/18/quote-of-the-day-bess-kalb-bessbell/

Note that senator Green here in Hawaii proposed (two sessions ago) a "mental fitness test" be required within 90 days prior to every firearm acquisition. Even the nut job fascists here in the Hawaii legislature had to postpone that one for a while. And also note that this comment is similar in nature to mayor Harry Kim's comment in his identical testimonies submitted for HB1908 and SB2046. (After finally getting an answer from the mayor's office ("protecting the people"  :rofl:) and my council rep I will be contacting the Board of Ethics when they open on Tuesday morning...).

Quote of the day—Bess Kalb @bessbell

"If you feel like you need an AR-15 you are not mentally fit to own an AR-15."

Bess Kalb @bessbell
Tweeted on February 15, 2018

[Don’t ever let anyone get away with telling you that no one wants to take your guns.

Just as gun owners have predicted. Mental competency tests are a very dangerous path to go down.

A better way to think of this is that if someone thinks this makes sense or will ever be tolerated it proves they aren’t fit to participate in discussions of our specific enumerated rights.—Joe].

Q

From Joe Huffman's blog: http://blog.joehuffman.org/2018/02/18/quote-of-the-day-bess-kalb-bessbell/

Note that senator Green here in Hawaii proposed (two sessions ago) a "mental fitness test" be required within 90 days prior to every firearm acquisition. Even the nut job fascists here in the Hawaii legislature had to postpone that one for a while. And also note that this comment is similar in nature to mayor Harry Kim's comment in his identical testimonies submitted for HB1908 and SB2046. (After finally getting an answer from the mayor's office ("protecting the people"  :rofl:) and my council rep I will be contacting the Board of Ethics when they open on Tuesday morning...).

Quote of the day—Bess Kalb @bessbell

"If you feel like you need an AR-15 you are not mentally fit to own an AR-15."

Bess Kalb @bessbell
Tweeted on February 15, 2018

[Don’t ever let anyone get away with telling you that no one wants to take your guns.

Just as gun owners have predicted. Mental competency tests are a very dangerous path to go down.

A better way to think of this is that if someone thinks this makes sense or will ever be tolerated it proves they aren’t fit to participate in discussions of our specific enumerated rights.—Joe].

Technically they aren't wrong.

No one NEEDS an AR-15; its the preferred weapon system of the individual.

Need is an objective necessity,  like the ability to keep and bear arms; preference is a subjective opinion.

There are numerous examples of individuals who can be just as effective, if not more effective, with a weapon system with a significantly lower fire rate and/or capacity than the average ar-15 owner. It all boils down to training and application of skills.

Is that justification for banning modern sporting rifles? Absolutely not. But its getting kind of ridiculous and redundant hearing guys who don't train on their weapon platform tell me how they need that particular weapon system, yet likely cannot respond in the scenarios and situations they imagine they will use their weapon in due to a lack of training.

Flapp_Jackson

Technically they aren't wrong.

No one NEEDS an AR-15; its the preferred weapon system of the individual.

Need is an objective necessity,  like the ability to keep and bear arms; preference is a subjective opinion.

There are numerous examples of individuals who can be just as effective, if not more effective, with a weapon system with a significantly lower fire rate and/or capacity than the average ar-15 owner. It all boils down to training and application of skills.

Is that justification for banning modern sporting rifles? Absolutely not. But its getting kind of ridiculous and redundant hearing guys who don't train on their weapon platform tell me how they need that particular weapon system, yet likely cannot respond in the scenarios and situations they imagine they will use their weapon in due to a lack of training.

I need the best, most affordable, most effective, most reliable and most adaptable weapon system I can legally own.

If the AR-15 fits those requirements, then I NEED AN AR-15.  If there were something else that fits that better, then I'd need that firearm instead.

"Need" is synonymous with "requirement".  Requirements are not necessarily based on intended application.  Often they are relative to other available options.  Such as, "I need the SUV with the most horsepower", or "the SUV with the most seating."  Why do you have these requirements? Because you don't want to be LIMITED by the trade-offs you know you'll have to make.  One day you might NEED to haul a heavy boat.  One day you might NEED to seat eight. Failing to consider the limitations a smaller engine or seating capacity create would mean you didn't make the choice that fit your future needs.

Few, if any, options are ever perfect.  So you list your top requirements, and choose what fits that list best.  That defines what you "need".
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

punaperson

Technically they aren't wrong.

No one NEEDS an AR-15; its the preferred weapon system of the individual.

Need is an objective necessity,  like the ability to keep and bear arms; preference is a subjective opinion.

There are numerous examples of individuals who can be just as effective, if not more effective, with a weapon system with a significantly lower fire rate and/or capacity than the average ar-15 owner. It all boils down to training and application of skills.

Is that justification for banning modern sporting rifles? Absolutely not. But its getting kind of ridiculous and redundant hearing guys who don't train on their weapon platform tell me how they need that particular weapon system, yet likely cannot respond in the scenarios and situations they imagine they will use their weapon in due to a lack of training.
Technically you're wrong.

You claim the original quote is "not wrong" because "need" is "objective necessity". Of course the word "need" has many more definitions than that, and is so used everyday (I need to wash my hands, I need to lose weight, I need five minutes to get ready, I need to get to work on time, etc. etc.). In fact I didn't see "objective necessity" as a definition in the dictionaries I looked at. As far as I can see the only "objective necessities" humans have, if we assume that a human is alive and "wants" to stay alive, are safe water, food and air, along with the ability to maintain a certain range of body temperature. Certainly "the ability to keep and bear arms" is not an "objective necessity" as you assert.

I'm not sure what your point is about the obvious intent of the original quote. It's clear what the writer meant, and it has nothing to do with "training and application skills". Please.

groveler

I think I have mentioned before I'm not particularly fond of the AR 15( Stoner).
I prefer Browning, Simonov, and Kalashnikov designs.
I wonder what the confused politician would say about me?
In this state thanks to our single party mentality,  I do need my
guns.

tillamook

Dear senator idiot.  I am a physician and have no way to tell if someone is going to kill someone.  In oregon, one of my patients killed someone with a knife and I had no idea he was going to do it when I did his physical

Or perhaps  you want me to torture the information out of them?  Perhaps for anyone wanting to buy a firearm we detain them and torture them until they admit they want to hurt someone.  And then we execute them for planning to commit murder. 

How about we require Senators to submit to a mental health and IQ qualification within 90 days of every bill they submit. 

Q

You claim the original quote is "not wrong" because "need" is "objective necessity". Of course the word "need" has many more definitions than that, and is so used everyday (I need to wash my hands, I need to lose weight, I need five minutes to get ready, I need to get to work on time, etc. etc.). In fact I didn't see "objective necessity" as a definition in the dictionaries I looked at. As far as I can see he only "objective necessities" humans have, if we assume that a human is alive and "wants" to stay alive, are safe water, food and air, along with the ability to maintain a certain range of body temperature. Certainly "the ability to keep and bear arms" is not an "objective necessity" as you assert.

 You basically just repeated exactly what i originally said by rewording the core argument and adding in a few more  words.

Key point: truth = you don't need an ar-15, you want one; big difference.

References: stories since the invention of firearms were better trained people with "inferior" firearms fuck up people with "superior" firearms, because those being fucked up lack the training to maximize the potential of utilizing those firearms.

 People can buy all the multicam taco pouches and gear they want and modify their AR15 all they want so they can impress the clique and try to impress other people's wives on range day, and it still won't be anything in comparison against and individual who is properly trained and masters foundational principles and fundamental skills and are just as effective, if not more effective, utilizing firearms with lower rates of fire and/or smaller capacities.


And the point of the post is to call people out on their bullshit.  The fact that individuals CAN utilize firearms with lower rates of fire and lower capacities means that needing an ar15 or any other modern sporting rifle with similar characteristics to protect life and liberty effectively 
Proves that NEEDING an ar15 is not an absolute, and therefore not a necessity; its a choice of preference for that weapon system,  as i originally stated.

I honestly don't care what kinds of guns you prefer,  but people shouldn't get butt hurt because facts don't justify them not needing something they want or prefer.

oldfart

NEED and WANT

"Bess NEEDs a slap on the head."
"I WANT to slap Bess on the head"

I should have been a schoolteacher.
What, Me Worry?

groveler

Dear senator idiot.  I am a physician and have no way to tell if someone is going to kill someone.  In oregon, one of my patients killed someone with a knife and I had no idea he was going to do it when I did his physical

Or perhaps  you want me to torture the information out of them?  Perhaps for anyone wanting to buy a firearm we detain them and torture them until they admit they want to hurt someone.  And then we execute them for planning to commit murder. 

How about we require Senators to submit to a mental health and IQ qualification within 90 days of every bill they submit.

I like what you say
"How about we require Senators to submit to a mental health and IQ qualification within 90 days of every bill they submit."

I would add ALL government legislators be tested.

P.S. Really good fishing out of Tillmook bay. Nasty Bar conditions though.

punaperson

Dear senator idiot.  I am a physician and have no way to tell if someone is going to kill someone.  In oregon, one of my patients killed someone with a knife and I had no idea he was going to do it when I did his physical

Or perhaps  you want me to torture the information out of them?  Perhaps for anyone wanting to buy a firearm we detain them and torture them until they admit they want to hurt someone.  And then we execute them for planning to commit murder. 

How about we require Senators to submit to a mental health and IQ qualification within 90 days of every bill they submit.
That's exactly what I actually wrote to senator Green about his proposal: All public servants, elected and appointed, be required to have both regular mental health and randomized drug testing. I also pointed out (Green being a physician) that the number of people killed by "preventable medical errors" was annually over TEN TIMES the total number of people killed by firearms, (two-thirds of whom are suicides), and that all medical personnel (doctors, nurses, aids, etc.) should have both kinds of testing on a regular and/or randomized basis since they are much more dangerous to "public safety". He never wrote me back. At least the bill failed.

macsak

That's exactly what I actually wrote to senator Green about his proposal: All public servants, elected and appointed, be required to have both regular mental health and randomized drug testing. I also pointed out (Green being a physician) that the number of people killed by "preventable medical errors" was annually over TEN TIMES the total number of people killed by firearms, (two-thirds of whom are suicides), and that all medical personnel (doctors, nurses, aids, etc.) should have both kinds of testing on a regular and/or randomized basis since they are much more dangerous to "public safety". He never wrote me back. At least the bill failed.

put them on rapback

changemyoil66

I don't "need" an AR, but it's what I can afford.  If I could afford a Tavor, I would have bought that.  If I could afford a quality AK, I would have bought that also.  If I could afford a M109, I would have bought that too.