Social Media censorship nutshell (Read 20255 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #20 on: September 13, 2021, 08:27:12 PM »
Not my point.

Showing that just because someone says something on social media doesn't mean people will follow it.

Googling "kidney beans" brings up tons of links discussing the toxin and how to properly cook them.  BTW, a slow cooker may not use high enough temps to solve the problem, so that isn't recommended.

Again, it goes back to people taking responsibility for their own lives.  If they read something on the Internet that they blindly follow and it turns out badly, it's nobody's fault but their own. 

If you post that a certain candy is high in nutrients, and people take your advice to order some, what if someone dies of an allergic reaction?  Should you have warned all your readers of the potential for allergic reactions to the ingredients, or should they take the responsibility to check?

If the guy who intentionally posts "eat kidney beans" can be censored, shouldn't all food related posts be censored, too?  You have no way of knowing if your post will cause harm, just like the kidney beans seldom result in hospitalization or death.

Again, you're trying to put the onus on the writer to protect/not harm his readers.  I'm telling you it's not only impossible, but it creates an inconsistent playing field where the censors have no idea what you are talking about.  If everyone expects censors to save them from "bad" posts, and one gets by, perhaps the false sense of security the readers had was the cause.  Without censors, people would know to "trust, but verify" anything that might prove harmful.

I'd say "Eating something you don't know how to safely cook" falls into that category.

Its a nice ideal that people should be responsible for our own lives but realistically we all take things on faith everyday. I don't check the Bus driver's license before I get on the bus, I don't read the user agreement on my new cell phone, I don't grill my doctor about the prescription he just gave me.

To be clear, I don't think this is a legal question for me, rather it is a question of moral responsibility. Social media could be manipulated in such a way that it could further a genocide (worst case scenario). Or heck, take terrorists brainwashing americans, trying to get them to join hate groups. It is an unavoidable question of whether FB should do something if they have the power. I totally get the slippery slope argument which is why censorship is a sword I would wield very sparingly but I don't believe that it doesn't have any place on social media. I am perfectly fine with FB choosing not to allow pornography for example. When political ideas become involved I would be much more conservative in the censor sword.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #21 on: September 13, 2021, 08:59:08 PM »
Its a nice ideal that people should be responsible for our own lives but realistically we all take things on faith everyday. I don't check the Bus driver's license before I get on the bus, I don't read the user agreement on my new cell phone, I don't grill my doctor about the prescription he just gave me.

To be clear, I don't think this is a legal question for me, rather it is a question of moral responsibility. Social media could be manipulated in such a way that it could further a genocide (worst case scenario). Or heck, take terrorists brainwashing americans, trying to get them to join hate groups. It is an unavoidable question of whether FB should do something if they have the power. I totally get the slippery slope argument which is why censorship is a sword I would wield very sparingly but I don't believe that it doesn't have any place on social media. I am perfectly fine with FB choosing not to allow pornography for example. When political ideas become involved I would be much more conservative in the censor sword.

I thought you used the word "realistically".  LOL!

We don't check the bus driver's license because ... why?  Because they are vetted by the bus service provider.  There's a system in place to test, issue and control commercial driver's licenses above and beyond standard licensing.

We don't read the user agreement because their lawyers don't want us to.  If you want to opt out, it means you can't use the phone.  Nothing in the agreement is going to stop you from activating and using your new device.

If you don't grill the doctor about drugs they prescribe, it's because there is a system in place to test, control, dispense, and monitor your use.  If there's an adverse reaction, you have immediate assistance available.

The people you listed are PROFESSIONALS in their fields.  We trust that they understand the things we need better than we do.

The dude on his sofa trolling Twitter isn't being paid 99% of the time.  He's not a professional giving you advice on Kidney beans.

To me it's partially  legal question.  We trust the professionals because they have specific training and knowledge.  If they are prescribing meds, they have liability if they do something wrong.  So, yes.  That system of recourse against a negligent or intentionally bad actor adds to the trust factor.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

aieahound

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #22 on: September 14, 2021, 11:33:27 AM »
Shit just got real.

Texas new law prohibiting censorship based on political views.
(I haven’t dug into it yet but it’s a conversation to be had.)

omnigun

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #23 on: September 14, 2021, 11:36:51 AM »
Shit just got real.

Texas new law prohibiting censorship based on political views.
(I haven’t dug into it yet but it’s a conversation to be had.)


Censorship is over

https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/9/22661626/texas-social-media-law-hb-20-signed-greg-abbott

changemyoil66

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #24 on: September 14, 2021, 11:37:53 AM »
Internal FB/IG documents show that certain people are "whitelisted" and can violate post standards and suffer no repercussions or enforcement.  Guess that's why Antifa can post what they post, while Andy Ngo gets banned.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-files-xcheck-zuckerberg-elite-rules-11631541353

drck1000

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #25 on: September 14, 2021, 11:54:46 AM »
Internal FB/IG documents show that certain people are "whitelisted" and can violate post standards and suffer no repercussions or enforcement.  Guess that's why Antifa can post what they post, while Andy Ngo gets banned.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-files-xcheck-zuckerberg-elite-rules-11631541353
No sm bias. . . you liar, lair, panty on fiyah. . .

 :rofl:

changemyoil66

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #26 on: September 14, 2021, 12:13:37 PM »
No sm bias. . . you liar, lair, panty on fiyah. . .

 :rofl:

Not proven in court.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #27 on: September 14, 2021, 10:01:26 PM »
I thought you used the word "realistically".  LOL!

I try to be a realist!

Quote
We don't check the bus driver's license because ... why?  Because they are vetted by the bus service provider.  There's a system in place to test, issue and control commercial driver's licenses above and beyond standard licensing. We don't read the user agreement because their lawyers don't want us to.  If you want to opt out, it means you can't use the phone.  Nothing in the agreement is going to stop you from activating and using your new device. If you don't grill the doctor about drugs they prescribe, it's because there is a system in place to test, control, dispense, and monitor your use.  If there's an adverse reaction, you have immediate assistance available.

And we put faith in those systems, those professionals. Problem with the kidney beans is that it is one of those unknown unknowns which you wouldn't have reason to question.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #28 on: September 14, 2021, 10:02:36 PM »
Internal FB/IG documents show that certain people are "whitelisted" and can violate post standards and suffer no repercussions or enforcement.  Guess that's why Antifa can post what they post, while Andy Ngo gets banned.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-files-xcheck-zuckerberg-elite-rules-11631541353

There were some on the left who got banned/censored as well, it wasn't only conservatives.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #29 on: September 14, 2021, 10:05:23 PM »
I try to be a realist!

And we put faith in those systems, those professionals. Problem with the kidney beans is that it is one of those unknown unknowns which you wouldn't have reason to question.

If you don't question a random suggestion by an unknown member on social media, that's you.

I give most people at least some benefit of the doubt in the common sense department when they start putting things into their bodies.

As lazy as many people are, the majority will use canned kidney beans anyway.  Safe toxin levels in the canned beans.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #30 on: September 14, 2021, 10:09:44 PM »
There were some on the left who got banned/censored as well, it wasn't only conservatives.

I've yet to see a list of those names.

Conservatives make the news so the shaming and harassment can continue.

Liberals never seem to be taken down for long.

President Trump, Steven Crowder and Project Veritas were repeatedly targeted and reinstated with the lame "it was done in error" excuse.

Meanwhile, the only people being hit on the Liberal side made the mistake of crossing the "don't stray outside the official COVID narrative box" rules.  Very different  than those Conservatives banned for their political beliefs.

https://infogalactic.com/info/List_of_people_censored_by_Twitter
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #31 on: September 14, 2021, 10:56:41 PM »
I've yet to see a list of those names.

Conservatives make the news so the shaming and harassment can continue.

Liberals never seem to be taken down for long.

President Trump, Steven Crowder and Project Veritas were repeatedly targeted and reinstated with the lame "it was done in error" excuse.

Meanwhile, the only people being hit on the Liberal side made the mistake of crossing the "don't stray outside the official COVID narrative box" rules.  Very different  than those Conservatives banned for their political beliefs.

https://infogalactic.com/info/List_of_people_censored_by_Twitter

I remember a story which covered some of the leftist accounts which had been blocked/censored/deleted but I don't know what percentage of blocked accounts they represented. But then even if we knew the political leaning breakdown of which accounts got banned or censored that would not give us a great picture since we don't know the offense rate either. Do liberals and conservatives break FB rules at equal rates?  Just like with crime it is foolish to think all disparities is proof of racism because we know that racial groups do not all commit crimes at the same rates. Another thing you seem to touch on is what topics get more attention, maybe the political leaning of the banned account isn't relative, and instead the topic is the focus, just so happen one political side is more into that particular topic than the other. So lots of variables to consider and I am not sure if FB releases enough of that data to be able to tell whether conservatives are disproportionately banned/censored by them. It is an interesting question though and I would say that since employees are human beings with some natural bias I wouldn't be surprised to find at least some disparity.

I am quite vocal politically speaking on FB and to the best of my knowledge I have never had any post removed or censored and I have never had my account blocked or received some sort of warning. Well once by a moderator for a group but that wasn't FB doing it. I have to wonder if some of the people being banned are just making enough noise that their ban gets more attention than it might be deserved. I could easily picture some sensational conservatives violating the rules, getting put in FB prison, then making a less than accurate video complaining about how they were just targeted unfairly.  Can be hard to pick out when people were really unjustly banned and those wanting to play the victim card.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #32 on: September 14, 2021, 11:25:09 PM »
I remember a story which covered some of the leftist accounts which had been blocked/censored/deleted but I don't know what percentage of blocked accounts they represented. But then even if we knew the political leaning breakdown of which accounts got banned or censored that would not give us a great picture since we don't know the offense rate either. Do liberals and conservatives break FB rules at equal rates?  Just like with crime it is foolish to think all disparities is proof of racism because we know that racial groups do not all commit crimes at the same rates. Another thing you seem to touch on is what topics get more attention, maybe the political leaning of the banned account isn't relative, and instead the topic is the focus, just so happen one political side is more into that particular topic than the other. So lots of variables to consider and I am not sure if FB releases enough of that data to be able to tell whether conservatives are disproportionately banned/censored by them. It is an interesting question though and I would say that since employees are human beings with some natural bias I wouldn't be surprised to find at least some disparity.

I am quite vocal politically speaking on FB and to the best of my knowledge I have never had any post removed or censored and I have never had my account blocked or received some sort of warning. Well once by a moderator for a group but that wasn't FB doing it. I have to wonder if some of the people being banned are just making enough noise that their ban gets more attention than it might be deserved. I could easily picture some sensational conservatives violating the rules, getting put in FB prison, then making a less than accurate video complaining about how they were just targeted unfairly.  Can be hard to pick out when people were really unjustly banned and those wanting to play the victim card.

All those words you typed, but not a single name.

That's the point.  If the heads of Twitter and FB were telling the truth about "errors", there would have been a more even distribution of "mistaken bans" of well-known users from all political leanings.

That has never been the case.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #33 on: September 15, 2021, 09:46:03 AM »
I remember a story which covered some of the leftist accounts which had been blocked/censored/deleted but I don't know what percentage of blocked accounts they represented. But then even if we knew the political leaning breakdown of which accounts got banned or censored that would not give us a great picture since we don't know the offense rate either. Do liberals and conservatives break FB rules at equal rates?  Just like with crime it is foolish to think all disparities is proof of racism because we know that racial groups do not all commit crimes at the same rates. Another thing you seem to touch on is what topics get more attention, maybe the political leaning of the banned account isn't relative, and instead the topic is the focus, just so happen one political side is more into that particular topic than the other. So lots of variables to consider and I am not sure if FB releases enough of that data to be able to tell whether conservatives are disproportionately banned/censored by them. It is an interesting question though and I would say that since employees are human beings with some natural bias I wouldn't be surprised to find at least some disparity.

I am quite vocal politically speaking on FB and to the best of my knowledge I have never had any post removed or censored and I have never had my account blocked or received some sort of warning. Well once by a moderator for a group but that wasn't FB doing it. I have to wonder if some of the people being banned are just making enough noise that their ban gets more attention than it might be deserved. I could easily picture some sensational conservatives violating the rules, getting put in FB prison, then making a less than accurate video complaining about how they were just targeted unfairly.  Can be hard to pick out when people were really unjustly banned and those wanting to play the victim card.

I've been banned from FB before. I also have been blocked by KITV, KHON on FB and on IG Hawaii News Now, KITV, KHON.  I've also had comments removed from IG post to said pages before I was banned.  None were derogatory in nature.  I know a few other members here who were also banned and all happened after posting pro 2a stuff to their articles which were anti 2a.  Pro 2a stuff like sayinig 2/3's of gun deaths are suicides (FBI/CDC stats), not derogatory comment.s

changemyoil66

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #34 on: September 15, 2021, 09:46:35 AM »
All those words you typed, but not a single name.

That's the point.  If the heads of Twitter and FB were telling the truth about "errors", there would have been a more even distribution of "mistaken bans" of well-known users from all political leanings.

That has never been the case.

Didn't Zuck testify that he couldn't name 1 leftist person who was banned?

drck1000

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #35 on: September 15, 2021, 09:58:46 AM »
I've been banned from FB before. I also have been blocked by KITV, KHON on FB and on IG Hawaii News Now, KITV, KHON.  I've also had comments removed from IG post to said pages before I was banned.  None were derogatory in nature.  I know a few other members here who were also banned and all happened after posting pro 2a stuff to their articles which were anti 2a.  Pro 2a stuff like sayinig 2/3's of gun deaths are suicides (FBI/CDC stats), not derogatory comment.s
A friend had a FB post removed over the weekend.  Was something about "it's starting to feel like we're in an episode of Purge and (i forget the other)".  I guess it was for potential for inciting violence.  I didn't take her post as that.  But she has been put in FB jail a number of times previously. . .

aieahound

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #36 on: September 15, 2021, 12:50:53 PM »
I’ve been deleted here numerous times.
I don’t post anywhere else.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #37 on: September 15, 2021, 01:01:33 PM »
Didn't Zuck testify that he couldn't name 1 leftist person who was banned?

All 3 CEOs (Google, FB & Twitter) were asked the exact same question by Sen. Ted Cruz:  Name one -- just ONE -- prominent Liberal member of your platform with a large following who was censored or banned in the same manner aa the at least dozens of conservatives we read about online and see in the news.  Not even the SAME ROUGH NUMBER, but just one.

Even though they were all asked this in past hearings with the same responses ("I'll have to get back to you with that -- I don't have it at the top of my mind."), they still came back again without a single name.  Not one. 

You wound think these geniuses would (1) anticipate the question is going to come up again, and (2) they should do the research ahead of the hearing to have at least one name ready.

Nope.  Maybe it's because the simplest answer is the correct answer.  They can't find a name because only prominent Conservatives and Republicans are being routinely banned on their platforms, and the algorithms are not the reason.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #38 on: September 15, 2021, 08:13:00 PM »
All those words you typed, but not a single name.

That's the point.  If the heads of Twitter and FB were telling the truth about "errors", there would have been a more even distribution of "mistaken bans" of well-known users from all political leanings.

That has never been the case.

You are making conclusions without the evidence to support it. Your conclusion may be right but what you are citing doesn't prove it.

"I heard about a whole bunch of conservatives being banned but not many liberals being banned" does not amount to proof and I already pointed out where you lack the data to make such a conclusion.

Again, I am not saying they ban left people and right proportionately  but do left and right sided people offend at the same rate? Without that you can't tell whether the bans are fair or not.
« Last Edit: September 15, 2021, 08:21:13 PM by eyeeatingfish »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Social Media censorship nutshell
« Reply #39 on: September 15, 2021, 08:19:04 PM »
I've been banned from FB before. I also have been blocked by KITV, KHON on FB and on IG Hawaii News Now, KITV, KHON.  I've also had comments removed from IG post to said pages before I was banned.  None were derogatory in nature.  I know a few other members here who were also banned and all happened after posting pro 2a stuff to their articles which were anti 2a.  Pro 2a stuff like sayinig 2/3's of gun deaths are suicides (FBI/CDC stats), not derogatory comment.s

KITV, KHON, etc are a little bit of a different story than FB, they get to control what is posted on their own pages.

I wonder though why my posts don't get banned, I am vocal on 2A issues. Maybe they have been banned and I didn't notice?