The Supreme Court is heavily political.... except it isn't (Read 868 times)

eyeeatingfish

The Supreme Court is heavily political.... except it isn't
« on: October 03, 2023, 10:30:06 PM »
The narrative in the news and public discourse sends the image that the Supreme court is broken, heavily partisan, and always votes along political lines.

This breakdown shows just how untrue this is.
Excerpt: Out of 58 cases for the October 2022 term half were decided unanimously and only 5 were along the 6 to 3 political lines.

https://twitter.com/FedSoc/status/1708853797907312870

changemyoil66

Re: The Supreme Court is heavily political.... except it isn't
« Reply #1 on: October 04, 2023, 08:10:50 AM »
This is an attempt by the fake news because the DNC no longer controls them.  The diff that I've been seeing at SCOTUS and other GOP type judges in other courts is that the GOP makes decisions based on facts and not feelings.  We can use the 2a as a prime example since it's the most relevant.

"public safety" has always been used by anti 2a (typically DNC) judges/courts, despite Heller (2008) SCOTUS ruling saying that it cannot be used. Buren further clarified this. Which means from 2008 to 2022, the 9th and other courts have been violating a SCOTUS ruling (Heller).

The fake news then began going after Thomas because they need to have a conservative judge removed so Biden can replace one by one with liberal judges.

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Supreme Court is heavily political.... except it isn't
« Reply #2 on: October 04, 2023, 02:27:02 PM »
This is an attempt by the fake news because the DNC no longer controls them.  The diff that I've been seeing at SCOTUS and other GOP type judges in other courts is that the GOP makes decisions based on facts and not feelings.  We can use the 2a as a prime example since it's the most relevant.

"public safety" has always been used by anti 2a (typically DNC) judges/courts, despite Heller (2008) SCOTUS ruling saying that it cannot be used. Buren further clarified this. Which means from 2008 to 2022, the 9th and other courts have been violating a SCOTUS ruling (Heller).

The fake news then began going after Thomas because they need to have a conservative judge removed so Biden can replace one by one with liberal judges.

I wouldn't put it only on the news. I have seen discussion among politicians, celebrities, regular folk, etc. all about how bad the supreme court is. I even remember here on 2a someone making the argument that the court is all about politics and how justices rule according to their tribe. 

On a side note, I think generally people get upset at the court when they don't like the way they rule. Most upset people don't know squat about legal concepts, precedent, etc. and why a decision was made the way it was, they just are unhappy they don't get their way.

Then there are those who are somewhat familiar with these things (many of us here) and can understand a fair amount of a court's decision but even then I see a lot of people just using this knowledge and bias to justify being upset at the way a court ruled.

This is not to say that courts, at various levels, never get it clearly wrong, but I just tend to see more bias in looking at decisions than objectivity. I listen to some legal podcasts that do a pretty good job of neutral coverage of court decisions and one of the hosts (Sarah Isgur I think) pointed out how much people sway their interpretation of the first amendment rights based on who is in power. When one party is in power they tend to have less interest in free speech but when they are in the minority they tend to have more interest in free speech. Ideals can be quite squishy...