Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol? (Read 13298 times)

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #20 on: October 20, 2022, 02:02:42 PM »
"Red dots aren't the way of the future.  Irons sights are a thing of the past."

A crusty old shooting instructor and former .mil quoted that recently.  Not sure if he made it up or where he got it from, but I've been following him for many years and he did have some issues when first trying RDS on pistols. 

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #21 on: October 20, 2022, 02:09:05 PM »
1) Do RDS pose a potential snag problem while concealed carrying?  How about printing?  Especially in Hawaii where our apparel is mainly t-shirt and shorts year round. 

2) I was watching this video and the notable thing I got from it was when Ken mentioned that most self defense encounters will be at 10 yards or less.  At that distance the difference is negligible.

SNIP

I'm old and haven't trained enough either way.  3) I want to pocket carry and I think the RDS will pose a snag and print problem.  But I do believe that RDS is the future for pistols and shooters.
1) In general no.  At least not in my experience and lots of folks that do CC with RDS handguns.  Many holster options accommodate RDS pistols in the base configuration.  Printing can be due to a number of factors, like body type, gun and holster selection, but also belt and clothing choices.  Just like a good holster or gun belt, shirt choice is a part of the gear/kit/outfit consideration.

2) Difference is negligible, or can be depending on the context.  His opinion, albeit a well respected opinion.  I prefer to think about stuff like RDS as an enabler.  Helps improve (insert your choice).  Always and enabler, never a disabler. 

3) Pocket carry is something I haven't really looked into. However, I have seek holster options that are essentially sleeves that cover the trigger and have options to shield the RDS. 

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #22 on: October 20, 2022, 08:16:06 PM »
What's the largest pistol you foresee you'll ever pocket carry?  Glock 42?  G43?  Sig 365?  Walther PPK?  Ruger LCP?

Once you establish your choice of gun/s from all available pistols (especially if you're planning to pick exclusively from what you already own), THEN see if an RDS is even an option and whether or not it makes sense.  You might find your chosen firearm doesn't have the option to properly mount an RDS.

I personally would expect a pocket gun I'm carrying to have less firepower (smaller caliber and/or smaller mag capacity assuming not a revolver), lighter weight, and to be employed for close quarters situations -- like point blank if possible.  In my experience, the smaller the pistol, the more difficult it is for me to hit where I'm aiming at 25 yards.  Lots of factors as to why, but the smaller size does make it harder to gain a firm purchase, shorter slides have a shorter sight radius using fixed sights, and even with .380 calibers, the felt recoil is less manageable than a larger frame gun with more weight and a larger grip surface area.

To me, a RDS on a G42, assuming they even offer the option, is like putting a spoiler on a Nissan LEAF.

That's just me.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #23 on: October 20, 2022, 10:26:29 PM »
Finally watched the whole video. He makes some excellent points. He has his opinion on the matter and seems like the video was more about defending his position(s) on feedback from the interwebs than anything else.

The point about training and perishable skills are very good. I agree a new shooter can and usually will pick up on RDS pistols well. However, something to think about in terms of a trend. For thousands of years, humans are threat or target focused. When did “focus on the front sight” come into play?

#thingsthatmakeyougohmm

changemyoil66

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #24 on: October 21, 2022, 11:40:05 AM »
"Red dots aren't the way of the future.  Irons sights are a thing of the past."

A crusty old shooting instructor and former .mil quoted that recently.  Not sure if he made it up or where he got it from, but I've been following him for many years and he did have some issues when first trying RDS on pistols.

1 can look at every rifle during a class. Everyone has an optic on it. Whether it be RDS or a scope.  In 4 years, I've only seen like 4 running irons not on purpose (noobs who didn't buy an optic yet).

As I have taken skill builders for the past 4 years, I've noticed similar with pistols. 4 years ago, only 1 maybe 2 had RDS on their pistols. Now it's more like 40-50% have.  1 SB, I was 1 of 2 not running RDS on a pistol.  So the future is RDS on pistols.

As someone whos tried back to back same pistols (VP9), 1 with RDS and 1 without, the noticeable diff was the reacquiring follow up shots much faster.  This was at about 10 yards.  My grouping with irons was about basketball and rapid fire. With RDS 5 seconds later was softball and I shot much faster. 

So Ken is right because in a sense because  I didn't miss the target at 10 yards. So both was 10 for 10. But what is note worthy was the time between shots was reduced with the RDS and the grouping was much better.  So at 5 yards, I would also assume hits on target will be 10/10 with both sights.

changemyoil66

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #25 on: October 21, 2022, 11:44:02 AM »
What's the largest pistol you foresee you'll ever pocket carry?  Glock 42?  G43?  Sig 365?  Walther PPK?  Ruger LCP?

Once you establish your choice of gun/s from all available pistols (especially if you're planning to pick exclusively from what you already own), THEN see if an RDS is even an option and whether or not it makes sense.  You might find your chosen firearm doesn't have the option to properly mount an RDS.

I personally would expect a pocket gun I'm carrying to have less firepower (smaller caliber and/or smaller mag capacity assuming not a revolver), lighter weight, and to be employed for close quarters situations -- like point blank if possible.  In my experience, the smaller the pistol, the more difficult it is for me to hit where I'm aiming at 25 yards.  Lots of factors as to why, but the smaller size does make it harder to gain a firm purchase, shorter slides have a shorter sight radius using fixed sights, and even with .380 calibers, the felt recoil is less manageable than a larger frame gun with more weight and a larger grip surface area.

To me, a RDS on a G42, assuming they even offer the option, is like putting a spoiler on a Nissan LEAF.

That's just me.

Colin Noir has a vid about top 5 CCW guns. 1 is his pocket carry. He states he uses it when he checks the mail because he doesn't want to have to put on a belt or certain pants. He just wants to go to the mailbox and back in his sweats.  So if pocket carry is only a reason like this, I see no need to spend extra $ on a RDS at all.  Pocket carrying for going to the store or longer than a walk to the mailbox and back, then maybe you have to look into it. The Holosun 507K/407K have a slightly slanted back part of the RDS. So this may help reduce any snagging. Compared to a flat backing like a Trijicon RMR or ACRO.

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #26 on: October 21, 2022, 11:52:49 AM »
1 can look at every rifle during a class. Everyone has an optic on it. Whether it be RDS or a scope.  In 4 years, I've only seen like 4 running irons not on purpose (noobs who didn't buy an optic yet).

As I have taken skill builders for the past 4 years, I've noticed similar with pistols. 4 years ago, only 1 maybe 2 had RDS on their pistols. Now it's more like 40-50% have.  1 SB, I was 1 of 2 not running RDS on a pistol.  So the future is RDS on pistols.

As someone whos tried back to back same pistols (VP9), 1 with RDS and 1 without, the noticeable diff was the reacquiring follow up shots much faster.  This was at about 10 yards.  My grouping with irons was about basketball and rapid fire. With RDS 5 seconds later was softball and I shot much faster. 

So Ken is right because in a sense because  I didn't miss the target at 10 yards. So both was 10 for 10. But what is note worthy was the time between shots was reduced with the RDS and the grouping was much better.  So at 5 yards, I would also assume hits on target will be 10/10 with both sights.
One excellent point was the one about dry fire to pick up the dot.  Where live fire is needed for the dot tracking, shooting at speed, etc. 

To me, the 10 yard and in for defensive encounters is neither here nor there.  I can see his point(s).  However, I think his point about likely or possible (or whatever he said) was more in the context of most people wouldn't have training or be training regularly.  I get the price/cost to get into RDS and that was a hurdle for me getting started.  You do you. . . for me, I highly recommend RDS on pistols for many reasons.  Of course, if one has the means and opportunity.  That said, I have to be sure to shoot with irons regularly too.  Well rounded. . .

changemyoil66

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #27 on: October 21, 2022, 01:44:52 PM »
One excellent point was the one about dry fire to pick up the dot.  Where live fire is needed for the dot tracking, shooting at speed, etc. 

To me, the 10 yard and in for defensive encounters is neither here nor there.  I can see his point(s).  However, I think his point about likely or possible (or whatever he said) was more in the context of most people wouldn't have training or be training regularly.  I get the price/cost to get into RDS and that was a hurdle for me getting started.  You do you. . . for me, I highly recommend RDS on pistols for many reasons.  Of course, if one has the means and opportunity.  That said, I have to be sure to shoot with irons regularly too.  Well rounded. . .

For me, comes to $. Do I have the additional $ to add 1 on. This is after spending on ammo and other training necessities like a holster, ear pro, mags, shoes, etc...what ever else is more needed.

Besides the obvious cost of the RDS, the cost of milling or plate. The cost of new sights.  The cost of new holster.  So 1 can easily spend more than the MSRP on 1 RDS unit for all the other cost involved. Pake style.

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #28 on: October 21, 2022, 01:48:09 PM »
For me, comes to $. Do I have the additional $ to add 1 on. This is after spending on ammo and other training necessities like a holster, ear pro, mags, shoes, etc...what ever else is more needed.

Besides the obvious cost of the RDS, the cost of milling or plate. The cost of new sights.  The cost of new holster.  So 1 can easily spend more than the MSRP on 1 RDS unit for all the other cost involved. Pake style.
PS5
Purple premium
1000 rounds of .45 acp

Selectively pake  ;D

aletheuo137

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #29 on: October 24, 2022, 08:09:58 AM »
PS5
Purple premium
1000 rounds of .45 acp

Selectively pake  ;D
Waycist!

Sent from my SM-A102U using Tapatalk

oldfart

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #30 on: October 24, 2022, 08:29:28 AM »
I put a red dot on my pistol

It's actually more on the pinkish side :rofl:
What, Me Worry?

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #31 on: October 24, 2022, 08:38:45 AM »
I put a red dot on my pistol

SNIP

It's actually more on the pinkish side :rofl:

oldfart

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #32 on: October 24, 2022, 08:53:26 AM »
But seriously, I do have electronic sights. Just not on my pistols.
...and not on any serious guns.

I'm trying to get away from electronic stuff.
I notice that a lot of electronic stuff fails prematurely nowadays.
What, Me Worry?

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #33 on: October 24, 2022, 09:19:14 AM »
But seriously, I do have electronic sights. Just not on my pistols.
...and not on any serious guns.

I'm trying to get away from electronic stuff.
I notice that a lot of electronic stuff fails prematurely nowadays.
"There are serious dudes doing serious work all around the world with RDS pistols" - Wise pistol instructor

I get what you're saying.  Electronics suffer many things.  That said, not all RDS or other sighting system technology is the same/equal. 

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #34 on: October 26, 2022, 08:30:38 PM »
 ;D

drck1000

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #35 on: December 06, 2022, 11:03:56 PM »


I watch some videos from this channel. I don’t agree with some, particularly their gear and gun reviews. However, they have regular day jobs and take a good amount of firearms classes. In this video, he hosts Mike Pannone on pistol red dots.

changemyoil66

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #36 on: December 21, 2022, 10:32:07 AM »
I put a red dot on my pistol

It's actually more on the pinkish side :rofl:

It's pink. Focus.

aletheuo137

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #37 on: December 22, 2022, 07:56:50 AM »
Already have a red dot. Two green ones too!

Sent from my SM-A102U using Tapatalk

zippz

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #38 on: December 22, 2022, 10:49:19 AM »

I was watching this video and the notable thing I got from it was when Ken mentioned that most self defense encounters will be at 10 yards or less.  At that distance the difference is negligible.


Around 7 yards is where you start to see the advantages of a red dot - speed in aiming, accuracy, aged eyes, view, etc.  Under that your using flash sight picture so doesn't make a difference unless you have a small target (assailant behind cover).

DocMercy

Re: Do You Really Need a Red Dot on Your Pistol?
« Reply #39 on: February 18, 2023, 07:40:13 AM »
I don't have a RDS, but I have a green Crimson Trace laser.  I am 72 and trying to focus on iron sights is difficult. With a laser you don't have to look through a sight, just look for the dot on the target.  I think it is great for SD distances up to 40 ft.

What do the surveys say about the conditions under which a CCW owner will require the use of his gun indoors or at night, where the RDS or Laser light will allow you to shoot more accurately? Second question is about CCW holsters that work with a laser targeting system? RDS works well in a Sig 365 pistol/holster combination, but finding a holster with a cutout for an under barrel laser light is not easy.