NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally" (Read 60257 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #80 on: May 10, 2019, 08:16:29 PM »
The red flags law deny all due process. Your guns get taken away prior to your court date where you have the chance to defend accusations.

There is no "partial". HPD shows up at your door and u had no clue.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

It's not like that is the only right that gets taken away before a court date.
If you get arrested for a crime based on probable cause you can be held until your court date. But the due process exists in things like the right to appeal, the right to a speedy trial, etc.  So I don't think it is unprecedented legally speaking to consider taking firearms away prior to a court hearing as long as there are protections in place like the ones I mentioned.


What do you think about the medical situation I mentioned in the post above? Should a person with a probably dangerous and contagious infection be allowed to walk around free until a test result confirms a diagnosis and courts order the person confined?

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #81 on: May 11, 2019, 11:02:01 AM »
So is it illegal to walk around with HIV/AIDS? Quaranteening someone is different from removing their right. Pretty sure if you have ebola, u will willlingly be in a hostpital or place of treatment without grumbling.

Can u name another right that is stripped until your court date to defend yourself? Right to vote, speech, press, religion, etc...

The media is making you think we need red flag laws. Like how they make people think we have an "assault rifle" problem, even though it was invented in 1957.



Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
« Last Edit: May 11, 2019, 11:11:24 AM by changemyoil66 »

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #82 on: May 11, 2019, 01:47:42 PM »
So is it illegal to walk around with HIV/AIDS? Quaranteening someone is different from removing their right. Pretty sure if you have ebola, u will willlingly be in a hostpital or place of treatment without grumbling.

Can u name another right that is stripped until your court date to defend yourself? Right to vote, speech, press, religion, etc...

The media is making you think we need red flag laws. Like how they make people think we have an "assault rifle" problem, even though it was invented in 1957.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

HIV is not very contagious so it isn't a very good comparison. I was thinking something more like ebola, small pox, or the plague.

Surprisingly, it is pretty common for people who think they have ebola to not want to go to ebola treatment centers. This has been noted in some African countries where Ebola is more common. Logically  I would agree with you but there seems to be something illogical about people's behavior. Maybe a fear they will catch it from other patients if they have symptoms but it is something else, or believing that going to the hospital just means you will never leave again (die there). But even if there were not such a phenomenon here in America you could still have an individual who decides to walk around in public.

So in such an instance, do you think a person should be allowed to walk around freely until he can have a court hearing?

As for other rights that are stripped, if you are arrested for a crime you can be held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date. That would be the most obvious one I can think of but there may be a few others. The medical quarantine laws might be another example but to be honest I don't fully understand the process of a judge ordering someone to be put in quarantine. I am sure there is a right to appeal but I don't think one necessarily gets a court hearing before a judge can order them quarantined.


The media isn't making me thing we need red flag laws. I have contemplated on the idea a fair amount outside of just legislators or the media saying we need it.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #83 on: May 11, 2019, 03:13:31 PM »
As for other rights that are stripped, if you are arrested for a crime you can be held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date.

Bullshit.  Arrest and detention involves due process. You're mirandized. You have the right to a lawyer.  You have to be arraigned in so many hours or be released without charges.  You may have the right to be freed on bail.

All of that, and more, is part of due process.  You won't be "held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date" unless and until your arraignment, which comes before any other limits are placed on your rights.  There has to be a warrant issued based on probable cause to violate your 4th amendment rights.

Red flags skip this whole judicial system designed to protect the rights of the accused and go right to firearm confiscation based on an ex parte process.  You may not even be arrested. They just confiscate your firearms.  Without an arrest, due process is not being Constitutionally violated.  it amounts to civil forfeiture based on a complaint without adequate protections for the accused.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #84 on: May 11, 2019, 03:32:41 PM »
red flag laws are dumb - drafted and conjured up by fearful, paranoid, gun-hating snowflakes who use govt to confiscate legally acquired firearms.
Dunno why you guys are asking that particular LEO about this, he would gladly come to your house and take your guns.
Deeds Not Words

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #85 on: May 11, 2019, 05:56:56 PM »
Bullshit.  Arrest and detention involves due process. You're mirandized. You have the right to a lawyer.  You have to be arraigned in so many hours or be released without charges.  You may have the right to be freed on bail.

All of that, and more, is part of due process.  You won't be "held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date" unless and until your arraignment, which comes before any other limits are placed on your rights.  There has to be a warrant issued based on probable cause to violate your 4th amendment rights.

Red flags skip this whole judicial system designed to protect the rights of the accused and go right to firearm confiscation based on an ex parte process.  You may not even be arrested. They just confiscate your firearms.  Without an arrest, due process is not being Constitutionally violated.  it amounts to civil forfeiture based on a complaint without adequate protections for the accused.

You can be held for up to 48 hours without actually being charged.
Then you can be held until arraignment.
Then (if you don't bail out) you can be held till your actual trial and you are convicted of a crime.


Now you might not think there is enough due process protections but the fact is the language does contain some due process for the accused.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB1466_HD2_.htm
The accuser may be required to testify under oath.
The respondent (accused) gets a hearing 14 days after the initial order is served
The accused can get a lawyer
Even if the 1 year prohibition is granted the accused can still petition the court at any time to remove the order.

Now I don't think that is quite enough protections but we can't sit around pretending there are no protections.



What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #86 on: May 11, 2019, 06:16:23 PM »
You can be held for up to 48 hours without actually being charged.
Then you can be held until arraignment.
Then (if you don't bail out) you can be held till your actual trial and you are convicted of a crime.


Now you might not think there is enough due process protections but the fact is the language does contain some due process for the accused.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB1466_HD2_.htm
The accuser may be required to testify under oath.
The respondent (accused) gets a hearing 14 days after the initial order is served
The accused can get a lawyer
Even if the 1 year prohibition is granted the accused can still petition the court at any time to remove the order.

Now I don't think that is quite enough protections but we can't sit around pretending there are no protections.



What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?

"A" process is not "due" process.  Confiscation is a deliberate punishment. Once again, if the person is so dangerous to the public they can't have guns, then detaining them and using EXISTING due process makes more sense.

The gaping hole in the logic of red flag laws is identical to denying guns to felons. You're preemptively violating a right without the person having done anything wrong to justify losing 2A rights. Most felons are not violent offenders. If they are violent, and they are too much of a safety risk to allow them to have guns, then they are too much of a risk to be free in society.

Same argument applies to "red flag" defendants. Lock them up, or don't.  Taking their guns is not a solution.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #87 on: May 11, 2019, 06:23:53 PM »
What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?

Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #88 on: May 11, 2019, 08:02:03 PM »
Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.

no tests...just a big red flag! Go get em
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #89 on: May 11, 2019, 08:06:48 PM »
If youre held in jail until your court date many rights are loss. Compared to a red flag where 2 are lost. The 2a is the only right thats targeted.

If someone had ebola, they would probably die before their court date.


So many sheriff departments said they will not enforce a red flag law. Would you "just follow orders" and enforce it?

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #90 on: May 11, 2019, 08:10:46 PM »
like many others have stated apply this red flag law to cars and people would be up in arms..the ACLU would step in, Mazie would demand answers, AARP would have a wheelchair riot etc.
but all these people are for disarming the law abiding citizens in order to do "something"
well, few realize that the "something" doesn't always do anything. You can yell at a tree to move all you want - but you did do "something" tree still there
We can pass more laws about drinking and driving to do something but until people start obeying the law it isn't going to do jack shit.
And guess what? gun owners are vetted law abiding citizens. Just by nature of the process. SO we are easy pickings when they pass a law. You think the average citizen will obey the law of drinking and NOT driving? How about speeding? See a car speeding "red flag" the car for confiscation as a speeding car is just as dangerous as a loaded gun in a preschool cubby hole.

This red flag law is complete horse shit!
Deeds Not Words

punaperson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #91 on: May 12, 2019, 07:29:57 AM »
like many others have stated apply this red flag law to cars and people would be up in arms..the ACLU would step in, Mazie would demand answers, AARP would have a wheelchair riot etc.
but all these people are for disarming the law abiding citizens in order to do "something"
well, few realize that the "something" doesn't always do anything. You can yell at a tree to move all you want - but you did do "something" tree still there
We can pass more laws about drinking and driving to do something but until people start obeying the law it isn't going to do jack shit.
And guess what? gun owners are vetted law abiding citizens. Just by nature of the process. SO we are easy pickings when they pass a law. You think the average citizen will obey the law of drinking and NOT driving? How about speeding? See a car speeding "red flag" the car for confiscation as a speeding car is just as dangerous as a loaded gun in a preschool cubby hole.

This red flag law is complete horse shit!
And yet... this is what "our" legislators "serve" us with... by a near unanimous vote! While the vast majority of ("socialist Democrat") voters in Hawaii apparently take great delight in seeing us being repeatedly bent over.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #92 on: May 12, 2019, 08:04:21 AM »
Good example about applying the same to cars and others. The 2 is the only right shit on all the time.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #93 on: May 13, 2019, 08:48:58 PM »
"A" process is not "due" process.  Confiscation is a deliberate punishment. Once again, if the person is so dangerous to the public they can't have guns, then detaining them and using EXISTING due process makes more sense.

The gaping hole in the logic of red flag laws is identical to denying guns to felons. You're preemptively violating a right without the person having done anything wrong to justify losing 2A rights. Most felons are not violent offenders. If they are violent, and they are too much of a safety risk to allow them to have guns, then they are too much of a risk to be free in society.

Same argument applies to "red flag" defendants. Lock them up, or don't.  Taking their guns is not a solution.

I do agree that if we think they are dangerous we should consider locking them up, not just taking away their firearms. Taking away their firearms doesn't make them no longer a threat. We are in definite agreement there.

A red flag law that is based off evidence and testimony, just like a normal criminal case, could stand the constitutional test in my opinion. Again, I am not saying that I support the particular red flag law we have now, I just can envision a form of red flag law that does respect due process and constitutional rights. The concept is workable but only with appropriate protections.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #94 on: May 13, 2019, 08:52:37 PM »
Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.

There are tests to help diagnose mental illnesses.

Whether in the disease scenario or a mental health scenario you have comparable similarities.
-Symptoms visible to people around the individual
-A person may refuse to seek medical or mental health evaluation
-The person may be a risk to others if the individual actually does have the condition in question.
-The situation deals with someone's constitutional rights being taken away.

So again I ask, should someone with symptoms of a deadly contagious disease be allowed to walk around free until someone can petition the court and he can have a court hearing before taking any rights away?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #95 on: May 13, 2019, 09:28:16 PM »
There are tests to help diagnose mental illnesses.

Whether in the disease scenario or a mental health scenario you have comparable similarities.
-Symptoms visible to people around the individual
-A person may refuse to seek medical or mental health evaluation
-The person may be a risk to others if the individual actually does have the condition in question.
-The situation deals with someone's constitutional rights being taken away.

So again I ask, should someone with symptoms of a deadly contagious disease be allowed to walk around free until someone can petition the court and he can have a court hearing before taking any rights away?

Statistically, the rate of violence among people diagnosed as mentally ill is nearly identical to the rate among the rest of the population.

Simply pigeon-holing someone as mentally ill has no additional impact on public safety.  Mentally ill are living and walking among the rest of us because they have civil rights to not be locked up if they haven't committed a crime or are unable to care for themselves.

Psychologists agree that there is no way for mental health professionals to identify who among us will commit an act of violence.  That includes the mentally ill.

Your hypothetical disease is still irrelevant.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #96 on: May 14, 2019, 08:51:03 AM »
The problem with the example is this.  I'm using ebola because it's easy to type.  A test will confirm you either have ebola or not.  So if you have it, it's highly contagious.  Are there test for mental issues, yes there are.  But shooting people or acting violently is what the test cannot prove will happen.  There are lots of non-violent people with mental problems.

And with ebola, you will probably feel like shit and seek help.  So the carrier is willingly going there or to sick to move.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #97 on: May 17, 2019, 12:31:07 PM »
a liquor store in downtown has due process more than we will have under this "red flag" BS of a law
https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #98 on: May 17, 2019, 12:50:14 PM »
a liquor store in downtown has due process more than we will have under this "red flag" BS of a law
https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license

That's because none of the following filed a complaint: family member, teacher, doctor, coworker.  :rofl:

It's just you know, the people, mayor, HPD, and everyone else.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #99 on: May 25, 2019, 08:00:48 PM »
Statistically, the rate of violence among people diagnosed as mentally ill is nearly identical to the rate among the rest of the population.

Simply pigeon-holing someone as mentally ill has no additional impact on public safety.  Mentally ill are living and walking among the rest of us because they have civil rights to not be locked up if they haven't committed a crime or are unable to care for themselves.

Psychologists agree that there is no way for mental health professionals to identify who among us will commit an act of violence.  That includes the mentally ill.

Your hypothetical disease is still irrelevant.

Maybe if you lump them together but some mental illnesses  do have higher rates of violence while others have lower rates of violence.  Of course we can't take a one size fits all approach.

I think you say my hypothetical scenario is irrelevant because you know you don't have a good answer. Even if you didn't think it was a good comparison you still couldn't answer the question.

You never even answered my earlier question about what to do with someone who shows signs of being mentally ill and violent but has committed no crime. You complain about proposed solutions but offer none of your own.