Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA (Read 17423 times)

Charles Nichols

From an NRA-ILA email I just received.

"The lawsuit, Livingston v. Ballard, challenges a concealed carry law in Hawaii that requires citizens demonstrate an “urgent” or “exceptional” need for a license. Because of that standard, no ordinary citizens have been issued concealed carry licenses since 2013. "

There is no link to the Complaint but having read all of the NRA Complaints filed this past decade I can pretty much guarantee that it makes the same legal argument that they all have, that states can ban Open Carry in favor of concealed carry even in states such as Massachusettes, New Jersey and Maryland where handgun carry licenses do not differentiate between concealed and Open Carry.

Charles Nichols

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #1 on: March 29, 2019, 05:39:27 PM »
At great expense (approximately $2.50) I have downloaded the NRA's Complaint and attached it to this post.

macsak

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #2 on: March 29, 2019, 06:42:08 PM »
At great expense (approximately $2.50) I have downloaded the NRA's Complaint and attached it to this post.

"kitiya m shiroma"

Charles Nichols

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #3 on: March 29, 2019, 07:11:13 PM »
"kitiya m shiroma"

"Prisencolinensinainciusol"

Heavies

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #4 on: March 29, 2019, 07:21:42 PM »
At great expense (approximately $2.50) I have downloaded the NRA's Complaint and attached it to this post.
:D

Rocky

“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.”
                                                           Franklin D. Roosevelt

punaperson

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #6 on: March 30, 2019, 06:05:16 AM »
I have only read through the brief very quickly, and won't have time to carefully read it until later today or tomorrow, but initially two things stand out.

First, as a relatively minor thing, I note that the brief claims "State of Hawaii's and County of Honolulu's primary basis for seeking en banc review in Young...". I may be wrong but the County of Honolulu was not a party to petition for en banc hearing, the County of Hawaii, where Mr. Young lives and was denied a license, was and is. You guys can't get who the parties in the case are correct? Not a good sign. I may be wrong, but I don't see anyone from the County of Honolulu listed on the petition for en banc. http://michellawyers.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Young-v.-Hawaii_Petition-for-Rehearing-En-Banc_155.pdf

Secondly, Mr. Nichols prediction was correct, as the brief asks for issuance of an open OR concealed carry license on the basis that denying such violates the right protected by the Second Amendment ("Hawaii's  de facto ban on all manner of carry by ordinary citizens both implicates and violates the Second Amendment."). This can only mean that this lawsuit is intended to be decided at some distant future date when SCOTUS has presumably overruled the en banc Ninth Circuit decision in Peruta that there is no constitutionally-protected right to concealed carry. Since all courts in the Ninth Circuit are bound by that decision, asking, as this lawsuit does, that concealed carry be granted because it is a protected right, is, well, worse than useless. But I could be wrong. Someone set me straight. Please.

RSN172

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #7 on: March 30, 2019, 06:29:58 AM »
. But I could be wrong. Someone set me straight. Please.

You are not wrong.  At our age, we will NEVER see the right for law abiding citizens to legally carry a firearm for SD. 
If by some miracle it did pass, the shock of it all would cause us to drop dead from a heart attack.  The end result would
Be the same.......Puna and RSN never got to legally carry in Hawaii.
Happily living in Puna

changemyoil66

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #8 on: March 30, 2019, 07:39:41 AM »
Glad im in my 30s. So maybe when i need a cane, i might be able to carry.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Heavies

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #9 on: March 30, 2019, 08:58:25 AM »
Puma and RSN. Did you guys try apply lately? With the rash of crackhead fueled violence on the BI, maybe that can justify the exceptional need clause?  The police don't seem to have them druggies under control... 

punaperson

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #10 on: March 30, 2019, 10:51:12 AM »
Puma and RSN. Did you guys try apply lately? With the rash of crackhead fueled violence on the BI, maybe that can justify the exceptional need clause?  The police don't seem to have them druggies under control...
There have been two people murdered in my subdivision in the past two months, one just down the street from me. God only knows how many burglaries, robberies, assaults, rapes and home invasions there have been. Unfortunately, as per the AG "letter" specifying the criteria to be issued a license, no amount of surrounding crime is sufficient... a person (lawyer, doctor, entertainer, business owner) must have a "credible threat" that can be "proven". As Evan Nappen, New Jersey attorney fighting their "almost no issue" law there, put it the other day, the only "proof" that would satisfy them there is if you are dead as a result of a crime, you would qualify... otherwise, too bad. You could have crack houses on both sides and across the street... pretty much what I've got here, and you're shit out of luck. I have the application, but there's really no point... unless and until some court issues an order that must be obeyed by the cops/legislature... and even then unless they get really specific there will still be onerous (aka preposterous) requirements for training, renewing, highly limited locations allowable, fees, etc., etc., etc. Somebody prove me wrong. Please.

I've done some searching for a pro bono attorney to handle a denied application... no luck. We need a younger woman with young children who has been sexually assaulted and/or a victim of domestic violence to be the client.

punaperson

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #11 on: March 30, 2019, 10:57:29 AM »
Glad im in my 30s. So maybe when i need a cane, i might be able to carry.
Don't get your hopes up...

This place'll probably be full tilt commie by then and they aren't fond of an armed populace... makes stocking the gulags a tiny bit more cumbersome...

groveler

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #12 on: March 30, 2019, 03:44:22 PM »
You are not wrong.  At our age, we will NEVER see the right for law abiding citizens to legally carry a firearm for SD. 
If by some miracle it did pass, the shock of it all would cause us to drop dead from a heart attack.  The end result would
Be the same.......Puna and RSN never got to legally carry in Hawaii.
Or Groveler! I'm a newbie, but I'm in it for the distance.
Open or concealed carry I don't care.  It is our right!

zippz

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #13 on: March 30, 2019, 05:05:53 PM »
Sounds like NRA wants another shot at SCOTUS and picked Hawaii due to it being the worst for CCW.

Heavies

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #14 on: March 30, 2019, 05:39:17 PM »
There have been two people murdered in my subdivision in the past two months, one just down the street from me. God only knows how many burglaries, robberies, assaults, rapes and home invasions there have been. Unfortunately, as per the AG "letter" specifying the criteria to be issued a license, no amount of surrounding crime is sufficient... a person (lawyer, doctor, entertainer, business owner) must have a "credible threat" that can be "proven". As Evan Nappen, New Jersey attorney fighting their "almost no issue" law there, put it the other day, the only "proof" that would satisfy them there is if you are dead as a result of a crime, you would qualify... otherwise, too bad. You could have crack houses on both sides and across the street... pretty much what I've got here, and you're shit out of luck. I have the application, but there's really no point... unless and until some court issues an order that must be obeyed by the cops/legislature... and even then unless they get really specific there will still be onerous (aka preposterous) requirements for training, renewing, highly limited locations allowable, fees, etc., etc., etc. Somebody prove me wrong. Please.

I've done some searching for a pro bono attorney to handle a denied application... no luck. We need a younger woman with young children who has been sexually assaulted and/or a victim of domestic violence to be the client.
Or Groveler! I'm a newbie, but I'm in it for the distance.
Open or concealed carry I don't care.  It is our right!

I feel for you all.  Sad that the state and counties of Hawaii put their own aristocrat lives at higher value than any other citizen.  It should not be.

Sounds like NRA wants another shot at SCOTUS and picked Hawaii due to it being the worst for CCW.

Im glad to see the NRA stepping up in states that are not a "sure win"  that's what I pay them for, represent me, when the people that do not, do not do it, for sure.

Charles Nichols

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #15 on: March 30, 2019, 08:00:05 PM »
Putting concealed carry aside for the moment, the Complaint assumes that notice pleading is sufficient for a Second Amendment lawsuit.  It should be but Teixeria v. Alameda left no doubt that 2A Complaints are subject to a much higher test to survive a motion to dismiss, which is what Teixeria had appealed. 

Teixeria should have been remanded back to the district court so that he could amend his Complaint.  Instead, the en banc court upheld the motion to dismiss with prejudice.  I suspect as well that declarations are no longer sufficient to defeat a motion to dismiss or a mechanism by which the defects in a Complaint can be cured.

George Young Jr., was never given the opportunity to amend his Complaint.  Like Teixeria, his Complaint was dismissed with prejudice on a motion to dismiss.  When a Complaint is dismissed with prejudice via a motion to dismiss, appellate review is supposed to be pretty straightforward.  The court of appeals looks to the Complaint and looks to any documents referenced in the Complaint and assumes all well-pleaded facts to be true and assumes the Answer to the Complaint (or other responsive filings) to be false.

Mr. Young's appeal was remanded (prior to the three-judge panel decision being vacated) in part because "Young does not address the additional limitation in section 134-9 providing that an open carry license may only be granted “[w]here the urgency or the need has been sufficiently indicated.” Nor could we evaluate such a requirement at the motion to dismiss stage, absent evidence showing the stringency of the requirement. Thus, we do not decide whether such requirement violates the Second Amendment."

I've read the Livingston Complaint a couple of times now.  In which paragraphs does the Complaint challenge the "urgency and need requirement" or attempt to plead an urgency or need?

I'm sure the Complaint would have been fine had it been filed eight or ten years ago but we have had a lot of 2A cases come and go since then.  A Complaint written today should have been written in light of all that has gone before it.

punaperson

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #16 on: March 31, 2019, 07:08:35 AM »
From Ms. Shiroma's Deskgram page (other firearm related photos there too... nice to see someone other than old white guys in the fray...): https://deskgram.net/imaekiss/taggedin?next_id=1449754815369429193

wolfwood

Please add my business facebook page if you are interested in my litigation
https://www.facebook.com/ABeckLaw/

punaperson

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #18 on: April 08, 2019, 02:04:00 PM »
https://www.nratv.com/videos/relentless-sean-brady-hawaii-rifle-association-and-nra-sue-over-hawaiis-concealed-carry-permit-ban

sean got interviewed.

As I posted elsewhere, one of the producers for Dana's show emailed me and asked if I'd be interviewed by Dana re the case. I told her that I had some "issues" with the case so it'd be best to talk to Harvey Gerwig and ask him who he'd recommend. I checked out the show to see who they ended up interviewing... and it was Sean Brady of Michel and Associates, the law firm in charge of the case. This was extremely humorous to me, as we had had a head to head on another forum in which he said some quite amusing things, such as we "secured a victory for the right to carry...  in the Peruta matter." and such. Anyway, among the other things in the interview, note how he completely skirts the open carry vs concealed carry issue (though admittedly Dana is confused about the different criteria for the different licenses), because their lawsuit claims, as they did in Peruta, that a state can ban open carry in favor of concealed carry, or vice versa. Now listen to Scalia read the section of Heller where he says that concealed carry bans are lawful [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmrfyYBdA-E&feature=share]. He does NOT say that open carry bans are lawful.  Note also that while Brady mentions Young, he avoids mentioning Nichols... gee, I wonder why?

Charles Nichols

Re: Livingston v. Ballard - Hawaii concealed carry lawsuit filed by NRA
« Reply #19 on: April 08, 2019, 04:14:45 PM »
As I posted elsewhere, one of the producers for Dana's show emailed me and asked if I'd be interviewed by Dana re the case. I told her that I had some "issues" with the case so it'd be best to talk to Harvey Gerwig and ask him who he'd recommend. I checked out the show to see who they ended up interviewing... and it was Sean Brady of Michel and Associates, the law firm in charge of the case. This was extremely humorous to me, as we had had a head to head on another forum in which he said some quite amusing things, such as we "secured a victory for the right to carry...  in the Peruta matter." and such. Anyway, among the other things in the interview, note how he completely skirts the open carry vs concealed carry issue (though admittedly Dana is confused about the different criteria for the different licenses), because their lawsuit claims, as they did in Peruta, that a state can ban open carry in favor of concealed carry, or vice versa. Now listen to Scalia read the section of Heller where he says that concealed carry bans are lawful [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmrfyYBdA-E&feature=share]. He does NOT say that open carry bans are lawful.  Note also that while Brady mentions Young, he avoids mentioning Nichols... gee, I wonder why?

As an opponent of concealed carry, I view Peruta v. San Diego (en banc) as a victory as well.  Partly because of the 25 or so Amicus briefs filed, mine was the only one which argued that the court should not decide the Open Carry question, which the court ultimately declined to do (despite the protestations to the contrary by the Young v. Hawaii en banc petitioners).   ;D 

I watched Sean Brady and his "partner" Clint B. Monfort argue their summary judgment motion in Flanagan v. Becerra.  It was a train wreck.  They even sat on the wrong side of the courtroom, which the judge pointed out to them.  Monfort, who was seated, stood up to move to the other side of the lectern but the judge told him to sit down.  For some reason, the district court judge didn't want the lawyers playing musical chairs while they were supposed to be arguing their case.  A pity as I was already greatly amused.   :popcorn:

The oral argument made that day by the brain trust from Michel & Associates was the same made in Peruta v. San Diego, which is to say that states can ban Open Carry in favor of concealed carry and so if the then Sheriff of Los Angeles County would give them concealed carry permits then their "prayer for relief" would be satisfied and everyone could go home.

Given that their argument was precluded by their victory in Peruta v. San Diego, they lost of course.  Worse for them, the district court judge said he wasn't going to decide the Open Carry question, not that the plaintiffs have standing to challenge California's Open Carry bans, even if they wanted to challenge California's Open Carry bans, which they don't.  I pointed that out in my Amicus Brief in Flanagan v. Becerra.

Surprisingly, Colion Noir invited me on his show but it fell through because my computer did not have the bandwidth to do video and I wasn't going to spend the money on a new cell phone just for an interview which his slack-jawed yokel* viewers would never understand.  His producer did introduce me to the Cam & Company show producer who, for some reason, never got back to me.   ;)

One of the many things the lawyers at the Michel & Associates NRA left-coast law firm fail to understand is that concealed carry is completely off the table in the 9th circuit, even if SCOTUS hadn't said that concealed carry is not a right.  There is no "alternative outlet" prior precedent in this circuit (which is what saved Wrenn in the DC Circuit).  Peruta v. San Diego en banc is binding in this circuit.  Peruta can only be overruled by a subsequent en banc panel or by SCOTUS.  SCOTUS denied the Peruta cert petition and SCOTUS has already denied several other concealed carry cert petitions this term.  Sorry folks, but the elevation of Judge Kavanuagh to Justice Kavanaugh put the icing on the cake.  His elevation means no concealed carry.

https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4748320/concealed-carry-amendment



Seeing Brady and Monfort in person confirmed a suspicion of mine.  I'm only 5' 10" in height but I tower over those two.  They looked like a couple of scrawny little chickens in cheap suits.  Alan Gura is a runt as well.

* "Slack-jawed yokel," according to Alan Gura, is what those of us are who support Open Carry and who oppose government issued permission slips.