SB 621 Fail to report gun theft within 24 hours, all remaining guns confiscated (Read 1709 times)

punaperson

SB 621 Fail to report gun theft within 24 hours, upon conviction, all remaining guns confiscated (after third conviction, if I'm reading it correctly). Some details below, read the full text here (exemption if in coma, etc.): https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB621_.HTM

SB621       

Measure Title:   RELATING TO FIREARMS.
Report Title:   Firearms; Lost, Stolen, or Destroyed Firearms; Reporting Requirements; Penalties
Description:   Requires a person to report the person's lost, stolen, or destroyed firearms to the appropriate county police department. Establishes penalties for failure to report.

Introducer(s):   NISHIHARA (Introduced by request of another party)

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=621&year=2019

"§134-     Reporting of lost, stolen, or destroyed firearms.  (a)  Every person or designee shall report the loss, theft, or destruction of a firearm that person owns or possesses to the county police department of the county within which the loss, theft, or destruction occurred, within twenty-four hours upon the discovery or [sic] such loss, theft, or destruction.  Every person reporting the loss, theft, or destruction of a firearm shall report the make, model, and serial number of the firearm, if known by the person, and any additional relevant information required by the county police department taking the report.

     (b)  Upon the receipt of a report of a lost, stolen, or destroyed firearm, the appropriate county police department shall enter into the National Crime Information Center database, to the extent known, the caliber, make, model, manufacturer, and serial number of the firearm and any other distinguishing number or identification mark on the firearm.

     (c)  If a person intentionally or knowingly fails to report to the appropriate county police department the loss, theft, or destruction of any firearm that person owns or possesses, or falsely reports the loss, theft, or destruction of that firearm, that person shall:

     (1)  Be guilty of a petty misdemeanor for the first offense;

     (2)  Be guilty of a misdemeanor for the second offense; and

     (3)  Be guilty of a misdemeanor for the third offense or subsequent offense.

     (d)  Any person found guilty under paragraph (c)(3) shall:

     (1)  Have all firearm registrations revoked;

     (2)  Surrender all firearms and ammunition to the chief of police of the appropriate county; and

     (3)  Be prohibited from owning, possessing, or registering any firearms.

tillamook

(4) if your firearms are stolen in the process of a crime where you are injured and rendered unconscious, you will be required to inform the police through telepathy or out of body experience. 

(5) you are legally required to be a victim.  If you are victimized, you will be held legally responsible for the effects of the victimization.  Once your victimization ends and you are judged a criminal, you may procure your firearms illegally and not register them and proceed to ignore any carry laws. 

Falken Hawke

I could be wrong, but I'm thinking fails Constitutional Rights Test.  If I plug in "Commits Slander" for example where "fails to report blah, blah, blah" is written, revoking the Right of free speech wouldn't fly.

I can see the mentality behind this but it's attaching way to much responsibility of a crime to an inanimate object rather than the perpetrator of the crime.  It's lazy ass police work as well as prosecution.

Besides, what's stopping a criminal from reporting the firearm stolen and then using it?  Now prosecution has to prove firearm wasn't stolen along with the crime and if successful, why was the law even necessary?

Things like this really reminds me of "Days of Thunder".  "Control is an illusion you infantile egomaniac".

Flapp_Jackson

It's unenforceable.

They give an "out" in the wording: "intentionally or knowingly fails to report", and "within twenty-four hours upon the discovery or [sic] such loss, theft, or destruction."

"Officer, if I'd known the gun was missing, I would have filed a report immediately and contacted my insurance carrier to file a claim."

No way they can prove otherwise. All they can do is bankrupt you by dragging you and your lawyer into court over and over until they tire of trying to get you to take a plea deal.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw