Poll

Has Facebook ever deleted or blocked political posts you made on Facebook?

Yes
No
I don't post political things on Facebook

Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made? (Read 10322 times)

Inspector

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #40 on: November 02, 2020, 03:01:14 AM »
No threats.
No cursing or swearing.
No inflammatory comments.
No insults.

Just a completely calm and cordial back and forth where the other person asked questions, and I answered pertaining to gun-related laws and issues.  Exactly as we all hope happens -- someone with no firearm experience asking specific questions.  Most anti-gunners have zero experience and only throw out talking points.  He was wanting to fill in the gaps of his knowledge.

After it was obvious (and stated in the posts) that he was having his eyes opened, my posts started being placed under moderator control.  Every single post that was a reply to his gun related questions was deleted.  The only post I could get to stick was one where I told him I'd been trying for almost a day to respond, but my posts were deleted.  Didn't want him to think I bailed.  I was shocked they let that one through.

Basically it was a game of attrition -- keep deleting my posts until I gave up.  But, you know me.  It didn't stop until they finally blocked me.

No notice.
No explanation.
No way to have it unlocked.

I could still use DISCUS on other sites, but not KITV for over a year.  Then it magically started allowing me again.
When my comments are removed it is mostly when citing financial issues such as our great economy. Facts don’t lie but can trigger people when they hear something different than they thought was true. I have had numerous discussions with people that were very cordial and thoughtful. And in one case the person I was having a discussion with had a lightbulb going on in their head moment. And was actually understanding that they had been lied to by the media. I think what has happened in my case is that I say something that triggers a person not involved in the conversation and they complain and FB is apt to just delete comments than to take the time to fact check the comments and the sources. Another example I recall is when I was having a firearms discussion with someone and my comment was that AR stood for Armalite Rifle and not Assault Rifle. That comment was removed. Then I wrote that the term Assault Rifle was a made up term by the Democrats for the media to use as a talking point and I cited a NYT article that admits just that. And that comment was deleted. In each case I doubt the person I was having the discussion with was the person that sent a complaint to FB. I belong to a couple of Q Anon and Anti-Communist and extreme right wing FB pages. I never participate in these groups. I just read what people write as I always want to know what the extreme right are saying. Sometimes they are right on but most of the time it is tinfoil hat time. Am I being targeted due to my affiliation with these FB groups?
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #41 on: November 02, 2020, 01:30:19 PM »
When my comments are removed it is mostly when citing financial issues such as our great economy. Facts don’t lie but can trigger people when they hear something different than they thought was true. I have had numerous discussions with people that were very cordial and thoughtful. And in one case the person I was having a discussion with had a lightbulb going on in their head moment. And was actually understanding that they had been lied to by the media. I think what has happened in my case is that I say something that triggers a person not involved in the conversation and they complain and FB is apt to just delete comments than to take the time to fact check the comments and the sources. Another example I recall is when I was having a firearms discussion with someone and my comment was that AR stood for Armalite Rifle and not Assault Rifle. That comment was removed. Then I wrote that the term Assault Rifle was a made up term by the Democrats for the media to use as a talking point and I cited a NYT article that admits just that. And that comment was deleted. In each case I doubt the person I was having the discussion with was the person that sent a complaint to FB. I belong to a couple of Q Anon and Anti-Communist and extreme right wing FB pages. I never participate in these groups. I just read what people write as I always want to know what the extreme right are saying. Sometimes they are right on but most of the time it is tinfoil hat time. Am I being targeted due to my affiliation with these FB groups?

If only that was true.

I've been suspended for days for posting something that was not dishonest or inciting violence, but those were the user allegations.  I had to delete the offending post/s and still wait in "FB jail" for the clock to allow me in.  Nothing even remotely resembled the rule they said I broke.

Yet, I've also reported Liberals for threatening violence -- actual harm to someone -- and was notified by FB the post did not violate the ToS.

AI does a lot of the censoring now before human intervention.  Complaint triggers AI review.  AI finds a word or two that may be bad.  AI blocks the post and may suspend the user.  If you contest the action, then a real human is notified.  They review the AI decision and decides if the action stands.

The bias is IN PART baked into the AI, as there are lists of users to not censor and lists of users and groups that are on their "watch lists".

These facts have been reported by several insiders. It's not a mystery unless you refuse to crawl out from under your "There's no evidence SM is biased" rock.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

drck1000

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #42 on: November 02, 2020, 01:46:11 PM »
I saw a liberal "friend" post about something she posted that was flagged as violating community standards.  It was something about a cute unicorn or some BS.  She was super mad!   :o  ???

I thought she was joking, so I was teasing her about it, but apparently it was like the end of the world what happened. 

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #43 on: November 02, 2020, 02:50:15 PM »
I saw a liberal "friend" post about something she posted that was flagged as violating community standards.  It was something about a cute unicorn or some BS.  She was super mad!   :o  ???

I thought she was joking, so I was teasing her about it, but apparently it was like the end of the world what happened.

I got flagged automatically once because apparently "learn to code" is now some kind of Extreme Right Wing dog whistle for .... something or other.

The inmates are running the asylums.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #44 on: November 02, 2020, 10:05:03 PM »
When my comments are removed it is mostly when citing financial issues such as our great economy. Facts don’t lie but can trigger people when they hear something different than they thought was true. I have had numerous discussions with people that were very cordial and thoughtful. And in one case the person I was having a discussion with had a lightbulb going on in their head moment. And was actually understanding that they had been lied to by the media. I think what has happened in my case is that I say something that triggers a person not involved in the conversation and they complain and FB is apt to just delete comments than to take the time to fact check the comments and the sources. Another example I recall is when I was having a firearms discussion with someone and my comment was that AR stood for Armalite Rifle and not Assault Rifle. That comment was removed. Then I wrote that the term Assault Rifle was a made up term by the Democrats for the media to use as a talking point and I cited a NYT article that admits just that. And that comment was deleted. In each case I doubt the person I was having the discussion with was the person that sent a complaint to FB. I belong to a couple of Q Anon and Anti-Communist and extreme right wing FB pages. I never participate in these groups. I just read what people write as I always want to know what the extreme right are saying. Sometimes they are right on but most of the time it is tinfoil hat time. Am I being targeted due to my affiliation with these FB groups?

I think it may be worth pointing out that not every time a comment is deleted is it necessarily Facebook. I just checked and on FB posts I have started there is an option for me to delete comments made in reply to my post. So it is possible that FB didn't touch the comment but the person who initiated the original discussion didn't like what you posted and they deleted it.

I am not sure if there is a way to see why a comment was deleted to tell if FB did it or a user did it but if I find something I will post it.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #45 on: November 02, 2020, 11:24:55 PM »
I think it may be worth pointing out that not every time a comment is deleted is it necessarily Facebook. I just checked and on FB posts I have started there is an option for me to delete comments made in reply to my post. So it is possible that FB didn't touch the comment but the person who initiated the original discussion didn't like what you posted and they deleted it.

I am not sure if there is a way to see why a comment was deleted to tell if FB did it or a user did it but if I find something I will post it.

I believe every time FB itself had an issue with my posts, they didn't delete them at all.  The post was either invisible to everyone but me, and I was instructed to delete it if I wanted to get out of FB jail, or they simply blocked my account, told me a post was flagged, and could read all I wanted but was barred from posting anything until I complied with whatever they wanted from me.  Basically holding my account hostage until I delivered the ransom.

If FB is actually doing the deletes, that started in the last few years since I left.  If they started deleting everything that was reported to them and later judged to be fine, they'd piss off a lot of users.  Leaving it up but blocked from public viewing makes more sense.

Anyway, it's pretty easy to see if FB flagged your post.  If it was another regular user, you may never even know it happened unless you try tp go read your comment and discover it's gone.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #46 on: November 05, 2020, 10:03:55 PM »
I believe every time FB itself had an issue with my posts, they didn't delete them at all.  The post was either invisible to everyone but me, and I was instructed to delete it if I wanted to get out of FB jail, or they simply blocked my account, told me a post was flagged, and could read all I wanted but was barred from posting anything until I complied with whatever they wanted from me.  Basically holding my account hostage until I delivered the ransom.

If FB is actually doing the deletes, that started in the last few years since I left.  If they started deleting everything that was reported to them and later judged to be fine, they'd piss off a lot of users.  Leaving it up but blocked from public viewing makes more sense.

Anyway, it's pretty easy to see if FB flagged your post.  If it was another regular user, you may never even know it happened unless you try tp go read your comment and discover it's gone.

Hmmm, I wonder why none of my stuff has gotten flagged then. I have been unfriended and blocked but that is the user themselves of course.

A few years back FB questioned whether the name on my account was real and locked it until I could provide a copy of an ID. Once I did they opened it right back up. I suspect some liberal was reporting me because they didn't like my comment but no comment ever got flagged that I could tell.

Maybe it is too late but I would be interested if I could run some sort of test, post certain types of things and see what causes it to get flagged.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #47 on: November 05, 2020, 10:12:53 PM »
Hmmm, I wonder why none of my stuff has gotten flagged then. I have been unfriended and blocked but that is the user themselves of course.

A few years back FB questioned whether the name on my account was real and locked it until I could provide a copy of an ID. Once I did they opened it right back up. I suspect some liberal was reporting me because they didn't like my comment but no comment ever got flagged that I could tell.

Maybe it is too late but I would be interested if I could run some sort of test, post certain types of things and see what causes it to get flagged.

Maybe you weren't ever targeted by the troll mobs (the people roaming SM and reporting people using multiple accounts).  Normally they only go after people with a hefty number of followers/friends, likes, shares and retweets.

When I was on FB and Twitter, my posts got a surprisingly high number of interactions, mainly because I was commenting on other people's posts who had a massive follower base.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #48 on: November 05, 2020, 10:18:42 PM »
Maybe you weren't ever targeted by the troll mobs (the people roaming SM and reporting people using multiple accounts).  Normally they only go after people with a hefty number of followers/friends, likes, shares and retweets.

When I was on FB and Twitter, my posts got a surprisingly high number of interactions, mainly because I was commenting on other people's posts who had a massive follower base.

Interesting, guess I will have to comment on some high value commentors then? So far nothing on Civil Beat's page has gotten me any attention from FB

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Poll: Has Facebook ever deleted political posts you made?
« Reply #49 on: November 05, 2020, 10:24:10 PM »
Interesting, guess I will have to comment on some high value commentors then? So far nothing on Civil Beat's page has gotten me any attention from FB

CB is watered down by most standards, and it mostly involves state issues, not national or global.  Makes a difference.  It also helps (getting you blocked/censored) if the topic is trending.  Attracts way more interest -- hence the damage delaying a post from being viewed does to a content creator's income and credability.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw