Substantive due process and procedural due process.
Hawaii red flag law clearly has procedural due process, so no, I wasn't wrong in there.
Substantive due process is more of a gray area and is subject to more interpretation. Some justices, Clarence Thomas included, reject the substantive due process concept. Within this concept there is more room where you could make that Hawaii's red flag law does not have/does not have enough due process protections. Not really any definitive answers on this one, not until a court rules on it and sets precedence.
Red flag laws aren't the only times rights are taken away prior to a hearing though so why do you think red flag laws are unique from others?
Very good, Googler. But you are still wrong.
Due Process requires that Neither of the categories be violated. In other words, if you have Procedural Due Process, that alone is not adequate. You must also have Substantive Due Process.
Both are necessary ingredients in determining whether or not Due Process has been afforded.
Substantive Due Process is not a "gray area."
"substantive due process protects individuals against majoritarian policy
enactments that exceed the limits of governmental authority: courts may
find that a majority's enactment is not law and cannot be enforced as such,
even if the processes of enactment and enforcement were actually fair.[3]
...
Much substantive due process litigation involves legal challenges to the validity
of unenumerated rights and seek particular outcomes instead of merely contesting
procedures and their effects.
In a nutshell, since lawmakers make mistakes and often write bad laws, you can't simply say, "Due Process was given in this case," just because the law was followed. There are also the rights of the individual, both spelled out in the constitution and those accepted in previous cases as rights to be protected.
Example: if the law says you get punished by having your property seized, and then you get a chance to have that property returned at great expense for lawyers
... AND the deprivation of that property also violates the second amendment without providing an opportunity to be heard PRIOR to your guns being taken ...
i find it easy to conclude that one's rights were violated and that due process was not afforded beforehand.
We are seeing several cases where state's that impose additional hurdles and waiting periods above the NICS background check and 3-day time limit being struck down now. Depriving someone of a right and then restoring it only after they comply with the government's list of conditions is unconstitutional.
I see a direct parallel between states forcing you to get a license to acquire while waiting as long as 30 days to buy a gun, and having your guns and ammo taken from you before you are allowed to face your accuser or present evidence to dispute the validity of the confiscation for what they say will be 2 weeks or less -- but we know how slow the courts can be these days.