Court: Brandishing NOT a crime even when no threat of imminent death/injury (Read 1739 times)

punaperson


Some people would call this decision "commonsense" (no, not THOSE people). This would never be allowed in Hawaii unless imposed by a higher court, and that will never happen with the Ninth Circuit... so only SCOTUS could impose such "commonsense" on this gawdawful state.

Read the full story for the details.

A Michigan Court Case Shows the Right of Armed Self-Defense Is Broader Than You Might Think

https://www.nationalreview.com/2019/08/a-michigan-court-case-shows-the-right-of-armed-self-defense-is-broader-than-you-might-think/?amp

The jury was instructed only on the affirmative defense of self-defense through the use of “deadly force.” To prove that deadly force was appropriate, a defendant has to prove that she “reasonably believes that the use of deadly force is necessary to prevent the imminent death of or imminent great bodily harm to himself or herself or to another individual.” (Emphasis added.)

Under this reasoning, a person could brandish a weapon only when she has the legal right to fire the weapon.

The court of appeals, however, said that’s not the law. When one brandishes a weapon without firing it, they don’t, in fact, use “deadly force.” They use nondeadly force, and the legal standard for the use of nondeadly force only requires the defendant to prove that she “reasonably believes that the use of that force is necessary to defend himself or herself or another individual from the imminent unlawful use of force by another individual.” (Emphasis added.)

Under this reasoning, a person can brandish a weapon to prevent the imminent use of force from escalating to a threat of imminent death.

As the court noted, “merely to threaten death or serious bodily harm, without any intention to carry out the threat, is not to use deadly force, so that one may be justified in pointing a gun at his attacker when he would not be justified pulling the trigger.” There’s a commonsense element to this conclusion. Police officers, for example, sometimes point a weapon at an individual as a means of preventing unlawful force even when they don’t have the legal right to fire a shot.

Flapp_Jackson

Some people would call this decision "commonsense" (no, not THOSE people). This would never be allowed in Hawaii unless imposed by a higher court, and that will never happen with the Ninth Circuit... so only SCOTUS could impose such "commonsense" on this gawdawful state.

Read the full story for the details.

A Michigan Court Case Shows the Right of Armed Self-Defense Is Broader Than You Might Think

https://www.nationalreview.com/2019/08/a-michigan-court-case-shows-the-right-of-armed-self-defense-is-broader-than-you-might-think/?amp

The jury was instructed only on the affirmative defense of self-defense through the use of “deadly force.” To prove that deadly force was appropriate, a defendant has to prove that she “reasonably believes that the use of deadly force is necessary to prevent the imminent death of or imminent great bodily harm to himself or herself or to another individual.” (Emphasis added.)

Under this reasoning, a person could brandish a weapon only when she has the legal right to fire the weapon.

The court of appeals, however, said that’s not the law. When one brandishes a weapon without firing it, they don’t, in fact, use “deadly force.” They use nondeadly force, and the legal standard for the use of nondeadly force only requires the defendant to prove that she “reasonably believes that the use of that force is necessary to defend himself or herself or another individual from the imminent unlawful use of force by another individual.” (Emphasis added.)

Under this reasoning, a person can brandish a weapon to prevent the imminent use of force from escalating to a threat of imminent death.

As the court noted, “merely to threaten death or serious bodily harm, without any intention to carry out the threat, is not to use deadly force, so that one may be justified in pointing a gun at his attacker when he would not be justified pulling the trigger.” There’s a commonsense element to this conclusion. Police officers, for example, sometimes point a weapon at an individual as a means of preventing unlawful force even when they don’t have the legal right to fire a shot.

This is what happens when people try to control every aspect of human behavior in all situations through statutes.

There should not be any laws telling anyone what they can do to defend themselves, From use of deadly force to saying threatening words, whatever the individual deems an appropriate response to a potential threat is THEIR CALL.

The RESULTS of that decision (shooting someone) should obviously be reviewed to ensure the situation was in fact self defense, and that the individual (not the dead guy's mother) reasonably believed they used that force necessary to stop the threat and to defend themselves.

Brandishing causes no physical results.  No one is injured, no property is damaged, etc.  Again, to point a weapon at someone threatening you should be up to YOU, not some law that deduces whether it was necessary based on some stupid idea that if you didn't shoot, then you didn't believe the threat was that severe.

From my research (based on others' research), the vast majority of Defensive Gun Uses (DGUs) involve no shots fired.  The mere presentation of a firearm stops the threat usually causing the assailant to flee.  These encounters are routinely not reported to law enforcement, since the initial crime was only "attempted" with no injury or theft resulting from it.  It's one reason the number of DGUs in the US has such a massive range of possible numbers.  Without being reported, we have no way of know how often DGUs with no shots fired occur.

Brandishing in public without cause should, of course, be unlawful.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

mrgaf

Makes sense however the PRH is “different”
To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.  Thomas Paine.

No man can get rich in politics unless he is a crook.  It cannot be done. Harry Truman

Only good liberal is one taking a dirt nap.