Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing (Read 37105 times)

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #160 on: December 12, 2023, 08:36:52 AM »
A Mcdonalds hamburger has ketchup on it. Maybe you would like more ketchup but that doesn't mean there is no ketchup just because you want more.
It is not that complicated.


Hahahahahahhaha

I'm Jack....Lame. (Anchorman 2 reference)

Brystont1

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #161 on: December 12, 2023, 08:44:48 AM »
He thinks if McDonald's gives him a burger with no ketchup but hands him a coupon for ketchup on a future visit, McDonald's is giving him the ketchup he ordered.

You can't get "more" until you get "some."

If the definition of a burger requires 3 squirts of ketchup yet there is only 1 squirt can you call it a burger?

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #162 on: December 12, 2023, 08:50:39 AM »
If the definition of a burger requires 3 squirts of ketchup yet there is only 1 squirt can you call it a burger?

What if you get your burger "plain"?  So no lettuce, condiments, onions, etc...Is it still a burger?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #163 on: December 12, 2023, 11:16:32 AM »
What if you get your burger "plain"?  So no lettuce, condiments, onions, etc...Is it still a burger?

A hamburger was originally just the samidge:  Bun and ground beef.

Now ground beef is labeled "hamburger," too.

All about the context in today's food world.

Quote
Evidence suggests that either the United States or Germany (the city of Hamburg)
was the first country where two slices of bread and a ground beef patty were
combined into a "hamburger sandwich" and sold.
There is some controversy over the origin of the hamburger because its two basic
ingredients, bread and beef, had been prepared and consumed separately for many
years in both countries before their combination. Shortly after its creation, the
hamburger quickly included all of its currently typically characteristic trimmings,
including onions, lettuce, and sliced pickles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_hamburger
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #164 on: December 12, 2023, 10:11:37 PM »
So, you think understanding Constitutional rights are as simple as ordering extra condiments?

LOL!!  That explains a lot.

Swoosh

Not comparing the two, I am giving you a simple example that not enough of something is not the same thing as none. Thats a non sequitur
Hawaii red flag law has due process. You think if doesn't have enough, and that is fine, I would like to see more due process protections as well, but that does not mean there is no due process. If there was no due process at all then it would be obviously unconstitutional. If there is some due process but you feel there needs to be more then it is not so clear whether it is unconstitutional or not.


Another thing to keep in mind in all of this is that unlike normal cases where an officer decides to arrest a person, a TRO, a warrant, and a red flag order are orders from a judge. When a cop receives such an order there is not much room for the cop to make a decision on the merit of the judge's order. A cop often has no idea about the case associated with an arrest warrant, the judge makes the order to have the person arrested and the cop follows the order not knowing whether the judge was correct in finding cause to make the arrest.


We should attack TROs before red flag laws since TROs can revoke your firearm rights without even finding cause you are a threat.
« Last Edit: December 12, 2023, 10:28:18 PM by eyeeatingfish »

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #165 on: December 13, 2023, 08:23:01 AM »
Swoosh

Not comparing the two, I am giving you a simple example that not enough of something is not the same thing as none. Thats a non sequitur
Hawaii red flag law has due process. You think if doesn't have enough, and that is fine, I would like to see more due process protections as well, but that does not mean there is no due process. If there was no due process at all then it would be obviously unconstitutional. If there is some due process but you feel there needs to be more then it is not so clear whether it is unconstitutional or not.


Another thing to keep in mind in all of this is that unlike normal cases where an officer decides to arrest a person, a TRO, a warrant, and a red flag order are orders from a judge. When a cop receives such an order there is not much room for the cop to make a decision on the merit of the judge's order. A cop often has no idea about the case associated with an arrest warrant, the judge makes the order to have the person arrested and the cop follows the order not knowing whether the judge was correct in finding cause to make the arrest.


We should attack TROs before red flag laws since TROs can revoke your firearm rights without even finding cause you are a threat.

Re-read everything we posted. I cannot comment any further as I'm not allowed to go deeper into it for you about red flags.

But yes, TRO's are also unconstitutional as they take your guns first before you get a chance to defend any allegations in court.  Re-read my post about custody battles. I have a friend who was served a TRO because his ex claimed he hit her on X date. Turns out he was in and was still in Vegas. So when the cops showed up to his parents home, where he lived, they got him on the phone and verified he was in Vegas and unable to present him with the TRO.  Imagine if he was a gun owner, he would also have his guns taken away.  He had to fight this in court on the assigned date and proved he wasn't even in state on the day she claimed he hit her. TRO dismissed. 

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #166 on: December 13, 2023, 07:45:52 PM »
Re-read everything we posted. I cannot comment any further as I'm not allowed to go deeper into it for you about red flags.

But yes, TRO's are also unconstitutional as they take your guns first before you get a chance to defend any allegations in court.  Re-read my post about custody battles. I have a friend who was served a TRO because his ex claimed he hit her on X date. Turns out he was in and was still in Vegas. So when the cops showed up to his parents home, where he lived, they got him on the phone and verified he was in Vegas and unable to present him with the TRO.  Imagine if he was a gun owner, he would also have his guns taken away.  He had to fight this in court on the assigned date and proved he wasn't even in state on the day she claimed he hit her. TRO dismissed.

I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #167 on: December 13, 2023, 07:49:46 PM »
I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

...

Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

macsak

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #168 on: December 13, 2023, 09:27:05 PM »
i love how he repeats his stance, while also trying to get people to "agree to disagree"
goalposts moved...

Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:

macsak

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #169 on: December 13, 2023, 09:28:29 PM »
so "reiterating" is of, but "repeating" is not?
which one is subjective and which one is objective?

I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #170 on: December 14, 2023, 08:30:58 AM »
Because repeating yourself is always the best way to strengthen your position.

 :crazy:

Like Jean, the more he repeats wrong information, the more he thinks hes no longer wrong.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #171 on: December 14, 2023, 08:34:05 AM »
I didn't develop amnesia, I know what was said in this repeating circle of arguments. We disagree. I was reiterating my stance to Flapp.

FYI, everything you mentioned about a TRO could happen just the same as an ex making an assault complaint except instead of just losing firearms they would also be put in jail with a hearing that would happen after your civil rights were taken away.

I support a challenge of red flags and TROs on due process grounds, I just wouldn't go as far as you to say that they are clearly unconstitutional or lack any due process. They are in a gray area that is very debatable, and until the SCOTUS rules on it all we have are ideological arguments but lack decisive case law. Hopefully one day they will take up a TRO and/or red flag law and rule in a way that will require more due process protections.

I'm glad you don't have amnesia, so that eliminates 1 theory about things.

Flapp already mentioned something like this, but rights don't have gray areas.  Also, you again mention your SCOTUS ruling and see my mag ban example (no amnesia right?). No SCOTUS ruling, so must be constitutional right? And other anti-2A un-SCOTUS rulings.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #172 on: December 14, 2023, 11:54:45 AM »
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #173 on: December 14, 2023, 12:11:18 PM »
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.

I anticipate a cricket serenade...
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #174 on: December 14, 2023, 04:12:29 PM »
I anticipate a cricket serenade...

I anticipate goal post moving or deflection.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #175 on: December 14, 2023, 10:51:40 PM »
i love how he repeats his stance, while also trying to get people to "agree to disagree"

What else am I supposed to do if there is an unresolvable disagreement?

Flapp and CMO both repeated their positions multiple times as well. I am just suggesting we move on because it isn't resolveable.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #176 on: December 14, 2023, 11:22:25 PM »
I was saving this for later, but since EEF thinks red flag laws are constitutional, then he must show via the Bruen SCOTUS test that it is.  The burden in on him, no one else to prove this.  So I'll wait for him to post historical analogies written laws about it.  And if he cannot, it will be deemed unconstitutional by default, per SCOTUS Bruen test standard.

Why is the burden on him even though he's not the state/government?  It's because HI too said the law is constitutional while they were passing it.  Since he agrees, proof under Bruen must be shown.  Yes, I am asking EEF to litigate this. And yes, technically, he is the state as well.

WHOOP THERE IT IS.

You misquote me, purposefully I can't help but wonder.

I never said "red flag laws are constitutional" in fact I criticized you for making blanket statements of that nature. I said red flag laws CAN be constitutional, that it depended on the specifics of each individual law.

If by the Bruen test you mean using text, history, and tradition, that is a methodology, but it isn't a completely binding one, not is it one that gives a clear answer. The History and tradition (redundant) portion creates its own problems, traditionally you could beat you wife, it wasn't a crime way back then so how would you incorporate any history and tradition into a question of punishment for spouse abuse? If you require history and tradition then laws banning spouse abuse would be unconstitutional would they not? Before laws that allowed women to vote they couldn't vote, again, you couldn't satisfy the history test if there was no prior history of women voting. I think you are over-estimating the application of the Buren test. I posted a podcast that went into a lot of these issues, did you even listen to it yet? You ignored where I pointed out to you multiple times that Rahimi is unique because unlike other TRO/Red flag law situations, Rahimi agreed to the stipulation that he not have firearms which means he doesn't have the same due process challenge compared to your average red flag/TRO case.

Why do you think the Bruen decision makes red flag laws unconstitutional.

I am no more a constitutional expert than you are, all we can do is read and listen to people who are more knowledgeable than us to try to form a more supporter opinion. I have read and listened to a number of such people and they don't know which way the court is going to rule or how exactly the text history and tradition framework would apply to the Rahimi case. That should tell you something about all of this. Like I said earlier, for practical purposes, until the SCOTUS rules on this very issue there is no practical answer, only ideological ones. The fact that legal experts aren't even sure how this one will go down alone should inform you that this is not a case where the constitutionality is something so plain and obvious as you claim it to be. I don't have such a solid answer or prediction of how the court will rule on this. If something is obviously unconstitutional it is a much easier answer, but when things are in the gray area the answer is not so obvious. I illustrated to you how there are so many rights that aren't recognized until a court interpreted the constitution a certain way that enshrined them into case law. Take for example a Terry Stop. It wasn't obvious the cop was within his power when he stopped those men, he just did what he thought he could and it was challenged in court which lead to the framework that shapes police detention to this day. There are numerous cases where someone had to do something that was challenged before anyone knew whether it was constitutional or not. 

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #177 on: December 15, 2023, 08:21:42 AM »
What else am I supposed to do if there is an unresolvable disagreement?

Flapp and CMO both repeated their positions multiple times as well. I am just suggesting we move on because it isn't resolveable.

Any why do you think it isn't resolvable? We call this a clue.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #178 on: December 15, 2023, 08:23:05 AM »
You misquote me, purposefully I can't help but wonder.

I never said "red flag laws are constitutional" in fact I criticized you for making blanket statements of that nature. I said red flag laws CAN be constitutional, that it depended on the specifics of each individual law.



And my reply to you was to post one that "can" be constitutional and u posted only 1 part of HI's one, leaving out all the other sections of it that shows take the guns first.  Damn, I'm thirty (Training Day reference)

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #179 on: December 15, 2023, 08:24:49 AM »


If by the Bruen test you mean using text, history, and tradition, that is a methodology, but it isn't a completely binding one, not is it one that gives a clear answer. The History and tradition (redundant) portion creates its own problems, traditionally you could beat you wife, it wasn't a crime way back then so how would you incorporate any history and tradition into a question of punishment for spouse abuse? If you require history and tradition then laws banning spouse abuse would be unconstitutional would they not? Before laws that allowed women to vote they couldn't vote, again, you couldn't satisfy the history test if there was no prior history of women voting. I think you are over-estimating the application of the Buren test. I posted a podcast that went into a lot of these issues, did you even listen to it yet? You ignored where I pointed out to you multiple times that Rahimi is unique because unlike other TRO/Red flag law situations, Rahimi agreed to the stipulation that he not have firearms which means he doesn't have the same due process challenge compared to your average red flag/TRO case.




AANNNNNNDDDDD here's the goal post moving.