NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally" (Read 60246 times)

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #120 on: May 27, 2019, 11:13:28 PM »
Being an alcoholic is not an arrestable offense. However your comment suggests that you support the police revoking someones firearms rights if they are found to have substance abuse issues. So get 2 DUIs and they get to take away your guns? Attend AA meetings and they get to take away your guns?

Your understanding is flawed. So take the scenario I just mentioned and pretend there is no red flag law. You call the police and say that you believe your brother is a danger. Cops come and talk to him but he plays it cool and denies all the things you claim. Or maybe your brother just politely refuses to speak to police. The cops can call the police psychologist but if they see no warning signs they aren't going to be able to force your brother to go with them to a mental health facility. The system you point to as the solution does not adequately do what you suggest it will, there are holes in the current system, holes that red flag laws are trying to patch.

You can either suggest a workable solution or sit and complain when they come up with a bad type of red flag law that doesn't have enough protections.


I don't get things which are based upon flawed logic.

I have a solution: don't pretend you are qualified to turn your brother into the authorities for having "risky" behaviors.  He's done nothing to warrant being arrested or have his guns taken away.

HYPOTHETICALLY, let's say YOU'RE A COP.  You see a man acting intoxicated on his own property and hurting nobody.  You also know this man owns guns. No neighbors have lodged any complaints about public drunkenness.  As an officer of the law, you need probable cause to arrest him or confiscate his guns.

So, as a "solution", you encourage lawmakers to pass red flag laws. Now, if someone eligible to do so reports that intoxicated man as being a "threat", his guns can be taken away even though he STILL hasn't committed any acts of violence.  As a Cop, you're eligible to report his behavior, and you do so.  His guns are confiscated, and now he has to suffer within the judicial system to recover his own property.

Alcoholism is not a criminal offense, but DUI, drunk and disorderly, and public intoxication are.  It's rare for true alcoholics to never once encounter the police while doing something wrong while drunk.  If the person you're using as an example has never had an alcohol-related visit from the Cops, then I guess he's not much of a nasty drunk, huh?

Please explain why you believe people who have never done anything illegal should be subjected to harassment and unconstitutional confiscation of their property without having broken the law nor explicitly threatened to harm others.  Then, please show a link to the test mental health professionals agree on that predicts violent behavior in humans, in particular those with mental illnesses or substance addictions.  Or, do you support including anyone for any set of reasons created by lawmakers in "risky groups" so their guns can summarily be taken before they ever break the law?

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #121 on: May 27, 2019, 11:31:18 PM »
Laws are ineffective without enforcement.

So, are you (EEF) also in favor of red flag laws punishing anyone who should have reported a murderer before they commit murder?  If you believe bad people display "red flags" that others can interpret, and it can be show those flags were present, why not arrest granny for making the decision to spare her favorite grandson from having to deal with the courts?

In Hawaii especially, people are reluctant to turn anyone in for any reason out of fear of retaliation by the person of their family and friends.  Do you really think people would turn in their family members as "risky" based on no laws broken (yet) unless there's a law mandating they do it? Even then, would the family report anyone?

You haven't thought this "solution" through very well.

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

rpoL98

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #122 on: May 29, 2019, 06:42:40 PM »
Hawaii has a rich tradition of "talk stink".  Red Flag law is just codifying something that already exists in local tradition.  at least, that's how they'll see it.

I mean, hey, look at the Kealoha's.  "Uncle is a mail box thief" as alleged, nieces & nephews being bamboozled, as alleged.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #123 on: June 02, 2019, 08:49:08 AM »
Nevada advances red flag bill. Goes to their dnc gov which he will sign.

Oh and they added in a ban on bump stocks as extra gravy.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #124 on: June 02, 2019, 09:44:26 AM »
Laws are ineffective without enforcement.

So, are you (EEF) also in favor of red flag laws punishing anyone who should have reported a murderer before they commit murder?  If you believe bad people display "red flags" that others can interpret, and it can be show those flags were present, why not arrest granny for making the decision to spare her favorite grandson from having to deal with the courts?

In Hawaii especially, people are reluctant to turn anyone in for any reason out of fear of retaliation by the person of their family and friends.  Do you really think people would turn in their family members as "risky" based on no laws broken (yet) unless there's a law mandating they do it? Even then, would the family report anyone?

You haven't thought this "solution" through very well.

Absolutely, false reports to police need to have a real consequence and this should include false TROs and false red flag type orders. On top of criminal action civil action is an option as well.

People "turn in" their own family members all the time when it comes to mental health issues.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #125 on: June 02, 2019, 10:20:49 AM »
Absolutely, false reports to police need to have a real consequence and this should include false TROs and false red flag type orders. On top of criminal action civil action is an option as well.

People "turn in" their own family members all the time when it comes to mental health issues.

Show me the proof of that "fact".

How many are turned in BEFORE they do or say something violent?  How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting?

Assuming that happens "all the time", then there's really no need for a new red flag law.  Current laws should be adequate.

Talking out of your ass again.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #126 on: June 02, 2019, 11:19:20 AM »
what's your solution Mr. Burgess?
I suggest a Red New Deal or something along those lines

I would envision a system that doesn't center only around firearms because of course they could use a number of weapons.

I would require there to be solid protections for the accused. There must be a higher level of proof that the accused is likely to commit an act of violence, that they be allowed counsel to defend themselves, and that they have a hearing within 48 hour of any revocation of rights.

I think a general system could be implemented where an individual who has reason to believe another individual is dangerous can petition the courts. If sufficient evidence is found then the judge can sign an order to have the person taken in against their will for a mental health evaluation. A psychologist makes an assessment of the individual meanwhile a detective could be assigned to see what evidence can be found to substantiate an allegation that the individual is likely or planning on doing something bad. In 48 hours if the police and the psychologist are unable to find sufficient evidence then the accused gets released and has all his/her rights fully restored. And no reapplication to get his/her own firearms back. However if there is sufficient evidence to believe the person is guilty then another hearing would be held within a reasonable time to determine how long the person should be confined to a mental health institution.

That is the basis I currently have in mind. Might need a few tweaks here and there but I think it a solid basis that recognizes that there needs to be a process to address a dangerous individual quickly but also needs to be ample protections for the accused.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #127 on: June 02, 2019, 11:26:11 AM »
Show me the proof of that "fact".

How many are turned in BEFORE they do or say something violent?  How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting?

Assuming that happens "all the time", then there's really no need for a new red flag law.  Current laws should be adequate.

Talking out of your ass again.

You think every time cops take someone in for an "MH-1" mental health evaluation they just happen to be driving by and see the crazy person?

How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting? Thats a pretty difficult question to answer and I think you know that. Thats like asking how many Einsteins were killed by abortion, you really can't get a solid answer on such a thing. Now there are incidents where it was likely that serious crimes were stopped by reporting. Take the individual in Waikiki who had a hotel room overlooking a major intersection and had a half a dozen firearms in the room. No one can say for sure what exactly he was going to do so ti is impossible to 100% say a crime was stopped.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/38173826/police-find-large-weapons-cache-in-waikiki-raid-prompted-by-disturbing-online-posts/

Where is your proof that no one ever reports family members? Maybe I missed it but I didn't see any rules on this forum that Flapp gets to require proof from everyone else but is exempt from doing it for himself. Sorry but I don't speak assanese.

Your objections basically illustrate that you have no solution. No one can ever be taken in until they commit a crime period. We will catch them after they kill 25 kids at a school or ram a car into a crowd. News flash, that isn't a solution to the problem. A lot of people complained why the flight instructor never told law enforcement that one of his students wanted to learn to take off and disable auto pilot but didn't want to learn to land a plane. After all the terrorist hadn't crashed a plane into any buildings yet and the pilot wasn't a psychologist or expert in mental illness or crime.
« Last Edit: June 02, 2019, 11:39:02 AM by eyeeatingfish »

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #128 on: June 02, 2019, 12:14:36 PM »
You think every time cops take someone in for an "MH-1" mental health evaluation they just happen to be driving by and see the crazy person?

How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting? Thats a pretty difficult question to answer and I think you know that. Thats like asking how many Einsteins were killed by abortion, you really can't get a solid answer on such a thing. Now there are incidents where it was likely that serious crimes were stopped by reporting. Take the individual in Waikiki who had a hotel room overlooking a major intersection and had a half a dozen firearms in the room. No one can say for sure what exactly he was going to do so ti is impossible to 100% say a crime was stopped.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/38173826/police-find-large-weapons-cache-in-waikiki-raid-prompted-by-disturbing-online-posts/

Where is your proof that no one ever reports family members? Maybe I missed it but I didn't see any rules on this forum that Flapp gets to require proof from everyone else but is exempt from doing it for himself. Sorry but I don't speak assanese.

Your objections basically illustrate that you have no solution. No one can ever be taken in until they commit a crime period. We will catch them after they kill 25 kids at a school or ram a car into a crowd. News flash, that isn't a solution to the problem. A lot of people complained why the flight instructor never told law enforcement that one of his students wanted to learn to take off and disable auto pilot but didn't want to learn to land a plane. After all the terrorist hadn't crashed a plane into any buildings yet and the pilot wasn't a psychologist or expert in mental illness or crime.

No.  I think people are reported AFTER THEY PRESENT THEMSELVES AS A THREAT.  Nobody reports someone as "mentally ill".  They report them as a threat to themselves or others.

There are lots of mentally ill people living at home, taking care of themselves, and causing no one harm.  It "happens all the time".   :rofl:
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #129 on: June 03, 2019, 10:11:00 AM »
"mentally ill" is a very vague term.  Like Flap mentioned, many are ill and non-violent. 

So in the end, we know who would enforce unjust laws because they were given "orders" to.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #130 on: June 03, 2019, 07:13:06 PM »
No.  I think people are reported AFTER THEY PRESENT THEMSELVES AS A THREAT.  Nobody reports someone as "mentally ill".  They report them as a threat to themselves or others.

There are lots of mentally ill people living at home, taking care of themselves, and causing no one harm.  It "happens all the time".   :rofl:

I was clearly talking about someone who is mentally ill in a way that is dangerous, not just reporting anyone who might show signs of ADD or something like that.

I have already illustrated to you how the current process police have can easily fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #131 on: June 03, 2019, 07:15:30 PM »
"mentally ill" is a very vague term.  Like Flap mentioned, many are ill and non-violent. 

So in the end, we know who would enforce unjust laws because they were given "orders" to.

This is true, but nowhere did I suggest this was a solution for just anyone who shows just some sign of a mental illness. My cousin washes his hands 5 times is not something to get someone's guns taken away or their freedom for that matter.

What are your thoughts on the system I mentioned to Red a few posts above?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #132 on: June 03, 2019, 08:17:37 PM »
I was clearly talking about someone who is mentally ill in a way that is dangerous, not just reporting anyone who might show signs of ADD or something like that.

I have already illustrated to you how the current process police have can easily fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.

And you've yet to illustrate how red flag laws will do anything other than continue to fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.  We've had several shootings by people who were identified as risks, and the police did nothing by way of stopping them.  If the person passes the evaluation, there's nothing they can do  Under the red flag scenario, they'd get their guns back.  Nothing changes.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #133 on: June 13, 2019, 10:00:13 PM »
And you've yet to illustrate how red flag laws will do anything other than continue to fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.  We've had several shootings by people who were identified as risks, and the police did nothing by way of stopping them.  If the person passes the evaluation, there's nothing they can do  Under the red flag scenario, they'd get their guns back.  Nothing changes.

I have laid out a number of situations that a red flag law could address.

Yes, you are right that if a person passes the evaluation there is nothing law enforcement or the courts can do but the key part you continue to miss (or ignore?) is that there is inadequate resources to force a person to get such an evaluation. Police only have a certain narrow window to work within in order to force a person to get an evaluation and people can fairly easily slip through.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #134 on: June 14, 2019, 11:29:37 AM »
I have laid out a number of situations that a red flag law could address.

Yes, you are right that if a person passes the evaluation there is nothing law enforcement or the courts can do but the key part you continue to miss (or ignore?) is that there is inadequate resources to force a person to get such an evaluation. Police only have a certain narrow window to work within in order to force a person to get an evaluation and people can fairly easily slip through.

I remember when a guy was arrested for being in his underwear at Ross with a knife waving.  He was found to be mentally fit by the state mental health person.  He killed someone the next day.  He didn't use a gun.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #135 on: June 18, 2019, 09:58:45 PM »
I remember when a guy was arrested for being in his underwear at Ross with a knife waving.  He was found to be mentally fit by the state mental health person.  He killed someone the next day.  He didn't use a gun.

Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #136 on: June 18, 2019, 10:22:57 PM »
Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.

maybe the doc should get a crystal ball? hire a psychic? We are just as accurate predicting the weather as we are predicting our own behavior.
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #137 on: June 19, 2019, 08:55:58 AM »
Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.

I'm leaning toward didn't do her job.  Because a guy in his underwear waving a knife in a retail store is not something a sane person would do.  It's not like there was video of it...oh wait, there is. 

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #138 on: June 19, 2019, 10:08:28 AM »
I'm leaning toward didn't do her job.  Because a guy in his underwear waving a knife in a retail store is not something a sane person would do.  It's not like there was video of it...oh wait, there is.

Medical professionals admit there is NO METHOD known to science that can predict who among us will commit an act of violence and who will not.

That's a fact.

It's so easy to say "She didn't do her job".  What if he hadn't stabbed someone?  Would you then say she did her job?

We can't hold healthcare workers to an outcome-based standard.  Human behavior is not as predictable as the marketing people like to have us believe.  Marketing firms try to influence behavior through product placement in stores, coupons, sales, media ad campaigns, free samples in stores, etc.  That's not predicting.  That's influencing.

Healthcare workers don't influence a sick person's decisions.  Most likely a truly sick person can't be convinced to abandon violent intentions.  The thought processes are not normal, so normal methods of persuasion have less chance of succeeding.

One big problem with the gun control debate is caused by the very belief you stated -- that the healthcare worker can stop violence if they do their job right.  Reality tells us you can't predict or stop a violent act especially if the perp is mentally defective.  Gun control is not about controlling guns.  It's about controlling people.  Since behavior can not be controlled -- only punished after the fact -- your expectations are set way too high.

1-  Healthcare professionals are not held legally liable if they set a dangerous person free and that person hurts or kills someone

2- Mental health doctors don't lock every person up that presents with a mental illness to err on the side of caution.

Those facts prove that even legislators and doctors understand nobody can be held accountable for failing to predict another's behavior.  The only way to stop people with a diagnosis of mental illness from committing violence is to lock them all up until their symptoms are controlled.  That's not only not going to happen (human rights), but it would prove the real crazy people we should fear are under the radar and can't be controlled no matter what the system tries.

It's a massive, complex problem.  That's the way most human behavior problems are.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #139 on: June 19, 2019, 10:33:12 AM »
I agree if  it's some normal looking person.  But when you have a dude in his underwear waving a knife around in a retail store, that screams something isn't right.   Vid shows that it wasn't self defense.

Now this differs from some dude wearing clothes and claiming self defense is the reason why he took his knife out.

Same goes with that lady walking naked in Hawaii Kai.  Either #1 she was attacked sexually or #2 she's not all there, or #3 her clothes were on fire.