Different barrel materials (Read 10049 times)

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #20 on: October 06, 2020, 01:56:22 PM »
My PSA upper with 4150 Chrome-Moly Vanadium barrel with nitride finish shipped today.   :geekdanc:

Now wish I had more ammo to do more extensive "consumer level" testing.   :(

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #21 on: October 06, 2020, 02:47:47 PM »
My PSA upper with 4150 Chrome-Moly Vanadium barrel with nitride finish shipped today.   :geekdanc:

Now wish I had more ammo to do more extensive "consumer level" testing.   :(

built an A4 out of one. Did not borescope that one yet
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #22 on: October 06, 2020, 02:57:43 PM »
built an A4 out of one. Did not borescope that one yet
I have a PSA Freedom melonite carbine upper that I got back in 2014-2015 ish timeframe. Not sure on the round count tho. It’s eaten up all the crap ammo I’ve shot with so far.

Heavies

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #23 on: October 07, 2020, 12:35:09 AM »
I have a Bartlein barrel. 416 stainless. It is the most accurate, easy to clean, and easiest to find a load barrel I have in my collection.   

Depends on your use and wants.

Over 1K .308 hot f-class rounds down the tube. Still will shoot one jagged hole at 100 yards if operator is doing their part. 

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #24 on: October 07, 2020, 08:51:27 AM »
What about differences in rifling, in combination with barrel materials? 

When I was researching bolt guns, I read quite a bit on material and rifling (not really for ARs).  I came close to waiting on a Rem 700 SPS with SS barrel with 5r rifling.  But ended up going with a more "standard" Rem 700 that was in stock.  My my skill level with bolt actions (much less experience with bolt guns than my ARs), I don't think I'd be able to tell much difference, particularly since I don't reload.  But I've always wondered about the performance difference. 

robtmc

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #25 on: October 07, 2020, 10:20:23 AM »
built an A4 out of one. Did not borescope that one yet
Got a PSA "freedom" upper with SS barrel a good while back as a hedge against PIAPS being elected.   Not finished it yet or shot, and now am ambivalent if I want to see what the bore and chamber of the PSA el-cheapo line looks like.

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #26 on: October 07, 2020, 10:31:21 AM »
Got a PSA "freedom" upper with SS barrel a good while back as a hedge against PIAPS being elected.   Not finished it yet or shot, and now am ambivalent if I want to see what the bore and chamber of the PSA el-cheapo line looks like.
Oh just shoot the darn thing!   ;D

Freedom!!! Pew, pew, pew  :shaka:

robtmc

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #27 on: October 07, 2020, 10:35:45 AM »
Oh just shoot the darn thing!   ;D

Freedom!!! Pew, pew, pew  :shaka:
More parts and new ammo type needed.

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #28 on: October 07, 2020, 10:41:49 AM »
More parts and new ammo type needed.
What kine parts you need?  Can prob help with that.  As long as you are ok with take offs type parts.

Ammo?  Well, that's a different story.   8)

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #29 on: October 07, 2020, 01:06:25 PM »
What about differences in rifling, in combination with barrel materials? 

When I was researching bolt guns, I read quite a bit on material and rifling (not really for ARs).  I came close to waiting on a Rem 700 SPS with SS barrel with 5r rifling.  But ended up going with a more "standard" Rem 700 that was in stock.  My my skill level with bolt actions (much less experience with bolt guns than my ARs), I don't think I'd be able to tell much difference, particularly since I don't reload.  But I've always wondered about the performance difference.

I've read some offerings by Shilen with their "ratchet" rifling. https://www.whiteoakarmament.com/shilen-service-rifle-barrel-1-8-ratchet-rifled-m4-ramps.html


Haven't tried it yet.
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #30 on: October 07, 2020, 01:17:37 PM »
I've read some offerings by Shilen with their "ratchet" rifling. https://www.whiteoakarmament.com/shilen-service-rifle-barrel-1-8-ratchet-rifled-m4-ramps.html


Haven't tried it yet.
Ahh. Interesting. Never heard of that one. Was browsing the Shilen site and there’s so much info.

A buddy in Texas swears by his 5r barrel Rem 700. I haven’t shot it though.

At one time, I was looking to build an AR for “more precision” and WOA was high in the list for barrels. Ended up going with a BCM upper, at least for my LPVO.

robtmc

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #31 on: October 07, 2020, 05:27:22 PM »

The Shilen info on ratchet rifling seems to be gone.  Really wanted to read about that.

Heavies

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #32 on: October 07, 2020, 05:55:27 PM »
Ahh. Interesting. Never heard of that one. Was browsing the Shilen site and there’s so much info.

A buddy in Texas swears by his 5r barrel Rem 700. I haven’t shot it though.

At one time, I was looking to build an AR for “more precision” and WOA was high in the list for barrels. Ended up going with a BCM upper, at least for my LPVO.

With those different types of less aggressive rifling profiles you can get less pressure, less jacket deformation, can load higher powder charges, and gain higher velocity.  Progressive twists are also a similar idea with similar benefits.

This is also assuming you can find a higher velocity accuracy node within safe operating pressure.   

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #33 on: October 08, 2020, 07:48:35 AM »
With those different types of less aggressive rifling profiles you can get less pressure, less jacket deformation, can load higher powder charges, and gain higher velocity.  Progressive twists are also a similar idea with similar benefits.

This is also assuming you can find a higher velocity accuracy node within safe operating pressure.
Disclaimer: These questions admittedly coming from pretty close to complete ignorance on the hand loading aspect of firearm performance. 

Re: less pressure and jacket deformation, I am assuming the differences are quite subtle "in barrel", but can translate to quite a bit down range, probably due to the velocities typically encountered for these rounds.  How much does tolerances in the "heads" play into this? 

I was reading some of the various tolerances, in both the ammo components and firearm.  Some folks get really into analyzing that.  I mean really.  Sounds like they would caliper grains of rice if they found that the size impacted the flavor of the rice.  ???  ;D

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #34 on: October 08, 2020, 08:05:21 AM »
Disclaimer: These questions admittedly coming from pretty close to complete ignorance on the hand loading aspect of firearm performance. 

Re: less pressure and jacket deformation, I am assuming the differences are quite subtle "in barrel", but can translate to quite a bit down range, probably due to the velocities typically encountered for these rounds.  How much does tolerances in the "heads" play into this? 

I was reading some of the various tolerances, in both the ammo components and firearm.  Some folks get really into analyzing that.  I mean really.  Sounds like they would caliper grains of rice if they found that the size impacted the flavor of the rice.  ???  ;D

you mean bullets  :grrr: :grrr: :grrr: :grrr:. Certain bullets such as VLDs have thin jackets to get better drag coefficients so a lot matters to what happens to that jacket. When a bullet is fired from the cartridge it is squeezed down that bore. The bullet creates an airtight seal until it exits the barrel, so any imperfections will be imparted on the jacket and influence its flight.
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #35 on: October 08, 2020, 08:33:48 AM »
you mean bullets  :grrr: :grrr: :grrr: :grrr:. Certain bullets such as VLDs have thin jackets to get better drag coefficients so a lot matters to what happens to that jacket. When a bullet is fired from the cartridge it is squeezed down that bore. The bullet creates an airtight seal until it exits the barrel, so any imperfections will be imparted on the jacket and influence its flight.
I meant heads. . .  ;D  :rofl:

I don't have the numbers off the top of my head, but I thought the differences in head bullet diameter was off by what I thought wasn't significant (say .2431 vs. .2434), but the Sniper Hide types were like they gotta group the low ends together and the high ends together.  Does the jacket account for that and they discussion that I fell into were worrying about something inconsequential? 

macsak

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #36 on: October 08, 2020, 08:41:18 AM »
Disclaimer: These questions admittedly coming from pretty close to complete ignorance on the hand loading aspect of firearm performance. 

Re: less pressure and jacket deformation, I am assuming the differences are quite subtle "in barrel", but can translate to quite a bit down range, probably due to the velocities typically encountered for these rounds.  How much does tolerances in the "heads" play into this? 

I was reading some of the various tolerances, in both the ammo components and firearm.  Some folks get really into analyzing that.  I mean really.  Sounds like they would caliper grains of rice if they found that the size impacted the flavor of the rice.  ???  ;D

actually, rice is graded upon consistency of grain size in japan...

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #37 on: October 08, 2020, 08:48:49 AM »
actually, rice is graded upon consistency of grain size in japan...
The rice in Hokkaido was noticeably better than the typical CA produced ones that we typically eat.  It amazed me how much the CA calrose rice is polished/treated prior to sale. 

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #38 on: October 08, 2020, 05:02:32 PM »
you guys are Joe Biden dumb.
Shooting your AR14s with reloaded "heads"
Deeds Not Words

robtmc

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #39 on: October 09, 2020, 09:51:21 AM »
The rice in Hokkaido was noticeably better than the typical CA produced ones that we typically eat.  It amazed me how much the CA calrose rice is polished/treated prior to sale.
I only buy Thai Jasmine rice, but I am Irish, what do I know about rice?