SB1318 Open/Conc. License Insurance Requirement; Training for Open Required (Read 5909 times)

punaperson

Not that any of us have to actually worry about this effecting us, since no one is getting a license, open or concealed, but.... Further evidence of the lies by the AG when claiming that open carry has always been available to anyone, not just security guards. This bill 1.extends the requisite proof of adequate training, as determined by the chief of police, to receive an open carry license (does anyone actually believe they left that out inadvertently for all these years when "ordinary law-abiding citizens" were eligible for those licenses, but only included a training requirement for concealed carry? I'd laugh if it wasn't such a blatant lie.), and 2. require anyone receiving an open or concealed license to show proof of "self-defense insurance".

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=1318&year=2019

SB1318   

Measure Title:   RELATED TO FIREARMS.
Report Title:   Open or Concealed Firearms; Firearms Insurance; Firearms Education and Training; Self-defense Insurance; License
Description:   Requires the chiefs of police to adopt procedures to: require that any person granted a license to carry an open or concealed firearm be qualified to use the firearm in a safe manner by successful completion of a course of instruction and firearm qualification test; and require that any person who has been approved for a license to carry an open or concealed firearm, who is not employed as a security guard by an authorized security company, show proof of valid firearms or self-defense insurance prior to being issued the license.
   
Introducer(s):   NISHIHARA (Introduced by request of another party)

Bill:  https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB1318_.HTM
« Last Edit: January 23, 2019, 07:58:45 AM by punaperson »

tillamook

That is actually quite funny. 

require non-existent insurance and non-existent training to issue a license that never gets issued. 

Why dont they require that only a third arm can be used to hold a firearm?  Or perhaps that that the license needs to be kept inside the gall bladder at all times.  Perhaps proof of breathing under water is required before the license is issued?

6716J

require that any person who has been approved for a license to carry an open or concealed firearm, who is not employed as a security guard by an authorized security company, show proof of valid firearms or self-defense insurance prior to being issued the license.


This type of bovine excrement ^^^

My only question is will criminals have to follow this new law also; or will they be exempted from these and all other HRS-134 requirements as they currently are?
I'd rather have a bottle in front of me, than a frontal lobotomy.

RSN172

Ok.  I go to Front Sight at least once a year for training.  I have USCCA insurance.  I have never been even charged with a misdemeanor, much less a felony in my life and my last traffic ticket was in 1989 for 35 in a 25 zone.  What are my odds of getting a carry permit?  I already know the answer.
Right now it is 0%.
Happily living in Puna

zippz

When I talked to Sen Nishihara last week his concerns on CCW was negligent discharges, not criminal use.  There will be negligent discharges by CCW holders since even police have problems with it.  But the overall reduction in crime and the ability to protect oneself vastly out weights the possible harm.  He didn't bring up the insurance topic, but I think he's referring to CCW insurance or liability insurance for accidents which I'm opposed to since you don't require insurance for a right and again blood's not going to flow into the streets from negligent discharges.  We have to educate people that guns have to stay in the holsters when out in public unless needed for an emergency.

punaperson

A few weeks ago I happened to be in town (Hilo) on a weekday, so just for fun I stopped by the police department to pick up a license to carry application to see what changes might have been incorporated since the Young decision in July of 2018.

Here is how the only reference to their option for issuing carry licenses STILL read:



THOSE ARE THE ONLY TWO CHOICES! Does that unconcealed option sounds like it applies to any "ordinary law-abiding citizen"? I guess I've misplaced my uniform, as I can't seem to find it. Also, I seem to have developed amnesia about my employer and even being so employed. But this is the application for the "ordinary law-abiding citizen" that the AG assured us has ALWAYS been eligible to get an unconcealed license and thus claiming that the Ninth Circuit panel in Young, and judge O'Scannlain in particular were morons for ruling the way they did, completely misapprehending the application of the law by Hawaii County PD.  >:( These people (AG, police chiefs, virtually all the legislators, etc.) are blatant lying scum asshole oath-breakers who not only deserve to lose their jobs, they should be tried, convicted, and imprisoned as well as personally fined huge sums of money. but instead... We get bent over and take it as they laugh behind our backs.

« Last Edit: January 23, 2019, 09:36:46 AM by punaperson »

punaperson

When I talked to Sen Nishihara last week his concerns on CCW was negligent discharges, not criminal use.  There will be negligent discharges by CCW holders since even police have problems with it.  But the overall reduction in crime and the ability to protect oneself vastly out weights the possible harm.  He didn't bring up the insurance topic, but I think he's referring to CCW insurance or liability insurance for accidents which I'm opposed to since you don't require insurance for a right and again blood's not going to flow into the streets from negligent discharges.  We have to educate people that guns have to stay in the holsters when out in public unless needed for an emergency.
This bill is "Introduced by request of another party". Nishihara tell you who that was? I think I can guess.

Here's the "justifcation" section of the bill:

SECTION 1.  The legislature finds that existing state law does not adequately address situations relating to the issuance of licenses to carry open or concealed firearms to individuals not employed as security guards by authorized security companies.  The inherent dangers of public firearm use by private citizens without instruction in the laws governing firearm use and practical firearms training are significant. [If you say so, it must be true! I won't bother to ask for evidence supporting that claim from the 43 states where at least 17 million people are carrying, because I know as a politician you wouldn't lie. It should be really simple to list all the cases of public injury and death and vast liability judgments due to lack of training and instruction in the laws governing firearm use in the 12 states that have permitless carry (no classes, no training, no exam, no license,  no nothing). Must be a lengthy list of horrific events, so I'll settle for a list of just a couple thousand such incidents. Show us.]

     The legislature further finds that a private citizen who is licensed to carry a firearm and does so may incur liability not only for damages to a victim of that use but also may incur significant costs in defending the citizen's own use of the firearm.  Thus, the purpose of this Act is to:

     (1)  Mitigate these dangers by requiring training and instruction to those individuals who are not employed as security guards by authorized security companies and who are granted licenses to carry firearms;

     (2)  Require those individuals to obtain firearms insurance, commonly referred to as "self-defense insurance", to assist in covering potential liability and defense costs; and

     (3)  Apply the existing concealed carry license law to the open carry of firearms as well.

* * * * *

Good to know their main motive is looking out for us and trying to make sure we don't get hurt in any way by bearing arms outside our home for self-defense. True humanitarians. Fuck them.

zippz



Well was copied wrong.   You have to paste the link, highlight it, then click the image icon (under the BOLD) button.  The link should have the .jpg at the end of it.

punaperson



Well was copied wrong.   You have to paste the link, highlight it, then click the image icon (under the BOLD) button.  The link should have the .jpg at the end of it.
zippz....thanks. First time using imgur. I assumed that the link next to "copy" on the right was the link, as that was how my previous no-longer-free image linking system worked. Now see that you have to hover the cursor over the image itself to get the proper link. Thanks. Just out of curiosity, what is the "copy" link (that doesn't work here) for? If you could just PM me...  :shaka:
« Last Edit: January 23, 2019, 11:26:14 AM by punaperson »

tillamook

Ok.  I go to Front Sight at least once a year for training.  I have USCCA insurance.  I have never been even charged with a misdemeanor, much less a felony in my life and my last traffic ticket was in 1989 for 35 in a 25 zone.  What are my odds of getting a carry permit?  I already know the answer.
Right now it is 0%.

I thought USCCA is just a sort of attorney retainer, not insurance.  They cover the cost of an attorney if something happens right?

RSN172

It is insurance, not just a retainer.  My policy has $1.15m coverage.  You can get more or less coverage if you want, but the one I have is the most popular.

SELF-DEFENSE LIABILITY COVERAGE FORM COVERAGE IS CLAIMS-MADE COVERAGE PLEASE READ THE ENTIRE FORM CAREFULLY Various provisions in this policy restrict coverage.  Read the entire policy carefully to determine rights, duties and what is and is not covered. Throughout this policy, the words “you” and “your” refer to the insured and any other person or organization qualifying as an insured under this policy.  The words “we”, “us” and “our” refer to the Company providing this insurance. The word insured means any person or organization qualifying as such under Section II – Who Is An Insured. Other words and phrases that appear in quotation marks have special meaning.  Refer to Section VI – Definitions. SECTION I – COVERAGES BODILY INJURY, PROPERTY DAMAGE LIABILITY AND DEFENSE PAYMENTS AND EXPENSES COVERAGE LIABILITY 1. Insuring Agreement a.  We will pay on behalf of the insured “damages”, in excess of the Each Claim Retention Amount subject to the Annual Aggregate Retention Amount stated in the Declarations, because of “bodily injury” or “property damage” arising out of: (1)  An “act of self-defense”; or (2)  “Covered legal liability” arising out of a non-insured’s use of a stolen:  (a)  “Safeguarded firearm”; or (b)  Firearm from a “secured location”; or (c)  Firearm from a “secured auto”; or (d)  Firearm taken from the “personal possession” of the insured arising out of a robbery. The insurance provided in item  1.a. (2)  above applies only if the theft of the firearm is promptly reported to the proper authorities upon discovery. b.  We will have the right and duty to defend the insured against any “suit” seeking those “damages”.  However, we will have no duty to defend the insured against any “suit” seeking “damages” for “bodily injury” or “property damage” to which this insurance does not apply.  We may, at our discretion, investigate any “occurrence” or incident involving “covered legal liability” and settle any claim or “suit” that may result.  But: (1)  The amount we will pay for “damages” is limited as described in  Section III  – Limits Of Insurance; and (2)  Our right and duty to defend ends: (a)   When we have used up the applicable occurrence and covered legal liability limit of insurance in the payment of costs and expenses incurred in the investigation, settlement or defense of any “suit”; or (b)   With the insured’s “conviction” of any criminal charge(s) caused by or arising out of: i.   The insured’s use of a firearm or other weapon related to the “occurrence” or ii.   The “covered legal liability” for which coverage under this insurance is being sought.  No other obligation or liability to pay sums or perform acts or services is covered unless explicitly provided for under Defense Payments and Expenses. c.  This insurance applies to “bodily injury” and “property damage” only if: (1)  The “bodily injury” or “property damage” did not occur before that date which the insured’s membership in the United States Concealed Carry Association, Inc. commenced; and (2)  The “bodily injury” or “property damage” is caused by an “occurrence” or arises due to an incident involving a “covered legal liability” that takes place in the “coverage territory”; and (3)  The “bodily injury” or “property damage” did not occur before the Retroactive Date shown in the Declarations or after the end of the policy period; and (4)  A claim for “damages” because of the “bodily injury” or “property damage” is first made against any insured, in accordance with paragraph d. below, during the policy period or any Extended Reporting Period we provide under Section V – Extended Reporting Periods. d.  A claim by a person or organization seeking “damages” will be deemed to have been made when notice of such claim is received and recorded by the “policyholder” or by us, whichever comes first. All claims for “damages” because of “bodily injury” to the same person, including “damages” claimed by any person or organization for care, loss of services, or death resulting at any time from the “bodily injury”, will be deemed to have been made at the time the first of those claims is made against any insured. All claims for “damages” because of “property damage” causing loss to the same person or organization will be deemed to have been made at the time the first of those claims is made against any insured.
Happily living in Puna

tillamook

It is insurance, not just a retainer.  My policy has $1.15m coverage.  You can get more or less coverage if you want, but the one I have is the most popular.

Thanks, I did not know that.   :thumbsup:

Flapp_Jackson

This has some very good info on different things to evaluate when choosing firearm/self-defense policies.

Main points I got:

(1) All policies are different. Do detailed research into limits, components, who selects your lawyer, are they only allowing payments to in-network lawyers?, etc.

(2) Don't trust any products that only offer reimbursement, and only after successfully winning the case. You'll still need massive resources personally to front the money for a quality defense.  And if you choose a plea deal to avoid jail time and a felony charge, the insurance doesn't have to pay you back.


The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

tillamook

you think they are going to make those 4 people with carry permits get insurance?

Flapp_Jackson

you think they are going to make those 4 people with carry permits get insurance?

Even the auto insurance requirement can be waived if you can "self insure". If they don't include that exclusion into the law, the state will be looking at an instant lawsuit.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

punaperson

you think they are going to make those 4 people with carry permits get insurance?
What four people have carry permits?

tillamook

What four people have carry permits?

These 4 that are the only ones in state history that got one

punaperson

you think they are going to make those 4 people with carry permits get insurance?
What four people have carry permits?
These 4 that are the only ones in state history that got one
Oh. You said "have" (I haven't seen the year end carry license issue totals yet... any day now... I thought either 1. a miracle happened, or 2. the AG "made" them issue some licenses to prove that "ordinary law-abiding citizens" get licenses...). I seriously doubt they can even find out who got the permits, good for one year, not renewed, on Maui in 2001, much less make them buy retroactive insurance, unless they have some "back to the future" technology... but I bet when they get it that's what they'll do with it. That permit on Kauai in 2013 was issued for 12 days, so she should get a good pro-rated deal. Judge Masuoka in 2006 was illegally issued a license for a term of 6 months (there is no discretion for term of issuance in the law, it says "one year"), which was then illegally re-issued after four months (you can only apply for renewal within 30 days of expiration) for a term of one year. Not renewed. I noticed that upon renewal he switched from a S&W .357 to a Glock .40. A judge certainly shouldn't need any liability insurance as who would know the law better than him?  :shaka: