Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit! (Read 19466 times)

Funtimes

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #20 on: July 07, 2012, 10:51:12 AM »
TROs are not a waste of time. They are no guarantee that someone will not bother you but in many cases it does make a difference even against scum.

If the person refuses to sign the TRO the cop will just issue it anyway and put in his report that the TRO was issued but the respondent was uncooperative.

I don't need you sign a document to be served with that document.  It's not voluntary.  The TRO is issued by the court and then served, all we need is to identify you and *give* you the paperwork.

Background: I serve court documents to keep the lights on :).
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

crazy cat

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #21 on: July 08, 2012, 10:40:14 AM »
This whole scene happened in the courtroom in Keaau; I was there and saw the whole thing.  My friend showed up for the hearing, the scumbag's wife accuser had her say, and then the bailiff put a paper down which my friend simply refused to sign*.  Since she hadn't actually been convicted of anything, turns out that there wasn't any cause to take her firearms.  Of course, if the Judge had decided to push it, the gun club would have hired an attorney and we all would have found out whether your Second Amendment rights can be infringed upon in the absence of a CONVICTION.

Ignoring the summons is not a good idea; but showing up in court and then refusing to voluntarily surrender your firearms is a different thing entirely.

*She told me later that she expected to be arrested at that point.  But she wasn't arrested, because she hadn't broken the law.

Funtimes

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #22 on: July 08, 2012, 04:19:29 PM »
This whole scene happened in the courtroom in Keaau; I was there and saw the whole thing.  My friend showed up for the hearing, the scumbag's wife accuser had her say, and then the bailiff put a paper down which my friend simply refused to sign*.  Since she hadn't actually been convicted of anything, turns out that there wasn't any cause to take her firearms.  Of course, if the Judge had decided to push it, the gun club would have hired an attorney and we all would have found out whether your Second Amendment rights can be infringed upon in the absence of a CONVICTION.

Ignoring the summons is not a good idea; but showing up in court and then refusing to voluntarily surrender your firearms is a different thing entirely.

*She told me later that she expected to be arrested at that point.  But she wasn't arrested, because she hadn't broken the law.

If the TRO is issued, your guns are taken when the writ is served.   Sounds to me is something else was going on besides the TRO.  I would say 99% of TRO's are ex-parte, so you wouldn't be there for a hearing until AFTER it was issued.  The TRO itself is not voluntary. I've seen cops that couldn't work because of TRO's.. I have had instructors have to call out because they can't train because of a TRO.  We wouldn't do this stuff voluntarily.
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

crazy cat

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #23 on: July 09, 2012, 09:11:48 PM »
So the whole "innocent until proven guilty" thing doesn't apply? 

bass monkey

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #24 on: July 09, 2012, 09:30:14 PM »
Hilarious huh how the legal system in america works.

Heavies

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #25 on: July 10, 2012, 03:22:03 AM »
So the whole "innocent until proven guilty" thing doesn't apply? 



I was wondering the same thing.  I just can not wrap my head around how it is possible to suspend one rights with out charge or trial, pretty much just an accusation of wrongdoing, with no options to contest the accusation. I'm not saying every case is frivolous, but that just doesn't seem correct to me.

Hilarious huh how the legal system in america works.

I think this is NOT the way the legal system in America works...  ???

Colt808

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #26 on: July 10, 2012, 03:56:52 AM »
Quote
07/07/2012 11:05:21 AM EDT -- Honolulu Star-Advertiser (HI)

Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit


A harassment conviction, even if it involved striking, shoving or kicking another person, is not a crime of violence under state law and therefore does not disqualify someone from obtaining a firearms permit, a federal judge has ruled.

U.S. District Judge Alan Kay made the finding last week when he issued a preliminary injunction ordering Honolulu Police Chief Louis Kealoha to issue Kirk C. Fisher a permit to acquire firearms.

Police arrested Fisher in 1997 on two counts of abuse involving his wife and daughter. They later charged him instead with harassment, to which Fisher pleaded guilty.

After his arrest in November 1997, a family court judge ordered Fisher to turn in his firearms to police, which he did.

After he completed his six months of probation, Fisher sought to get back his firearms. In December 1998, another family court judge ordered police to return the firearms to Fisher as long as state or federal law did not prohibit him from possessing them.

Police complied and returned the firearms.

In 2009, Fisher applied for a permit to obtain another firearm.

Acting Police Chief Paul Putzulu denied the request. He said Fisher was not qualified to own or possess a firearm because of his 1997 harassment conviction. He also ordered Fisher to turn in whatever firearms he already possessed within 30 days.

Instead, Fisher transferred ownership of them to his wife, who had obtained her own permits.

After failing to persuade police to reconsider his permit application, Fisher last September sued Kealoha, Putzulu, the department and the city in federal court, claiming violation of his constitutional rights to bear arms and to due process.

State law directs the chiefs of police of the respective counties to be the issuing authority for firearm permits.

The law prohibits anyone who has been convicted in Hawaii or anywhere else of a felony, any crime of violence or of the illegal sale of any drug from owning or possessing a firearm.

It defines crime of violence as any offense, as defined in the state penal code, that involves injury or threat of injury to another person.

The crime for which Fisher was convicted is for striking, shoving, kicking or otherwise touching another person in an offensive manner or for subjecting another person to offensive physical contact with the intent to harass, annoy or alarm the other person.

HPD says it denies firearm permits to people convicted of harassment when it involves striking, shoving or kicking. The police departments for Maui, Kauai and Hawaii counties say that is their practice as well.

Kay says in his order that he is unaware of any case law to support their claim that harassment is a crime of violence that involves injury or threat of injury to another person. Nor have lawyers for Kealoha and the city cited any, he said.

The department says it has not seen Kay's order.

Fisher's lawyer, Donald Wilkerson, said he has not served HPD with Kay's order but that Fisher will reapply for a firearms permit sometime this week.

The four county police departments processed 15,375 firearm permit applications in 2011, according to data compiled by the state Attorney General's Office.

They rejected 230, or 1.5 percent, of the applications. Almost half of the rejections, 112, were due to the applicants' prior criminal history. Nine were for harassment.

Credit: Nelson Daranciang


(c) 2012 Oahu Publications Inc.

Reason obeys itself; and ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it. ~Thomas Paine


And I still see stupid people.

Cougar8045

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #27 on: July 10, 2012, 09:00:14 AM »
So the whole "innocent until proven guilty" thing doesn't apply?
No, it doesn't.  I was the instructor who had to cancel because of a TRO; there is no option not to sign or refuse service or anything of the sort.  You don't even find out this stuff is afoot until a nice officer from the SWAT team calls you to tell you you're about to be served with a TRO.  Then you talk to your lawyer, who tells you to go sign the paperwork, turn in your guns, and stand by for a hearing.  Your hearing will be scheduled for within ten days.  When your day in court arrives, you and your lawyer will show up at court and wait to be called.  (Unless they don't get to you that day, in which case you can sit around and have a $1200 conversation with your lawyer.  Hope you get along well with him.)  After they stay your hearing for another week, you show up, go into court, and finally get to defend yourself.  (At this point you've been disarmed for about three weeks.)  Once you tell your side of the story, and the judge agrees that your ex-wife is full of fluff and that you're a wonderful man who should be afforded the full confidence and trust of owning firearms again, the TRO is dissolved.  (Boo-yah!  I'mma git mah guns back!)  Then you go to HPD to show them the paperwork that says you're a good person, and that the case was dismissed with prejudice.  They tell you to just hold on, you need to get a court order demanding the return of firearms from "evidence".  F**K!!

All right, fine.  Call your lawyer up again.  Good thing you hired a standout attorney; he's already filed the paperwork for that hearing, and it'll be heard in a few weeks.  (In the meantime, HPD has no reason to deny you a permit to acquire, so snub your nose at "the man" by applying for a long gun permit, and buying yourself a shiny new gun.  Might as well, right?)  Finally your hearing for the return of your firearms comes up, and of course the judge grants the order.  Hooray!  Now you can go BACK to HPD, show them that *additional* paperwork, and be good to go...after you fill out permit to acquire paperwork, submit to a new background check, and wait the requisite two weeks.  (Go back home, play with the shiny gun, and grumble some more.)  After THAT two weeks is up, you can triumphantly head down to HPD and get your guns back.  Total time: about two months.  Total cost: about $4,000. 

Remember, this is the process for someone who is manifestly innocent of ANY wrongdoing.  I hold a DoD security clearance, I am an NRA-certified instructor, and all my friends tell me I'm an all-around good fellow.  My ex decided to pursue a TRO for leverage in our divorce; it was entirely spurious, but it was still an ordeal that cost me thousands of dollars and several months of anxiety.  Did I mention that this whole sh*t-show didn't cost my ex a thin dime?  Honestly, I can't think of a single reason why everyone involved in a contested divorce wouldn't file a spurious TRO, it costs you nothing but a few hours of your time, and you might get lucky and hang a protective order on the ex, which will follow that person around for life and all but guarantee you a favorable outcome in the divorce proceeding. 

And that, my friends, is why I think TROs are a bunch of bull-butter.
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

DuckFat

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #28 on: July 10, 2012, 09:51:04 AM »
No, it doesn't.  I was the instructor who had to cancel because of a TRO; there is no option not to sign or refuse service or anything of the sort.  You don't even find out this stuff is afoot until a nice officer from the SWAT team calls you to tell you you're about to be served with a TRO. 
[massive snip]
And that, my friends, is why I think TROs are a bunch of bull-butter.
Totally agree. TROs and rape claims really needs to be handled differently. It can devastate the life of someone falsely accused.
http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/05/25/11877259-california-high-school-football-star-cleared-of-rape-10-years-later?lite
What if rhinos are just fat unicorns?

Tom_G

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #29 on: July 10, 2012, 03:19:32 PM »
Wow.  What an excellent description.

Working in the spirit of this system, it seems to be that a lawsuit for harassment would be completely in line!

No, it doesn't.  I was the instructor who had to cancel because of a TRO; there is no option not to sign or refuse service or anything of the sort.  You don't even find out this stuff is afoot until a nice officer from the SWAT team calls you to tell you you're about to be served with a TRO.  Then you talk to your lawyer, who tells you to go sign the paperwork, turn in your guns, and stand by for a hearing.  Your hearing will be scheduled for within ten days.  When your day in court arrives, you and your lawyer will show up at court and wait to be called.  (Unless they don't get to you that day, in which case you can sit around and have a $1200 conversation with your lawyer.  Hope you get along well with him.)  After they stay your hearing for another week, you show up, go into court, and finally get to defend yourself.  (At this point you've been disarmed for about three weeks.)  Once you tell your side of the story, and the judge agrees that your ex-wife is full of fluff and that you're a wonderful man who should be afforded the full confidence and trust of owning firearms again, the TRO is dissolved.  (Boo-yah!  I'mma git mah guns back!)  Then you go to HPD to show them the paperwork that says you're a good person, and that the case was dismissed with prejudice.  They tell you to just hold on, you need to get a court order demanding the return of firearms from "evidence".  F**K!!

All right, fine.  Call your lawyer up again.  Good thing you hired a standout attorney; he's already filed the paperwork for that hearing, and it'll be heard in a few weeks.  (In the meantime, HPD has no reason to deny you a permit to acquire, so snub your nose at "the man" by applying for a long gun permit, and buying yourself a shiny new gun.  Might as well, right?)  Finally your hearing for the return of your firearms comes up, and of course the judge grants the order.  Hooray!  Now you can go BACK to HPD, show them that *additional* paperwork, and be good to go...after you fill out permit to acquire paperwork, submit to a new background check, and wait the requisite two weeks.  (Go back home, play with the shiny gun, and grumble some more.)  After THAT two weeks is up, you can triumphantly head down to HPD and get your guns back.  Total time: about two months.  Total cost: about $4,000. 

Remember, this is the process for someone who is manifestly innocent of ANY wrongdoing.  I hold a DoD security clearance, I am an NRA-certified instructor, and all my friends tell me I'm an all-around good fellow.  My ex decided to pursue a TRO for leverage in our divorce; it was entirely spurious, but it was still an ordeal that cost me thousands of dollars and several months of anxiety.  Did I mention that this whole sh*t-show didn't cost my ex a thin dime?  Honestly, I can't think of a single reason why everyone involved in a contested divorce wouldn't file a spurious TRO, it costs you nothing but a few hours of your time, and you might get lucky and hang a protective order on the ex, which will follow that person around for life and all but guarantee you a favorable outcome in the divorce proceeding. 

And that, my friends, is why I think TROs are a bunch of bull-butter.
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

bass monkey

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #30 on: July 10, 2012, 03:35:16 PM »
Hilarious huh how the legal system in america works.

And I will say it again!

crazy cat

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #31 on: July 11, 2012, 09:43:42 AM »
Then you talk to your lawyer, who tells you to go sign the paperwork, turn in your guns, and stand by for a hearing. 

Just 'cause you sign the form promising to show up for the hearing doesn't mean that you have to turn in your guns.  Your lawyer will tell you that if you do so voluntarily, it will look better in court.

My friend didn't have a lawyer, and she didn't know what would happen if she just refused to sign the paper that included agreeing to turn in her guns (in court, after the hearing).  But she did have an Associates degree in law enforcement and wasn't going to be disarmed without a fight.  So she told the bailiff NO and he scurried into the judges chambers for 20 minutes (where I assume they looked up what the law actually said), then came back with an amended order that specifically stated that she could keep all her firearms, at which point she signed the RO and promised to stay away from the scumbag neighbor's wife.

Like I said, the whole TRO thing is voluntary; you don't have to sign anything, and they can't take your guns if you haven't been convicted of a crime.  Remember that your lawyer is an officer of the court; he/she is more afraid of pissing off the judge than of losing a case.

PS  This cost my friend one afternoon sitting in court, and gas money to get there.

Funtimes

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #32 on: July 11, 2012, 11:33:59 AM »
The TRO is a Temporary Restraining ORDER from the court. Not a request that you can deny.  What part of this are you missing?

It is justified under the premise that the greater good served, and that a 'temporary' loss of your rights is not an issue to preserve the safety and well being of the other person. Due process requires that the order be served upon the individual.  Failure to disclose the location of your firearms is a crime.  The police have the authority (under our current laws) to confiscate these arms. If you say no, you can be arrested on the spot.

To further educate this post already has a bunch of information:

Quote
Advertisement (Bad banner? Please let us know)
A court order that lasts only until the court can hear further evidence.

A Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) is a court order of limited duration. A TRO commands the parties in the case to maintain a certain status until the court can hear further evidence and decide whether to issue a preliminary injunction.

Under federal and state rules of Civil Procedure, a person may obtain a TRO by visiting a judge or magistrate without notice to, or the presence of, the adverse party. A TRO may be issued by a court only if (1) it appears from specific facts shown in a signed, sworn Affidavit or complaint that immediate irreparable injury, loss, or damage will result to the applicant before the adverse party or the adverse party's attorney can be heard in opposition; and (2) the applicant's attorney describes to the court in writing the efforts, if any, that have been made to give notice to the adverse party and gives reasons to support the claim that notice should not be required.

Temporary restraining orders are extraordinary measures because they are court orders issued against a party without notice to that party and without giving the party an opportunity to argue against the order. A TRO usually lasts only two or three days, until the court can hear both sides of the issue and decide whether to issue a preliminary Injunction. A court generally hears arguments on the preliminary injunction as soon as possible after the TRO is issued. On the federal level, rule 65 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure mandates that a TRO should not last longer than ten days, and that a TRO may be renewed only for an additional ten days. State courts have similar provisions in their rules of civil procedure.

The immediate potential for irreparable harm is the gravamen of the TRO. If an applicant is unable to prove that the harm suffered will be irreparable or that the irreparable harm is imminent, a court will not approve a TRO. Assume that a person purchases a car with financing from the dealership. The buyer then becomes embroiled in a dispute with the dealership over the car and stops making payments; the dealership responds by threatening to repossess the car. If the buyer applies for a TRO preventing the dealership from taking the car, a court would likely refuse the request, because the loss of the car is not imminent. Moreover, the loss of a car is not an irreparable injury; a court would likely expect the buyer to carry on with other modes of transportation.

Now assume that the purchased vehicle is a large utility van that the buyer has customized to use in her catering business. The loss of the van for a few days would be disastrous to the business and could eventually lead to Bankruptcy, so the buyer would likely be able to obtain a TRO, provided the harm was sufficiently imminent.

The adverse party cannot appeal the issuance of a TRO to a higher court. The best remedy for an adverse party is to obtain a court hearing as soon as possible on the issuance of a preliminary injunction. preliminary injunctions may be appealed to higher courts.

TROs are commonly issued in situations involving Stalking and harassment or damage to property. Other common TRO situations include Unfair Competition and trademark, copyright, or patent infringement, all of which involve potentially irreparable damage to a party's economic livelihood.
See: http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Temporary+Restraining+Order

You can also infer it from this statement by Nanci Kreidman, the CEO of Domestic Violence Action Center.
Quote
Kreidman says a TRO is something a person can request from a judge, and it is granted based on the victim's word alone. The victim takes the TRO to police, and police then serve the alleged perpetrator with the TRO. A hearing is set for both sides to appear, and from there, Kreidman says a judge can grant the victim a protective order.  Kreidman says a TRO and a protective order generally have the same conditions. "Like you have to turn over your firearms, you can't come to my place of employment or to my children's school, you can't come to my home," said Kreidman.
  Source: http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/Global/story.asp?S=10038752 "Are restraining orders, protective orders effective against domestic violence?"


Moreover, HRS 134-7 states:
Quote
(f)  No person who has been restrained pursuant to an order of any court, including an ex parte order as provided in this subsection, from contacting, threatening, or physically abusing any person, shall possess, control, or transfer ownership of any firearm or ammunition therefor, so long as the protective order, restraining order, or any extension is in effect, unless the order, for good cause shown, specifically permits the possession of a firearm and ammunition.  The restraining order or order of protection shall specifically include a statement that possession, control, or transfer of ownership of a firearm or ammunition by the person named in the order is prohibited.  Such person shall relinquish possession and control of any firearm and ammunition owned by that person to the police department of the appropriate county for safekeeping for the duration of the order or extension thereof.  In the case of an ex parte order, the affidavit or statement under oath that forms the basis for the order shall contain a statement of the facts that support a finding that the person to be restrained owns, intends to obtain or to transfer ownership of, or possesses a firearm, and that the firearm may be used to threaten, injure, or abuse any person.  The ex parte order shall be effective upon service pursuant to section 586-6.  At the time of service of a restraining order involving firearms and ammunition issued by any court, the police officer may take custody of any and all firearms and ammunition in plain sight, those discovered pursuant to a consensual search, and those firearms surrendered by the person restrained.  If the person restrained is the registered owner of a firearm and knows the location of the firearm, but refuses to surrender the firearm or refuses to disclose the location of the firearm, the person restrained shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.  In any case, when a police officer is unable to locate the firearms and ammunition either registered under this chapter or known to the person granted protection by the court, the police officer shall apply to the court for a search warrant pursuant to chapter 803 for the limited purpose of seizing the firearm and ammunition.

I think your biggest thing is not understanding that the order may or may not include the order to turn in your guns.  But despite what your order says, ex parte hearings, and the order that results from them, don't get your input, and are not voluntary in nature.  If an order is issued because you were "contacting, threatening, or phsycially abusing any person" then you can not "possess, control, or transfer ownership of any firearm or ammunition" under State law, unless a Judge approves it. However, these are things you get to bring up after being served with the notice, and after going to court.  They are not things that happen when an ex-parte motion is filed, granted, and ordered.   

There is a block on every court document for the individual to sign.  About 80% of the time I get "I won't sign that."  Great! I don't care if you do or not, you have already been served with the order granted by a judge.

We could go back on this all day between what you have seen or done.  I personally have experiences to the contrary, and so have many other people.  I will just let people consider the source of information and decide whose information to take.
« Last Edit: July 11, 2012, 04:45:27 PM by Funtimes »
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

dubya

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #33 on: July 11, 2012, 02:34:00 PM »
I think your biggest thing is not understanding that the order may or may not include the order to turn in your guns.

No person who has been restrained pursuant to an order of any court, including an ex parte order as provided in this subsection, from contacting, threatening, or physically abusing any person, shall possess, control, or transfer ownership of any firearm or ammunition therefor, so long as the protective order, restraining order, or any extension is in effect, unless the order, for good cause shown, specifically permits the possession of a firearm and ammunition.  The restraining order or order of protection shall specifically include a statement that possession, control, or transfer of ownership of a firearm or ammunition by the person named in the order is prohibited.  Such person shall relinquish possession and control of any firearm and ammunition owned by that person to the police department of the appropriate county for safekeeping for the duration of the order or extension thereof.  In the case of an ex parte order, the affidavit or statement under oath that forms the basis for the order shall contain a statement of the facts that support a finding that the person to be restrained owns, intends to obtain or to transfer ownership of, or possesses a firearm, and that the firearm may be used to threaten, injure, or abuse any person.  The ex parte order shall be effective upon service pursuant to section 586-6.  At the time of service of a restraining order involving firearms and ammunition issued by any court, the police officer may take custody of any and all firearms and ammunition in plain sight, those discovered pursuant to a consensual search, and those firearms surrendered by the person restrained.

Haw. Rev. Stat. § 134-7(f) (2011) (emphasis added).

Funtimes

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #34 on: July 11, 2012, 04:43:46 PM »
No person who has been restrained pursuant to an order of any court, including an ex parte order as provided in this subsection, from contacting, threatening, or physically abusing any person, shall possess, control, or transfer ownership of any firearm or ammunition therefor, so long as the protective order, restraining order, or any extension is in effect, unless the order, for good cause shown, specifically permits the possession of a firearm and ammunition.  The restraining order or order of protection shall specifically include a statement that possession, control, or transfer of ownership of a firearm or ammunition by the person named in the order is prohibited.  Such person shall relinquish possession and control of any firearm and ammunition owned by that person to the police department of the appropriate county for safekeeping for the duration of the order or extension thereof.  In the case of an ex parte order, the affidavit or statement under oath that forms the basis for the order shall contain a statement of the facts that support a finding that the person to be restrained owns, intends to obtain or to transfer ownership of, or possesses a firearm, and that the firearm may be used to threaten, injure, or abuse any person.  The ex parte order shall be effective upon service pursuant to section 586-6.  At the time of service of a restraining order involving firearms and ammunition issued by any court, the police officer may take custody of any and all firearms and ammunition in plain sight, those discovered pursuant to a consensual search, and those firearms surrendered by the person restrained.

Haw. Rev. Stat. § 134-7(f) (2011) (emphasis added).

And the point of your quoted post, which was specifically stated in my comment, is?  What exactly does that have to do with a TRO being voluntary? Nothing.  ::)   If the order says turn it in, then you turn your stuff in or face criminal charges - Period.   We don't like it, and it would take a lot to change it. However, it it is what is, and that is an involuntary process.

Misleading people to think something is voluntary, when it could potentially and very likely be a criminal offense, is not something I sit back and watch happen.
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

GZire

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #35 on: July 11, 2012, 06:04:34 PM »
^^^C to me this quote means that the TRO needs to specifically note that the restrainee has to show reason for possession/control/transfer, then it's allowed.  Next part states that the TRO needs to specifically include a statement about the restrainee being restricted from possession/control/transfer............then again I'm not a lawyer and this is something that should be discussed with one.




Quote
No person who has been restrained pursuant to an order of any court, including an ex parte order as provided in this subsection, from contacting, threatening, or physically abusing any person, shall possess, control, or transfer ownership of any firearm or ammunition therefor, so long as the protective order, restraining order, or any extension is in effect, unless the order, for good cause shown, specifically permits the possession of a firearm and ammunition. The restraining order or order of protection shall specifically include a statement that possession, control, or transfer of ownership of a firearm or ammunition by the person named in the order is prohibited.  Such person shall relinquish possession and control of any firearm and ammunition owned by that person to the police department of the appropriate county for safekeeping for the duration of the order or extension thereof.

Funtimes

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #36 on: July 11, 2012, 10:12:43 PM »
^^^C to me this quote means that the TRO needs to specifically note that the restrainee has to show reason for possession/control/transfer, then it's allowed.  Next part states that the TRO needs to specifically include a statement about the restrainee being restricted from possession/control/transfer............then again I'm not a lawyer and this is something that should be discussed with one.

Yes as my statement above shows, your order may not include confiscation of your firearms. These orders may be no contact, not coming within x direction, not seeing a child, not leaving the city / state / area etc.  There can be a large list of things that could be in that temporary restraining order.  However, if an order is given, say to not take a child out of the state. You can't say, "Oh, I don't want to sign that," and then bail with the kid (and not expect to get reamed for it).

So yes, for example, if I had a TRO filed against me, I would be going to court to argue that as an instructor for a firearms education organization I have special circumstance etc. that require me to continue to use and have access and possession of my firearms.  The judge could grant that, and then I would exempted from the first sentence of that section.  However, if the judge didn't grant it, I couldn't just say "no" and keep teaching.   


Here is the biggest problem:

1.) Most TRO's are done without the knowledge, consent, or presences of the person or entity being restrained.
2.) Once the judge rules, there is an "order."  (Shit you must comply with or face contempt charges + whatever other charges.)
3.) By the time you get your chance to argue over the initial temporary restraining order, you have already been 'restrained' at least for a little bit.  This means if you had guns, they were already probably taken if your TRO was done for some sort of violence, and the appropriate confiscation language was in the order signed by the judge.
« Last Edit: July 11, 2012, 10:38:14 PM by Funtimes »
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

Colt808

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #37 on: July 12, 2012, 04:53:27 AM »
From some of the posts, two things are very clear to me...Some know very little and some think they know it all. That's a tactful way to say ya'll don't know shit.

Having been served with several TRO's and protective orders. I can tell you all that Cougar8045's experience is the norm, especially when its a contested divorce/custody. It's just how things are and there is NOTHING any bitching can do about it. Why? Because it comes down to protecting the victim. If they are willing to swear an affidavit stating that you are a threat, that's all it takes. Whether the subject of a TRO/protective order is truly a danger, is something to be sorted out at your hearing. Until then, the law/courts/whatever, will not take the chance. It doesn't matter if you're a firearms instructor, gun shop owner, or law enforcement; you will surrender your personal firearms until cleared. Is it fair? Nope, but the system can't take the chance of being wrong.

For those thinking being served with a TRO is "voluntary"? You couldn't be more wrong. You can avoid, delay, or whatever, but once they've got you...you WILL take the papers. If you're not a home/hiding behind a locked door? They'll just visit you at work or school. Which do you prefer? You can be an ass and refuse to sign if you want, the officer(s) will just witness that you were served, but refused signing and note it in the report. None of which will help your case. And if you think you'll just hold on to your guns until the court date because you're "not guilty of anything"? Think again, failing to comply will almost guarantee the courts granting an extension of the TRO. Then you're truly screwed and without any guns for 1-5 years (depending on how badly you've pissed off the judge). Just do what you've got to do and comply, then have your day in court.

Here is the biggest problem:

1.) Most TRO's are done without the knowledge, consent, or presences of the person or entity being restrained.
2.) Once the judge rules, there is an "order."  (Shit you must comply with or face contempt charges + whatever other charges.)
3.) By the time you get your chance to argue over the initial temporary restraining order, you have already been 'restrained' at least for a little bit.  This means if you had guns, they were already probably taken if your TRO was done for some sort of violence, and the appropriate confiscation language was in the order signed by the judge.

I disagree. The biggest problem is that the DVAC/DVCH (Domestic Violence Action Center/Domestic Violence Clearinghouse Hawaii) has an advocate/vulture sitting at the family court while people file TRO's. They counsel/coach victims on what to write and say to guarantee the judge will issue the TRO. One of the questions on the form is: "Does he/she own weapons?" If that box is checked off, you're automatically classified as "Armed and Dangerous" and guaranteed service by HPD's Specialized Services (SWAT). As firearm owners, this is our "special" treatment.
Reason obeys itself; and ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it. ~Thomas Paine


And I still see stupid people.

crazy cat

Re: Who read this? Court clears way for convict to get firearms permit!
« Reply #38 on: July 12, 2012, 02:04:44 PM »
Shrug.

My friend had already been assaulted by her neighbor, who had been arrested and released on bail.  He was hoping that his wife filing a TRO would mean that my friend would be disarmed so he could go back over and finish the assault.  Since she lives in an isolated subdivision, the process server called her and arranged to meet her out at the highway (so he wouldn't have to drive in on the bad roads).  No one said anything about firearms; she got a summons and a date to appear in court.

Just think of the can of worm that would have been opened if a perp could go the a judge and get their victim disarmed just by telling a few lies.