Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol? (Read 13303 times)

macsak

Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« on: October 08, 2022, 08:24:34 AM »

ren

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #1 on: October 08, 2022, 08:52:24 AM »
One more thing to fail. One more thing to buy....
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #2 on: October 08, 2022, 09:07:12 AM »
Lots of good points, esp for newbies considering and think no need to put in time and train to be gtg. But taller optic height for natural eye line on a pistol? 🤔

Stack_Xchange

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #3 on: October 08, 2022, 09:43:10 AM »
I personally don't have one and wouldn't put one. One of the reasons why I prefer Glock's is because of the low profile. I can basically shoot anything of reasonable size up to 15 ft. without using the sights. If I can look at it with my eyes, I can point my finger at it. If I can point my finger at it, I can hit it. Look at the target, bring the gun up to your eyes, fire. You don't point the gun at the target then line up your eyes/body behind the gun. You line up your eyes/body, then bring the gun up to your eyes. I have Ameriglo and they work great. Big bright orange front post in the day and double lum at night.

I do have a red dot on two rifles, one on a 45 deg. offset with a 4x, and the other is just a lone aimpoint on my foldable "backpack gun".

I can see competition shooters using red dots because shooting targets 50+ feet would be faster, but for self-defense applications you are probably going to be shooting targets much closer. Besides, the further you get, the skill needed to hit the shot is going to be about the same, since you're either going to be dealing with a red dot like 6 MOA or really fat pistol iron sights anyway.

The bottom line is: do what feels best for you and train with what you intend to use. If you really think you need a red dot for indexing purposes at close range, or that you will need a little extra faster target acquisition at 50+ feet, just do it. Also remember to check your batteries or get a good co-witness with irons if you're the type to run out of your phone battery all the time.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #4 on: October 08, 2022, 10:12:06 AM »
No need to over-analyze the question.

Try with a red dot, and without.  Pick the one you use better. 

Practice with both. If your red dot fails, you still need to be proficient with the backups.

Why would your red dot fail right at the moment you need it most?

#Murphy'sLaw
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

QUIETShooter

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #5 on: October 08, 2022, 01:20:19 PM »
Don't know nothing about red dots.  But the few times I fired a pistol with red dots, it took my eyes a while to get focused and acquire the dot on target.  Scary in a life and death situation.

Is this normal or will practice allow me to get an instant focus of the dot on target?

There seems to be a lot of different views by the experts on how to shoot the handgun.

Some say in SD situations just point and shoot, don't aim.  Nomo time they say.

I like iron sights. ;D
Sometimes you gotta know when to save your bullets.

Heavies

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #6 on: October 08, 2022, 04:24:34 PM »
Don't know nothing about red dots.  But the few times I fired a pistol with red dots, it took my eyes a while to get focused and acquire the dot on target.  Scary in a life and death situation.

Is this normal or will practice allow me to get an instant focus of the dot on target?

There seems to be a lot of different views by the experts on how to shoot the handgun.

Some say in SD situations just point and shoot, don't aim.  Nomo time they say.

I like iron sights. ;D

With a dot you’re supposed to focus on the target. With irons it’s the front sight.

With a dot you need to train your presentation of the pistol. That way the dot will be in view when you bring the gun up to your eye. Once muscle memory is in place it’s said to be faster. That’s why there are different classes in comp shooting using optics. There is an advantage, once the practice and skill has been developed.

If you’ve trained and used irons for a long time, it can take a while to train to use a dot. Presentation is different and focus is different.

Dots are more precise at longer distances. Even a 6MOA dot is much finer than the wide post on most modern firearms.

changemyoil66

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #7 on: October 08, 2022, 06:42:09 PM »
Ive tried 2 of the same pistols back to back, 1 with rds and 1 with irons.  For rapid fire and pretty much zero xp using a rds, the pick up for follow up shots was noticiably better with the rds. And grouping at 10yrds was basketball (irons) to jabone (rds).

So overall rds was a huge improvement and that was with pretty much zero rds practice.

Only reason i havent RDS'd was $.

I look at it this way, the future of sights and pistols is RDS. Like rifles, i rarely see 1 without an optic. Pistols will be the same.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #8 on: October 08, 2022, 08:01:17 PM »
Don't know nothing about red dots.  But the few times I fired a pistol with red dots, it took my eyes a while to get focused and acquire the dot on target.  Scary in a life and death situation.

Is this normal or will practice allow me to get an instant focus of the dot on target?

There seems to be a lot of different views by the experts on how to shoot the handgun.

Some say in SD situations just point and shoot, don't aim.  Nomo time they say.

I like iron sights. ;D

Simple answer is: it's easier to place a single red dot on the target you're focused on and know you're going to be hitting very close to the dot

versus trying to position a front sight vertically and horizontally in the rear sight's "notch".  Focusing on the front sight can mean you are no longer seeing the target as clearly as before sighting in.

As for point and shoot, that's a method used when you're standing within very close proximity to the threat.  If you don't have a comfortable distance in which to extend your arms and use the sights, you should keep your hands close to your chest and fire from that stance. If you're within a few feet, using sights to aim is a waste of time and unnecessary plus you're taking a risk the threat can reach for the gun and disarm you if you extend your arms.  At very close range, you''re unlikely to miss.

We were taught a 5-count draw at Front Sight:

1.  Clear your shirt/garment -- I found using my weak hand to pull it up and away was easier than my strong hand;
2.  Obtain a solid purchase on the pistol;
3.  Draw the gun high above the holster but still pointed down (elbow bent and pointed to the rear, not out to the side like a "wing");
4.  Rotate pistol muzzle forward while it's still close to your chest.  Keep your support hand against your chest to prevent if from being forward of barrel;
5.  Extend strong hand toward target and let weak hand meet the pistol as it reaches full extension.

Once you do #4, the gun is rotated, and you're clear to fire as long as the weak hand remembered to remain flat against the chest, or at least somewhere away from the muzzle.   :thumbsup:  No aiming, just fire once the gun is rotated toward the threat.
« Last Edit: October 09, 2022, 06:38:46 PM by Flapp_Jackson »
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

hvybarrels

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #9 on: October 09, 2022, 01:35:04 PM »
I had an extra one so tried it on my air pistol and once you get used to it the difference is night and day at longer distances. Still looking for what Elijah Dicken was using for an optic but if I was doing the drill name after him I would definitely want a red dot.
You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

zippz

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #10 on: October 09, 2022, 04:30:58 PM »
Red dots have a lot of advantages over irons.  I'm still getting used to red dots, but I can see why they're so popular now and will eventually become standard.  So far here's what I've found:

1.  More accurate and quicker at farther distances, 7+ yards
2.  Better view of the target
3.  Easier to aim in reduced light
4.  Easier to see from different positions ie under a car, prone, etc.
5.  Some can be used with NVGs
6.  Better for those with bad eyesight
7.  Easier to use for people that never shot a gun before

Disadvantages
1.  Costly to buy and mount.
2.  People used to iron sights takes time to get used to them.
3.  Slower to use at short distances if you're not used to it.
4.  Failures:  batteries, breakage, loosening
5.  Not as robust as irons
6.  Can get dirty
7.  Holster compatability

ren

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #11 on: October 09, 2022, 05:15:57 PM »
no public range to practice...
Deeds Not Words

RSN172

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #12 on: October 09, 2022, 07:43:35 PM »
I don't have a RDS, but I have a green Crimson Trace laser.  I am 72 and trying to focus on iron sights is difficult. With a laser you don't have to look through a sight, just look for the dot on the target.  I think it is great for SD distances up to 40 ft.
Happily living in Puna

WTF?Shane

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #13 on: October 09, 2022, 11:43:54 PM »
yes

eyeeatingfish

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #14 on: October 11, 2022, 09:32:07 PM »
I have been thinking about getting one on a pistol but haven't decided. Everyone tells me that in the beginning it is hard to find the dot but they like it once they get used to it and can find the dot quickly. Seems like accuracy would be better since there is more precision than irons. I am leaning towards the Leupold since it has that low profile one but the small window seems like it would be a potential issue.

Heavies

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #15 on: October 13, 2022, 04:31:19 PM »
I have been thinking about getting one on a pistol but haven't decided. Everyone tells me that in the beginning it is hard to find the dot but they like it once they get used to it and can find the dot quickly. Seems like accuracy would be better since there is more precision than irons. I am leaning towards the Leupold since it has that low profile one but the small window seems like it would be a potential issue.

I didn’t find the small window made it more or less difficult.  Because it’s a small tube, I found it easy to line that up and find the dot quickly.  I have the Glock version, and the Glock grip angle was more of an issue, for me.

One problem I found is that on my Glock, I had installed a red fiber optic front sight, and on draw and firing, I mistook the red fiber optic for the red dot. That made me shoot a little high. Switched the red to green fiber, and turned up the brightness some to solve that problem.  Again the grip angle of the Glock, and my presentation training, made this problem, not the optic itself, IMO.

Problem is I switch from pistol to pistol. Most of them have a more natural pointing grip angle to them. When ever I go back to the Glock, I really need to reset my muscle memory big time. After a few draws and presentations it’s not a problem. In an emergency situation, you won’t get practice runs. So there’s that.

Sodie

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #16 on: October 15, 2022, 01:31:03 PM »
Do you NEED a red dot on your pistol?

It depends…

Are you shooting carry optics or open division in USPSA?  Then yes.

Plinking? Do what makes you happy.

Self-defense?  You don’t NEED one, but chances are really good you’ll get better results with an RDS, with a little practice.      I reject the argument against buying one that “they take time to get used to.”  Were you shooting the lights out the first time you picked up an iron-sighted pistol?  “I can’t find the dot.”  Dry fire.  It’ll be there by the end of the first half hour.

I’ve shot iron sights and a dot on otherwise identical guns at the square range; dot wins hands down.  Tighter groups.

I’ve shot iron sights and a dot on otherwise identical guns in USPSA; dot wins hands down.  Faster and more accurate at all ranges.

One legit issue with dots is that the dot looks like it’s moving around a bunch more on target than with iron sights.  The gun is moving the same amount, it just looks more exaggerated with a dot.  You have to get over your desire to get the dot to stop, because it never, ever will.

Do you NEED one?  Probably not.  But I bet if you put in even a little practice, you’ll shoot better with one.

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #17 on: October 15, 2022, 04:34:00 PM »
Do you NEED a red dot on your pistol?

It depends…

Are you shooting carry optics or open division in USPSA?  Then yes.

Plinking? Do what makes you happy.

Self-defense?  You don’t NEED one, but chances are really good you’ll get better results with an RDS, with a little practice.      I reject the argument against buying one that “they take time to get used to.”  Were you shooting the lights out the first time you picked up an iron-sighted pistol?  “I can’t find the dot.”  Dry fire.  It’ll be there by the end of the first half hour.

I’ve shot iron sights and a dot on otherwise identical guns at the square range; dot wins hands down.  Tighter groups.

I’ve shot iron sights and a dot on otherwise identical guns in USPSA; dot wins hands down.  Faster and more accurate at all ranges.

One legit issue with dots is that the dot looks like it’s moving around a bunch more on target than with iron sights.  The gun is moving the same amount, it just looks more exaggerated with a dot.  You have to get over your desire to get the dot to stop, because it never, ever will.

Do you NEED one?  Probably not.  But I bet if you put in even a little practice, you’ll shoot better with one.
Embrace the wobble!  ;D

Shoot some, find what is acceptable. Then see it and send it.

For many, the cost of a good RDS is a factor. The cost of aftermarket slide or milling plus the RDS was a factor for me. Less of a concern nowadays with optic ready models. I don’t envision buying another pistol without an RDS. Except for say a classic pistol, but not much interest in those.

QUIETShooter

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #18 on: October 20, 2022, 09:10:56 AM »
Do RDS pose a potential snag problem while concealed carrying?  How about printing?  Especially in Hawaii where our apparel is mainly t-shirt and shorts year round. 

That's if we ever get around to being able to conceal carry, being that Hawaii is the most communist state in the Union with assh*le politicians and leaders taking the oath to defend and protect the Constitution by talking through their a$$.

But I digress and is fodder for another thread.

I was watching this video and the notable thing I got from it was when Ken mentioned that most self defense encounters will be at 10 yards or less.  At that distance the difference is negligible.



I'm old and haven't trained enough either way.  I want to pocket carry and I think the RDS will pose a snag and print problem.  But I do believe that RDS is the future for pistols and shooters.

« Last Edit: October 20, 2022, 09:16:35 AM by QUIETShooter »
Sometimes you gotta know when to save your bullets.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #19 on: October 20, 2022, 01:31:33 PM »
Do RDS pose a potential snag problem while concealed carrying?  How about printing?  Especially in Hawaii where our apparel is mainly t-shirt and shorts year round. 

That's if we ever get around to being able to conceal carry, being that Hawaii is the most communist state in the Union with assh*le politicians and leaders taking the oath to defend and protect the Constitution by talking through their a$$.

But I digress and is fodder for another thread.

I was watching this video and the notable thing I got from it was when Ken mentioned that most self defense encounters will be at 10 yards or less.  At that distance the difference is negligible.

I'm old and haven't trained enough either way.  I want to pocket carry and I think the RDS will pose a snag and print problem.  But I do believe that RDS is the future for pistols and shooters.

Is distance the only factor in whether or not a Red Dot Sight is beneficial?

I think we've beaten that horse to death.  Just like caliber, the choice is going to be an individual decision based on the factors they feel are relevant.

Age, eyesight (corrected or uncorrected), visible in daylight, visible in the dark, speed of sight acquisition, target focus, etc, etc, etc.

If you're watching a YouTube video to tell you what to do, you will probably never make that decision -- too many videos with good reasons for choosing and not choosing a given gun/sight/caliber/etc.

Try it.  If you prefer it, use it.  If it doesn't improve what you were using, why switch?
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw